No one has said that there aren't any antifa individuals or groups who aren't just there looking for a fight, obviously there are but they're a very small minority, and not representative of the far larger antifa tent. And there are nowhere near as many of them as there are of fascists/white supremacists who who are just out looking for a fight (prefering one heavily weighted in their favour, with unarmed opponents who can't fight back effectively, like they targeted at Charlottsville).
How do we know they are a small minority? You've continuously said there is no organization, no creed, which means no accountability. I haven't seen any internal policing of actions at all, in any video so far. Seems this stuff is widely accepted, otherwise there would be some push back don't you think?
No one is claiming that egging/milkshaking is going to deter immediate violence; but there's an entirely separate thread on that subject, and discussion is best left there.
No. You can freely bring up Charlottsville continuously in any conversation regarding antifa, I will bring up actions taken at this specific event and how they affected it. Much more on topic, and in no way veering into the purpose of the other thread.
There was another incident at this event. From one account, some guy was milkshaked and got into a fight with the guy that did it (or whoever happened to be around). Fight breaks out, pepper sprays, fists thrown etc etc. Afterwards another fight breaks out with the same group involving some older guy. He's got his metal hat, metal baton, and in turn gets beat over the head by a bunch of 'antifa' guys with metal batons. Could have been started by anything of course, but once started sure escalated quickly. And they'll feel justified that they were 'defending themselves'.
Nope. Antifa's view is that we already live in a state of lawlessness, when those who enforce the laws do so selectively, turning a blind eye toward lawlessness from their favoured groups committed against "undesirables"; and they are simply acting in the way the authorities should be, when the authorities have demonstrated an unwillingness to do so.
That is their view, sure. What I would love to know is how their actions do anything but make it impossible to enforce the laws they complain they aren't enforcing. Plenty of video of cops having eggs, water bottles, milk shakes etc thrown at them while trying to keep the peace. Holding back people trying to get at the right wing protesters. Sure doesn't seem like they are doing anything to help the situation. Especially when the right wingers number in the 2-3 dozen and the 'antifa' protesters number in the hundreds.
Know what might make it easier? Being like the other protesters that were there that weren't attempting to engage in mortal combat with 'nazis'. They sure didn't seem to be taking up the bulk of the polices resources to deal with. The mocked, danced, played loud music to drown out the right wing rhetoric, shared drinks and had a jolly time by the looks of it.