In fact, it's the abhorrent views that need protection, not the popular ones.
Well, no, it's the
unpopular views that need protection. Advocating for mass murder of "undesirables" or child rape are, or at least should be, beyond the pale in any truly civilized society. Advocating for or inciting harm should not be tolerated any more than causing harm.
I'm glad you bring it up. You know how their main opponents tried to stop Hitler and his party? Street violence. Didn't work out so well. In fact, it played right into the Nazis' hands.
No, that's not quite how it worked. The brawls were not just between Nazis and communists, and no particular party had the upper hand prior to the Nazi gaining power. Further, Ernst Röhm's brownshirts did not limit their violence to communists, but also attacked Jews, Romani, and trade unionists, none of whom were actively involved in street fighting. The Nazis were even less popular with the public than the communists were.
And far from turning people off, the communists were gaining power in the German federal government, and popularity with German workers. Which is why the hard-right-leaning Hindenburg appointed the minority Nazi party's head, Adolph Hitler, as chancellor; in order to form a majority bloc to opposed the communists.
Even that wasn't enough to stem the growing communist popularity. It took the engineering of the Reichstag fire and manufacturing of a communist scapegoat to convince Hindenburg to suspend civil rights and order a mass-arrest of communists and other undesirables.
Again, it wasn't street fighting, but the growing popularity of the communists and their political presence in the German parliament, that was the reason for Hindenburg to engineer the Nazi party's rise to power.
Not to mention that it wasn't even about stopping Nazism as it was about stopping the competition. The Communists failed in Germany, but succeeded elsewhere, with results just as bad.
I don't want to live in a society where "antifa" gets to decide politics via street violence.
---
I don't want to live in a society where Nazis get to decide politics via street violence, either. But we all seem to agree on that point already. The problem - specifically, in this thread - is that some people still think political violence is okay, as long as it's not "Nazis" who are doing it.
Question, are you a strict pacifist? If not, then you accept that some political violence is justified.
As for deciding politics by street violence, we already live in such a society. That's the problem. Fascists and white nationalists have been getting away with advocating and committing street violence for quite some time now, and the federal government has strongly indicated that they do not intend to do anything about the problem, to the point of purging terrorism lists of white supremacist organizations.
If it wasn't for the government condoning, tacitly or openly, the activities of these fascist white nationalist groups, defensive direct action against them wouldn't be needed.