Journalist attacked by violent mob

Nope. Antifa's view is that we already live in a state of lawlessness, when those who enforce the laws do so selectively, turning a blind eye toward lawlessness from their favoured groups committed against "undesirables"; and they are simply acting in the way the authorities should be, when the authorities have demonstrated an unwillingness to do so.

Does Antifa think that the authorities should have assaulted Andy Ngo?

Whether that is true in all cases is certainly arguable, and I'd definitely say that there are instances where the response has been disproportionate; but for the most part it's a fairly accurate view of the world as it is. Keep in mind that the overwhelming majority of antifa individuals are those who are themselves direct targets of fascist and white nationalist violence -- ethnic minorities, women, LGTBQs, and so on.

Andy Ngo is an ethnic minority, and antifa (especially in Portland) is overwhelmingly white.

What is being accomplished is that the fascists are not being allowed free reign to control the streets and openly intimidate and assault minorities and other "undesirables"

Andy Ngo hasn't assaulted anyone. He was the one who was openly intimidated and assaulted.
 
Er, no. If everyone is a "journalist", then no one is, because the category at that point the term becomes effectively meaningless. A set that contains literally everything is not a useful set.

Yes, as a matter of fact, "journalist" is meaningless when it comes to rights.

The whole point of freedom of the press is that the government cannot censor journalists or journalistic organizations

No. This is a profound misunderstanding you have. The government cannot generally censor anyone. In regards to the 1st amendment, the "press" is an activity, NOT a category of person. Journalists are not an entitled class with rights that the rest of us don't have. Your belief to the contrary is deeply, deeply undemocratic and anti-constitutional.
 
Er, no. If everyone is a "journalist", then no one is, because the category at that point the term becomes effectively meaningless. A set that contains literally everything is not a useful set.

Just out of curiosity, does this argument work well for you in other contexts?

If everyone is human, no one is human?

If everyone has the right to free speech, no one has the right to free speech?

The right of free press is the right of anyone to publish, just like the right of free assembly is the right of anyone to assemble.

---

It's a mistake to conflate this idea of publication as a basic human right, with the institutionalized practice of publication by organized groups of people.
 
They're posting the home address of these people, and you're becoming more sympathetic to Antifa?



What exactly do you think the purpose of posting their home address is? What do you want to happen to them? Should they be assaulted? Should they be SWATed? Should they be killed? Because that's where this is quite predictably heading.



Well I was more thinking of shaming or shunning them or maybe a dirty look at a coffee shop, but you go on with your slippery slope to murder.
 
Well I was more thinking of shaming or shunning them or maybe a dirty look at a coffee shop

And why is their home address necessary in order to do that? It isn't. It serves no purpose whatsoever for your stated goal.

but you go on with your slippery slope to murder.

What, you think nobody would be willing to SWAT them? You think nobody could get killed by being SWATed?
 
Well I was more thinking of shaming or shunning them or maybe a dirty look at a coffee shop, but you go on with your slippery slope to murder.

I have mixed feelings about the doxxing.

Personally, I would love to know if Spencer moved into my neighborhood. While I am wholly opposed to Antifa's extrajudicial violence, their tactics of naming and shaming overt and closet racists and neo-nazis is one I support 100%. People like Spencer should never be allowed to escape the stigma of their failed ideologies, nor be afforded the benefits of polite society. I would love to have the opportunity to daily remind such a person how contemptible they are and would take joy in their inability to participate in the broader community as a respectable person.

That said, given the trends of political "discourse" these days, posting his address is likely to endanger his life. While I would not engage in political violence, one has to be willfully naive to believe that posting his address would not vastly increase his risk of being harmed by someone. Posting the address, knowing that such bad actors are around, seems like an implicit approval of such violence.

I find it a bit of moral quandary.
 
What is being accomplished is that the fascists are not being allowed free reign to control the streets and openly intimidate and assault minorities and other "undesirables"; like the Brown Shirts did in Nazi Germany. The end game is to have the relevant authorities actually step in and rein in the fascists and their inciters, so that direct action is no longer necessary. I'm surprised that this still needs to be spelled out for some people.
The end game is to have the relevant authorities step in and rein in the fascists and their inciters how exactly? By eroding personal freedoms? How does vigilante violence by groups like Antifa help those relevant authorities reach that end game without turning their focus towards those violent vigilantes? Wouldn't peaceful protest and lobbying to authorities be more effective in getting what you want?
 
And why is their home address necessary in order to do that? It isn't. It serves no purpose whatsoever for your stated goal.

How about the poster saying near here, or "around the corner," or "in this neighborhood?" How about "on this block?"

What, you think nobody would be willing to SWAT them? You think nobody could get killed by being SWATed?
I think that people who are willing to commit a felony possibly resulting in death of another person are resourceful enough to find their address if needed. I doubt that they need a nudge from a street poster. And obviously, I don't believe your last sentence, so kindly cut it out.

If he finds himself subscribed to a bunch of liberal mailing lists and gay hamster porn magazines, however, that would be kind of awesome.

SuburbanTurkey said:
I find it a bit of moral quandary.
Yeah, me too. I'm connecting the dots and realizing that there were some radical types outside his place a while ago. At first I figured that it was a line for one of those pop-up stores, but now that I think about it they were probably doing a street action.
 
Er, no. If everyone is a "journalist", then no one is, because the category at that point the term becomes effectively meaningless. A set that contains literally everything is not a useful set.

The whole point of freedom of the press is that the government cannot censor journalists or journalistic organizations simply because the press is critical of the government, or the government does not like what is being said, unless there is a compelling reason to do so that does not unduly infringe on the right to a free press -- eg. incitement to commit a crime, incitement to violent overthrow of the government, libel or slander, etc.

Demonstrable falsehoods are something of a gray area, and have traditionally been considered safe from government censorship except when they form actionable libel or slander against an individual or organization. Oddly, that exclusion does not seem to apply to classes of people, only individuals and incorporated entities. A definitely loophole in the law that should be considered for redress.

We are not talking about government censorship we are talking about a knob being assaulted for no reason other than being a knob.
 
Exactly. Conspiracy-theory-driven mass murder is just the price we pay for free speech. Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice!

When that actually happens, when there is another Hitler, then we get to use violence. We don't get to point at folks we don't like scream " they are genociding right for us" and start attacking.
 
How about the poster saying near here, or "around the corner," or "in this neighborhood?" How about "on this block?"

How about them? They weren't what was actually posted.

I think that people who are willing to commit a felony possibly resulting in death of another person are resourceful enough to find their address if needed.

The thing about having the address easily available is that it lowers the bar, making it more likely that someone might do something on impulse. Even if they could do the same thing with effort, requiring that effort still provides some measure of protection against crazies. Posting that address has the effect of lowering that protection.

And you yourself should have blurred that address in the picture before you posted it.
 
Well I was more thinking of shaming or shunning them or maybe a dirty look at a coffee shop, but you go on with your slippery slope to murder.

Then the home address would come into play where? If you see him. .. shame him, whatever that means.

And Hey if you are cool with people coming over to someones place to "shame" them for political views post your address and picture. I'm sure I could come up with some online activity that would get you "shamed" and shunned if it was on a poster.
 
I have mixed feelings about the doxxing.

Personally, I would love to know if Spencer moved into my neighborhood. While I am wholly opposed to Antifa's extrajudicial violence, their tactics of naming and shaming overt and closet racists and neo-nazis is one I support 100%. People like Spencer should never be allowed to escape the stigma of their failed ideologies, nor be afforded the benefits of polite society. I would love to have the opportunity to daily remind such a person how contemptible they are and would take joy in their inability to participate in the broader community as a respectable person.

That said, given the trends of political "discourse" these days, posting his address is likely to endanger his life. While I would not engage in political violence, one has to be willfully naive to believe that posting his address would not vastly increase his risk of being harmed by someone. Posting the address, knowing that such bad actors are around, seems like an implicit approval of such violence.

I find it a bit of moral quandary.

Wow that is some toxic ****.

Your point of view would lead to zero incentive for anyone who got caught up in any hate group or gang to ever leave. Way to make lifelong dedication to this **** a more appealing option.

Think then form a philosophy not the other way around.
 
Terrorist seems strong. Maybe street thugs?

I'd be okay with the general gang definition. As this is typically how gangs start. Political motivation groups people, but soon enough I see this going the way of any gang that starts to "protect " people.

They will turn to profitable illegal acts to fund their goal, then more and more focus on said acts till the goal is just branding for the criminal acts making money.

Very ironically what happened to legit white power organized crime.
 
How about them? They weren't what was actually posted.



The thing about having the address easily available is that it lowers the bar, making it more likely that someone might do something on impulse. Even if they could do the same thing with effort, requiring that effort still provides some measure of protection against crazies. Posting that address has the effect of lowering that protection.

And you yourself should have blurred that address in the picture before you posted it.

100% right.

I'm my 20s after a night at the bar, if I came across a legit sign with that prick's address, I'd for sure go cause some kind of ruckus. And i was the last crazy of my friends.

Would I have stalked him every day to find out if he happened to move to my city? Not at all.

And as much as I'm older and wiser I'm sure there are plenty of drunk 20 somethings willing to pick up the slack.
 
Wow that is some toxic ****.

Your point of view would lead to zero incentive for anyone who got caught up in any hate group or gang to ever leave. Way to make lifelong dedication to this **** a more appealing option.

Think then form a philosophy not the other way around.

Spencer has not repudiated his ideology. His star may have waned, but there is no reason for anyone to assume he thinks any differently than he did before.

My post should not be construed to mean that redemption is impossible. Spencer is not seeking redemption.
 
Spencer has not repudiated his ideology. His star may have waned, but there is no reason for anyone to assume he thinks any differently than he did before.

My post should not be construed to mean that redemption is impossible. Spencer is not seeking redemption.

But you said you want it to follow them, to harass them, to make polite company impossible. Now suddenly you have limits? Things like this don't die,and if he recanted today these same people who think like you do would be putting up these signs till the day he dies.

I don't think you believe redemption is impossible which makes your view all the more toxic and sick. You believe it is possible but hold a philosophy in which you make it impossible via doing everything possible to exclude this person from any company other than that of his own kind.

If this guy wanted to broaden his horizons by meeting different people, you would have that be impossible. If he wanted to fold up shop because he hates what he has done you would have that be impossible. If he wanted to volunteer under a pseudonym to atone, you would make that impossible. I could keep going but the point is obvious.

And this doesn't even touch on the bulk of the everyday idiots that get wrapped up in this crap for a year or two and come to their senses. Not in your world, post their info and make sure that they can't even leave the state without this **** following them.

If I thought you believed redemption was impossible I'd find your philosophy merely silly. As it is I find it as morally reprehensible as I can find a philosophy that is not genocide based.
 
But you said you want it to follow them, to harass them, to make polite company impossible. Now suddenly you have limits? Things like this don't die,and if he recanted today these same people who think like you do would be putting up these signs till the day he dies.

I don't think you believe redemption is impossible which makes your view all the more toxic and sick. You believe it is possible but hold a philosophy in which you make it impossible via doing everything possible to exclude this person from any company other than that of his own kind.

If this guy wanted to broaden his horizons by meeting different people, you would have that be impossible. If he wanted to fold up shop because he hates what he has done you would have that be impossible. If he wanted to volunteer under a pseudonym to atone, you would make that impossible. I could keep going but the point is obvious.

And this doesn't even touch on the bulk of the everyday idiots that get wrapped up in this crap for a year or two and come to their senses. Not in your world, post their info and make sure that they can't even leave the state without this **** following them.

If I thought you believed redemption was impossible I'd find your philosophy merely silly. As it is I find it as morally reprehensible as I can find a philosophy that is not genocide based.

Richard Spencer is not some ignorant racist that got caught up in a movement. Richard Spencer is the intellectual elite of the white nationalist movement. He's the president of a white nationalist think tank and responsible for organizing and directing alt-right extremist groups. he is literally a man that organizes torch-lit parades of chanting neo-nazis. I feel perfectly comfortable holding him in extreme disregard. He's the second coming of Goebbels, and that's not hyperbole.

I reject the idea that we have to be nice to the racists so they can learn, gently and at their own pace, that being a racist is bad. These people are adults and fully developed sense of morality. They can own the consequences of their bigotry. It is not unreasonable to say "this guy is a neo-nazi that yearns for an ethnically cleansed America" when it is literally true. Should that make him not welcome at his local whole foods, so be it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom