Journalist attacked by violent mob

It's exactly what people here have been effectively arguing for *years* about not just antifa, but also Black Lives Matter.

A violent terrorist organization that people advocate driving their cars into such violent protests. That is of course all ok.

Advocating driving your car into a peaceful protest is not in anyway encouraging violence and the like, while standing up to nazis is the worst thing someone can do. After all it was the driving into protestors that was getting laws proposed to make it all legal and protect the drivers from litigation.
 
Last edited:
Also present:

Gavin McGinnis (Why hasn't he been deported yet?), who openly encouraged violence

Laura Loomer, who said that antifa was preparing to throw acid-filled balloons in people's faces,

Milo the child rapist enabler, who...eh, who cares?

and Joey Salads, who claimed he would stand behind Dolt 45 in Congress. My guess is that video he posted of himself pissing into his own mouth will greatly hinder his campaign.

Remember, this was a "Defend Free Speech" rally.



Yes, the local anarchists were breaking things and acting like fools, just as they did during Dolt 45's inaguration - when DC police came by later and rounded up/charged everyone in the area, including credentialed journalists. Since they had no evidence against anyone they arrested, nobody was ever convicted. DC police have learned since then.

BLM DC was there with their own setup discussing how to fight fascism worldwide before violence becomes necessary. All Out DC had a DJ setup with people dancing. And lots of folks were just there to show solidarity.

However!

When one of the Proud Boys rushed up and punched a nonviolent antifa protestor, the cops arrested...the Antifa guy. And at least one cop was photoed giving dap to another Proud Boy.

So don't give them too much credit.

No city has a perfect, or even mostly good, record here. Sure.

Let's not compare these cities against some ideal, let's compare them against eachother.

All things considered, which city do you think is taking the right approach here? If you were mayor of some unidentified city that was facing similar protests in the near future, which tactic would you take?

You have the Portland "hands off, let them fight" tactics that has resulted in Portland being an antifa-altright thunderdome.

You have other cities, like DC, who make sure to physically separate these would be combatants, allow permitted displays to occur (including those by right wing undesirables), and mostly maintain a level of peace.

Which, in your mind, is the better and why?
 
Nah, you're thinking of the American prison system. In the Gulag system, though forced to do labour, inmates were paid the same wages as other workers. Besides, if it were just a place for reaping the benefits of slave labour then you'd sentence your inmates to more than on average 4 years, you'd at least sentence them to more than 5 years, like the American liberal democracy does.

You make gulags sound so awesome!

ETA: Have you noticed that the high mortality rates you refer to are either during a devastating nation-wide famine (1933) or during the devastation of the second world war?

When the famine is caused by (or exacerbated by) the communist government, it still counts as the communists killing people. Especially when the famine is sorta on purpose to subdue a population that isn't getting with the program.
 
Last edited:
And you think anyone who identifies as alt-right qualifies?

Uh, yeah. By wiki definition:

The alt-right, an abbreviation of alternative right, is a loosely connected far-right, white nationalist movement based in the United States.

White nationalism is just a watered down version of Nazism from every angle I've viewed it from. It appears to be accepted given the amount of people who admit to holding similar beliefs. Sure, we can nitpick this down more if you want, but I don't have a whole lot of skin in this game. If you don't believe it, fine. Don't. I was asked a question and I gave a response.
 
You really should check your definitions. You can't just twist them around like this and expect to be taken seriously.

I know exactly what it is, who coined the term, the year it was coined, and the explicitly stated goal of the person who coined it.

I stand by what I said.
 
I know exactly what it is, who coined the term, the year it was coined, and the explicitly stated goal of the person who coined it.

I stand by what I said.

Of course you do. As several have pointed out here and elsewhere, there's end to how wide some'll cast a net labelled "Nazis".
 
Of course you do. As several have pointed out here and elsewhere, there's end to how wide some'll cast a net labelled "Nazis".

...but for the record. The question was is the ideology widely held. The beliefs between white nationalism and Nazism are extremely similar. In fact, they are way more ******* similar than they are different. I never claimed alt-right people were Nazi's because that wasn't the question.

You seem to be arguing a point no one is making.
 
Yeah, in other words it's not Nazism. It's just convenient for you to call it as such.


Well, yes, it is Nazism, and a whole lot of other, similar things. The coiner of the term "alt.right", Richard Spencer, is himself one of the most prominent neo-Nazi leaders in the US.

"Alt.right" is a catchall term for any far-right, fascist, white supremacist organization or individual. Neo-Nazis, neo-Confederates, the KKK, Proud Boys, Identity Evrorpa, Ayran Nations, Stormfront, The Right Stuff, American Renaissance,, Atomwaffen Division, Hammerskins, ANP, League of the South, American Freedom Party, and any number of other, smaller groups and unaffiliated individuals who ascribe to fascist and white supremacist ideologies. Many of whom were represented at the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville.

Not all alt.right people are Nazis, but all Nazis are alt.right; and there are far more and far stronger similarities between them, than there are differences.

That's why the term was coined, to bring together all of the disparate far-right extremists under one umbrella, sanitize their identity for the general public, and thereby increase their social presence and political power. Fortunately, it hasn't worked as well as Spencer had intended; particularly after Unite the Right helped to demonstrate the true, violent nature of these groups, and decreased their social capital somewhat. Not enough, but at least the cohesion was short-lived, which is a blessing. It's much easier to prevent a handful of smaller, disorganized groups from gaining power than it is to stop a single large, well-organized entity.
 
Last edited:
Ah and we are back to exactly how broadly can we accurately call someone a nazi. Does allowing jews to remain after ethnically cleansing the country of all lesser races to make it the white ethnostate really fit with being a nazi or not.
 
Then Belz is right and plague311 is wrong.

No, I'm not because as I carefully explained, I didn't claim alt-right were ******* Nazi's. How is this getting mixed up?

I was asked if the ideology is accepted, and I brought up my vague research. Google instantly paired alt-right and Nazism. Why? Because the beliefs are extremely similar. Way more so than they are different. What Luchog said is perfectly in line with what I claimed, and this pathetic nitpick is tiresome.

If you can't understand this basic point I'm making, after another explanation, then I don't know how to further help.
 
No, I'm not because as I carefully explained, I didn't claim alt-right were ******* Nazi's. How is this getting mixed up?

I was asked if the ideology is accepted, and I brought up my vague research. Google instantly paired alt-right and Nazism. Why? Because the beliefs are extremely similar. Way more so than they are different. Want Luchog said is perfectly inline with what I claimed, and this pathetic nitpick is tiresome.

If you can't understand this basic point I'm making, after another explanation, then I don't know how to further help.

Look if you fine any reason to differentiate it is enough to not class them as the same. Like it is wrong to call any church that goes against the bible and ordains women as christian.
 
Look if you fine any reason to differentiate it is enough to not class them as the same. Like it is wrong to call any church that goes against the bible and ordains women as christian.

We make this claim regularly without it being argued so much.

It's the same claim as "Not all Trump supporters are racist", which is true. The phrase "All racists are Trump supporters", can also be true. Whether I know if it is or not, it's certainly more accurate given everything we know.

Like Luchog said, not all alt-right are Nazi's, but by definition all Nazi's are alt-right.
 
We make this claim regularly without it being argued so much.

It's the same claim as "Not all Trump supporters are racist", which is true. The phrase "All racists are Trump supporters", can also be true. Whether I know if it is or not, it's certainly more accurate given everything we know.

Like Luchog said, not all alt-right are Nazi's, but by definition all Nazi's are alt-right.

All Trump supporters support a white supremacist but pointing that out is right out. I mean you can't just right off all ethnonationalists as white supremacists after all. You have to use the politically correct terms for them, they will be horribly triggered if you use the accurate terms after all.
 
I'd have been more much willing to answer if you had answered mine first.

You know, as both a way to show that you're actually interested in discussion, and also to show how that you know what a Nazi is, potentially setting theprestige up for another around of '"Nazis."'

Implicity, obviously, in my question, is my response. The discussion was about how one would search for the X million people who identify with the alt-right. Plague311 said he did a vague internet search. When further queried he said he looked for "people who identify with nazis" or something similar.

YOU jumped on the word "nazi". The rest of us were still talking about how to count/identify the alt-right.

Now, as to whether those are Alt-Right or merely alt-right, we have yet to determine, but the self-anointed definition of alt-right is some combination of "white supremacist, white nationalist.... even nazi supporting or nazism espousing...."

You don't want to admit that? That was my question. It was pretty obvious by the question that I so identify the alt-right.
 
Ah and we are back to exactly how broadly can we accurately call someone a nazi. Does allowing jews to remain after ethnically cleansing the country of all lesser races to make it the white ethnostate really fit with being a nazi or not.

Apparently those guys have never heard of Lenny Kravitz or Lisa Bonet...
 
I was asked if the ideology is accepted, and I brought up my vague research. Google instantly paired alt-right and Nazism. Why? Because the beliefs are extremely similar.

That's... not how Google works.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom