Journalist attacked by violent mob

So when people didn't do something, your response is simply to add: "... yet!"

I am not exaggerating when I say that, on the Alex Jones show, he and his guests this week were calling the alleged cement milkshakes "chemical weapons" and openly advocating for the start of a "kinetic" (as opposed to a cold) civil war, criminalizing Antifa, asking Trump to federalize the National Guard, and openly killing liberal journalists in the streets.
 
I am not exaggerating when I say that, on the Alex Jones show, he and his guests this week were calling the alleged cement milkshakes "chemical weapons" and openly advocating for the start of a "kinetic" (as opposed to a cold) civil war, criminalizing Antifa, asking Trump to federalize the National Guard, and openly killing liberal journalists in the streets.


Given that that kind of rhetoric has pretty much defined Alex Jones' entire broadcasting career, not seeing why it's anything noteworthy in this case.
 
Except, of course, that's been totally debunked. There were no acid- or cement-infused milkshakes. They were, in fact, vegan milkshakes that the police tried to say were cement.

Be fair though, that's an easy mistake to make.


That ... that is just soy delicious!
 
For the record, I believe that all the white-power mental defectives and the kids playing super-hero dress-up should be hung from the same tree.
 
Given that that kind of rhetoric has pretty much defined Alex Jones' entire broadcasting career, not seeing why it's anything noteworthy in this case.

It's significant to me in that AJ and his fellow travelers have been crusading against federal power since the Clinton administration, and this week he had a guest calling on Trump to "federalize" the National Guard from border states and AJ agreed with him. Also the overt calls for violence are coming fast and furious lately.
 
Depends what you mean by the word, I guess. But there are certainly left wingers with ideologies which are just as violent, just as controlling, just as destructive, as just as evil as any fascist. So sure, I'll give you the semantic point if you insist, but it doesn't mean much.

Are you serious? Or do you just lack a good dictionary? I look forward to your conservative brethren rushing into the thread to correct you. Nazis, see, can only be card-carrying members of Hitler's National Socialists. Just as merely chanting anti-semitic slogans, wearing swastikas, giving Nazi salutes, celebrating Hitler's birthday, etc... cannot be used to call someone a nazi, I think merely being violent towards your political ends is further No True Nazi behavior.

You'll need a new word.
 
Are you serious? Or do you just lack a good dictionary? I look forward to your conservative brethren rushing into the thread to correct you. Nazis, see, can only be card-carrying members of Hitler's National Socialists. Just as merely chanting anti-semitic slogans, wearing swastikas, giving Nazi salutes, celebrating Hitler's birthday, etc... cannot be used to call someone a nazi, I think merely being violent towards your political ends is further No True Nazi behavior.

You'll need a new word.

I thought you were supposed to be good with language, yet you're falling down spectacularly in ignoring its actual purpose. I don't care which specific word gets used, and I'm not interested in fighting about it. But words get used to convey meaning. And the relevant meaning that people were trying to convey with the word fascist is an authoritarian and violence-prone group. And the communists fit that bill quite well. Want to call them fascists? I don't care. Refuse to call them fascists? I don't care. Meaning is more important than vocabulary. Yet meaning is what you're studiously avoiding here.
 
And the relevant meaning that people were trying to convey with the word fascist is an authoritarian and violence-prone group.

By that definition every state is a fascist state, and every police department is a fascist group.
 
By that definition every state is a fascist state, and every police department is a fascist group.

Uh... no. Not even close. Plus, the whole point is that I don't care if you drop the term "fascist". I'm not trying to define "fascist". There are definitions of fascism under which communists are not fascist. And I'm OK with such definitions. But that doesn't mean communists aren't as bad as fascists. They are.
 
Is there anything in there? I'm not listening to 1:11:00 of Ngo droning on in a pity party with a fellow right wing non-entity.

Bret Weinstein supported Bernie Sanders over Clinton, describes his politics as "progressive" and has never voted Republican. What are you trying to say when you describe him as "right wing"
 
Uh... no. Not even close.

Uh...yes, not just close but exactly on target. The state, almost by definition, holds the monopoly on the use of violence and is, again almost by definition, authoritarian; and expresses both primarily through its police departments. How the hell is this even contentious?

Plus, the whole point is that I don't care if you drop the term "fascist". I'm not trying to define "fascist". There are definitions of fascism under which communists are not fascist. And I'm OK with such definitions. But that doesn't mean communists aren't as bad as fascists. They are.

I'm sure there are definitions of fascism under which pretty much anything is true. Indeed, I present you a definition of fascism under which you are a fascist: Define fascism as whatever it is that Zigg believes or supports.

The definition you actually gave though, makes every state a fascist state and every law enforcement department a fascist group, whether communist, liberal democratic, or "fascist" in the usual sense of the word.
 
Uh...yes, not just close but exactly on target. The state, almost by definition, holds the monopoly on the use of violence and is, again almost by definition, authoritarian;

"Authoritarian" doesn't simply mean that they are an authority. And the fact that the state has a monopoly on violence doesn't mean that that's always their go-to tool. Unless you want to take some weird anarchist view of all states being illegitimate, then there's clearly a difference between states in regards to both how controlling they are and how violent they are.

The definition you actually gave though, makes every state a fascist state and every law enforcement department a fascist group, whether communist, liberal democratic, or "fascist" in the usual sense of the word.

Except "authoritarian and violent" isn't my definition of fascism. I'm not trying to define fascism. I was, in fact, trying to get away from the use of the word. But you're so clueless you tried circling back to it because... well, there's really no logical reason at all. It's so stupendously stupid a move that I can't possibly come up for a motivation behind it.
 
"Authoritarian" doesn't simply mean that they are an authority.

True, they'd for example have to impose their authority through violence, which leads us to...

And the fact that the state has a monopoly on violence doesn't mean that that's always their go-to tool.

Then by that logic nobody or no group is fascist, because for nobody it is the case that violence is always their go-to tool.

Unless you want to take some weird anarchist view of all states being illegitimate, then there's clearly a difference between states in regards to both how controlling they are and how violent they are.

The definition did not say anything about "legitimate" or "illegitimate" violence, furthermore it is the case for any group that they're going to consider their own violence "legitimate." It remains, however, a simple and empirically observable fact that the state is by far the most violent authoritarian group in society.

Except "authoritarian and violent" isn't my definition of fascism. I'm not trying to define fascism. I was, in fact, trying to get away from the use of the word. But you're so clueless you tried circling back to it because... well, there's really no logical reason at all. It's so stupendously stupid a move that I can't possibly come up for a motivation behind it.

I'd rather not get away from the use of the word, it has epistemic use as a political category. Or at least it does under some proper definition of the word rather than the stupid one you gave (and note here that I never said that it was your definition of fascism, merely that you gave it - as in, presented it as an example of a definition of fascism). As for a motivation behind it, in general because that sort of definition of fascism gets thrown around a lot mostly by the politically ignorant and it makes sense to point out that such definition is simply defining any state, and in particular because of the following comment you made:

And you're actually excusing actual violence, you're in no position to lecture me.

I wanted to see whether 1) you would acknowledge that such definition applies to even a liberal democratic state and 2) whether you would start excusing the actual violence when it comes from "your" side, such as by introducing concepts such as "legitimate vs illegitimate violence."
 
Last edited:
I'd rather not get away from the use of the word, it has epistemic use as a political category. Or at least it does under some proper definition of the word rather than the stupid one you gave (and note here that I never said that it was your definition of fascism, merely that you gave it - as in, presented it as an example of a definition of fascism).

No. I didn't give it as my definition, or ANYONE ELSE's definition, of fascism. I gave them as relevant qualities of two groups under consideration. Right-wing fascists have those qualities, but they may not suffice to define fascism, and I didn't claim they did. I didn't even claim anyone else did either. I'm merely pointing out that both people on the far right AND the far left have these qualities. And for the purposes of the discussion that was taking place, those qualities are the most important ones.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom