Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

Another thing I think is getting lost in this when someone says it's "open season on criminals" is Horn didn't get a pat on the back from the police here. The grand jury took TWO WEEKS to decide whether to indict. Not for the trial, for the DECISION TO INDICT! That's not Jim Crow, that's dissecting every word of testimony, every piece of physical evidence, and engaging in vigorous debate over the relevant parts of the penal code.

If I'm reading it correctly, the evidence proves the first criminal was closer to him when he fired than he was when the warning was issued. That means he advanced. From there it becomes a bit more speculative but my best guess is the guy came towards him in a threatening manner, Horn cocked the gun, and then the guy turned to flee. Unfortunately for him by that time Horn had made the decision to fire.

As far as the second guy goes, the bottom line is together the two burglars constituted a single threat. And once you've decided to use lethal force, the rule to "keep firing until there's no longer a threat" (which is not the same thing as "keep shooting until your target is dead"). In a situation where you have a criminal in close range and you've just killed his firend, you may not have time to decide whether he's turning to run or turning to keep you from seeing him pull the gun out of his inside-waistband holster.

That isn't blood lust, it's panic. It's why cops tell you to fire at least three times to center mass (chest), because even the guys who train for these moments often miss badly on their shot due to the fear-driven adrenaline rush which comes with the situation. You have a split second to make a terrible decision with a thousand thoughts all rushing through your head at once.

...so yeah, I have no problem giving Horn the benefit of the doubt. He never should have gone out there in the first place, but whether he had murder on his mind or simple concern for his neighbors when he opened his front door is something none of us can ever really know.
 
Another thing I think is getting lost in this when someone says it's "open season on criminals" is Horn didn't get a pat on the back from the police here. The grand jury took TWO WEEKS to decide whether to indict. Not for the trial, for the DECISION TO INDICT! That's not Jim Crow, that's dissecting every word of testimony, every piece of physical evidence, and engaging in vigorous debate over the relevant parts of the penal code.

If I'm reading it correctly, the evidence proves the first criminal was closer to him when he fired than he was when the warning was issued. That means he advanced. From there it becomes a bit more speculative but my best guess is the guy came towards him in a threatening manner, Horn cocked the gun, and then the guy turned to flee. Unfortunately for him by that time Horn had made the decision to fire.

As far as the second guy goes, the bottom line is together the two burglars constituted a single threat. And once you've decided to use lethal force, the rule to "keep firing until there's no longer a threat" (which is not the same thing as "keep shooting until your target is dead"). In a situation where you have a criminal in close range and you've just killed his firend, you may not have time to decide whether he's turning to run or turning to keep you from seeing him pull the gun out of his inside-waistband holster.

That isn't blood lust, it's panic. It's why cops tell you to fire at least three times to center mass (chest), because even the guys who train for these moments often miss badly on their shot due to the fear-driven adrenaline rush which comes with the situation. You have a split second to make a terrible decision with a thousand thoughts all rushing through your head at once.

...so yeah, I have no problem giving Horn the benefit of the doubt. He never should have gone out there in the first place, but whether he had murder on his mind or simple concern for his neighbors when he opened his front door is something none of us can ever really know.

I would like to give the grand jury the benefit of the doubt. None of us were in that room when the evidence was presented, so it is presumptuous to try to second guess them.

We can all speculate about what really happened. Whether the first robber wa running towards Horne with a weapon and then turned as Horne was firing, or whether he was running to escape and had to take a step towards Horne to, for example, get around a bush and was then shout in the back several seconds later when any reasonable observer would have concluded that his actions were not threatening to Horne is unknown. The best I can do is assume that the grand jury examined the evidence and came to the conclusion that Horne's claim that he believed he was threatened was credible.

I also agree with the assessment of Horne's probable mental state. He went out with a gun to confront two crooks, found himself in over his head, and panicked.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom