Journalist attacked by violent mob

Other than the ACLU?

I am very skeptical that today's ACLU would automatically defend the Nazis' right to assemble the way that they did in the Frank Collins / Skokie case. The new generation of members is much more comfortable with the idea that speech can actually be violence, having come of age in a time of speech codes, "hate speech," etc.
 
If adherents of a violent, genocidal ideology with a history of violent activity showing up in your town en masse carrying weapons and shields doesn't qualify as a clear and present danger; well, then your definition of clear and present danger definitely needs reconsideration.

Well, you would have to use two words and show how they applied.

Those words are "clear" and "present".

It isn't just a phrase. Each word in the phrase has to have meaning.

So, no amount of ideology is going to matter, because that could only ever hint that something might happen. They might be inclined to do things that someone else has done in the past. There will be nothing "clear" about it, because there will be no way to say, "based on their ideology, I think they are about to do X". Likewise, there will be nothing "present", because based on their ideology, at best you can say, "People who think like X might be inclined to do Y", but unless they are actually doing Y right now, then the danger is not "present". That's what "present" means.

The presence of weapons, on the other hand, might be a different story. I would be perfectly willing to restrict people's activities based on possession of weapons while they are doing it. I think it would be perfectly acceptable to make it a condition of a parade or park permit not be carrying weapons, and allow police to revoke their permit if it is found that a significant number of them are aremed, even with "defensive" weapons like shields or pepper spray. When it comes to deadly weapons that can cause death at a distance, i.e. guns, I'm one of those left wing commie pinkos who think that it ought to be just plain illegal to wander about with those things without a permit, and I would make it difficult to get one of those permits, but that's just me. Well, it isn't just me, but it's me and an insufficient number of voters to make it happen in many places.


The constitution guarantees the right to peaceably assemble, but if it's clear that the assembly is not peaceable, then it ought to be dispersed.


Here's the thing, though. That applies to all elements of the political spectrum. I don't care whether they are "good people" or "bad people" or which side they are on. If I see people forming a shield wall in a public place, I'm pretty sure they are up to no good, and I don't care how self righteous they get about the importance of their cause. Get the heck off the street. The only shield walls I want to see are police or SCA, and the SCA people don't put up their shield walls in places that block traffic.
 
This isn't a battle between Nazis and everyone else. There are more than two sides. Antifa has a very large communist component. And if you want to appeal to history, the United States has fought some bloody fights with communists too, and communists have killed far more people than Nazis ever did. To use your color swatch analogy, it's not black versus white, it's black vs red vs white. And you want me to ignore the red because you're color blind.

Nazis and communists fighting each other in the streets. I wonder if that has ever happened before. I wonder how it turned out.
 
Other than the ACLU?

I am very skeptical that today's ACLU would automatically defend the Nazis' right to assemble the way that they did in the Frank Collins / Skokie case. The new generation of members is much more comfortable with the idea that speech can actually be violence, having come of age in a time of speech codes, "hate speech," etc.


The ACLU no longer defends neo-Nazis or other alt.right hate groups who advocate and participate in violence; and has become more circumspect about who they do defend.

https://www.vox.com/2017/8/20/16167870/aclu-hate-speech-nazis-charlottesville
 
Here's the thing, though. That applies to all elements of the political spectrum. I don't care whether they are "good people" or "bad people" or which side they are on. If I see people forming a shield wall in a public place, I'm pretty sure they are up to no good, and I don't care how self righteous they get about the importance of their cause. Get the heck off the street. The only shield walls I want to see are police or SCA, and the SCA people don't put up their shield walls in places that block traffic.


So no self-defense is legitimate then? If the police refuse to do anything about the violent right-wing gangs, then the rest of us are just supposed to accept being beaten and possibly even killed so that you can continue to pretend you have the moral high ground? Are you really saying that the violent racist thugs should be allowed to control the streets, because that is the upshot of what you are saying. The police have very often shown great reluctance to interfere with the violent racists, because they themselves are in large part violent racists. So what options are left for those of us who don't want to see our cities taken over by violent racists?

Get the heck off the street.


And what if the fascists decide to, oh I don't know, invade a church and start attacking parishioners (like happened at Charlottesville), are you going to decry the parishioners for fighting back and insist that they shouldn't have been in the church? How bad does the situation have to get before you'll acknowledge that people have a right to defend themselves and their communities?
 
Nazis and communists fighting each other in the streets. I wonder if that has ever happened before. I wonder how it turned out.


In the US? More times in the last 70 years or so than I can count right now. And mostly just ended up with a buncha people being arrested; and a few dead on both sides, though mostly on the communist side, because the government has generally been on the side of the Nazis.
 
To engage in said test I would have to violate forum rules on cross thread posting. So no I will not get a yellow card for you.

I think my point is obvious without getting myself an infraction thank you.

I understand entirely.

In that case, PM me a few links that support your point, and I'll share your list with any interested parties. Thank you in advance.
 
So no self-defense is legitimate then?


Defending themselves from what?
How does forming a shield wall on a public street constitute self defense of anything?


Unless you can describe, specifically, the violence from which they were protecting themselves, then the danger is not clear.


Unless that violence is happening, or about to happen, immediately, then the danger is not present.


In order to say that speech constitutes a threat, both elements have to be present. (note dual meaning of "present").


I just don't understand how people forming a shield wall to block a path could ever be considered "self defense".


Now, that "shield wall" stuff was really a reference to earlier issues, as far as I know, but in Portland this weekend, something else happened. In this case, one group of right wing idiots were told to go to one park. A different group of right wing idiots were told to go to a different park. The left wing idiots were told to go to a third park. According to a report linked earlier in this thread, some of the left wing idiots left their assigned park and initiated confrontations with the right wing idiots.

I don't know how I can find any sort of "self defense" on the part of any of the idiots, but I can be absolutely certain that when the left wing idiots left their park and approached the right wing idiots' park, the left wing idiots were not defending themselves.

I can also be certain that they are all idiots.
 
Last edited:
So no self-defense is legitimate then?

The law permits self defense under certain conditions. Unless you think current self-defense laws are too restrictive, then self defense isn't actually at issue here.
 
So what options are left for those of us who don't want to see our cities taken over by violent racists?


Do they have a parade permit? Set up a concession stand and sell them cool drinks, at a profit. I don't recommend milkshakes, though.
 
The constitution guarantees the right to peaceably assemble, but if it's clear that the assembly is not peaceable, then it ought to be dispersed.

I bet that if pressed, the Supreme Court would probably rule that it's possible to exercise the right to peaceably assemble, and exercise the right to bear arms, simultaneously. I think they'd probably rule that bearing arms is not by itself sufficient justification to infringe on their right of assembly.

Especially in an environment where the opposition faction has made it clear that they intend to use violence to suppress or disperse such assemblies.
 
Nazis Fascists and communists fighting each other in the streets. I wonder if that has ever happened before. I wonder how it turned out.

Adjusted to align better with my answer.

My answer is: It depends where you're talking about. In Germany, the fascists won. In Russia, the communists. In the US, both sides were shrugged off (though the communists achieved a toehold in popular culture that they still cling to even now).

In a lot of places, it wasn't even the fascists. The communists were just fighting whatever the established order was in the country, if it wasn't already communism. In some countries, even if it was already communism.
 
I bet that if pressed, the Supreme Court would probably rule that it's possible to exercise the right to peaceably assemble, and exercise the right to bear arms, simultaneously. I think they'd probably rule that bearing arms is not by itself sufficient justification to infringe on their right of assembly.

Especially in an environment where the opposition faction has made it clear that they intend to use violence to suppress or disperse such assemblies.

You are probably correct, but I suspect it would be a split decision, and I would be on the side of "it's ok to revoke the permit".

When a whole bunch of people show up with weapons, whether those weapons are guns, shields, or milkshakes, they aren't looking for anything peaceful.

Of course, this whole thing depends on the ability and willingness of the police to protect people, and sometimes, the police decide that the safest path is to tolerate the low level violence between the groups for fear that police intervention would just escalate the violence, not to mention redirect it toward the police. I feel sympathy for those on the ground who have to make the decision.
 
BTW, Oregon is an open carry state. In Portland, openly carried guns have to be unloaded unless you have a concealed carry permit.
 
Defending themselves from what?
How does forming a shield wall on a public street constitute self defense of anything?


Did you miss the whole Charlottesville debacle? Would certainly have been useful there when the fascists started stomping unarmed, non-violent protesters. The protesters formed a wall without shields, and got beaten because of it.

Unless you can describe, specifically, the violence from which they were protecting themselves, then the danger is not clear.


See above. Also the Patriot Prayer rally where they came armed with firearms and set up snipers on a nearby parking garage roof.

I can also be certain that they are all idiots.


Perhaps. But one group of idiots is trying to actively intimidate and harm anyone who isn't their brand of white fascist, another group of idiots is at least trying to prevent the white fascists from harming those who aren't white fascists while the government does nothing to defend said non-white non-fascists, while a third group of idiots is sitting safely behind their keyboards whinging about how they can't tell the difference between the first two groups. I know which groups of idiots I'm more sympathetic to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom