Journalist attacked by violent mob

How does beating up Andy Ngo fit into that? :confused:


Depends on what he was doing. I wasn't there, so I don't what agitating or avoiding-involvement went on. If he wasn't actually there agitating and inciting as the rest of them were, then he didn't deserve to get beaten. Given his history, however, of right-wing agitation and activism (despite his claims to the contrary), I am suspicious that he was there strictly as a "journalist".
 
Did you miss the whole Charlottesville debacle?


I am confident I have watched a lot more video of the Charlottesville debacle than you have.


I would not agree with Mr. Trump that there were good people on both sides, but I would certainly say that there were a lot of bad people on both sides. However, that was covered in a different thread.
 

That piece is long on discussion, and short on what was actually said. In fact, as far as I can tell, that piece doesn't actually cite the original statement at all. They just refer to it, without even linking it. They link other stuff they refer to. They even embed a video of Trump talking about it later. But the actual statement itself? Nowhere at that link.

I mean...

Seriously?
 
That piece is long on discussion, and short on what was actually said. In fact, as far as I can tell, that piece doesn't actually cite the original statement at all. They just refer to it, without even linking it. They link other stuff they refer to. They even embed a video of Trump talking about it later. But the actual statement itself? Nowhere at that link.

I mean...

Seriously?

Oh THAT quote. Yeah, the Atlantic had it in quotes:

“I’ve condemned neo-Nazis. I’ve condemned many different groups. But not all of those people were neo-Nazis, believe me,” he said.

“You had many people in that group other than neo-Nazis and white nationalists,” Trump said. “The press has treated them absolutely unfairly.”

“You also had some very fine people on both sides,” he said.

I'm not sure that in context it's going to be much better.
 
That piece is long on discussion, and short on what was actually said. In fact, as far as I can tell, that piece doesn't actually cite the original statement at all. They just refer to it, without even linking it. They link other stuff they refer to. They even embed a video of Trump talking about it later. But the actual statement itself? Nowhere at that link.

I mean...

Seriously?


I mean...

Do you think that everything everyone, even a president says to reporters is televised or otherwise recorded on video?

Seriously?
 
So it’s important that we all get up and defend Ngo's freedom to spread lies!

What would you say is the appropriate response to his opinion piece in WSJ?

(Assuming that simply refuting it in print isn't enough.)

I'm under the impression that a few people in my feeds would argue that maybe a punch in the head is really the way to go here, but I wouldn't impute that view to anyone in this forum, because that would be insulting. ;)
 
Last edited:
I mean...

Do you think that everything everyone, even a president says to reporters is televised or otherwise recorded on video?

Seriously?

I do not. Obviously it must have been recorded somewhere, though, otherwise we wouldn't know about it and you wouldn't keep repeating it. So. Where was it recorded?
 

Thanks!

Here's the transcript:
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/15/rea...ald-trumps-jaw-dropping-press-conference.html

And here's what President Trump actually said:

You have some very bad people in that group, but you also had people that were very fine people on both sides.​

It's pretty clear from the preceding passages of the transcript that he's is saying that there were very bad, violent people on both sides of that incident, but there were also fine people on both sides. Somehow the Fake News Progressives have traduced this into President Trump saying that violent white supremacists are fine people, even though he explicitly excludes them from that statement, in the statement itself.

Carry on.
 
Last edited:
Thanks!

Here's the transcript:
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/15/rea...ald-trumps-jaw-dropping-press-conference.html

And here's what President Trump actually said:

You have some very bad people in that group, but you also had people that were very fine people on both sides.​

It's pretty clear from the preceding passages of the transcript that he's is saying that there were very bad, violent people on both sides of that incident, but there were also fine people on both sides. Somehow the Fake News Progressives have traduced this into President Trump saying that violent white supremacists are fine people, even though he explicitly excludes them from that statement, in the statement itself.

Carry on.

Now we just have to find out where the people that were on the "unite the right" side that weren't Neo-Cons, Nazi's, Nazi sympathizers, or some shade there of, is that possible? I haven't seen many images of Johnny Q. Taxpayer just chilling at the event.

Is that what you're implying? Maybe I'm missing something because I didn't see any first amendment activists or anything like that there. I'm happy to be proven wrong though.

Turns out the Atlantic isn't your friend. Or maybe it is, in a "friends like these..." sort of way.

I provided the quote you were looking for with as much context as I felt was deserved from a source I figured you wouldn't argue with.
 
One of the sides was a coalition of nazis, neo-Confederates, patriot militias, the ******* Ku Klux Klan and other white supremacists. Which of those groups has the fine people? :boggled:
 
Now we just have to find out where the people that were on the "unite the right" side that weren't Neo-Cons, Nazi's, Nazi sympathizers, or some shade there of, is that possible? I haven't seen many images of Johnny Q. Taxpayer just chilling at the event.

Is that what you're implying? Maybe I'm missing something because I didn't see any first amendment activists or anything like that there. I'm happy to be proven wrong though.



I provided the quote you were looking for with as much context as I felt was deserved from a source I figured you wouldn't argue with.

Maybe Trump was wrong about there being fine people on both sides, in addition to the very bad people he explicitly acknowledged. It wouldn't be the first time he was wrong about event attendance.

But.

He was right that there were very bad people there. And he was right that the very bad people were not very fine people.

I'm not trying to imply anything. I'm saying outright that it's clear from the transcript that Trump was actually saying the opposite of what some people pretend he saying, and that other people now naively believe he was saying.

Even you went with the Atlantic quote, even though it truncated exactly that part of the statement that reverses the widely-understood meaning of the bit that they keep. Even you thought that was as much context as the statement deserved. You've spent the past two years believing what you were told about the truncated statement, instead of going back to the video or the transcript and seeing for yourself what was actually said.

I hope now you understand a least a little bit what I'm getting at, when I say the Atlantic is not your friend.

---

And please, don't choose this hill to die on. There's plenty of reasons to vilify Trump, without having to depend on deceptive edits and wilful misrepresentation. You're better than this.
 
Adjusted to align better with my answer.

My answer is: It depends where you're talking about. In Germany, the fascists won. In Russia, the communists. In the US, both sides were shrugged off (though the communists achieved a toehold in popular culture that they still cling to even now).
In a lot of places, it wasn't even the fascists. The communists were just fighting whatever the established order was in the country, if it wasn't already communism. In some countries, even if it was already communism.

Yes, in Charlottesville you could see all those hammers n' sickles on the protesters' shirts and shields. Just as many as the nazis were displaying their symbols on theirs!!!
Oooh! I bet some of them wore Che Guevara shirts! Treason!
 
God is like clockwork.

Once the debate gets into trying to actually dive into any complex issue, everyone scrambles for something trump related to talk about to make themselves feel more confidant in their opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom