Islam's war on freedom

FGM has nothing to do with Islam or religion, it is a regional / cultural problem.

in Nigeria for example, there are are more FGM cases in the Christian part of the country than in the Moslem part of the country.

something Islamaphobes like MrBaracude dont want to hear.
If this is true we should be critisizing Christian philosophy that permits or encourages FGM.

But there is a real problem with your claim. Islam and Christianity both put high value on chastity. Both call for the killing of adultery. To simply excuse religion as though it plays no part it is ignorance or dishonest.

It would be nice if you posted the evidence for higher incidences of Christian FGM than Muslim FGM.
 
Last edited:
If this is true we should be critisizing Christian philosophy that permits or encourages FGM.

But there is a real problem with your claim. Islam and Christianity both put high value on chastity. Both call for the killing of adultery. To simply excuse religion as though it plays no part it is ignorance or dishonest.

What's ignorant or dishonest is blaming everything on religion even when you've been shown that religion is neither necessary nor sufficient to explain the problem.

FGM is not a Muslim practise, it's a northern African cultural practise which is tolerated by some Muslim sects and actively opposed by others. It's practitioners justify it on alleged grounds of hygiene, chastity or social acceptance and not on religious grounds. It's got no more to do with being Muslim than eating pizza has to do with being Catholic.

Lots of cultures put a high value on chastity. Only the cultures in that specific region practice FGM, and Christians, Muslims and even some Jews all did it.
 
This should make clear how much I respect the UN HRC's decision and the barbaric death cult of a certain Arabian child-molesting terrorist.

Islam =

crybaby.jpg
 
Last edited:
If this is true we should be critisizing Christian philosophy that permits or encourages FGM.

But there is a real problem with your claim. Islam and Christianity both put high value on chastity. Both call for the killing of adultery. To simply excuse religion as though it plays no part it is ignorance or dishonest.

It would be nice if you posted the evidence for higher incidences of Christian FGM than Muslim FGM.

pls here you go

http://who.int/reproductive-health/publications/fgm/fgm_statement_2008.pdf

some more details about Nigeria
http://www.asylumlaw.org/docs/nigeria/usdos01_fgm_Nigeria.pdf

but i cant find the report (think it was 2003, WHO)
where it showed higher % in Christian parts of the country.
 
Last edited:
FGM has nothing to do with Islam or religion, it is a regional / cultural problem.

Stop living in a fantasy world. And you, Kevin Lowe, should read this as well.

See here, or here for examples, or what I wrote here. This is exactly what I meant in the thread with Upchurch and you when I was talking about propaganda. The very same propaganda you fall for over and over again. When cornered - just blame it on 'culture' or 'tribes'.

in Nigeria for example, there are are more FGM cases in the Christian part of the country than in the Moslem part of the country.

Yes, but we are not talking about that here right now. You are free to condemn Christianity for this practice if you can indeed source it back to the bible for example.

something Islamaphobes like MrBaracude dont want to hear.

Stop using that word on me just because you don't understand anything. What you don't want to hear is clear facts supported by evidence in for example the form of fatwas - which are based on Islamic core texts.

As for Kevin Lowe, tell me: Which sect did Muhammad belong to?
 
Last edited:
Stop living in a fantasy world. And you, Kevin Lowe, should read this as well.

See here, or here for examples, or what I wrote here. This is exactly what I meant in the thread with Upchurch and you when I was talking about propaganda. The very same propaganda you fall for over and over again. When cornered - just blame it on 'culture' or 'tribes'.



Yes, but we are not talking about that here right now. You are free to condemn Christianity for this practice if you can indeed source it back to the bible for example.



Stop using that word on me just because you don't understand anything. What you don't want to hear is clear facts supported by evidence in for example the form of fatwas - which are based on Islamic core texts.

As for Kevin Lowe, tell me: Which sect did Muhammad belong to?


can you source FGM back to the Koran?

btw how come FGm was already practioned while Mohammed was still alive.

MrBaracude, you are an Islamophobe.
do you think Islam is trying to take over the world?
 
Last edited:
can you source FGM back to the Koran?

You're only showing how much you don't understand about how Islam works and what place the ahadith have.

btw how come FGm was already practioned while Mohammed was still alive.

If you want to take this as indicative, probably mainly because of the Jews being around practising it.

MrBaracude, you are an Islamophobe.

No. We had all of this before. Why do you have to repeat it here?

do you think Islam is trying to take over the world?

Yes, and you are one of their useful idiots.
 
Can you show any actual evidence of this being the case in the last few decades? Faisal had some resistance back in the 60s but Muhammad employed unbelievers on the occasion so Faisal was able to argue around it.

It's a complex situation, but apart from the sectarian violence, I guess Iraq is a good example in parts. Now, I lost the plot. :(:D

That is not a situation that can be generalised across the islamic world.

No, but if there's hatred you can easily base on your religious texts, it does matter and not help when those helpers are outside of your own religion and the opposite. ;)
That Faisal could do it, good for him. He and his nation were probably still pretty weak at that point, right?

I mean, I guess you can argue they still are. My understanding though is they're (king and princes etc) walking a tight rope when it comes to those things even nowadays.
 
Last edited:
You're only showing how much you don't understand about how Islam works and what place the ahadith have.



If you want to take this as indicative, probably mainly because of the Jews being around practising it.



No. We had all of this before. Why do you have to repeat it here?



Yes, and you are one of their useful idiots.


oh so i dont understand Islam? well i do agree somehow, i really cant understand religions that whorship fantasy beeings.

but we learned from you that Islam is pretty monolithic. how some some Sunnis forbid FGm while other Sunnis claim it to be abligatory?
why are some Imans claiming that FGM is against the Koran and islam while other imans try to teach us that the Koran wants you to do FGM on your kids?


ah you brought up Jews. How come some Jewish communitys do still FGM?
how some when this is such a islamic thing?

i think in this case you are the usefull idiot :)
 
but we learned from you that Islam is pretty monolithic.

Oh? Where? It's not my imagination that 90% of Muslims identify themselves as 'Sunni'. You might want to look up what Sunni even means and where the word stems from and then what the word it stems from means.

I'll expand the question to you: Which sect did Muhammad belong to? What was his religion?

how some some Sunnis forbid FGm while other Sunnis claim it to be abligatory?

Who and on what basis? You realize you'll have a hard time going against genital mutilation when you have a sound hadith quoting Muhammad saying it's your 'natural state and Abraham did it', don't you?

You know, the very same stuff those people over at islamonline.net are basing their recommendations on. I urge you to read them again, which you clearly have not. Also read the posts I made and the relevant parts of them.

why are some Imans claiming that FGM is against the Koran and islam while other imans try to teach us that the Koran wants you to do FGM on your kids?

The Quran is not relevant here. Also, it's imam, not iman. Iman means 'belief'. Happens to be my sister's Muslim name by the way. :boggled:
I'd like to see your example of an imam arguing for FGM on the basis of what the Quran says. You'll most likely not find him. If you can, he is either lying or incompetent.

Also, don't make the mistake and think being an imam is anything special. It can be your regular guy from the neighbourhood just leading people in prayer. Nothing else.

ah you brought up Jews. How come some Jewish communitys do still FGM?
how some when this is such a islamic thing?

Can you read and comprehend something I write for a change?

a or the source (the when it comes to Muslims)

As for the Jews: Hell, why should I know? Why are we talking about Jews and Christians in here anyway? What's the problem with you people, always bringing up Christianity or Judaism when the topic clearly is Islam?

But anyway, ask a Jew. Probably has to do with the Talmud or what those tradition recordings are called. At least when it's really not tin the OT.

i think in this case you are the usefull idiot :)

You don't even understand the term and why I used it, do you?
And no, you are the useful idiot.
 
Last edited:
Oh? Where? It's not my imagination that 90% of Muslims identify themselves as 'Sunni'. You might want to look up what Sunni even means and where the word stems from and then what the word it stems from means.

I'll expand the question to you: Which sect did Muhammad belong to? What was his religion?



Who and on what basis? You realize you'll have a hard time going against genital mutilation when you have a sound hadith quoting Muhammad saying it's your 'natural state and Abraham did it', don't you?

You know, the very same stuff those people over at islamonline.net are basing their recommendations on. I urge you to read them again, which you clearly have not. Also read the posts I made and the relevant parts of them.



The Quran is not relevant here. Also, it's imam, not iman. Iman means 'belief'. Happens to be my sister's Muslim name by the way. :boggled:
I'd like to see your example of an imam arguing for FGM on the basis of what the Quran says. You'll most likely not find him. If you can, he is either lying or incompetent.

Also, don't make the mistake and think being an imam is anything special. It can be your regular guy from the neighbourhood just leading people in prayer. Nothing else.



Can you read and comprehend something I write for a change?



As for the Jews: Hell, why should I know? Why are we talking about Jews and Christians in here anyway? What's the problem with you people, always bringing up Christianity or Judaism when the topic clearly is Islam?

But anyway, ask a Jew. Probably has to do with the Talmud or what those tradition recordings are called. At least when it's really not tin the OT.



You don't even understand the term and why I used it, do you?
And no, you are the useful idiot.


it seems i missunderstood you, i thought you brought up FGM as a Islamic problem.
but now you agree that it indeed is not an islamic problem.
 
it seems i missunderstood you, i thought you brought up FGM as a Islamic problem.
but now you agree that it indeed is not an islamic problem.

It is an Islamic problem but not to the same extent and is not the same as for example this disgusting practice of sewing shut the vaginas of little girls as, I dunno who exactly does it, some African tribes do.
It still remains a practice very much connected to Islam and you can not deny this, unless you want to ignore the evidence I have already presented. Not that you'd have a problem with dismissing this. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
It is an Islamic problem but not to the same extent and is not the same as for example this disgusting practice of sewing shut the vaginas of little girls as, I dunno who exactly does it, some African tribes do.
It still remains a practice very much connected to Islam and you can not deny this, unless you want to ignore the evidence I have already presented. Not that you'd have a problem with dismissing this. :rolleyes:

but it is not only an islamic problem, it is then also a Christian problem and a jewish problem.

when some African fam that is Christian is doing FGM, then it is a cultural or tribe problem.
when a African fam that are Moslems do FGM, then it is an Islamic problem?

and this is Islamic propaganda?
http://www.islam.ch/typo3/index.php?id=69&no_cache=1&tx_articlecpl_pi1[showUid]=186
 
Last edited:
but it is not only an islamic problem, it is then also a Christian problem and a jewish problem.

You really don't get it, do you? Do I really have to explain everything as if you were a child?

when some African fam that is Christian is doing FGM, then it is a cultural or tribe problem.

When it has absolutely no basis in Christianity, yes, then it is most likely not a problem based on Christianity.

when a African fam that are Moslems do FGM, then it is an Islamic problem?

If they do it because their religion tells them to, yes. See below for more.


Yes, directed at people like you, easing your mind about Islam. Without reading everything, they are addressing something I - and others here I suppose - are not talking about in the context of Islam. And that is the complete removal of the clitoris, as well as the labia and - what I have said and not linked to Islam - the sewing.

I was going to make it clear, but discarded it then because I thought I was clear enough when I linked to what I have said before. Apparently I was wrong to assume you would actually understand my position. You'd do good to actually read things I specifically link you to. Namely this:

[quote='Umdat al-Salik, Purification - e4.0 THE BODY]

e4.3 Circumcision is obligatory (O: for both men and women. For men it consists of removing the prepuce from the penis, and for women, removing the prepuce (Ar. bazr) of the clitoris (n: not the clitoris itself, as some mistakenly assert). (A: Hanbalis hold that circumcision of women is not obligatory but sunna, whileHanafis consider it a mere courtesy to the husband.)[/quote]

You read the islam.ch article as 'Oh my, Islam is against genital mutilation' - in the sense of any. But it's very specific and does not address the removal of the prepuce.

And now just for you a short summary in German:

Der Artikel auf islam.ch handelt von der Praxis, die nicht dem Islam zugeschrieben werden kann, wie ich bereits vage sagte, nämlich das Entfernen der Schamlippen, der Klitoris und das Zunähen der Vagina. Den Fehler den du begehst ist der, einen Artikel wie diesen flüchtig zu lesen und dann zu glauben, dass Beschneidung 'unislamisch' wäre - und damit hat sich das - was nicht stimmt. Vielleicht liegt's ja am Wort 'mutilation'?

Wie dem auch sei, in Zukunft lesen und verstehen was ich dir an Material geb. Sonst lass ich das mit dir, denn es fängt langsam echt an zu nerven dir alles drei mal erklären zu müssen, weil du es entweder wegen der Fremdsprache nicht verstehst, oder weil du einfach zu blöd bist oder es dir einfach nicht ins Weltbild passt und es deswegen ja nicht sein kann.
 
Last edited:
You really don't get it, do you? Do I really have to explain everything as if you were a child?



When it has absolutely no basis in Christianity, yes, then it is most likely not a problem based on Christianity.



If they do it because their religion tells them to, yes. See below for more.



Yes, directed at people like you, easing your mind about Islam. Without reading everything, they are addressing something I - and others here I suppose - are not talking about in the context of Islam. And that is the complete removal of the clitoris, as well as the labia and - what I have said and not linked to Islam - the sewing.

I was going to make it clear, but discarded it then because I thought I was clear enough when I linked to what I have said before. Apparently I was wrong to assume you would actually understand my position. You'd do good to actually read things I specifically link you to. Namely this:



You read the islam.ch article as 'Oh my, Islam is against genital mutilation' - in the sense of any. But it's very specific and does not address the removal of the prepuce.

And now just for you a short summary in German:

Der Artikel auf islam.ch handelt von der Praxis, die nicht dem Islam zugeschrieben werden kann, wie ich bereits vage sagte, nämlich das Entfernen der Schamlippen, der Klitoris und das Zunähen der Vagina. Den Fehler den du begehst ist der, einen Artikel wie diesen flüchtig zu lesen und dann zu glauben, dass Beschneidung 'unislamisch' wäre - und damit hat sich das - was nicht stimmt. Vielleicht liegt's ja am Wort 'mutilation'?

Wie dem auch sei, in Zukunft lesen und verstehen was ich dir an Material geb. Sonst lass ich das mit dir, denn es fängt langsam echt an zu nerven dir alles drei mal erklären zu müssen, weil du es entweder wegen der Fremdsprache nicht verstehst, oder weil du einfach zu blöd bist oder es dir einfach nicht ins Weltbild passt und es deswegen ja nicht sein kann.

you are a liar.

it is not propaganda at all. it was a conference of important figures in Islam and Doctors, they had a debate about all the diffrent forms of FGM. they also debated about if all of them should be forbidden. and the doctors was able to convince that all forms of FGM are painfull dangerous and not needed from any meidical viewpoint. and so the Islam guys agreed on that, and released somekind of fatwa that should forbid all forms of FGM. they even used the Koran to justify this.

btw, they also searched in the Koran if there is anything that would demand them to do FGM. and they came to the conclusions the only things you find in the Koran are very very vague. they see no justification in the Koran.

but maybe you know the Koran and theyr religion alot better than those peoples. maybe you could teach them a bit about theyr religion........

and while you claimed that i am to stupid to understand what they talked., can you point out which form of FGM they still alow ?

or is the whole thing just propaganda for ppl like me? they dont mean what they decided?
can you show me a fatwa that does demand FGM?
 
you are a liar.

Nope. You just don't understand what I am saying. What a surprise.

it is not propaganda at all. it was a conference of important figures in Islam and Doctors, they had a debate about all the diffrent forms of FGM. they also debated about if all of them should be forbidden. and the doctors was able to convince that all forms of FGM are painfull dangerous and not needed from any meidical viewpoint. and so the Islam guys agreed on that, and released somekind of fatwa that should forbid all forms of FGM. they even used the Koran to justify this.

Tell you what, I said I didn't read the whole thing. But from the first part, where examples of cutting and sewing are mentioned, I am pretty sure to know where it's going.

Point out where it contradicts what I've said here.

btw, they also searched in the Koran if there is anything that would demand them to do FGM. and they came to the conclusions the only things you find in the Koran are very very vague. they see no justification in the Koran.

but maybe you know the Koran and theyr religion alot better than those peoples. maybe you could teach them a bit about theyr religion........

Do you know what the ahadith are, and what authority they have? Yes or no.

and while you claimed that i am to stupid to understand what they talked., can you point out which form of FGM they still alow ?

or is the whole thing just propaganda for ppl like me? they dont mean what they decided?
can you show me a fatwa that does demand FGM?

Thing is, I showed you two already, you dolt!
Read and understand.
 

Protests are widely considered to be a political act. If some's religion and politics are one and the same it should be posible to show that protesting over food prices fits into islamic theology.



Clean up the rest of your post, it's unreadable.

Contains a total of 3 spelling errors. I think it can reasonably be parsed.
 
Who and on what basis? You realize you'll have a hard time going against genital mutilation when you have a sound hadith quoting Muhammad saying it's your 'natural state and Abraham did it', don't you?


There are no sound hadiths that go either way on the subject of FGM. There are quite a collection of unsound ones allowing pretty much every position to be argued which is about what we would expect to see if islam was droped over the top of existing tribal traditions.

In much the same wait that various christian saints and the pratices associated with them are pretty clear adoptions of pre-christian traditions.
 
Nope. You just don't understand what I am saying. What a surprise.



Tell you what, I said I didn't read the whole thing. But from the first part, where examples of cutting and sewing are mentioned, I am pretty sure to know where it's going.

Point out where it contradicts what I've said here.



Do you know what the ahadith are, and what authority they have? Yes or no.



Thing is, I showed you two already, you dolt!
Read and understand.

you linked me twice to "Circumcision for males" this is not comaprable to FGM.
a guy online gives advice. from 2004
while i linked you to a Debate at an University with real imortant people in Islam and Doctors. from 2006.
when Islam is only partial as Monolithic like you belive it is, then now FGM is forbidden in Islam.

so i ask again, can you show me the part in the koran or some fatwa or something like that that demands FGM in Islam?

btw: you didnt even read my link and you conclusded already that it is propaganda for idiots like me......
tells me alot about you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom