Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

I actually disagree with the findings. The recordings are are actually pretty damning proof that he his life was never at risk and that he was looking to pick a fight especially when police was already enroute and when he fired at the burglers who were running away.

What would be the same decision if a police officer had shot unarmed burglers in the back?
 
I actually disagree with the findings. The recordings are are actually pretty damning proof that he his life was never at risk and that he was looking to pick a fight especially when police was already enroute and when he fired at the burglers who were running away.

You must be unfamiliar with the "Castle Law" in Texas then.

What would be the same decision if a police officer had shot unarmed burglers in the back?

Since were making things up.
Would it be the same if two people ate hotdogs at a Yankee game?

The burglars were not unarmed and Joe Horne was operating with the law.
 
You must be unfamiliar with the "Castle Law" in Texas then.
Nope, not familiar with it. Does the castle law apply to ones own property of someone elses?

Since were making things up.
Would it be the same if two people ate hotdogs at a Yankee game?

The burglars were not unarmed and Joe Horne was operating with the law.
The article did not state if they were armed. If they were, I stand corrected. What were they armed with?
 
All of the above (hence the no-bill)

I understand with melee weapons. Pipes, crowbars of some sort.

Then I agree with the decision. The article does mention that one of the burglars ran towards him before running away...I guess it could mean that he felt his life was at risk. I still don't think he was acting responsibly.

However, I do have an issue if the Castle Law applies to someone elses property. While I see no problem with shooting someone who is burglarizing your property or if you think your neighbor's life was a risk, I wonder if it will lead to vigilantism and use of force when it would not have been necessary?

How exactly is the Castle Law worded? Any idea?
 
What would be the same decision if a police officer had shot unarmed burglers in the back?


It would depend where it happened and what color the suspects were.

In Cincinatti, it is perfectly legal for police to shoot unarmed men in the back.
 
Fallacious logic, as usual. You do not know what the grand jury thought. They, like you, may support vigilantes shooting criminals who are not threatening them in the back.

I know that the Grand Jury voted that there was not enough evidence that this man committed a crime to a attempt a prosecution.


:irule:13:
 
That is the point of the jury system, is it not?
We are not debating the point of the jury system. We were debating whether you support vigilantes who are not themselves threatened shooting criminals in the back. I was merely pointing out that the jury failing to indict is not proof that this did not happen, as you have implied. Try again.
 
I'm as 2nd Amendment as anyone, but based on what I know about the case I definitely disagree with the Grand Jury. What Horn did seems to fit every definition of "escalation" I've ever seen.

That said, I'm not worried about any great travesty of justice here. You break into a house, you takes your chances. I'm not saying it was a fitting punishment, but it was a situation they put themselves in.
 
We are not debating the point of the jury system. We were debating whether you support vigilantes who are not themselves threatened shooting criminals in the back. I was merely pointing out that the jury failing to indict is not proof that this did not happen, as you have implied. Try again.

No, and that was not the circumstance.

Fallacy: Straw Man


:irule:13:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom