Journalist attacked by violent mob

What would you say is the appropriate response to his opinion piece in WSJ?

(Assuming that simply refuting it in print isn't enough.)


It isn't enough, obviously. Why do you think Baylor keeps repeating the lie? Why do think nobody in this thread is concerned about Ngo's lies, only about his freedom to lie?

At the height of the 2016 election, researchers at the RAND Corporation released a report documenting an unusual propaganda model dubbed the “firehose of falsehood.” The report described a strategy where a propagandist could overwhelm the public by producing a never-ending stream of misinformation and falsehoods.
The report found that these lies didn’t have to be believable — even clear falsehoods, repeated widely and frequently enough, could be effective in warping public opinion in the propagandist’s favor.
Why obvious lies make great propaganda (Vox, April 31, 2018)





I'm under the impression that a few people in my feeds would argue that maybe a punch in the head is really the way to go here, but I wouldn't impute that view to anyone in this forum, because that would be insulting. ;)


If anybody deserves a punch in the head ...
So let's hear, 'what would you say is the appropriate response to Ngo's opinion piece in WSJ?'
 
Given the putative nature of the protest (to protect a statue of a Confederate general) why would you prefer neo-con to mean neo-conservative rather than neo-confederate? Whilst I often disagree with you theprestige I think you are usually honest, and honesty in this case surely falls on the side of the neo-confederate definition.

He snipped my statement short for a specific reason, because the rest of the people I labeled gave my statement context.

I will work to be more clear in the future.
 
No. He's a guy with a blog. That's not the same as being a journalist. He also happens to join up with the Proud Boys whenever they come to Portland to fight.

No. The whole point of freedom of the press is that everyone is a journalist. Reporters aren't an elite caste. You don't get to decide who is exempt from political violence because of their press credentials. Antifa doesn't get to decide that. Everybody has those credentials.
 
Given the putative nature of the protest (to protect a statue of a Confederate general) why would you prefer neo-con to mean neo-conservative rather than neo-confederate? Whilst I often disagree with you theprestige I think you are usually honest, and honesty in this case surely falls on the side of the neo-confederate definition.

I don't prefer one over the other, except in the sense that I think the connotations and context make one interpretation of "neo-con" more likely than the other.
 
What would you say is the appropriate response to his opinion piece in WSJ?

(Assuming that simply refuting it in print isn't enough.)

It isn't enough, obviously.
So what would you say is the appropriate response to Ngo’s opinion piece in WSJ?

If anybody deserves a punch in the head...
How would you finish that sentence, dann?

So let's hear, 'what would you say is the appropriate response to Ngo's opinion piece in WSJ?'

Refuting it in print, obviously.
 
Last edited:
It isn't enough, obviously. Why do you think Baylor keeps repeating the lie? Why do think nobody in this thread is concerned about Ngo's lies, only about his freedom to lie?










If anybody deserves a punch in the head ...
So let's hear, 'what would you say is the appropriate response to Ngo's opinion piece in WSJ?'

We are not hearing about his lies because he was doing nothing illegal and was assaulted. If you wanted to start a thread about the guy in CT go nuts, you will likely have almost complete agreement he is an idiot and a liar.

Just like how in a rape case it is in bad taste to say " but she was a slut" here is the same. He was a victim, a minority victim at that, and for the purposes of this thread that is what matters.

If words are such an effective weapon, why we're they not used instead? If you are saying words are so dangerous he should be assaulted why not then use that weapon you are so afraid of?

The answer is simple, you are not afraid of them. You want him to shut the **** up, and a punch in his face is the quickest way to do that to your logic.
 
Why do think nobody in this thread is concerned about Ngo's lies, only about his freedom to lie?


Because until this thread, I had never heard of Ngo and I really don't care who he is of what he has done. On the other hand, I do know what freedom is, and I think it is important to protect everyone's freedom.

So, if he uses that freedom to lie, that's really unfortunate for him, but I will still support his freedom to do so.*


(*Some exceptions apply, but "It really makes me mad" is not one of them. Nor is, "If people believe his lies, bad things might happen someday.")
 
Because until this thread, I had never heard of Ngo and I really don't care who he is of what he has done. On the other hand, I do know what freedom is, and I think it is important to protect everyone's freedom.

So, if he uses that freedom to lie, that's really unfortunate for him, but I will still support his freedom to do so.*


(*Some exceptions apply, but "It really makes me mad" is not one of them. Nor is, "If people believe his lies, bad things might happen someday.")

I find the same for most of these super influential menaces.

The only people that know who they are are their extreme minority of fans and people who sniff around for offense like a dog looking for floor snacks.

To paraphrase a line from James Rolfe " its like if someone took a ****, buried it, then you come along dig up and complain they are gross." . This guy and others like him will never have mass appeal. Out of the tiny percentage of people who listen to him likely 1/3 are doing it for a laugh, 1/3 are saying they do to rile people up, and the last fraction of a tiny percent of humanity are his actual fans.
 
I'm resisting the urge to go through Ngo's claims one-by-one until we've established that punching people in the head isn't the way to deal with errant journalists and/or editorialists. I would hate to think that by critiquing his claims of fact or value I would be indirectly inciting violence.
 
I just can't understand the strategy of this at all. Ngo is a propagandist for sure. His writing is red meat for the extreme right wing. I have no problem agreeing that he is a vile person. Antifa practically put up a "wanted" poster for him before the rally and beat him on sight without provocation. This is pure vigilantism.

Antifa is so ready to declare a state of lawlessness. Either we are a nation of laws, or we are a failed state in armed struggle. The two cannot co-exist. Meanwhile, antifa beats up right wing nobodies and the real seat of power hardly notices.

What exactly is antifa accomplishing here? Ngo will be back. Patriot Prayer will be back. The trading of blows will continue while ordinary people look on with increasing dread. The local authorities will only look the other way so long as the violence remains at a low enough level to ignore. Should it escalate, right wing and left wing brawlers will share the same cells and morgues when the police sweep up the street rabble. What is the end game here? What is actually being accomplished here?
 
No. The whole point of freedom of the press is that everyone is a journalist. Reporters aren't an elite caste. You don't get to decide who is exempt from political violence because of their press credentials. Antifa doesn't get to decide that. Everybody has those credentials.


Er, no. If everyone is a "journalist", then no one is, because the category at that point the term becomes effectively meaningless. A set that contains literally everything is not a useful set.

The whole point of freedom of the press is that the government cannot censor journalists or journalistic organizations simply because the press is critical of the government, or the government does not like what is being said, unless there is a compelling reason to do so that does not unduly infringe on the right to a free press -- eg. incitement to commit a crime, incitement to violent overthrow of the government, libel or slander, etc.

Demonstrable falsehoods are something of a gray area, and have traditionally been considered safe from government censorship except when they form actionable libel or slander against an individual or organization. Oddly, that exclusion does not seem to apply to classes of people, only individuals and incorporated entities. A definitely loophole in the law that should be considered for redress.
 
Impression from the pictures and updates from people on the ground pretty much match my initial view. As much as a few posters here seem to position 'antifa' as protectors, definitely seem to be antagonizers in general looking for a fight.


No one has said that there aren't any antifa individuals or groups who aren't just there looking for a fight, obviously there are but they're a very small minority, and not representative of the far larger antifa tent. And there are nowhere near as many of them as there are of fascists/white supremacists who who are just out looking for a fight (prefering one heavily weighted in their favour, with unarmed opponents who can't fight back effectively, like they targeted at Charlottsville).

Another reason the whole "they are egging/milkshaking to humiliate" schtick doesn't sit well with me. It's a means to entice a fight, not a deterrent to violence.


No one is claiming that egging/milkshaking is going to deter immediate violence; but there's an entirely separate thread on that subject, and discussion is best left there.
 
(*Some exceptions apply, but "It really makes me mad" is not one of them. Nor is, "If people believe his lies, bad things might happen someday.")


Exactly. Conspiracy-theory-driven mass murder is just the price we pay for free speech. Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice!
 
Antifa is so ready to declare a state of lawlessness.


Nope. Antifa's view is that we already live in a state of lawlessness, when those who enforce the laws do so selectively, turning a blind eye toward lawlessness from their favoured groups committed against "undesirables"; and they are simply acting in the way the authorities should be, when the authorities have demonstrated an unwillingness to do so.

Whether that is true in all cases is certainly arguable, and I'd definitely say that there are instances where the response has been disproportionate; but for the most part it's a fairly accurate view of the world as it is. Keep in mind that the overwhelming majority of antifa individuals are those who are themselves direct targets of fascist and white nationalist violence -- ethnic minorities, women, LGTBQs, and so on.

What is the end game here? What is actually being accomplished here?


What is being accomplished is that the fascists are not being allowed free reign to control the streets and openly intimidate and assault minorities and other "undesirables"; like the Brown Shirts did in Nazi Germany. The end game is to have the relevant authorities actually step in and rein in the fascists and their inciters, so that direct action is no longer necessary. I'm surprised that this still needs to be spelled out for some people.
 
Last edited:
There ya go. So you want to get together with the OP and help him draft the "Let's Declare Rose City Antifa a Terrorist Organization". Get that over to the UN and the DoJ and everyone will feel better. All you then have to show is where their mission statement or material says they're for terrorism.



Of course, you'll have to first get past the language police. You know, the right wing apologists who insist that you actually show where they say that they are for Terrorism. Terrorism, you know... like TERRORIZING civilian populations. Seems to me like they're terrorizing Patriot Prayer, the Proud Boys and countless alt-right armchair quarterbacks.



And then you have to subpoena their membership lists and show that the perps on Saturday were RCA members and not "Hooligans For Bernie", "Red Spring", "Gamers For Fair Play" or any other such organization.



The OP wasn't suggesting that this particular antifa group be outlawed, but that it's time to declare Antifa as terrorists.



But at least you gave it a try.



Your post above is ridiculous.

The ***** who attacked him should be arrested and prosecuted.



One of the attackers at the Rose City Antifa event was doing the attacking while wearing a Rose City Antifa T-shirt. But hey maybe he’s just a fan like a sports fan wearing a jersey.

I actually have specific interest in the Portland Antifa guys; they have caused me to reconsider Antifa in general after listening to them. I obviously don’t want them banned as a terrorist organization.

As we speak, there are some antifa type folks doing a little activism in my neighborhood. Apparently Richard Spencer lives here now and they are outing him. I’m becoming more sympathetic to them as I think more about it.

e7d8d1e70cee7b0a4a98433bdcfb0f3f.jpg
 
Nope. Antifa's view is that we already live in a state of lawlessness, when those who enforce the laws do so selectively, turning a blind eye toward lawlessness from their favoured groups committed against "undesirables"; and they are simply acting in the way the authorities should be, when the authorities have demonstrated an unwillingness to do so.

Whether that is true in all cases is certainly arguable, and I'd definitely say that there are instances where the response has been disproportionate; but for the most part it's a fairly accurate view of the world as it is.

Having grievances with the government isn't the same as a state of lawlessness. The entire point of our laws is that grievances, sufficiently felt by enough citizens, can be addressed through pre-defined processes.

Antifa is a repudiation of that. To support armed struggle is to pre-suppose that grievances cannot be addressed in a lawful, peaceful way.

This is all besides the point.

Antifa isn't political in any meaningful sense. They, and patriot prayer and the others, are political LARPers. They don't challenge real power in any meaningful sense. The small groups of thugs meet on the street and beat the snot out of each other. Portland PD lets them fight. In the rare instances one of these thugs forgets their place and attacks a cop, they get a hard lesson in what real power is.

Antifa will never effect a meaningful change in the way political power is wielded in this country. But they will be used as poster children for authoritarians looking for reasons to crack down on civil engagement.
 
As we speak, there are some antifa type folks doing a little activism in my neighborhood. Apparently Richard Spencer lives here now and they are outing him. I’m becoming more sympathetic to them as I think more about it.

They're posting the home address of these people, and you're becoming more sympathetic to Antifa?

What exactly do you think the purpose of posting their home address is? What do you want to happen to them? Should they be assaulted? Should they be SWATed? Should they be killed? Because that's where this is quite predictably heading.
 
Er, no. If everyone is a "journalist", then no one is, because the category at that point the term becomes effectively meaningless. A set that contains literally everything is not a useful set.
The right of human beings to observe and report on the world around them is indeed universal. It is not restricted to employees of media corporations. It is not granted by the receipt of a White House Press Pass.

Andy Ngo is every bit as entitled to exercise the right to free press, by publishing his thoughts and opinions, as any New York Times reporter or AP stringer. The only accreditation he needs, to practice acts of journalism whenever and however he chooses, is the fact that he is a human being with human rights.

Certainly antifa is not entitled to grant journalistic exceptions from their political violence, to people who work for media corporations.

Journalists are not an elite caste. The press is not actually an estate of the government, with barriers to entry that citizens must cross to enjoy its protections.

The whole point of freedom of the press is that the government cannot censor journalists or journalistic organizations simply because the press is critical of the government, or the government does not like what is being said, unless there is a compelling reason to do so that does not unduly infringe on the right to a free press -- eg. incitement to commit a crime, incitement to violent overthrow of the government, libel or slander, etc.
The whole point of freedom of the press is that the government cannot censor anyone, whether they are employed by someone as a "journalist" or not.

Journalists are not an elite caste. Journalism is not a privileged role granted only to employees of media corporations. Anyone, at any time, can speak up and say, "this is what I saw, this is what I think" without fear of retaliation. That's the freedom of the press.

The idea that Andy Ngo is somehow not entitled to safety from antifa's violence because he is not formally accredited by some media corporation is perverse and obscene. As is the idea that he is not entitled to the human right to publish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom