Journalist attacked by violent mob

Now we just have to find out where the people that were on the "unite the right" side that weren't Neo-Cons

I doubt anyone involved in "unite the right" was a neo-con. What do you think neo-cons are?
 
I doubt anyone involved in "unite the right" was a neo-con. What do you think neo-cons are?

A bad word that people they like use in a negative way.

Or

One step away from nazis but close enough they shouldn't be covered under assault laws.
 
The guy on the right is wearing a "Rose City Antifa" shirt.
Me wearing the playing strip of my favourite football team doesn't make me a professional footballer. Me wearing a Darth Vader T-shirt doesn't make me Darth Vader. Also, he's not wearing the official bleeding-heart liberal latte-sipping weakling Antifa black uniform and battle-gear. So proof of nothing.
 
This board has taught me to find a girl that looks at me the way leftists look at violence, so there's that.
Is that an accurate description of your position? You like violence against your opponents? Probably not. That's probably a gross misrepresentation of what you really believe. But that's exactly what you're doing here, presenting a gross misrepresentation of your opponents.

You are capable of making better arguments than this. I've seen it before. But you're failing badly here.

You're looking for a girl who finds you abhorrent?
 
Portland Antifa are pretty well organized. I heard them interviewed on a podcast a few months ago, and they didn't strike me as a bunch of disparate groups.

Note that capital A. Rose City Antifa.

There ya go. So you want to get together with the OP and help him draft the "Let's Declare Rose City Antifa a Terrorist Organization". Get that over to the UN and the DoJ and everyone will feel better. All you then have to show is where their mission statement or material says they're for terrorism.

Of course, you'll have to first get past the language police. You know, the right wing apologists who insist that you actually show where they say that they are for Terrorism. Terrorism, you know... like TERRORIZING civilian populations. Seems to me like they're terrorizing Patriot Prayer, the Proud Boys and countless alt-right armchair quarterbacks.

And then you have to subpoena their membership lists and show that the perps on Saturday were RCA members and not "Hooligans For Bernie", "Red Spring", "Gamers For Fair Play" or any other such organization.

The OP wasn't suggesting that this particular antifa group be outlawed, but that it's time to declare Antifa as terrorists.

But at least you gave it a try.
 
Can we name all bigots as terrorists?

You and folks like you have been giving it your best effort.

Funny how when the shoe is on the other foot nuance is suddenly a thing. Almost like you view yourself as human. .. and the bigots as something else.

Hilited.... this should be easy. Please show me where I recommended that we name all bigots as terrorists.

Or you could retract your misrepresentation of my position.

Or you will be shown to be a liar.

Hi, Sadhatter. Good to see you posting in the thread again.

In case you missed it, your previous post was given a very basic challenge. Now, I don't wanna put you on the spot, but I've already placed a substantial wager on which outcome will be shown as true. So hurry up and respond. There's a lot of money on the line!

To engage in said test I would have to violate forum rules on cross thread posting. So no I will not get a yellow card for you.

I think my point is obvious without getting myself an infraction thank you.

Sadly (or sadlyhatterly) you opted for the third choice.... shown yourself to be a liar.

How hard is it to admit that you were just shooting your mouth off and had no knowledge on which to base your slander? There's no rule in the MA about cross-posting. There's a directive to not import arguments from other threads. If you actually had a post where I said that all bigots should be classified as terrorists, you would show it. (Further, one of my dedicated fanboyz would be delighted to show it for you.)

It doesn't exist.
 
I'm guessing they meant neo-conservative, and are actively promoting conflation of anyone to the right of them and neo-Nazis.

But neo-Confederates were actually among those at the Unite the Right rally, not neo-conservatives.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unite_the_Right_rally

The Unite the Right rally[4] was a white supremacist[5][6][7][8] rally that occurred in Charlottesville, Virginia, from August 11 to 12, 2017.[9][10] Protesters were members of the far-right and included self-identified members of the alt-right,[11] neo-Confederates,[12] neo-fascists,[13] white nationalists,[14] neo-Nazis,[15] Klansmen,[16] and various right-wing militias.[17] The marchers chanted racist and antisemitic[citation needed] slogans, carried semi-automatic rifles, Nazi and neo-Nazi symbols (such as the swastika, Odal rune, Black Sun, and Iron Cross), the Valknut, Confederate battle flags, Deus Vult crosses, flags and other symbols of various past and present anti-Muslim and antisemitic groups.[18][8][9][19][20][21][22] Within the Charlottesville area, the rally is often known as A12[23] or 8/12.[24] The organizers' stated goals included unifying the American white nationalist movement[11] and opposing the removal of the a statue of Robert E. Lee from Charlottesville's Lee Park.[21][25]

So neo-Confederates were among the attendees, but not neo-conservatives.
 
Neoconfederates would make sense, although it's bad usage to abbreviate as "Neo-Con" because of the confusion it causes.

Particularly when even the people who disparage them can't figure out who the **** they are. We have a new thinking-man's reactionary on the boards who thinks the NeoCons are frustrated Trotskyites.

They're actually a catchall handy group. Lefties hate 'em because they're warmongers who claim to be former lefties. Righties hate 'em because the new (Alt) right are isolationists and don' wan' no furrin intanglements.
 
Depends on what he was doing. I wasn't there, so I don't what agitating or avoiding-involvement went on. If he wasn't actually there agitating and inciting as the rest of them were, then he didn't deserve to get beaten. Given his history, however, of right-wing agitation and activism (despite his claims to the contrary), I am suspicious that he was there strictly as a "journalist".

So the hilite is grounds for the assault? Not sure why it is so hard to just say, yes, shouldn't have hit him. Seems his mere presence agitated and incited the violence. Doesn't appear anything extra was required.
 
Depends on what he was doing. I wasn't there, so I don't what agitating or avoiding-involvement went on. If he wasn't actually there agitating and inciting as the rest of them were, then he didn't deserve to get beaten. Given his history, however, of right-wing agitation and activism (despite his claims to the contrary), I am suspicious that he was there strictly as a "journalist".

I see. He was asking for it. Isn't that what you are trying to say?
 
yes he is a journalist and that is precisely why he was targeted and attacked. Not because he is a member or supporter of the Proud Boys, not because he is a white supremacist or NAZI or a fascist, he was attacked because he was already well known to antifa prior to this event because of history as a journalist and blogger.

No. He's a guy with a blog. That's not the same as being a journalist. He also happens to join up with the Proud Boys whenever they come to Portland to fight.
 
No. He's a guy with a blog. That's not the same as being a journalist. He also happens to join up with the Proud Boys whenever they come to Portland to fight.

How do you define journalist?

- An individual reporting on events?

- Someone anointed by a corporation?
 
I'm guessing they meant neo-conservative, and are actively promoting conflation of anyone to the right of them and neo-Nazis.
Given the putative nature of the protest (to protect a statue of a Confederate general) why would you prefer neo-con to mean neo-conservative rather than neo-confederate? Whilst I often disagree with you theprestige I think you are usually honest, and honesty in this case surely falls on the side of the neo-confederate definition.
 
No. He's a guy with a blog. That's not the same as being a journalist.

Why do you think that's even relevant? Do you think journalists (however you choose to define them) deserve protections that the rest of us plebes don't?
 
Sadly (or sadlyhatterly) you opted for the third choice.... shown yourself to be a liar.

How hard is it to admit that you were just shooting your mouth off and had no knowledge on which to base your slander? There's no rule in the MA about cross-posting. There's a directive to not import arguments from other threads. If you actually had a post where I said that all bigots should be classified as terrorists, you would show it. (Further, one of my dedicated fanboyz would be delighted to show it for you.)

It doesn't exist.

Trying to bait me into a yellow card is off topic and kinda silly. Not taking the chance and your opinions on anyone right of Guevara are obvious to anyone likely even your " fanboyz".
 
Trying to bait me into a yellow card is off topic and kinda silly. Not taking the chance and your opinions on anyone right of Guevara are obvious to anyone likely even your " fanboyz".

Oh come now. I gave you the option of backing up your claim through a private message. So far, you have not taken the opportunity. You may think this strategy of I will accuse you of nefarious deeds and not back them up because I'm just not allowed to works in your favor, but you'd be mistaken.

Either validate your accusation, or retract it. It's just the honest thing to do.
 
Right wing protesters

Left wing - mostly antifa-ish mix

There are also some photos of just regular 'left wing' protesters that seem to be decently numbered and just regular people, no protective gear etc. separate from the other group.

Impression from the pictures and updates from people on the ground pretty much match my initial view. As much as a few posters here seem to position 'antifa' as protectors, definitely seem to be antagonizers in general looking for a fight.

Another reason the whole "they are egging/milkshaking to humiliate" schtick doesn't sit well with me. It's a means to entice a fight, not a deterrent to violence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom