Joe Horne Cleared by Grand Jury

....That said, I'm not worried about any great travesty of justice here. You break into a house, you takes your chances. I'm not saying it was a fitting punishment, but it was a situation they put themselves in.....


And in Texas, to boot. Whatever business a man is in, he needs to know all there is to know about it.
 
I'm as 2nd Amendment as anyone, but based on what I know about the case I definitely disagree with the Grand Jury. What Horn did seems to fit every definition of "escalation" I've ever seen.

I disagree with his actions but if this version of the "castle law" as passed by "those crazy Texans" say its okay, I can't fault the Grand Jury for giving this guy a pass. I personally think that the guy is a moron who escalated a situation beyond his control. He is irresponsible.

That said, I'm not worried about any great travesty of justice here. You break into a house, you takes your chances. I'm not saying it was a fitting punishment, but it was a situation they put themselves in.
I can't fault someone for shooting a burglar who is invading your home but I worry that laws like this can basically mean a license to kill anyone trespassing...there should be a clause of "reasonable threat" to life, safety etc. which could allow a Persecutor or Grand Jury to indict if someone unreasonably kills someone. Anyone familiar with the Texas "Castle Law" and its clauses etc.?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_law
 
Last edited:
I dunno, while I'm a BIG fan of the castle doctrine to me the argument seems to lose credibility since he crossed borders. It really should end at one's own moat.

But then I'm not a grand juror. Tough break illegal aliens committing crimes. :p
 
Last edited:
I guess Texans hate America more than most? WTF kind of decision is this?
 
I dunno, while I'm a BIG fan of the castle doctrine to me the argument seems to lose credibility since he crossed borders. It really should end at one's own moat.

But then I'm not a grand juror. Tough break illegal aliens committing crimes. :p

Joe's lawyer said that the suspects stepped onto Joe's lawn.
 
Joe's lawyer said that the suspects stepped onto Joe's lawn.

From the way I read it, that happened after he'd confronted them.

It's grey area, and to be honest I'm glad they erred on the side of the guy who didn't set out to break the law that night. But if he'd been indicted I wouldn't have argued his rights were being violated.
 
I'm as 2nd Amendment as anyone, but based on what I know about the case I definitely disagree with the Grand Jury. What Horn did seems to fit every definition of "escalation" I've ever seen.

That said, I'm not worried about any great travesty of justice here. You break into a house, you takes your chances. I'm not saying it was a fitting punishment, but it was a situation they put themselves in.

Thoroughly agree. "Castle doctrine" or no, I think you really have to undertake some convoluted mental gymnastics to find moral justification for what Horne did. Not only that, but he also provides a ready-made poster child for anti-gun activists who like to paint pro-gun and pro-CHL people as trigger-happy hillbillies who think they're John Wayne Justice Dispensers.:rolleyes:
 
Thoroughly agree. "Castle doctrine" or no, I think you really have to undertake some convoluted mental gymnastics to find moral justification for what Horne did.

Not really.

It is not a stretch to assume that his neighbors house was the only one on their list (whether for that evening or another). These were not boy scouts, they were career criminals. Anyone who violates another persons home in such a way should not be given the benefit of the doubt.


Not only that, but he also provides a ready-made poster child for anti-gun activists who like to paint pro-gun and pro-CHL people as trigger-happy hillbillies who think they're John Wayne Justice Dispensers.:rolleyes:

Those half-a-tards need no excuse to malign law abiding citizens and begin dry-humping criminals.:rolleyes:
 
Not really.

It is not a stretch to assume that his neighbors house was the only one on their list (whether for that evening or another). These were not boy scouts, they were career criminals. Anyone who violates another persons home in such a way should not be given the benefit of the doubt.
Now that is amazing mental gymnastics. You don't get to kill someone for a crime they have yet to commit and the fact that they were "career criminals" is irrelevant when the punishment does not fit the crime. You don't shoot a pick pocket even if they that person is a murderer. That sparks of vigilantism.

It is this type of moral gymnastics that make me fear the abuse of this law.
 
Now that is amazing mental gymnastics. You don't get to kill someone for a crime they have yet to commit and the fact that they were "career criminals" is irrelevant when the punishment does not fit the crime. You don't shoot a pick pocket even if they that person is a murderer. That sparks of vigilantism.

I think you misunderstand what I am saying.

My comments were to give a simple explanation of the thought process that drove Mr. Horne outside.

He wanted to shoo away the criminals from his home. The criminals made the deadly mistake to run at a citizen with a shotgun.


It is this type of moral gymnastics that make me fear the abuse of this law.

It is the criminals that are guilty of abuse.

Invasion/violation of someones home is a crime of terror.

For those who are worried about the criminals give them some advice taken from the Jim Carrry movie Liar, Liar

STOP BREAKING THE LAW *******!!!!
 
I'm as 2nd Amendment as anyone, but based on what I know about the case I definitely disagree with the Grand Jury. What Horn did seems to fit every definition of "escalation" I've ever seen.
BUt it is texas, so being able to stand your ground is far more important than worrying about things like escalation
That said, I'm not worried about any great travesty of justice here. You break into a house, you takes your chances. I'm not saying it was a fitting punishment, but it was a situation they put themselves in.

A wonderful argument for lethal traps as home defense that.
 
I think you misunderstand what I am saying.

My comments were to give a simple explanation of the thought process that drove Mr. Horne outside.

He wanted to shoo away the criminals from his home. The criminals made the deadly mistake to run at a citizen with a shotgun.
Which smacks of vigilantism that ended with self-defense...lucky for Horne that it wasn't the neighbor's drunk friends or family.


It is the criminals that are guilty of abuse.

Invasion/violation of someones home is a crime of terror.
No argument from me. If someone violates my home, I'd shoot him with my gun. I'm more worried about the precedent of the gung ho Horne's going around acting the hero...this will lead to tragedy, either Mr Hero is going to get killed of Mr. Hero is going to mistakenly kill some poor innocent person.
 
He will probably face a civil lawsuit and a federal civil rights charge.

I read somewhere that federal charges may be pending.

Horne is still in trouble.

It's BS, but he's still in trouble.
 
Not really.

It is not a stretch to assume that his neighbors house was the only one on their list (whether for that evening or another). These were not boy scouts, they were career criminals. Anyone who violates another persons home in such a way should not be given the benefit of the doubt.

That's out the window once he called 9/11. Once you've done that, and then confront the criminals yourself (with an operator pleading with him to stay inside) you're actively engaging the criminal. He could have called and kept his gun pointed at the front door in case they tried to break into his house before the law got there, and if they tried to "enter his castle" he'd be totally justified in turning them into swiss cheese.

Seeing someone commit a crime does not give us the right to become judge, jury and executioner.

For those who are worried about the criminals give them some advice taken from the Jim Carrry movie Liar, Liar

STOP BREAKING THE LAW *******!!!!

True dat. Regardless of how far over the line I think the homeowner went, ridding the earth of those scumbags doesn't dampen my day one bit.


But it is a right to grab a gun and confront someone, that is as american as anything you care to name. Well maybe not the glass armonica.

No, that's as Hollywood as anything you care to name. Real world has very different rules, as Horn is probably finding out during his sleepless nights. In the movies, you kill the bad guy and move on. The reality is even a completely justified shooting is going to leave deep psychological scars on someone who always considered themselves to be law-abiding.
 
No, that's as Hollywood as anything you care to name. Real world has very different rules, as Horn is probably finding out during his sleepless nights. In the movies, you kill the bad guy and move on. The reality is even a completely justified shooting is going to leave deep psychological scars on someone who always considered themselves to be law-abiding.

He is law abiding, that is what the grand jury said so that he doesn't have to resolve bit of cognitive dissonence.

Given how many people think that he did the perfect thing, it would say that it is very american, remember americans are a very violent people, just look at murder rates compared to the rest of the western world.

Not avoiding confrontation is a major part of those stand your ground laws.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom