Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

I would not think they are close to the line. Both initiate conflict and brandish a weapon.

Yeah, but if I'm writing the laws I give a little leeway to the guy who didn't set out to commit a crime. Absence of forethought goes a long way over premeditated criminal behavior in my book.
 
A great many of the people locked up are of no threat to the comunity.

Manslaughter is the classic conviction of someone who is highly unlikely to be a continueing threat.

This may be true. but as I said, I am not particularly concerned about Horne being let off in what is a marginal case because I don't think he is a threat to the community. I would be far more upset about a child molester who was released because of police malfeasance.
 
Yeah, but if I'm writing the laws I give a little leeway to the guy who didn't set out to commit a crime. Absence of forethought goes a long way over premeditated criminal behavior in my book.

I agree. In this case he survived and the criminals didn't. I wonder how people would react if he had missed the criminals and killed a 4 year old kid with his wayward shot. Probably much less likely to give him the benefit of the doubt, even if his motivations were the same in both instances.
 
Yeah, but if I'm writing the laws I give a little leeway to the guy who didn't set out to commit a crime. Absence of forethought goes a long way over premeditated criminal behavior in my book.

This would seem to go against the views of imposing more penalties on drunk drivers who kill people though.

It also becomes interesting when you look at that Murder By duel case recently. Two people had a dispute, they both went home and got their guns and one killed the other.

It would seem that if you where writting the laws neither did anything seriously wrong.
 
This would seem to go against the views of imposing more penalties on drunk drivers who kill people though.


When did I say I thought we needed more penalties for drunk driving? We've got plenty of them as it is.

Dueling, by its very nature, requires premeditation. Therefore it would not be protected under the Drudgewire Rules of Engagement.

And after finally reading the Texas law concerning Castle Doctrine, bottom line is Horn acted within the confines of the law:

Sec. 9.42. Deadly Force to Protect Property.
A person is justified in using deadly force against another to protect land or tangible, movable property:
(1) if he would be justified in using force against the other under Section 9.41; and
(2) when and to the degree he reasonably believes the deadly force is immediately necessary:
(A) to prevent the other's imminent commission of arson, burglary, robbery, aggravated robbery, theft during the nighttime, or criminal mischief during the nighttime; or
(B) to prevent the other who is fleeing immediately after committing burglary, robbery, aggravated robbery, or theft during the nighttime from escaping with the property; and
(3) he reasonably believes that:
(A) the land or property cannot be protected or recovered by any other means;
or
(B) the use of force other than deadly force to protect or recover the land or property would expose the actor or another to a substantial risk of death or serious bodily injury.


Texas Penal Code
shoot.gif
 
Does this apply to protecting one's neighbor's property as well as one's own? Or does the Castle Doctrine only apply to one's own castle?
 
Does this apply to protecting one's neighbor's property as well as one's own? Or does the Castle Doctrine only apply to one's own castle?

Seems that the same rules apply:

Sec. 9.43. Protection of Third Person's Property.

A person is justified in using force or deadly force against another to protect land or tangible, movable property of a third person if, under the circumstances as he reasonably believes them to be, the actor would be justified under Section 9.41 or 9.42 in using force or deadly force to protect his own land or property and:
(1) the actor reasonably believes the unlawful interference constitutes attempted or consummated theft of or criminal mischief to the tangible, movable property; or
(2) the actor reasonably believes that:
(A) the third person has requested his protection of the land or property;
(B) he has a legal duty to protect the third person's land or property; or
(C) the third person whose land or property he uses force or deadly force to protect is the actor's spouse, parent, or child, resides with the actor, or is under the actor's care.

So really, the only argument is whether the law is just. Horn, by living in Texas, was within his legal rights and absolutely should not have been indicted.
 
When did I say I thought we needed more penalties for drunk driving? We've got plenty of them as it is.

So all that rates is a ticket
Dueling, by its very nature, requires premeditation. Therefore it would not be protected under the Drudgewire Rules of Engagement.

This particular case was changed under the anti dueling laws. There does not seem to be any premeditation other than "This guy is doing things I don't like, so I will get my gun and use it to get him to back off" When done by both parties that falls under the anti dueling laws in west virginia.
And after finally reading the Texas law concerning Castle Doctrine, bottom line is Horn acted within the confines of the law:

I see texas really has declaired open season on criminals.
 
So all that rates is a ticket

Wow, leap much? I said we have plenty of laws already... which include vehicular homicide. Not wanting to pile on from there is a far cry from "yes, let's buy them a beer and send them on their way."

This particular case was changed under the anti dueling laws. There does not seem to be any premeditation other than "This guy is doing things I don't like, so I will get my gun and use it to get him to back off" When done by both parties that falls under the anti dueling laws in west virginia.

"Going back to my gun" makes it premeditated. Taking a gun to a dispute is called "escalation." Both are illegal, and have been for a long time now. And that's how I'd keep the law.

I see texas really has declaired open season on criminals.

So be it. Not how I'd write the law, but if I made the decision to live in Texas I'd be subject to their rules. The rule there is "break into a house and it's OK to shoot you," so who am I... a guy who doesn't live there and has no plans to... to argue? v:)v
 
Last edited:
Wow, leap much? I said we have plenty of laws already... which include vehicular homicide. Not wanting to pile on from there is a far cry from "yes, let's buy them a beer and send them on their way."

Not all states have vehicular homicide laws that focus on drunk driving.


"Going back to my gun" makes it premeditated. Taking a gun to a dispute is called "escalation." Both are illegal, and have been for a long time now. And that's how I'd keep the law.

And yet that is what both parties you suggested tested the limits did.


So be it. Not how I'd write the law, but if I made the decision to live in Texas I'd be subject to their rules. The rule there is "break into a house and it's OK to shoot you," so who am I... a guy who doesn't live there and has no plans to... to argue? v:)v

That prevents few people from expressing their views on much of anything.

"sure having political murders of reporters critical of the goverment in russia is not what I would want but I don't live there so why should I care?"

And it does seem that there are those who want to spread those sort of laws to more of this country.
 
Not all states have vehicular homicide laws that focus on drunk driving.


I find that hard to believe. Not saying you're wrong, just that I'd like to see proof of that. MADD has been around a long time.


And yet that is what both parties you suggested tested the limits did.


What? Both Horn and Dickey were up against unarmed people intent on breaking the law. While I personally feel they might have overreacted, it's miles from being the same thing as a duel.


That prevents few people from expressing their views on much of anything.

"sure having political murders of reporters critical of the goverment in russia is not what I would want but I don't live there so why should I care?"

And it does seem that there are those who want to spread those sort of laws to more of this country.

You can argue it all you want, and sure there are those who'd like to see those laws elsewhere. But they aren't elsewhere, they're in Texas. These idiots committed their crime in Texas. They were legally gunned down for their actions in Texas.

And since my initial take on it was based on what I assumed to be outside of the spirit of the law, I no longer have any problem with it and feel arguing a point I've since reversed myself on is sort of silly.
 
Seems that the same rules apply:

Quote:
Sec. 9.43. Protection of Third Person's Property.

A person is justified in using force or deadly force against another to protect land or tangible, movable property of a third person if, under the circumstances as he reasonably believes them to be, the actor would be justified under Section 9.41 or 9.42 in using force or deadly force to protect his own land or property and:
(1) the actor reasonably believes the unlawful interference constitutes attempted or consummated theft of or criminal mischief to the tangible, movable property; or
(2) the actor reasonably believes that:
(A) the third person has requested his protection of the land or property;
(B) he has a legal duty to protect the third person's land or property; or
(C) the third person whose land or property he uses force or deadly force to protect is the actor's spouse, parent, or child, resides with the actor, or is under the actor's care.

So really, the only argument is whether the law is just. Horn, by living in Texas, was within his legal rights and absolutely should not have been indicted.

Too many clauses and terms for which I do not know the precise legal definition. It does not appear that #2 applies, unless the neighbor had asked him to watch the house. Which leaves us with #1, which only applies to "tangible movable property", not "land and property." Still, the way I read this, if you see someone coming out of your neighbor's house holding a television, you can shoot him. If it turns out it was your neighbor's brother-in-law, you are still in the clear because all the law requires is that the actor "reasonably believes" that an attempted or consummated theft has taken place. So I would not characterize this as open season on criminals, but open season on suspected criminals. And given the inclusion of "criminal mischief", I would not recommend TPing someone's house on Halloween. It's now a capital offense.

Fortunately, most Texans have common sense. Not so sure about Mr. Horne.
 
Hi

I think it's important to remember that Grand Juries don't determine guilt. They only determine sufficiency of evidence.

They MAY simply have decided that the case against him was too weak to warrant continuing the prosecution, right?
 
Hi

I think it's important to remember that Grand Juries don't determine guilt. They only determine sufficiency of evidence.

They MAY simply have decided that the case against him was too weak to warrant continuing the prosecution, right?

Or they may have believed that he broke the law but that the victims deserved it, as when white juries during Jim Crow refused to indict those responsible for lynchings.
 
So we really do belong with nations that have reporters exicuted then?

We clearly belong in nations that don't have the rule of law as a strong principle.
That's a huge load of self-serving left-wing garbage. You can prove pretty much anything if you massage the data enough, or take it far enough out of context.

Read the FBI Uniform Crime Statistics, and the DOJ statistics. The US does not have even remotely close to the level of the general populace slagging each other that many other industrialized nations (such as the aforementioned Russia and Mexico) do.

The vast majority of the violent crime that makes up that misleadingly simplistic number is internecine warfare between drug-money-funded street gangs, and other fallout from the War on Drugs. Factor that out, and our violent crime rate is on a par with Western Europe and Canada.
 
So I would not characterize this as open season on criminals, but open season on suspected criminals. And given the inclusion of "criminal mischief", I would not recommend TPing someone's house on Halloween. It's now a capital offense.

It's not "open season" on anybody. Between this and the comments about how "burglary is not a capital crime" the point is being missed completely.

No one (well, almost no one) is saying death is a fair punishment for breaking into an empty house, but as someone on another forum discussing this put it: "Death may not be a fair punishment for pointing a spray-painted water pistol at a cop, but that will be the result. Self defense is about exactly that, self defense. It's about removing the threat. Death is only an unfortunate side-effect. The punishment fitting the crime is not a relevant argument in this scenario."

They aren't being sentenced to death for their actions, they're putting themselves in a potentially lethal situation in order to rob from people they assumed wouldn't fight back. Again, personally they can have my TV all day as long as I don't feel threatened. But as I think more and more about this case I get more and more happy there are places where the laws don't automatically require us to passively sit back and watch criminals steal from those we care about.

And that's what it really boils down to: Not "don't steal or you can be killed," but "don't be so brazen about your criminal activity you do it in plain sight and think you won't face any serious consequences."
 
That's a huge load of self-serving left-wing garbage. You can prove pretty much anything if you massage the data enough, or take it far enough out of context.

which does not prove that this was done in the present case.
Read the FBI Uniform Crime Statistics, and the DOJ statistics. The US does not have even remotely close to the level of the general populace slagging each other that many other industrialized nations (such as the aforementioned Russia and Mexico) do.

You are comparing Mexico with a per capita income of 12K and Russia with a per capita income of 14K with the US, with a per capita income of 45K. Would this, perhaps, be apples and oranges?

The vast majority of the violent crime that makes up that misleadingly simplistic number is internecine warfare between drug-money-funded street gangs, and other fallout from the War on Drugs. Factor that out, and our violent crime rate is on a par with Western Europe and Canada.

Reinforcing your point that "you can prove pretty much anything if you massage the data enough, or take it far enough out of context".
 
Reinforcing your point that "you can prove pretty much anything if you massage the data enough, or take it far enough out of context".


Bottom line, when it comes to guns there's only one statistic that matters to me. That's the guy who becomes one because he tried to make me one.
clint.gif
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom