caveman1917
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2015
- Messages
- 8,143
I don't think we need to go to such extremes in order to discuss the current happenings in the United States. The Nazis (current and past) were/are very, very bad. The gulags were also very, very bad. Most of the time, when one group decides to lock another group up for wrongthink, things have gotten very, very bad.
It depends, let's consider an example of one of the largest groups (150k) of political prisoners sent to the Gulags, as described in the Black Book of Communism[*]:
Black Book of Communism said:A singular fate was reserved for the Vlasovtsy, the Soviet soldiers who had fought under the Soviet general Andrei Vlasov. Vlasov was the commander of the Second Army who had been taken prisoner by the Germans in July 1942.
On the basis of his anti-Stalinist convictions, General Vlasov agreed to collaborate with the Nazis to free his country from the tyranny of the Bolsheviks. With the support of the German authorities, Vlasov formed a Russian National Committee and trained two divisions of an "Army for the Liberation of Russia." After the defeat of Nazi Germany, the Allies handed over General Vlasov and his officers to the Soviet Union, and they were promptly executed. The soldiers trom Vlasov's army, following an amnesty decree of November 1945, were deported for six years to Siberia, Kazakhstan, and the far north. In early 1946, 148,079 Vlasovtsy, most of them noncommissioned officers, were accused of treason and sent to the gulags.
What other option would you have suggested? Especially considering that the group actively participated in the Holocaust then a 6-year prison sentence doesn't seem all that "very, very bad" to me.
Or another large group (37k) of political prisoners:
Black Book of Communism said:The first occupation of western Ukraine, from September 1939 to June 1941, had brought about the formation of a fairly powerful armed resistance movement, the OUN, or Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists. Members of this organization subsequently enlisted as special troops in SS units to fight Communists and Jews. In July 1944, when the Red Army arrived, the OUN set up a Supreme Council for the Liberation of Ukraine. Roman Shukhovich, the head of the OU N, became commander of the UPA, the Ukrainian insurgent army. According to Ukrainian sources, the UPA had more than 20,000 members by the autumn of 1944. On 31 March 1944, Beria signed an order stipulating that all family members of soldiers in the OUN and UPA were to be arrested and deported to the region of Krasnoyarsk. From February to October 1944, 100,300 civilians (mainly women, children, and old people) were deported under Beria's order. As for the 37,000 soldiers who were taken prisoner during this time, all were sent to the gulags.
What other option would you have suggested? Especially considering that this group didn't just actively participate in the Holocaust but did so with such ferocity and brutality (such as ripping apart babies) that it even made their SS superiors uneasy and they had to intervene to tone it down a bit. A couple of years of hard labour in an attempted re-education effort doesn't seem all that "very, very bad" to me.
* I suppose one advantage of the Black Book of Communism is that it doesn't even attempt to hide its Nazi apologia, whereas other such political propaganda under the guise of historical scholarship usually simply refers to such political inmates as "freedom fighters" or "heroic victims of communist oppression" or something.
Last edited: