Journalist attacked by violent mob

No. I didn't give it as my definition, or ANYONE ELSE's definition, of fascism. I gave them as relevant qualities of two groups under consideration. Right-wing fascists have those qualities, but they may not suffice to define fascism, and I didn't claim they did. I didn't even claim anyone else did either.

What you literally said was this:
And the relevant meaning that people were trying to convey with the word fascist is an authoritarian and violence-prone group.

So unless you want to quibble over the distinction between "the relevant meaning conveyed by the word X" and "the definition of the word X" that constitutes you giving it as a - someone else's - definition of the word "fascism."

I'm merely pointing out that both people on the far right AND the far left have these qualities.

Then surely you would have no issue with me additionally pointing out that people on the center, center-left, and center-right do so as well.
 
What you literally said was this:


So unless you want to quibble over the distinction between "the relevant meaning conveyed by the word X" and "the definition of the word X" that constitutes you giving it as a - someone else's - definition of the word "fascism."

It's not a quibble. It's very common for people to use a word then they want to convey part of the definition of the word, but possibly not the entire definition. That's often how language actually gets used.
 
It's not a quibble. It's very common for people to use a word then they want to convey part of the definition of the word, but possibly not the entire definition. That's often how language actually gets used.

Fine, let's call them "relevant qualities" then. Moving on, you then further made the following moral judgement:

But that doesn't mean communists aren't as bad as fascists. They are.

based on them sharing those relevant qualities. Would you then also judge centrists, center-lefts, and center-rights (presumably including yourself somewhere in there, if not then explicitly include yourself) to be "as bad as" fascists? As per the argument outlined in my previous posts, which you ignored whilst only focusing on the question of whether those relevant qualities do or do not constitute a "definition" of the word.
 
Last edited:
Would you then also judge that centrists, center-lefts, and center-rights (presumably including yourself somewhere in there, if not then explicitly include yourself) to be "as bad as" fascists?

For the most part, no, they aren't nearly as bad.

I'll even go a step further. There are even people on the far left and far right who aren't into violence or totalitarian control. But the far ends of both side is where you find most of the political evil. And the far left isn't any better than the far right in that regard.
 
For the most part, no, they aren't nearly as bad.

I'll even go a step further. There are even people on the far left and far right who aren't into violence or totalitarian control. But the far ends of both side is where you find most of the political evil. And the far left isn't any better than the far right in that regard.

You're asserting, not arguing. If communists are "as bad as" fascists because of sharing those "relevant qualities" then why isn't the rest of the political spectrum "as bad as" fascists if they also share those "relevant qualities"?
 
You're asserting, not arguing.

You asked me for my judgment, not my reasoning. I gave it to you.

If communists are "as bad as" fascists because of sharing those "relevant qualities"

Plus, you know, their actual history of killing even more people than fascists ever did.

then why isn't the rest of the political spectrum "as bad as" fascists if they also share those "relevant qualities"?

Because they don't. You're taking a deliberately superficial interpretation of my words which obviously doesn't match the actual intent of my posts in order to make some stupid bull **** argument which has no point and no place in this thread, for no reason comprehensible to anyone else but you.
 
Plus, you know, their actual history of killing even more people than fascists ever did.

Well in that case liberal democracies should definitely be "as bad as" fascists because of their actual history of killing even more people than either fascists or communists.

Because they don't. You're taking a deliberately superficial interpretation of my words which obviously doesn't match the actual intent of my posts in order to make some stupid bull **** argument which has no point and no place in this thread, for no reason comprehensible to anyone else but you.

You're more than free to make your argument and have been all this time. Oh and, if you hold that arguments that communists are "as bad as" fascists because of sharing certain qualities have a point and place in this thread, as you seem to do, judging by you making these arguments in this very thread, then you can hardly claim that it would have no point and no place in this thread to argue the same for other parts of the political spectrum.

Have you considered that going on rants rather than substantively engaging with any of the points made may be due to cognitive dissonance, in particular regarding the moral high ground you've asserted for yourself in relation to luchog with respect to the "actually excusing actual violence" point, which may be found baseless if it turns out you can not argue that your reference to "legitimate vs illegitimate violence" constitutes anything else but merely one form such "actual excuse for actual violence" can take?
 
Last edited:
Change the names Fascists, communist, Trump Voters, right or left wing to Christians, Jews, Muslims, or any other religious group and it reads the same. Those heretics don't believe in my one true god, they don't deserve to live!
 
Hell, to win this particular discussion, all we have to do is to point out how many people Nazis have killed in the US in the last year versus how many people Antifa have killed. Really puts the lie to their handwringing.

And how many people cops (and other such parts of the state) have killed.
 
Change the names Fascists, communist, Trump Voters, right or left wing to Christians, Jews, Muslims, or any other religious group and it reads the same. Those heretics don't believe in my one true god, they don't deserve to live!

That's actually a good example of a difference between communists and fascists, and a defining feature of fascism, even if one were to cherry pick for communism the worst excesses made by any states calling themselves socialist. Fascists would essentialize ("you don't deserve to live because you are, in essence, X") and hence show the behaviour of, for example, killing children. The socialist states didn't but rather considered it as a problem of education (Gulags were re-education facilities, education through (forced) labour) and hence did not show such behaviour.
 
Gulags were schools 'eh? Not a place for reaping the benefits of slave labor in obscene, inhumane conditions? It is worse than I thought.
 
Gulags were schools 'eh? Not a place for reaping the benefits of slave labor in obscene, inhumane conditions? It is worse than I thought.

Nah, you're thinking of the American prison system. In the Gulag system, though forced to do labour, inmates were paid the same wages as other workers. Besides, if it were just a place for reaping the benefits of slave labour then you'd sentence your inmates to more than on average 4 years, you'd at least sentence them to more than 5 years, like the American liberal democracy does.

Either way, it remains demonstrably the case that your analogy of "you don't deserve to live because you don't hold a certain belief" doesn't apply to fascists but may, again if one were cherry picking the worst excesses of any states calling themselves socialist, apply to communists.
 
Death rates:
According to Nicolas Werth, author of The Black Book of Communism, the yearly mortality rate in the Soviet concentration camps strongly varied, reaching 5% (1933) and 20% (1942–1943) while dropping considerably in the post-war years (about 1 to 3% per year at the beginning of the 1950s).[5][6] The emergent consensus among scholars who utilize official archival data is that of the 18 million who were sent to the Gulag from 1930 to 1953, roughly 1.5 to 1.7 million perished there or as a result of their detention.[7][8][9] However, some historians question the reliability of such data and instead rely heavily on literary sources come to higher estimations.[7][10] Archival researchers have found "no plan of destruction" of the gulag population and no statement of official intent to kill them, and prisoner releases vastly exceeded the number of deaths in the Gulag.[7]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag


The Bureau of Justice Statistics estimates that 17,358 individuals in custody died during the period from 2007-2010.[13] Other publications focus on the rate per 100,000. US jails report deaths that total a mortality rate of 128, and prisons at 264 per 100,000.[14] There are differences in methodology used to obtain these statistics, as some jurisdictions include deaths during attempted arrests, while others do not


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_...ion_of_custody


A lot of deaths for a school system vs. a prison system.
 
Death rates:
According to Nicolas Werth, author of The Black Book of Communism, the yearly mortality rate in the Soviet concentration camps strongly varied, reaching 5% (1933) and 20% (1942–1943) while dropping considerably in the post-war years (about 1 to 3% per year at the beginning of the 1950s).[5][6] The emergent consensus among scholars who utilize official archival data is that of the 18 million who were sent to the Gulag from 1930 to 1953, roughly 1.5 to 1.7 million perished there or as a result of their detention.[7][8][9] However, some historians question the reliability of such data and instead rely heavily on literary sources come to higher estimations.[7][10] Archival researchers have found "no plan of destruction" of the gulag population and no statement of official intent to kill them, and prisoner releases vastly exceeded the number of deaths in the Gulag.[7]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag


The Bureau of Justice Statistics estimates that 17,358 individuals in custody died during the period from 2007-2010.[13] Other publications focus on the rate per 100,000. US jails report deaths that total a mortality rate of 128, and prisons at 264 per 100,000.[14] There are differences in methodology used to obtain these statistics, as some jurisdictions include deaths during attempted arrests, while others do not


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_...ion_of_custody


A lot of deaths for a school system vs. a prison system.

Oh but I agree that the Gulags were the Soviet prison system, they were not the Soviet school system, never said otherwise.

It's not clear what point you're trying to make. Are you arguing that the Soviet prison system wasn't based on the principle of re-education? Are you aware that the author you refer to, Werth, has stated that one of the clearest differences between the USSR and Nazi Germany was the absence of death camps in the former? This would further call your analogy of "you don't deserve to live because you don't believe X" in doubt, along with the fact that fascists would kill people on account of who they are and not just on account of what they believed in.

ETA: Have you noticed that the high mortality rates you refer to are either during a devastating nation-wide famine (1933) or during the devastation of the second world war? Outside of that they are within an order of magnitude of the numbers in the American prison system, and that's not considering the problem of comparing mortality rates in the 1940s-50s with those of today (for example differences in medical ability may have made things like outbreaks of infectious diseases more lethal). What is not within an order of magnitude is the wage received by American inmates relative to the minimum wage outside of prison, whereas for the Soviet prison system inmates received about equal pay as minimum wage workers, so if anything you'd have a better case for declaring the American prison system a "place for reaping the benefits of slave labor" than the Soviet one.
 
Last edited:
Not all fascists had death camps. Exterminating the undesirables was the Hitlerite perversion.

If Hitler had simply been willing to re-educate, he might actually have established a thousand year Reich. Probably not, but also he probably wouldn't have done much worse than International Socialism. Which is already pretty bad.

Spain and Italy never had death camps worth mentioning, in their fascist phases.

Stop conflating Nazism with fascism. It's at least as much uniquely Hitlerism, as it is anything else.
 
Hell, to win this particular discussion, all we have to do is to point out how many people Nazis have killed in the US in the last year versus how many people Antifa have killed. Really puts the lie to their handwringing.

Wow, antifa has killed less people than their NAZI opponents have. Now that is a super important and impressive data point! How bad is antifa in this discussion? Well lets compare and contrast them to NAZIs and now we know using that benchmark, by that comparison, they are hardly violent at all really.
I seriously don't understand that point. It makes no sense. "Hey, lets support these guys, they are less violent than NAZIs!"
 
Oh but I agree that the Gulags were the Soviet prison system, they were not the Soviet school system, never said otherwise.

It's not clear what point you're trying to make. Are you arguing that the Soviet prison system wasn't based on the principle of re-education? Are you aware that the author you refer to, Werth, has stated that one of the clearest differences between the USSR and Nazi Germany was the absence of death camps in the former? This would further call your analogy of "you don't deserve to live because you don't believe X" in doubt, along with the fact that fascists would kill people on account of who they are and not just on account of what they believed in.

ETA: Have you noticed that the high mortality rates you refer to are either during a devastating nation-wide famine (1933) or during the devastation of the second world war? Outside of that they are within an order of magnitude of the numbers in the American prison system, and that's not considering the problem of comparing mortality rates in the 1940s-50s with those of today (for example differences in medical ability may have made things like outbreaks of infectious diseases more lethal). What is not within an order of magnitude is the wage received by American inmates relative to the minimum wage outside of prison, whereas for the Soviet prison system inmates received about equal pay as minimum wage workers, so if anything you'd have a better case for declaring the American prison system a "place for reaping the benefits of slave labor" than the Soviet one.
Look at you defending the Gulags. How cute!
 
Bret Weinstein supported Bernie Sanders over Clinton, describes his politics as "progressive" and has never voted Republican. What are you trying to say when you describe him as "right wing"

Well, oops, I was wrong.

I'm asking you what's in the video. That's a common request. Long videos should have some explication. What is proved/proven in the video. What new insights does it offer.

WHY WOULD I WANT TO VIEW IT?
 
Bret Weinstein supported Bernie Sanders over Clinton, describes his politics as "progressive" and has never voted Republican. What are you trying to say when you describe him as "right wing"


Bret Weinstein, despite having a somewhat left-leaning past, has spent the last few years cozying up to the first circle of hard-right pundits. Rather than being a true progressive, his political leanings have always been more libertarian, starting from left-libertarian, and have been steadily creeping farther to the right since the Obama administration.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom