Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

Bottom line, when it comes to guns there's only one statistic that matters to me. That's the guy who becomes one because he tried to make me one.

That's certainly an important one.
Your mother must be very proud.
 
That's certainly an important one.
Your mother must be very proud.

I took her shooting for the first time a month ago and she's been running around showing everyone her targets ever since. :D
 
Hi

When I got out of Vietnam, I slept for a couple of years with a pistol under my pillow, contrary, at times, to Army regulations and stuff, but I took great pains to not impose this fact on others who might be sensitive.

Once, I went to my parent's house for a surprise visit.

After all the hugging and, "what a surprise,"ing, my mother scurried (she was short and plump... she scurried remarkably well) into the bathroom.

After a bit, she popped her head out the door and yelled down the corridor, "do you still sleep with a gun under your pillow?"

I was flabbergasted! I could have sworn that my Mom had never seen my pistol!!

"No, " I answered, stuttering, "I... I haven't for a few months." Then, I asked, "how did you know about that?"

My Mom turned into the bathroom for a moment then walked into the hall, holding a pillowcase. As she held it up, there, rendered in gun grease, was the outline of my Smith and Wesson Model 59!

She had, without any word of censure or complaint, put the same set of gun-grease-stained sheets and pillowcases on the bed I would be sleeping in for two years of announced visits.

:D So, yeah, I think my Mom WAS proud of me. :D
 
Last edited:
Wow. Isn't that special.

Perhaps we could start a new thread:

"I am a gun owner and my mom is proud of me because..."

Maybe there's someone out there whose mom stuffed the first rat she shot at the dump and had it placed on the mantelpiece.
 
Hi

Hmmm...

An Ad Mominem attack?

He's been leading up to it ever since the Jim Crow reference out of right field.

That's when I go into "yeee haw I shore luvs me sum guns
banjo.gif
" mode, drives them right over the edge. :D
 
I find that hard to believe. Not saying you're wrong, just that I'd like to see proof of that. MADD has been around a long time.

I know that in south carolina that many drunk crashes(where say they drive into a tree) never get prossecuted. That is because at least where my brother works as a firefighter paramedic they don't charge anyone unless the police stop him. You get out of the car and they say that they don't know who was driving your car.

What? Both Horn and Dickey were up against unarmed people intent on breaking the law. While I personally feel they might have overreacted, it's miles from being the same thing as a duel.

Dickey it seemed hard to tell, and it was from a site defending him, it did not make any claim about the drunks other than that they where seeming to be.

And remember they where only charged with anti dueling laws because likely otherwise it would have been basicly legal.

You can argue it all you want, and sure there are those who'd like to see those laws elsewhere. But they aren't elsewhere, they're in Texas. These idiots committed their crime in Texas. They were legally gunned down for their actions in Texas.

Sure, and women in Saudi Arabia should know that being in the car with a man they deserve a beating. That is the law there and who are we to complain.
 
I know that in south carolina that many drunk crashes(where say they drive into a tree) never get prossecuted. That is because at least where my brother works as a firefighter paramedic they don't charge anyone unless the police stop him. You get out of the car and they say that they don't know who was driving your car.

As a South Carolinian, I can promise you that's garbage.*

Your other points are too silly to respond to.




*How am I so sure? Have a friend or two who's tried it. :o
 
Last edited:
It's not "open season" on anybody. Between this and the comments about how "burglary is not a capital crime" the point is being missed completely.

It is open season, it is not Hornes property being stolen
No one (well, almost no one) is saying death is a fair punishment for breaking into an empty house, but as someone on another forum discussing this put it: "Death may not be a fair punishment for pointing a spray-painted water pistol at a cop, but that will be the result. Self defense is about exactly that, self defense. It's about removing the threat. Death is only an unfortunate side-effect. The punishment fitting the crime is not a relevant argument in this scenario."

Or that say they might live next to someone who inspite of being dirrected not to thinks it is fun confronting people engaged in robbery with a shotgun.

And that's what it really boils down to: Not "don't steal or you can be killed," but "don't be so brazen about your criminal activity you do it in plain sight and think you won't face any serious consequences."

Don't expect people not to choose violence in texas seems to be the lesson.
 
Bottom line, when it comes to guns there's only one statistic that matters to me. That's the guy who becomes one because he tried to make me one. [qimg]http://www.lethalwrestling.com/upload/clint.gif[/qimg]

So you are also for killing any census taker you see.

Might even be legal in texas, he did walk up to your door with out your permission.
 
It is open season, it is not Hornes property being stolen

So you are in full support of stealing other people's property. Noted.

Maybe it comes from liberal/marxist leanings. I mean, people like you want most of my paycheck redistributed to those who don't deserve to have it (because they did not earn it). At least you are consistent.

Or that say they might live next to someone who inspite of being dirrected not to thinks it is fun confronting people engaged in robbery with a shotgun.

He was directed not to for his own safety, not because it was illegal. In two recent interviews he makes his feelings on the incident very clear.

Protecting your or someone elses life, property is something that is only made possible by someone trying to take it. Go figure. So it is not fun, just necessary.


Don't expect people not to choose violence in texas seems to be the lesson.

This case is the exception not the rule. Most people, even in the great state of Texas become victims. I wish it were not so, but it is. However, we Texans have the right to defend our life and property as well as the life and property of our neighbors with deadly force if needed.

[Sean Connery]Here endeth the lesson.[/Sean Connery]
 
So you are also for killing any census taker you see.

Might even be legal in texas, he did walk up to your door with out your permission.


You can have my household's median income when you pry it from my cold, dead fingers. :cool:


It might well have to do with what county you are in as well.


Granted, but it's not like we don't have investigators here capable of checking things like car seat position, DNA if there's blood from the driver, and other basic techniques which can help determine these things just like everyone else does.

Believe it or not, we have indoor plumbing too.
 
So you are in full support of stealing other people's property. Noted.
Since he never said that, are you making things up or using a straw man for fun?
Back to his point, do approve of people running around confronting or killing other people even when it is not their property or life is at stake? You call it what you want, I call vigilantism.

Maybe it comes from liberal/marxist leanings. I mean, people like you want most of my paycheck redistributed to those who don't deserve to have it (because they did not earn it). At least you are consistent.
What complete bullcrap. Just because people are for gun control, it MUST mean that they are liberal? Talk about ad hominem garbage.

He was directed not to for his own safety, not because it was illegal. In two recent interviews he makes his feelings on the incident very clear.
Maybe he was directed not to confront the criminals because they were afraid he was going to go out and start shooting when the police could have managed to bring them in without any deaths?

Protecting your or someone elses life, property is something that is only made possible by someone trying to take it. Go figure. So it is not fun, just necessary.
Right, and you seem to have the impression that anyone has the right to enforce/protect not only their own property life/property but anyone elses as they see fit. I await the vigilante who accidentally kills someone because of a "misunderstanding".

This case is the exception not the rule. Most people, even in the great state of Texas become victims. I wish it were not so, but it is. However, we Texans have the right to defend our life and property as well as the life and property of our neighbors with deadly force if needed.

[Sean Connery]Here endeth the lesson.[/Sean Connery]
It is you Texans who have decided to allow a form of legal vigilantism. It is your State's right and it is legal. But don't pretend it is anything else.
 
Right, and you seem to have the impression that anyone has the right to enforce/protect not only their own property life/property but anyone elses as they see fit. I await the vigilante who accidentally kills someone because of a "misunderstanding".

Just like I'm sure you can't wait for the explosion of deaths that will be caused by giving law-abiding people access to guns in Washington DC.

And in both cases you might want to pack a lunch, because in the real world gun owners are not the cowboys you think we are.
 
Just like I'm sure you can't wait for the explosion of deaths that will be caused by giving law-abiding people access to guns in Washington DC.
Yeah, have you actually responded to my point or are you attempting a Red herring and ad hom?

BTW: I opposed the DC Handgun ban. I thought it was stupid and was happy when it was struck down. So...what was you point again?

And in both cases you might want to pack a lunch, because in the real world gun owners are not the cowboys you think we are.
Yeah...must be reason I own a handgun as well huh? I may think I'm responsible but I sure as hell am not deluded to believe that all gun owners are. Horne is an example.
 
Yeah, have you actually responded to my point or are you attempting a Red herring and ad hom?

BTW: I opposed the DC Handgun ban. I thought it was stupid and was happy when it was struck down. So...what was you point again?

You're presenting a hypothetical is if it's already a given and I'm the one tossing around red herrings?

Thanks for your support on Heller though. It really was as unfair a law as you'll find on the books anywhere. :)

Yeah...must be reason I own a handgun as well huh? I may think I'm responsible but I sure as hell am not deluded to believe that all gun owners are. Horne is an example.

And yet he acted within the scope of Texas penal law. Where's the irresponsibility?
 
You're presenting a hypothetical is if it's already a given and I'm the one tossing around red herrings?
Get your logical fallacies right. It's actually a Slippery Slope argument, not a Red Herring.

Seriously, it is a real concern that I have about this precedent. What are the limits of taking actions against criminals? I understand the right to protect your property and life and maybe the life of your neighbors but anything more should be left to those trained and which we delegate the responsibility to ie. the police.

Thanks for your support on Heller though. It really was as unfair a law as you'll find on the books anywhere. :)
I believe in the Right to bear arms but I believe it is also constitutional to limit ownership within limits certain limits. I consider each law on its own merits. The DC law was just absurd.

And yet he acted within the scope of Texas penal law. Where's the irresponsibility?
You can't base a responsible decision solely on the law otherwise it is "responsible" to beat your wife in Saudi Arabia.

It was irresponsible of him to refuse to listen to the 911 operator and to escalate the situation beyond his control even when no risk was present to others. As I've mentioned, I can't fault someone to respond to threats to themselves or to the lives of others but to respond with violence to criminal acts just leads to vigilantism.
 
Get your logical fallacies right. It's actually a Slippery Slope argument, not a Red Herring.


doh.gif



Seriously, it is a real concern that I have about this precedent. What are the limits of taking actions against criminals? I understand the right to protect your property and life and maybe the life of your neighbors but anything more should be left to those trained and which we delegate the responsibility to ie. the police.

Believe me, I see your argument (if you go back through the thread, I was anti-Horn at the beginning. The pro-gunner in me just comes out when I see the leaps the other side makes and gets my motor running).

It does disturb me that some (not so much here as other forums) are painting him as a hero, which he's far from. I'm not going to name my cat after him, but when all is said and done I can't find myself worried about two criminals... one of whom brazenly advanced on an old man wielding a weapon... assuming room temperature and said old man not having to spend the rest of his life in jail as a result.

If he HAD been indicted, I promise I wouldn't have been one of the ones crying about what an injustice it was. And if anyone wants to paint this as "him getting away with it" I don't have a problem with that either. I'll even agree... he got away with murder, state-sanctioned murder.

I'm not going to lose any sleep over it.

He acted within the law, and anyone who doesn't think they do things a little differently in Texas has never heard of the state. This won't open the floodgates to other states trying to loosen their laws to allow people to shoot suspected criminals in the back, and it wouldn't surprise me if this case led to them re-evaluating their wording in Texas. It was one case of a fed-up old man vs. two criminals, and at the end of the day the lesser of two evils got to go home.

So be it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom