Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

He is law abiding, that is what the grand jury said so that he doesn't have to resolve bit of cognitive dissonence.

Given how many people think that he did the perfect thing, it would say that it is very american, remember americans are a very violent people, just look at murder rates compared to the rest of the western world.

Not avoiding confrontation is a major part of those stand your ground laws.

We're 24th in per-capita murder rates:

http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_percap-crime-murders-per-capita

And on the internet, you'll get plenty of people defending just about anything. To say that reflects America is simply retarded.
 
I did not claim that we are 1 in the world in murder rate just #1 for any kind of developed western country.

Finland is the next highest with a bit over half americas murder rate. .043 vs .028.

"Any kind of developed?" No. "Any kind of developed" would include Russia, Poland, Mexico and so forth. "Fully developed" yes, but it's not us and the countries who stone witches with similar rates.

And the fact is, if we have such a high murder rate I'm damn sure going to protect myself. That's the reason for one in the pocket, one in the glove compartment, and one in the nightstand.
clint.gif
 
Hehehe, no matter what side I take in a forum thread about firearms, by page 2 I'm Mr. NRA. :D
 
I did not claim that we are 1 in the world in murder rate just #1 for any kind of developed western country.

Finland is the next highest with a bit over half americas murder rate. .043 vs .028.

We are also number 1 in the world for countries that exist between Canada and Mexico.

Way to force the figures support your viewpoint.
 
Fallacious logic, as usual. You do not know what the grand jury thought. They, like you, may support vigilantes shooting criminals who are not threatening them in the back.

well maybe but when you are finished manufacturing maybes to try and justify your fallacious position - the law said that he was not a vigilante and that he was acting within the laws of Texas.

And therefore, you are wrong.

And the lesson would be - don't break into houses in Texas.
 
well maybe but when you are finished manufacturing maybes to try and justify your fallacious position - the law said that he was not a vigilante and that he was acting within the laws of Texas.

And therefore, you are wrong.

And the lesson would be - don't break into houses in Texas.

Looks more like that is what the grand jury decided. The laws don't seem to have been interpreted correctly. He was in no danger. He went outside with the intent of killing them.

He placed himself in danger so that he could kill them justifiably. That does not appear to be the intent of the laws. I think the grand jury went with the outcome they wanted and not with what the law should have dictated.
 
"Any kind of developed?" No. "Any kind of developed" would include Russia, Poland, Mexico and so forth. "Fully developed" yes, but it's not us and the countries who stone witches with similar rates.

So we really do belong with nations that have reporters exicuted then?

We clearly belong in nations that don't have the rule of law as a strong principle.
 
We are also number 1 in the world for countries that exist between Canada and Mexico.

Way to force the figures support your viewpoint.

So american police really should have their corruption measured against the mexican police? Or the Russian police?

I guess those are the nations that represent the kind of company america wants to think of themselves as being with.

Kind of like we should respect when we earn our place on lists like US, Iran, Pakistan, China and Saudi Arabia. That shows our views.
 
So we really do belong with nations that have reporters exicuted then?

We clearly belong in nations that don't have the rule of law as a strong principle.

Nobody else has the freedom of speech rights we do either, as is evidenced by the Australia thread a couple of spots below this one. When you base your rights on our Constitution, you take the good with the bad (if you want to think it's bad. I consider it taking the good with the good myself).
 
Looks more like that is what the grand jury decided. The laws don't seem to have been interpreted correctly. He was in no danger. He went outside with the intent of killing them.

He placed himself in danger so that he could kill them justifiably. That does not appear to be the intent of the laws. I think the grand jury went with the outcome they wanted and not with what the law should have dictated.

There have been a strong desire and trend to remove any idea that people have some obligation to try to avoid conflict. Now he did go further and initiated conflict but broadly it does seem to support such vigilantism.
 
Nobody else has the freedom of speech rights we do either, as is evidenced by the Australia thread a couple of spots below this one. When you base your rights on our Constitution, you take the good with the bad (if you want to think it's bad. I consider it taking the good with the good myself).

This has not been about guns until now you realize. This is about when society sanctions violence.
 
There have been a strong desire and trend to remove any idea that people have some obligation to try to avoid conflict. Now he did go further and initiated conflict but broadly it does seem to support such vigilantism.

Even if you want to believe that about Texas (which is still iffy at best) it's grossly unfair to blanket all of America with this mindset. Hell, here in South Carolina we're all about the Castle Doctrine and law and order and all that. But you better stay within the clearly-defined boundries of what you can and can't do with a gun.

Google "Jason Dickey." It's our most well-known case of what does and doesn't constitute legal use of lethal force. Again, he did engage but the circumstances were different across the board (and in every way, he at least seemed more justified than Horn). Yet he sits in jail.

One instance does not a societal trend make.
 
Although I am uncomfortable with the precedent, I am not all that unhappy with the outcome in this case. Based on the reports at least, it looks to me like Joe Horne is an honorable person who tried to do the right thing, got over his head, panicked, and shot two thieves in the back. I do not particularly mourn that two career criminals received what amounts to excessive punishment for their misdeeds. There are too many innocents in the world far more deserving of tears. And I don't think that Joe Horne is much of a threat to the community, so locking him up would serve little purpose other than making him an example for future vigilantes.
 
There have been a strong desire and trend to remove any idea that people have some obligation to try to avoid conflict. Now he did go further and initiated conflict but broadly it does seem to support such vigilantism.

Yes, we should all stand by as our neighbor's property is being jacked, or when your friend's car is being stolen from it's parking space, or when a man is beating another in public, and etc...In these cases, or any other for that matter, we should cower in our homes fearfully staring at the door while we await to see whether we're next. After all, it's not your stuff right? Besides, we each have a personal policeman to protect us who follows each of us around 24 hrs a day. And trying to stop another person from committing a crime, or warning them not to attempt the same crime on you is the same a creating conflict; nevermind that the "conflict" was, in reality, created by the criminals themselves. By the way, how do you know he was not in any danger? How do you know that his home was not next?
 
Even if you want to believe that about Texas (which is still iffy at best) it's grossly unfair to blanket all of America with this mindset. Hell, here in South Carolina we're all about the Castle Doctrine and law and order and all that. But you better stay within the clearly-defined boundries of what you can and can't do with a gun.

Google "Jason Dickey." It's our most well-known case of what does and doesn't constitute legal use of lethal force. Again, he did engage but the circumstances were different across the board (and in every way, he at least seemed more justified than Horn). Yet he sits in jail.

One instance does not a societal trend make.

Maybe but the general trend to remove requirements for people to try to avoid conflict if possible is certainly there.

This might not be typical, but he certainly fits well with in the stand your ground mindset that is being promoted.

As for Jason Dickey, I don't have a problem with him being in jail.

It would seem that if he was fine, then I am reminded of a similar situation before the famous one in Jena. In that two groups where having an arguement, one teen goes to his truck and gets his shotgun, and returns, the others take it away from him.

They get charged with theft of a fire arm, so once again it shows that bringing guns into an arguement is often not punished like it should be(there it seems like it might have been strongly racialy motivated, but such a motivation can not be dismissed in the dismissal of horne either)
 
Yes, we should all stand by as our neighbor's property is being jacked, or when your friend's car is being stolen from it's parking space, or when a man is beating another in public, and etc

First there was no one home and no ones life was at risk. Horne chose to put his life at risk.

Of course listening to the police is also something that no one should ever do as well(9/11 operators are all on the side of the criminals it is a well known fact)
...In these cases, or any other for that matter, we should cower in our homes fearfully staring at the door while we await to see whether we're next. After all, it's not your stuff right?

Ah you clearly support killing people over property crimes. Then the police should have the same ammount of power as private citizens like mr. Horne so kill ciminals when they decide it is warrented.

By the way, how do you know he was not in any danger? How do you know that his home was not next?

Because he was in his house calling 9/11. If he stayed inside and did not initiate the conflict he would have been totaly safe. But he grabed his gun and went looking for trouble.
 
As for Jason Dickey, I don't have a problem with him being in jail.


I really don't either. Both he and Horn were right at the line I'd personally draw if I was making the law, and when you're that close the hammer can fall on either side of a verdict.
 
And I don't think that Joe Horne is much of a threat to the community, so locking him up would serve little purpose other than making him an example for future vigilantes.

A great many of the people locked up are of no threat to the comunity.

Manslaughter is the classic conviction of someone who is highly unlikely to be a continueing threat.
 
I really don't either. Both he and Horn were right at the line I'd personally draw if I was making the law, and when you're that close the hammer can fall on either side of a verdict.

I would not think they are close to the line. Both initiate conflict and brandish a weapon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom