Journalist attacked by violent mob

Wow, antifa has killed less people than their NAZI opponents have. Now that is a super important and impressive data point! How bad is antifa in this discussion? Well lets compare and contrast them to NAZIs and now we know using that benchmark, by that comparison, they are hardly violent at all really.
I seriously don't understand that point. It makes no sense. "Hey, lets support these guys, they are less violent than NAZIs!"


Tell you what, why don't you tell us just how many people antifa activists have killed. I would, but so far I haven't been able to find a single death as the result of direct action by antifa activism in the last decade.

In contrast, there were forty-nine killed by one single fascist white supremacist in one single country alone, just this year. There were fifty such murders in 2018, and in the last decade, that number is well into the hundreds.

Really puts all those "violent" eggings and milkshakings in perspective, doesn't it. Apparently, the type of violence is just as important as the number of incidents.
 
Well, oops, I was wrong.

I'm asking you what's in the video. That's a common request. Long videos should have some explication. What is proved/proven in the video. What new insights does it offer.

WHY WOULD I WANT TO VIEW IT?

Thank you. Truly. I get frustrated when people try to brand everybody they don't like or don't agree with a blanket statement.
 
Bret Weinstein, despite having a somewhat left-leaning past, has spent the last few years cozying up to the first circle of hard-right pundits. Rather than being a true progressive, his political leanings have always been more libertarian, starting from left-libertarian, and have been steadily creeping farther to the right since the Obama administration.

Isn't this a No true Scotsman? He votes progressive. He describes his politics as progressive. For sure, he has found a new audience after leaving Evergreen but I hardly see him as anything but a liberal.
 
Zero.

Why are we contrasting antifa to the worst and most violent people in our society? What is the purpose of that? You need to raise the bar.

These comparisons aren't being pulled out of thin air. This thread is replete with thinking conservatives pointing out that lefties on the antifa side are more violent by far than those on the right, and that this brutal attack is but one example. The counter-evidence is being offered in lieu of those ridiculous smoke-blowing defenses of the noble extreme right. The facts don't support their clownish argumentation but that matters not; they'll just take a deep breath and repeat the same accusations again and again.

That someone counters with the actual evidence showing them to be wrong? Well, that's their fault. They started it! :D
 
These comparisons aren't being pulled out of thin air. This thread is replete with thinking conservatives pointing out that lefties on the antifa side are more violent by far than those on the right, and that this brutal attack is but one example. The counter-evidence is being offered in lieu of those ridiculous smoke-blowing defenses of the noble extreme right. The facts don't support their clownish argumentation but that matters not; they'll just take a deep breath and repeat the same accusations again and again.

That someone counters with the actual evidence showing them to be wrong? Well, that's their fault. They started it! :D

any conservatives painting the antifa side more violent is absurd in the extreme. This is a stupid game to play. I like what Ricky Gervais had to say in a series of tweets.
Ricky Gervais has written some cool tweets about this:
Opposing left wing extremism doesn't mean you support right wing extremism. Opposing right wing extremism doesn't mean you support left wing extremism. You're allowed to hate all extremism. There are loads of other choices. Also, stop wasting milk.
and
It's interesting that the people who believe that throwing a milkshake in someone's face shouldn't be considered assault are often the same people who believe that 'saying things' should be.
and
Whatever side you're on politically, 'left' or 'right', you don't need violent factions joining you or representing you. They bring your cause into disrepute. They don't even care about your cause, they're just in it for the violence. Denounce them.

If I criticize antifa, that isn't an endorsement of NAZIsm or the proud boys or of the patriot prayers or of the 3 percenters. I ******* hate these people and so does everybody I know. It is only in Antifa that I run into apologists and sympathizers and so I feel compelled to say something about it. It doesn't matter that the others are worse. So what?
 
If I criticize antifa, that isn't an endorsement of NAZIsm or the proud boys or of the patriot prayers or of the 3 percenters. I ******* hate these people and so does everybody I know. It is only in Antifa that I run into apologists and sympathizers and so I feel compelled to say something about it. It doesn't matter that the others are worse. So what?

This.
 
Look at you defending the Gulags. How cute!

You should've just said from the start that you were intending to troll and not to have any sort of serious discussion, would've saved me the trouble of looking up the data.

ETA: Oh and, if we're going down this route anyway: "Look at you defending the Nazis. How cute!" (the source you referred to, the "Black Book of Communism", is one long text of Nazi apologia, for example including SS guards killed in Dachau during an escape attempt by Soviet prisoners as "victims of communism")
 
Last edited:
Not all fascists had death camps. Exterminating the undesirables was the Hitlerite perversion.

If Hitler had simply been willing to re-educate, he might actually have established a thousand year Reich. Probably not, but also he probably wouldn't have done much worse than International Socialism. Which is already pretty bad.

Spain and Italy never had death camps worth mentioning, in their fascist phases.

Stop conflating Nazism with fascism. It's at least as much uniquely Hitlerism, as it is anything else.
Nazis were fascists so if you want an example of an actual "by the book" fascist movement gaining power and behaving as their claimed ideology said to behave then they are a very useful example.

Could you give me an example of a fascist movement that gained power and was a relatively good state?
 
Not all violence is created equal, some is imbued with righteousness, and defended as same
 
Last edited:
Couldn't help noticing the sound of crickets when I mentioned Eric Clanton, the part-time instructor in "philosophy and ethics" and who enjoyed spending some of his (doubtlessly ample) spare time in 'black-bloc' Antifa attire smashing the aforementioned "fascists" over the head with a 2 kg u-lock.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muoR8Td44UE

https://www.berkeleyside.com/2017/0...ally-assaults-criticizes-police-investigation

Plenty of discussion on the web at the time, but here's a random comment that puts it as well as any;

What school of thought would an ethics instructor ascribe to if they believed "if I disagree with your politics then I am obliged to fracture your skull"?


ETA >> I challenge anyone to find an example of a leftist/liberal/progressive even criticising Clanton, let alone denouncing him. He skated away from the felony assault charges brought against him with 3 years probation. To be honest, given SoCal law-enforcement's form in enabling maggots like him, I was actually surprised the charges were brought at all.
 
Last edited:
You should've just said from the start that you were intending to troll and not to have any sort of serious discussion, would've saved me the trouble of looking up the data.
You try telling me Gulags were for re-education knowing full well they worked people to death for the crime of not thinking right and you are good with that? I'm not trolling, just showing your lack of credibility and dishonesty. You did it all yourself. Your violence is good and those people deserved to be hurt, right?


How can here be a serious discussion when you defend the undefendable?
 
You try telling me Gulags were for re-education knowing full well they worked people to death for the crime of not thinking right and you are good with that? I'm not trolling, just showing your lack of credibility and dishonesty. You did it all yourself. Your violence is good and those people deserved to be hurt, right?


How can here be a serious discussion when you defend the undefendable?

If they "worked people to death" then how come the sentences were so short and almost everyone was reintegrated in society after having served their sentences (only a small minority of inmates died in the Gulags)? If they were intending the facilities to be used for extracting value from slave labour then why did they pay the inmates wages comparable to minimum wages of other workers?

But these points have already been raised and you have not addressed them. The fact that you use a widely discredited source filled with Nazi apologia (the Black Book of Communism) also says a lot about your, in the best case, utter ignorance of the facts or, in the worst case, your political bias. Telling me about my "lack of credibility and dishonesty" has got to be one of the most ironic comments I've read in a while. All you're basically doing is repeating your assertions ad nauseam whilst ignoring any of the data that refutes them.

I hence remain of the opinion that you are simply trolling because it's the only thing you have left after your ignorance of the facts had been exposed. Did you know about the wage structure of the Gulag system? Did you know about the dynamics of the mortality rates refuting your claim of "being worked to the death"? Did you know about the sentencing statistics showing that most sentences were very short (less than 4 years)? Did you know about the sentencing statistics showing that only a small minority was sentenced to the Gulags for political crimes and most were sentenced, as in any other country with a prison system, for crimes such as theft and other things? No of course you didn't, why bother gathering any data when you can just argue out of ignorance? Maybe you should read your own signature line.
 
Zero.

Why are we contrasting antifa to the worst and most violent people in our society? What is the purpose of that? You need to raise the bar.

As someone said on twitter, you can't look in a mirror and say "Nazis suck" three times without someone popping up to ask, "What about antifa?"
 
Today I learned the gulags were just really tough and competitive schools.

I just... can't...



I don't think we need to go to such extremes in order to discuss the current happenings in the United States. The Nazis (current and past) were/are very, very bad. The gulags were also very, very bad. Most of the time, when one group decides to lock another group up for wrongthink, things have gotten very, very bad.
 
Last edited:
What absolute rubbish. Aggressors justify their aggression by claiming that it's actually "self defense". They seek out these conflicts and instigate them. What they don't seem to understand is that their own actions, their own "resistance" fuels the very thing they claim to oppose. You think attacking Andy Ngo was a propaganda victory for antifa or for the so-called fascists?

Ngo has repeatedly used his work to provide target lists for aggressively violent groups in the past, in at least one case without bothering to verify that the people he pointed out were at all aligned with Antifa. Given this, I think it's reasonable to think "It's worth the 'PR loss' to beat him badly enough to get him to stop putting innocent people in danger." I'm not saying I agree, but I'm not too sure that I disagree, either. Remember, he was ready to record them right there, right then, and the police will stop neither him, nor his aggressively violent pals.

Sometimes, the best way to deal with a bully is to whip him with a bicycle chain until he spends the rest of high school trying to stay away from you. Would a just society provide a better option? Doesn't matter if you live in a badly flawed one, like the US.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom