Journalist attacked by violent mob

What ideology does Antifa have, though?

This is the main problem you're running into - "Antifa" isn't any sort of organization with a list of policies, a leadership, and so forth. They're just anyone who works against fascism. That's it. There's a major difference between the Black Bloc anarchists, are are definitely into destroying property and will attack Proud Boys, red hats, etc. on sight, Black Lives Matter, the nonviolent group that works through protest, voting drives, and so forth - and various online groups who work via doxxing, educational videos, and so forth. And yes, lone actors will often jump in as well.

And yet they are all morally equivalent to white supremacists in the eyes of so many here.
 
And yet they are all morally equivalent to white supremacists in the eyes of so many here.

I'm not willing to give their illiberal tactics a pass just because they aren't literally as bad as nazis.

There's a spectrum of illiberalism, in which Nazis and Antifa are not equal. Both are well passed the point of acceptability. The special alarm I hold for antifa is entirely due to the disturbing fact that so many are willing to treat their illiberal violence as acceptable, including those in positions of power tasked to stop them.

So yeah, getting clubbed in the head is better than being gunned down in a synagogue or run over by a car. We shouldn't pretend getting clubbed in the head is an acceptable outcome just because it isn't literally the worst thing possible.
 
Last edited:
And yet they are all morally equivalent to white supremacists in the eyes of so many here.

It's actually really easy to take a stance against direct action political violence without looking like a Nazi apologist. Here's how it's done:

"I appreciate that you have taken upon yourself to help solve the problem with white supremacy and Nazism, but I think you are hindering progress instead of helping it when you attack Nazis in the street. The police are there to help people who are attacked by the Nazis, and you don't need to do that."

I don't agree with the above, but it ought to encapsulate the feelings of those that don't agree with political violence and also don't agree with Fascism. Instead we get "Antifa are just like the Nazis hurr hurr", which is straight out of the alt-right playbook.
 
I'm not willing to give their illiberal tactics a pass just because they aren't literally as bad as nazis.

There's a spectrum of illiberalism, in which Nazis and Antifa are not equal. Both are well passed the point of acceptability. The special alarm I hold for antifa is entirely due to the disturbing fact that so many are willing to treat their illiberal violence as acceptable, including those in positions of power tasked to stop them.

So yeah, getting clubbed in the head is better than being gunned down in a synagogue or run over by a car. We shouldn't pretend getting clubbed in the head is an acceptable outcome just because it isn't literally the worst thing possible.

And of course the non violent ones like BLM are just as bad as the violent ones too. Why photographing nazi events and doxing the attendees is clearly just as bad as hitting someone with a club.
 
It's actually really easy to take a stance against direct action political violence without looking like a Nazi apologist. Here's how it's done:

"I appreciate that you have taken upon yourself to help solve the problem with white supremacy and Nazism, but I think you are hindering progress instead of helping it when you attack Nazis in the street. The police are there to help people who are attacked by the Nazis, and you don't need to do that."

I don't agree with the above, but it ought to encapsulate the feelings of those that don't agree with political violence and also don't agree with Fascism. Instead we get "Antifa are just like the Nazis hurr hurr", which is straight out of the alt-right playbook.

The problem is that antifa isn't just those being willing to use violent methods. And reducing all those who are part of it as such is a horrible generalization. It helps fit into the idea that the death of Heather Heyer was justified because she was part of the violent antifa attack on them.
 
The problem is that antifa isn't just those being willing to use violent methods. And reducing all those who are part of it as such is a horrible generalization. It helps fit into the idea that the death of Heather Heyer was justified because she was part of the violent antifa attack on them.

That's true, and you can note that I didn't say "Antifa" in my attempt at a suggestion. However, the US political system is so obsessed with labels that it simply doesn't sink in what Antifa means.

Maybe I can try an analogy? Antifa is like Football. It's something you do. The New York Giants is a football club, analogous to a local chapter who calls themselves Antifa.

Does that make sense?
 
Only in Portland is there a life-and-death struggle of illberial leftism vs neo-fascism, where one must pick sides to avoid being clubbed. In the civilized world, where the police haven't surrendered the streets to thuggery, participation in the public square remains a protected right.

Portland is the poster-child for the exact wrong way to handle these highly charged protests.


I would agree with this, except for the fact that it's not just Portland where the police have ceded the streets to the Nazis and brawlers. Police in too many cities have been far too willing to let the fascist white supremacists stomp around unopposed, and in some cases have openly sympathized with them. That's why Charlottesville happened, the police chose to do nearly nothing effective to halt the clear and present threat that a bunch of armed fascist thugs comprised; not even when those thugs started beating unarmed, non-violent protesters. It wasn't until the antifa direct-action groups intervened to oppose the fascists that the police started to get involved in a meaningful way.

And that's the problem overall. If the police were actually there as a neutral presence to protect the people, then we wouldn't be seeing the violent resistance from antifa groups. But they're not, and never have been. Portland police are among the most openly racist, but nearly all PDs across the country have a problem with racism and far-right sympathies.
 
And of course the non violent ones like BLM are just as bad as the violent ones too. Why photographing nazi events and doxing the attendees is clearly just as bad as hitting someone with a club.


It isn't that long ago that Black Lives Matter activists were being called terrorists simply for existing and non-violently protesting against racist police violence and policy. As far as the far-right is concerned, a "terrorist" is anyone who opposes their worldview.
 
I would agree with this, except for the fact that it's not just Portland where the police have ceded the streets to the Nazis and brawlers. Police in too many cities have been far too willing to let the fascist white supremacists stomp around unopposed, and in some cases have openly sympathized with them. That's why Charlottesville happened, the police chose to do nearly nothing effective to halt the clear and present threat that a bunch of armed fascist thugs comprised; not even when those thugs started beating unarmed, non-violent protesters. It wasn't until the antifa direct-action groups intervened to oppose the fascists that the police started to get involved in a meaningful way.

And that's the problem overall. If the police were actually there as a neutral presence to protect the people, then we wouldn't be seeing the violent resistance from antifa groups. But they're not, and never have been. Portland police are among the most openly racist, but nearly all PDs across the country have a problem with racism and far-right sympathies.

Sure, plenty of police departments have mishandled these very charged political protests and counterprotests. Plenty of these police departments have strong right-wing and racist affinities. The tactics of the police at Charlottesville has a lot to answer for allowing such extreme escalation to occur prior to the death of Heyer.

The solution is not to abandon all hope for peaceful protest. Public pressure is being put on these departments. Charlottesville did very poorly on the day, but in the aftermath was shamed into acting appropriately. Those goons that beat Harris in the parking garage were identified, arrested, and prosecuted, though initially it seemed they might escape all justice due to disinterest by the police. Chris "the crying Nazi" Cantwell plead guilty and was banished from the state for 5 years. Four white supremacists were charged with rioting. The KKK man who discharged a firearm was arrested aand sentenced to 4 years prison. All of these things occurred, despite the original inclination of the police to do nothing (or, in the case of Harris, to pursue the victims). Public pressure works.

My reading is that most cities have learned how to appropriately respond. There is a reason that Portland is the repeat venue for these clashes, and that reason is that Portland is one of the few cities where these clashes can occur without interference by the police. They have refused to learn the lessons of the violent clashes.
 
Last edited:
Sure, plenty of police departments have mishandled these very charged political protests and counterprotests. Plenty of these police departments have strong right-wing and racist affinities. The tactics of the police at Charlottesville has a lot to answer for allowing such extreme escalation to occur prior to the death of Heyer.

The solution is not to abandon all hope for peaceful protest. Public pressure is being put on these departments

Yea but that doesn't matter, it isn't like public pressure can force any kind of change in the police. It takes a lot more than that to get any kind of change and there simply is no political will to reform the police.
 
Oh I get it. You live in a fantasy world where "gather support and gain legitimacy" isn't "part of the plan."

So what's the solution again? Criminalise speech we find unacceptable? How does one define what's acceptable or not in a way that doesn't come back to bite us in the ass afterwards?

I've never really had a good answer to that.
 
So what's the solution again? Criminalise speech we find unacceptable?

People always speak of this is hushed tones like it's an opinion that can only come from some totalitarian overlord, but all societies do it to some degree. No functioning concept of free speech that actually exists in the real world is absolute. I can't yell fire in a crowded theater, accuse you of something you aren't without good reason, claim to be Dutchess of York on my Passport application, or countless other things.

Suggesting that a health society does not need Nazis shouting in the streets doesn't make me a... well Nazi.

How does one define what's acceptable or not in a way that doesn't come back to bite us in the ass afterwards?

The same way we outlawed shouting fire in a crowded theater without it coming back to bite us in the ass afterwards. The same way we have slander and libel laws without destroying parody and satire. The same we have barbers who can cut your hair but not have barbers who can cut your head off.

"Okay but what if we go too far?" as an on call, open ended worry shuts down everything, all discussion and all actions forever of all time.

We can't do anything if "Okay but what if we go too far?" is allowed as a universal retort.
 
People always speak of this is hushed tones like it's an opinion that can only come from some totalitarian overlord, but all societies do it to some degree. No functioning concept of free speech that actually exists in the real world is absolute. I can't yell fire in a crowded theater, accuse you of something you aren't without good reason, claim to be Dutchess of York on my Passport application, or countless other things.

Suggesting that a health society does not need Nazis shouting in the streets doesn't make me a... well Nazi.



The same way we outlawed shouting fire in a crowded theater without it coming back to bite us in the ass afterwards. The same way we have slander and libel laws without destroying parody and satire. The same we have barbers who can cut your hair but not have barbers who can cut your head off.

"Okay but what if we go too far?" as an on call, open ended worry shuts down everything, all discussion and all actions forever of all time.

We can't do anything if "Okay but what if we go too far?" is allowed as a universal retort.

I can guarantee you that no good law will come from masked antifa and prouds boys clubbing each other in the streets. Expect an authoritarian overreach in the form of aggressive policing, prohibition of public assembly, or some other erosion of civil rights.
 
A second 2020 democratic hopeful, Eric Swalwell, has condemned the attacks:

Sadly, it seems like we need a Journalist Protection Act.

It kinda seems like it, but I actually disagree.

Journalists enjoy exactly the same right to speech and publication as every other citizen. In terms of human rights and government protections, assaulting a journalist is already against the law, because assaulting anyone is against the law.

Assault, whether political or otherwise, probably shouldn't be a federal crime, just like most common crimes aren't federal crimes.

I really don't want people to have to get on some federal "official journalist" registry, just so they can appeal to federal courts when they are assaulted. For one thing, it's redundant with existing laws and principles of civil society. For another thing, it would tend to create a false boundary between free citizen and "legitimate" journalist.

It's really frustrating to me that Andy Ngo, who has a legitimate complaint, has chosen to present that complaint in terms of "legitimate journalism" rather than in terms of "free citizen with human rights".
 
It kinda seems like it, but I actually disagree.

Journalists enjoy exactly the same right to speech and publication as every other citizen. In terms of human rights and government protections, assaulting a journalist is already against the law, because assaulting anyone is against the law.

Assault, whether political or otherwise, probably shouldn't be a federal crime, just like most common crimes aren't federal crimes.

I really don't want people to have to get on some federal "official journalist" registry, just so they can appeal to federal courts when they are assaulted. For one thing, it's redundant with existing laws and principles of civil society. For another thing, it would tend to create a false boundary between free citizen and "legitimate" journalist.

It's really frustrating to me that Andy Ngo, who has a legitimate complaint, has chosen to present that complaint in terms of "legitimate journalism" rather than in terms of "free citizen with human rights".

I agree. Again, the problem with Ngo's case isn't that beating the hell out of someone at a protest isn't illegal enough, it's that the law isn't being enforced. It doesn't matter how severe the punishment is if there is 0% chance of the police enforcing the law and making arrests, as is the case in Portland.

I also would not single out journalists for special protection. I would be ok with laws being passed to make political violence a more severe form of battery and carrying a more severe penalty. Throwing a fist a political event has much more a negative societal impact than your average bar-fight, and I would support sentences that reflect that.

Extra-legal beatings at a political event has a chilling effect on public participation in politics, and that ought to be harshly punished.
 
How does one define what's acceptable or not in a way that doesn't come back to bite us in the ass afterwards?

I've never really had a good answer to that.

By gaining total control. When you make all the decisions, the standards always work for you. Stalin pulled it off, so did Mao.
 
For the sake of sanity, compare Washington DC, whose police haven't totally abdicated their duty, to Portland.

Alt-right and antifa both showed up this weekend for a very charged protest/counterprotest, much like those in Portland. Except the police didn't let them roam the streets beating the snot out of eachother and bystanders.

Project Europa, noted white-supremacist group, made absolute fools out of themselves by screeching on stage how they got kicked off of Tinder. https://twitter.com/AlexThomasDC/status/1147529517902245888

Antifa knocked over a newsstand.

As far as I can tell, nobody got their skull cracked for daring to take a photo.



Only in Portland is there a life-and-death struggle of illberial leftism vs neo-fascism, where one must pick sides to avoid being clubbed. In the civilized world, where the police haven't surrendered the streets to thuggery, participation in the public square remains a protected right.

Portland is the poster-child for the exact wrong way to handle these highly charged protests.

So, the guys who go on and on about degeneracy and whoreishness in society and who want to remove women's rights and lock them in houses are happy to use Tinder? :boggled:

Jesus christ, somebody help me, the cognitive dissonance and irony is suffocating.

I still don't understand this movement.
 
Last edited:
The solution is not to abandon all hope for peaceful protest. Public pressure is being put on these departments. Charlottesville did very poorly on the day, but in the aftermath was shamed into acting appropriately. Those goons that beat Harris in the parking garage were identified, arrested, and prosecuted, though initially it seemed they might escape all justice due to disinterest by the police. Chris "the crying Nazi" Cantwell plead guilty and was banished from the state for 5 years. Four white supremacists were charged with rioting. The KKK man who discharged a firearm was arrested aand sentenced to 4 years prison. All of these things occurred, despite the original inclination of the police to do nothing (or, in the case of Harris, to pursue the victims). Public pressure works.


The problem with that is that this is just a handful of token prosecutions for the most extreme cases, under public pressure to take action. IIRC, at least one of these would not have even been prosecuted had it not been for the efforts of antifa activists.

Aside from those, there are literally hundreds of participants in Unite the Right; dozens of those were involved in violence against non-violent protesters, and have gotten off scot-free.

As for other cities learning from Charlottesville, well, time will tell. A few big cities have improved their handling of these events; but police responses to far-right violence are still lacking in much of the US. And since we haven't seen anything anywhere near the scale of Charlottesville since, we can't really say how much better things have gotten.

At least the ACLU has finally stopped supporting violent fascists and white supremacists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom