Journalist attacked by violent mob

Are you still pretending Any Ngo is a journalist?

I'm not sure him being one or not has any bearing on whether he should be assaulted. Regardless, this tendency to want to slap a label on someone that makes assaulting them ok is disturbing.

So it’s important that we all get up and defend Ngo's freedom to spread lies!

Are you saying that lies should be illegal? Who fact-checks this?
 
So did Hitler. If only someone had stopped him before he rose to power.

The best defense against an authoritarian ******* taking power is a broad middle who respect civil liberties for as many as possible. Not people who demonize the other side while lauding violence.
 
I can guarantee you that no good law will come from masked antifa and prouds boys clubbing each other in the streets. Expect an authoritarian overreach in the form of aggressive policing, prohibition of public assembly, or some other erosion of civil rights.


American policing has always been defined by authoritarian over-reach. The "Bloody Sunday" Selma march, the Kent State Massacre, Stonewall, COINTELPRO, the assassinations of Black Panther leaders, "Free Speech Zones", numerous BLM protests, particularly the 2014 Berkeley incident, the WTO conference in Seattle, and so on and so on. That's one of the problems that is being protested.

Civil rights have been eroding steadily for most of my lifetime; not because of protesters, but because of government pandering to megacorps, Dominionist Christians, and now neo-Nazis. Since Reagan, we've taken as many steps backwards as we have forwards. The War on Drugs, "Religious Freedom" legislation, anti-abortion legislation, military transgender ban, corporate personhood, the rollback of worker protections, the rollback of disabled and LGTBQ student protections, increasing restrictions on criticism and fair use of media via "intellectual property" legislation, and on and on. Not to mention Trump's "enemy of the people" rhetoric and policy of excluding non-sympathetic journalists. None of these are related to protesters or street brawling, they're all due to inherent authoritarianism, and pandering to billionaires and religious fanatics.

There isn't much the government can do to roll back civil rights that they have not already been working hard to do.
 
Andy Ngo hasn't assaulted anyone. He was the one who was openly intimidated and assaulted.

Ah, but Ngo reports for right-wing audiences, which includes neo-Nazis, which kind-of subscribe to an ideology that resulted in millions of death. Ergo, he's just as bad as Hitler. Stop asking so many questions? Why do you like the Holocaust? Oh, you don't? Well, get punching, then.

Sorry, it's hard to write such nonsense in a way that sounds genuine. Somehow luchog manages to do it.

Okay, I can't have read that correctly. Are you saying fascist gangs are marching openly in the streets, intimidating minorities and "undesirables" because they have a grievance against the government?

He's talking about Antifa, for pete's sake.

Wait a minute here. First, we're being told that antifa are terrorists because they commit political violence, now we're being told that they're not political, which means that they can't be terrorists by definition. Which is it?

It is possible for two people to hold mutually-exclusive opinions.
 
So did Hitler. If only someone had stopped him before he rose to power.

They did, remember? Put him in prison and everything.

The problem was that Weimar Germany was in the throes of socioeconomic collapse, and simultaneously in the middle of the fascist/socialist revolutionary spasm that had gripped much of Europe at the time.

So you have a region where the central government is weak, and the institutions that normally curb political excess are in tatters. At the same time, you have revolutionary mobs in the streets, exploiting the weakness of the government to lay down their own law with their fists.

The only people who were really in a position to stop Hitler at that point were the other Nazis, whom Hitler purged to avoid that very thing, and the Communists. And as we have seen wherever the Communists did win their revolutionary street fights, that cure was just as bad as the disease.

Historically, there are two things that stop fascists: Stable governments and prosperous societies, whose citizens are not particularly receptive to the fascist gospel of strength through unity and purity; and Communists, who preach the same gospel, use the same techniqes, and depend on the same social breakdown.

That's one of the subtler nuances of the antifa tantrums in Berkeley. They weren't defending anyone against violence. They weren't even just assaulting people preaching violence. A lot of what went on in Berkeley was "anti-fascists" attacking innocent bystanders and trashing local businesses. In Berkeley. That's not anti-fascism, that's anti-society. It's creating exactly the kind of societal breakdown that these violent revolutionaries thrive in.

In which these violent revolutionaries thrive.
 
So, the guys who go on and on about degeneracy and whoreishness in society and who want to remove women's rights and lock them in houses are happy to use Tinder? :boggled:

Jesus christ, somebody help me, the cognitive dissonance and irony is suffocating.

I still don't understand this movement.

A whore is a women who won't sleep with them. If they were getting laid, they'd have no problem with promiscuous women. That's the short answer.
Repeated failures on the romantic market is an indication that society is broken. Introspection is not an option for these types.
 
Last edited:
Are libelous personal attacks like this persuasive to anyone? Do they serve some other purpose?

Personal gratification.

It is starting to make sense: Andy Ngo isn't a real journalist, he is "fake news" and an "enemy of the people" and something "ought to be done about it". Also Jews and Asians we don't like are NAZIs.
You're right theprestige, the milkshake apologists are unsurprisingly head clubbing apologists.

Well, they were punching apologists before that so it's no surprise.

I disagree. Leftists not engaging in this sort of violence only means they become victims, because the right sure as hell won't stop.

Ah, there we have it. That's at least two posters here who espouse the idea that the US has become a Mad Max, lawless wasteland and that they need to go extra-judicial to save their civilisation.

Gee, who does that remind me of? Oh yeah, Nazis!
 
Leftists don't defend themselves. Leftists aren't victims. Leftists engage in violence because their ideology requires them to engage in violence. Killing millions of my fellow citizens cannot happen without violence and killing billions of my fellow citizens is the heart and soul of socialist philosophy--it's what socialism is all about. That is why demonstrations where antifa show up always end in bloodshed.

Chill out, dude. Smearing "the left" by lumping them together with the worst of them isn't any better than them calling all right-wingers "Nazis".

Nazis, see, can only be card-carrying members of Hitler's National Socialists.

Weren't you the one arguing about the capitalisation of the A in Antifa?

"Authoritarian" doesn't simply mean that they are an authority. And the fact that the state has a monopoly on violence doesn't mean that that's always their go-to tool. Unless you want to take some weird anarchist view of all states being illegitimate, then there's clearly a difference between states in regards to both how controlling they are and how violent they are.

I'm continually amazed at how often such basic things have to be explained to grown adults on this forum.
 
People always speak of this is hushed tones like it's an opinion that can only come from some totalitarian overlord, but all societies do it to some degree.

Notice what exceptions exist, however: those who post an immediate threat or danger.

In fact, it's the abhorrent views that need protection, not the popular ones.
 
I'm glad you bring it up. You know how their main opponents tried to stop Hitler and his party? Street violence. Didn't work out so well. In fact, it played right into the Nazis' hands.

Not to mention that it wasn't even about stopping Nazism as it was about stopping the competition. The Communists failed in Germany, but succeeded elsewhere, with results just as bad.

I don't want to live in a society where "antifa" gets to decide politics via street violence.

---

I don't want to live in a society where Nazis get to decide politics via street violence, either. But we all seem to agree on that point already. The problem - specifically, in this thread - is that some people still think political violence is okay, as long as it's not "Nazis" who are doing it.
 
Honor killings, subjugating women, mutilating genitalia, homophobia, hell, even human sacrifice must be celebrated in a multicultural utiopia. Only small minded bigots would disagree.

Those are all conservative values.
 
Until this thread, I didn’t think that violence was widely seen as an acceptable response to speech.



Bunch of violent authoritarians on this forum
Then you don't know much about Nazis. They have always used violence to silence those they don't want to have speech.
 
In fact, it's the abhorrent views that need protection, not the popular ones.


Well, no, it's the unpopular views that need protection. Advocating for mass murder of "undesirables" or child rape are, or at least should be, beyond the pale in any truly civilized society. Advocating for or inciting harm should not be tolerated any more than causing harm.

I'm glad you bring it up. You know how their main opponents tried to stop Hitler and his party? Street violence. Didn't work out so well. In fact, it played right into the Nazis' hands.


No, that's not quite how it worked. The brawls were not just between Nazis and communists, and no particular party had the upper hand prior to the Nazi gaining power. Further, Ernst Röhm's brownshirts did not limit their violence to communists, but also attacked Jews, Romani, and trade unionists, none of whom were actively involved in street fighting. The Nazis were even less popular with the public than the communists were.

And far from turning people off, the communists were gaining power in the German federal government, and popularity with German workers. Which is why the hard-right-leaning Hindenburg appointed the minority Nazi party's head, Adolph Hitler, as chancellor; in order to form a majority bloc to opposed the communists.

Even that wasn't enough to stem the growing communist popularity. It took the engineering of the Reichstag fire and manufacturing of a communist scapegoat to convince Hindenburg to suspend civil rights and order a mass-arrest of communists and other undesirables.

Again, it wasn't street fighting, but the growing popularity of the communists and their political presence in the German parliament, that was the reason for Hindenburg to engineer the Nazi party's rise to power.

Not to mention that it wasn't even about stopping Nazism as it was about stopping the competition. The Communists failed in Germany, but succeeded elsewhere, with results just as bad.

I don't want to live in a society where "antifa" gets to decide politics via street violence.

---

I don't want to live in a society where Nazis get to decide politics via street violence, either. But we all seem to agree on that point already. The problem - specifically, in this thread - is that some people still think political violence is okay, as long as it's not "Nazis" who are doing it.


Question, are you a strict pacifist? If not, then you accept that some political violence is justified.

As for deciding politics by street violence, we already live in such a society. That's the problem. Fascists and white nationalists have been getting away with advocating and committing street violence for quite some time now, and the federal government has strongly indicated that they do not intend to do anything about the problem, to the point of purging terrorism lists of white supremacist organizations.

If it wasn't for the government condoning, tacitly or openly, the activities of these fascist white nationalist groups, defensive direct action against them wouldn't be needed.
 
Antifa in Berkeley and Portland have a lot in common with the early days of Mussolini's blackshirts (copied by Hitler with his brownshirts). If they don't know this, it just means they're uneducated or stupid or both. I'm going with "both".
 
Well, no, it's the unpopular views that need protection.

No, Belz is right. It's unpopular to say Nickelback is a great band, but nobody really cares. It's abhorent to say that transwomen are not women, or that transwomen are women, or that abortion is murder, or that abortion is a fundamental right, etc. There is no objective measure of what's abhorent, and not everything is abhorent to everyone. But it's the views that somebody finds abhorent which they try to ban.

Advocating for or inciting harm should not be tolerated any more than causing harm.

Inciting illegal action is already illegal. And "harm" is too vague a term to have any use here. Some people claim harm from statements that reasonable people don't consider harmful. Some forms of harm are perfectly acceptable. Lose a subsidy on your Prius because of tax reform? That's harm. Your taxes were raised to pay for someon'e Prius tax credit? That's harm. We don't need to keep people from advocating for these things.
 
Well, no, it's the unpopular views that need protection.

Well, abhorrent views tend to be unpopular.

Advocating for mass murder of "undesirables" or child rape are, or at least should be, beyond the pale in any truly civilized society.

Good news: it is. But beyond the pale and illegal are different things. Nazis are already pariahs pretty much everywhere, for good reason. My concern is interpreting edgelords and hard-right folks are Nazis just to make it easier to lump them up with the actual monsters and justify violence against them.

Also, views are not actions. I don't think the former should be illegal, ever.

No, that's not quite how it worked. The brawls were not just between Nazis and communists, and no particular party had the upper hand prior to the Nazi gaining power.

I said nothing about it being just between these two, so I don't know what argument you think you're addressing. As for the rest, assuming you're correct, it makes all of the other arguments irrelevant as well, don't you think? If the Nazi's rise to power was a ploy to counter the growing power of the communists, then it has nothing to do with their ideology not being met with violence, rather than said violence being ineffective.
 
Nazism is a widely-accepted ideology? News to me.

Isn't it? It certainly extends across the pond, and I'd dare to say it's global.

On a vague internet search I got numbers between 11-24 million Americans have "alt-right" beliefs. If there are more people globally, we can even say that many for the rest of the entire globe. It would be in the 20-50 million people range. That's quite a few.

Depends on your definition of "accepted". I would say, yes, though. It is a widely-accepted ideology. Getting to be more that way as of lately.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom