Journalist attacked by violent mob

That's... not how Google works.

It's a keyword search. If it locates the word inside of those articles, etc. then it associates the keyword with the article. It so happens that my search criteria that included Nazi's brought up a ton of alt-right articles. Further proving my point. I didn't feel I needed to explain how ******* google searches work, but when you guys don't have **** to fall back on then you have to dick around with dumb **** like this.

I'm a network administrator by trade, and I can explain how each packet traverses the network and **** too. How specific do you want it? Christ.
 
You missed 5) nazis have made a detrimental impact on US political discourse by normalizing violence as an acceptable response to speech.

One is a potential, one has happened.

Antifa had already normalized violence as an acceptable response to speech, in Berkeley, a year or more before Charlottesville.
 
It's a keyword search. If it locates the word inside of those articles, etc. then it associates the keyword with the article.

Which doesn't make those associations true, it just makes them common. Like "moon landing" and "hoax" show up together a lot. If lots of people call the alt right "nazis", then google will associate them, regardless of whether that accusation is true. So google making that association doesn't prove it's true, it only proves that lots of people make the claim. Do you understand the difference?

I didn't feel I needed to explain how ******* google searches work

Or apparently to understand it either.

I'm a network administrator by trade, and I can explain how each packet traverses the network and **** too. How specific do you want it? Christ.

And yet, you failed spectacularly at understanding what those packets actually mean. I suppose you don't have to in order to do your job, though. As long as the packets get where they're supposed to go, you've succeeded, you're not in charge of making them make any sense. Garbage in, garbage out.
 
Which doesn't make those associations true, it just makes them common. Like "moon landing" and "hoax" show up together a lot. If lots of people call the alt right "nazis", then google will associate them, regardless of whether that accusation is true. So google making that association doesn't prove it's true, it only proves that lots of people make the claim. Do you understand the difference?

Seriously? What ******* relevance does any of this have to do with anything that I said? Again, I explained the god damned association in the post. This is some ridiculous nitpicking, even for here.

Or apparently to understand it either.

I have a degree and certifications that say differently. Again, I didn't see the ******* relevance any of this has so I have no need to explain it in depth. This is just you trying to "win" any argument you can so we're veering off into this nonsensical argument about keyword searches and packets like it means **** all. You're changing the subject because you can't address the actual content or claims that I made. It's transparent.

And yet, you failed spectacularly at understanding what those packets actually mean. I suppose you don't have to in order to do your job, though. As long as the packets get where they're supposed to go, you've succeeded, you're not in charge of making them make any sense. Garbage in, garbage out.

That would be neat if any of it were true, but I get it. You have to find a way to try and make me look stupid in order for you to feel better about yourself. If you want me to hand you your ass in networking then start a thread. Until then, this is a red herring, and a ******* dumb one at that.
 
:rolleyes: Only if you're not paying attention to what anyone is actually saying, and can't see past your own straw men.

A timeline.

2012: "Uh, there's this guy named Richard Spencer trying to get all the violent white nationalist groups to work together..."

Them: "Oh, he's just one guy."

2013: "So this site called 4chan is making fake black feminists to get people worked up. Here's a list of them..."

them: "Quiet! I'm fighting against #endfathersday. Damn those SJWs."

2014: "Um, Remember that Richard Spencer? Breitbart is using the internet to influence Gamergaters and the like."

: "Gamers? They're just nerds in their mother's basement."

2015: "Guys, all those groups we've been warning you about are workingg together and rallying behind Trump because he's saying so many racist things."

them: "Huh? Those are just memes, why are you worried."

2016: "Guys! Their president is in office! Pay attention!
They're talking about taking to the streets and killing people!"

them: "Checks and balances. Plus, those damn SJWs are still worse, they're getting people banned from Facebook.*"

2017, Charolettesville, them: "OH MY GOD THIS IS TERRIBLE HOW WERE THERE NO WARNING SIGNS!"

"...are you serious right now?"

*: actual discussion on this board. But you knew that one, luchog.

(and if you were on the side that SJWs were worse or as bad as the alt-right...just stop talking and listen to the people who were right all along.)
 
Last edited:
It's a keyword search. If it locates the word inside of those articles, etc. then it associates the keyword with the article. It so happens that my search criteria that included Nazi's brought up a ton of alt-right articles. Further proving my point. I didn't feel I needed to explain how ******* google searches work, but when you guys don't have **** to fall back on then you have to dick around with dumb **** like this.

I'm a network administrator by trade, and I can explain how each packet traverses the network and **** too. How specific do you want it? Christ.

"you guys"?
 
"you guys"?

Yes, it implies more than one person. As in, Belz... nit picking over the association I wasn't making (that I claimed alt-right and Nazi's are the same, when I wasn't), and Zigg bringing up internet keyword searches and networking.

Any other hands that need to be held?
 
Seriously? What ******* relevance does any of this have to do with anything that I said? Again, I explained the god damned association in the post.

You think the association means something more than it actually means. It's basically the correlation/causation problem. The association between "nazi" and "alt right" in google search results is a correlation. You've assumed a particular causation for that correlation, but haven't actually demonstrated it.

I have a degree and certifications that say differently.

I seriously doubt that your degree says you understand correlation/causation distinctions. And if it does, you should ask for a refund.

That would be neat if any of it were true, but I get it. You have to find a way to try and make me look stupid in order for you to feel better about yourself.

It appears I don't have to try. Why is it people always whip out their degrees to defend themselves when they're making fools out of themselves?

If you want me to hand you your ass in networking then start a thread.

I'm quite willing to assume you know far more about networks than I do. But this isn't a network problem. It's a logic problem. Your failure to see that is yet another irony here.
 
Yes, it implies more than one person. As in, Belz... nit picking over the association I wasn't making (that I claimed alt-right and Nazi's are the same, when I wasn't), and Zigg bringing up internet keyword searches and networking.

Any other hands that need to be held?

You brought up both internet keyword searches and networking, not me.
 
The beliefs between white nationalism and Nazism are extremely similar. In fact, they are way more ******* similar than they are different.

Based on what? I mean, in the end it's going to be your interpretation.

Well, yes, it is Nazism, and a whole lot of other, similar things. The coiner of the term "alt.right", Richard Spencer, is himself one of the most prominent neo-Nazi leaders in the US.

"Alt.right" is a catchall term for any far-right, fascist, white supremacist organization or individual. Neo-Nazis, neo-Confederates, the KKK, Proud Boys, Identity Evrorpa, Ayran Nations, Stormfront, The Right Stuff, American Renaissance,, Atomwaffen Division, Hammerskins, ANP, League of the South, American Freedom Party, and any number of other, smaller groups and unaffiliated individuals who ascribe to fascist and white supremacist ideologies. Many of whom were represented at the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville.

Not all alt.right people are Nazis, but all Nazis are alt.right; and there are far more and far stronger similarities between them, than there are differences.

That's why the term was coined, to bring together all of the disparate far-right extremists under one umbrella, sanitize their identity for the general public, and thereby increase their social presence and political power. Fortunately, it hasn't worked as well as Spencer had intended; particularly after Unite the Right helped to demonstrate the true, violent nature of these groups, and decreased their social capital somewhat. Not enough, but at least the cohesion was short-lived, which is a blessing. It's much easier to prevent a handful of smaller, disorganized groups from gaining power than it is to stop a single large, well-organized entity.

I'm not sure you realised, but you proved my point.
 
You think the association means something more than it actually means. It's basically the correlation/causation problem. The association between "nazi" and "alt right" in google search results is a correlation. You've assumed a particular causation for that correlation, but haven't actually demonstrated it.

At least pretend like you've kept up with the thread. I was asked if the ideology is widely accepted. I did that basic internet search that brought numbers and surveys that asked people if they associate or condone alt-right held beliefs. I then stated, without any internet search, that alt-right and Nazi's hold many of the same beliefs as confirmed by the way they identify themselves. This is easily found. I don't know what the **** you're talking about here, I'm assuming it's another strawman.

I seriously doubt that your degree says you understand correlation/causation distinctions. And if it does, you should ask for a refund.

Teehee you really showed me *giggles*

Was your goal to ensure everyone here knows you can't read for comprehension? If it was, congrats.

It appears I don't have to try. Why is it people always whip out their degrees to defend themselves when they're making fools out of themselves?

I didn't see you pull out your degree, since I'm not the one making a fool of myself. You're the one devolving this conversation into completely off topic nonsense to try and stroke your ego.

These are trump style debate tactics. You're be....nm

I'm quite willing to assume you know far more about networks than I do. But this isn't a network problem. It's a logic problem. Your failure to see that is yet another irony here.

No, it's not. My point is and has been that this shouldn't be about networking at all. Also, you started this by saying "that's not how google works" as if at any point in time I tried to illustrate or explain how it works in the slightest.

I can't wait to see where this goes next.

ETA: Everyone seemed to understand what I was saying until you came around some hours later trying to bicker about the methods of Google.
 
Last edited:
Based on what? I mean, in the end it's going to be your interpretation.

Based on the ******* people at the "Unite the Right" rally wearing swastikaz and Nazi uniforms. Based on their stated beliefs on their respective propaganda. Based on their actions over the last x amount of years.

Are you implying that those that belong to the alt-right do not hold, largely, the same beliefs as Nazi's?

**** I hate when people can't just say what they're getting at and do this fishing expedition nonsense until they get to a point where some "gotcha" can be employed. Just say what you're getting at.
 
No, I'm not because as I carefully explained, I didn't claim alt-right were ******* Nazi's. How is this getting mixed up?

I was asked if the ideology is accepted

The NAZI ideology, not the wider net you cast deliberately. I'm aware that white nationalism is way too prevalent, but that isn't Nazism.

Implicity, obviously, in my question, is my response. The discussion was about how one would search for the X million people who identify with the alt-right.

It absolutely wasn't, but it's increasingly clear that you and others don't know the difference.

Which doesn't make those associations true, it just makes them common. Like "moon landing" and "hoax" show up together a lot. If lots of people call the alt right "nazis", then google will associate them, regardless of whether that accusation is true.

That reminds me of a "discussion" I had with some asshat on the IMDB boards before they were shut down. He insisted that his view that movie X was bad was based on objective truth because the "best" reviews on the site agreed with him. He thought "best" meant just that -- that those were the most accurate reviews, rather than just the ones that got upvoted the most.
 
A timeline.

2012: "Uh, there's this guy named Richard Spencer trying to get all the violent white nationalist groups to work together..."

Them: "Oh, he's just one guy."

2013: "So this site called 4chan is making fake black feminists to get people worked up. Here's a list of them..."

them: "Quiet! I'm fighting against #endfathersday. Damn those SJWs."

2014: "Um, Remember that Richard Spencer? Breitbart is using the internet to influence Gamergaters and the like."

: "Gamers? They're just nerds in their mother's basement."

2015: "Guys, all those groups we've been warning you about are workingg together and rallying behind Trump because he's saying so many racist things."

them: "Huh? Those are just memes, why are you worried."

2016: "Guys! Their president is in office! Pay attention!
They're talking about taking to the streets and killing people!"

them: "Checks and balances. Plus, those damn SJWs are still worse, they're getting people banned from Facebook.*"

2017, Charolettesville, them: "OH MY GOD THIS IS TERRIBLE HOW WERE THERE NO WARNING SIGNS!"

"...are you serious right now?"

*: actual discussion on this board. But you knew that one, luchog.

(and if you were on the side that SJWs were worse or as bad as the alt-right...just stop talking and listen to the people who were right all along.)

The above really shows how easy it is to win an argument when you control both sides of the discussion.
 
Yes, it implies more than one person. As in, Belz... nit picking over the association I wasn't making (that I claimed alt-right and Nazi's are the same, when I wasn't)

You've repeatedly implied that they are either one and the same, or that the distinction doesn't matter. Hell, even right here you call it nit picking.
 
The NAZI ideology, not the wider net you cast deliberately. I'm aware that white nationalism is way too prevalent, but that isn't Nazism.

For the 500th time. Their beliefs are largely the same.

That reminds me of a "discussion" I had with some asshat on the IMDB boards before they were shut down. He insisted that his view that movie X was bad was based on objective truth because the "best" reviews on the site agreed with him. He thought "best" meant just that -- that those were the most accurate reviews, rather than just the ones that got upvoted the most.

Now if only I had done that. Except I didn't say my information was the best, did I? theprestige asked me where I got my information, because the only thing I claimed were the numbers shown in my search from the few articles I read over that did surveys inquiring as to how many people believe or side with alt-right held beliefs.
 
Based on the ******* people at the "Unite the Right" rally wearing swastikaz and Nazi uniforms.

You just told me that the unite the right rally included Nazis AND other groups. So clearly you can't use the larger number as telling of how many of the smaller group there is.

This is basic logic. You don't have a degree for that, do you?

**** I hate when people can't just say what they're getting at and do this fishing expedition nonsense until they get to a point where some "gotcha" can be employed. Just say what you're getting at.

What I'm getting at is right there in the posts I write. There is no hidden punchline. I've said, quite clearly, that you're wrong to inflate Nazi numbers to bolster your unsupported claim.
 
You've repeatedly implied that they are either one and the same, or that the distinction doesn't matter. Hell, even right here you call it nit picking.

LoL this is getting insane.

Lets get back to the basics.

Do you agree or disagree that Nazism and those who identify as alt-right hold, largely, the same beliefs? i.e. white's are superior, anti-LGBTQ, anti-minorities, etc.

Once we get beyond this I think we'll get headed in the right direction.
 
You just told me that the unite the right rally included Nazis AND other groups. So clearly you can't use the larger number as telling of how many of the smaller group there is.

This is basic logic. You don't have a degree for that, do you?

The ******* Nazis and the other groups are being used as the larger number because the ******* ideology is, largely, the same. That's why they were all on the same "side". I get that they aren't exactly the same in every way, but the core tenants to each are based around white supremacy.

I did have to take logic, yes.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom