Islam's war on freedom

......
Doesn't sound like they're talking about the permissible circumcision as laid out by 'Umdat al-Salik and islamonline.net, now does it? It's pretty vague in my opinion:

no it does indeed not sound like they are talking about permissible circumcision as laid out by 'Umdat al-Salik and islamonline.net because on islamonline he was talking about circumcision for MALE.

and it is not Vague at all.

they came to the conclusions that ALL forms of FGM is HURTING the person, thus HURTING a moslem, and this is against Islam according to those people at that conference.........

this means, ALL forms of FGM are against Islam according to the guy you linked me to to show how FGM is an islamic problem......
 
no it does indeed not sound like they are talking about permissible circumcision as laid out by 'Umdat al-Salik and islamonline.net because on islamonline he was talking about circumcision for MALE.

Okay, I give up now. I quote your source, your page and talk about that page which is talking about the conference you cite, and you are telling me I am quoting a fatwa about male circumcision.

You are indeed a maroon.

and it is not Vague at all.

Yes vague. All the highlighting wasn't for fun, you know?
 
Okay, I give up now. I quote your source, your page and talk about that page which is talking about the conference you cite, and you are telling me I am quoting a fatwa about male circumcision.

You are indeed a maroon.



Yes vague. All the highlighting wasn't for fun, you know?

you said "it does indeed not sound like they are talking about permissible circumcision as laid out by 'Umdat al-Salik and islamonline.net"

i agreed on that because on islamonline.net, where you linked me to they was talking about male cicumcision............. and NOT FGM......

it is not vague, i wondered already why you left important parts unmarked.
Hurting moslems is against Islam/Koran (clerly stated in theyr debate)
they also agreed on that EVERY FORM OF FGM is hurting moslems.........
thus according to them, FGM is not OK for Moslems or Islam.....

does that mean no moslem will ever again FGM his little girl?
NO because they are not monolithic. some will maybe get convinced that it is not OK. and others will keep following theyr traditions and reject to THINK.
 
but pls, make clear your possition, im sure i am not the only one that has troubles understanding your position.
 
it is not vague, i wondered already why you left important parts unmarked.

One more try. What would those be?

Hurting moslems is against Islam/Koran (clerly stated in theyr debate)
they also agreed on that EVERY FORM OF FGM is hurting moslems.........
thus according to them, FGM is not OK for Moslems or Islam

So, if all forms are forbidden now on the basis of "Hurting moslems is against Islam/Koran", why is there a fatwa from one month ago telling us basically science is respected but useless when it comes to male circumcision, which is pretty much the same as female circumcision, since both involves removing the prepuce, from the penis and the clitoris, respectively, all the while at the conference they suddenly respect science so much, they would go as far as banning something which was apparently condoned and tolerated by Muhammad himself, even if the chain of narrators for that specific hadith is weak?

Another question would be: Why is there no update on islamonline.net about this, when this conference was so important and such a breakthrough?
 
What's ignorant or dishonest is blaming everything on religion even when you've been shown that religion is neither necessary nor sufficient to explain the problem.

FGM is not a Muslim practise, it's a northern African cultural practise which is tolerated by some Muslim sects and actively opposed by others. It's practitioners justify it on alleged grounds of hygiene, chastity or social acceptance and not on religious grounds. It's got no more to do with being Muslim than eating pizza has to do with being Catholic.

Lots of cultures put a high value on chastity. Only the cultures in that specific region practice FGM, and Christians, Muslims and even some Jews all did it.
I critisize religion for being conducive to the practice. To the extent that religion is in opposition to FGM then cool. I'm happy for that. But that doesn't excuse the degree to which sects are in favor of it or that Islam views women as property.
 
pls here you go

http://who.int/reproductive-health/publications/fgm/fgm_statement_2008.pdf

some more details about Nigeria
http://www.asylumlaw.org/docs/nigeria/usdos01_fgm_Nigeria.pdf

but i cant find the report (think it was 2003, WHO)
where it showed higher % in Christian parts of the country.
Thanks though you haven't shown that it is higher in Christian parts of the country.

Let's keep our perspective here. The thread is not about FGM. However it is clear that religion is conducive to FGM. It's clear that religion places a high value on chastity and that all of 3 Abrahamic religions call for the killing of adulterers. Yes, Christ and the first stone but that didn't put an end to Christians taking a dim view of fornication.
 
Last edited:
I critisize religion for being conducive to the practice. To the extent that religion is in opposition to FGM then cool. I'm happy for that. But that doesn't excuse the degree to which sects are in favor of it or that Islam views women as property.

Yes, and 'FGM' is not the only reason Islam can be criticised for.
I'm annoyed this has turnt into such an extensive discussion of 'FGM'
 
all of 3 Abrahamic religions call for the killing of adulterers. Yes, Christ and the first stone but that didn't put an end to Christians taking a dim view of fornication.

I'd argue against it because of that example which constitutes a break with the former rules and practices. Maybe another time, another place though. ;)
 
Christianity has been involved in burning people at the stake, for example. The pope tells people they can't divorce, they can't use birth control, even though the population problem is going to cause huge problems in South American countries, the Christian Serbs massacred the Muslim Bosnians. Christian missionaries as actively undermining Buddhist cultures in China. Christianity has plenty of it's own problems, both in the past and recently.
And I speak out, often, against Christian attrocities. Please join me in the R&P forum to discuss. If you want to talk about any current Christian attrocity in this forum I'm there. Please PM me if I fail to do so and call me to account.

Tu Quoque is poor argument AUP.
 
<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/G5-wgtoqFrk&hl=en&fs=1"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/G5-wgtoqFrk&hl=en&fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>
Did you mean,

 
Thanks though you haven't shown that it is higher in Christian parts of the country.

Let's keep our perspective here. The thread is not about FGM. However it is clear that religion is conducive to FGM. It's clear that religion places a high value on chastity and that all of 3 Abrahamic religions call for the killing of adulterers. Yes, Christ and the first stone but that didn't put an end to Christians taking a dim view of fornication.

yes i did indeed not find the link to that old report about Nigeria.

and yes i think i can agree that religions can be conducive to FGM.

the problem i have with the Abrahamic religions is hat they do contradict itself.
it always depends on how you interpret the old book the religion is based on.
it was my oppinion that all 3 of those religions do forbid killing eachother.
You shall not kill , you shall not judge, how comes killing adulterers into play here?
Only Allah may give or take live. how somes killing adulterers into play here?
i guess the Jews also have those contradictions.
 
ETA: I will read the rest of this thread and actually contribute, promise:p.

And WHAT kind of nick name is Tsukas? That has got to be the WORST butchering I've seen yet!!!!
@#$@!@#$@!@%T^
Then what about... wait for it...

416px-

STUKA BUDDHA!



(ducks)
 
Last edited:
Folks the thread is not about FGM. Though clearly there are Muslim, Christians and Jews that practice it and clearly religion and the irrational religious dogma is at the root of it.

The thread is about the HRC and criticizing religion.
 
i guess the Jews also have those contradictions.
Yes, but understand something, something crucially important here.

Judaism has a tradition of dissent and questioning.

Islam doesn't.

Debate and questioning is taught in Rabbinical schools. Submission and unquestioning is taught in madrases.

I'm more than happy to criticize Judaism. I've no problem with that whatsoever. The point is that Islam as it is constituted now is by and large resistant to change and takes criticism of Islam as heresy and is ready and willing to kill to stop criticism.

Preventing criticism is paramount more important than all other issues. Don't agree with me? Look at the cartoon mess. Look at Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Look at Salman Rushdie.

And don't give me that lunatic fringe nonsense. Perhaps not every Muslim but enough to make Rushdie and Ali fear their lives in every and any corner of the world.

Sadly, those who should be at the forefront of criticizing Islam choose PC instead.

Not me. Not here. Not today.
 
oh dear, that his linbough or so?
do you agree with him?
From a rhetorical stand point it's always best to attack the speaker first so I give you kudos on your rhetorical skills but I'm afraid you get no points for your argument.

No, it's not Limbaugh. I don't know who it is.

But let's discuss it.

He makes a great point. Muslims don't get outraged much over Muslim atrocity. You won't have Muslims filing to the streets in protests over Muslim atrocity. Muslims do get outraged over cartoons and they will take to the streets with AK-47 and banners if you print a cartoon of Mohammad.

Here's the thing. When Al Jazeera and the Muslim street express the degree of outrage over Muslim atrocity that they do over cartoons we will have gotten somewhere.

That's the point that I want the criticism to move us to. That's not likely to happen so long as those who should be in favor or human rights choose first to try and silence criticism of Islam in the name of political correctness.
 
Yes, but understand something, something crucially important here.

Judaism has a tradition of dissent and questioning.

Islam doesn't.

Debate and questioning is taught in Rabbinical schools. Submission and unquestioning is taught in madrases.

I'm more than happy to criticize Judaism. I've no problem with that whatsoever. The point is that Islam as it is constituted now is by and large resistant to change and takes criticism of Islam as heresy and is ready and willing to kill to stop criticism.

Preventing criticism is paramount more important than all other issues. Don't agree with me? Look at the cartoon mess. Look at Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Look at Salman Rushdie.

And don't give me that lunatic fringe nonsense. Perhaps not every Muslim but enough to make Rushdie and Ali fear their lives in every and any corner of the world.

Sadly, those who should be at the forefront of criticizing Islam choose PC instead.

Not me. Not here. Not today.
i knew that about judaism.

and a few posts ago i posted that Islam has huge problems especially in that case, change. they belive the Koran is Gods word, so it may not be changed.
and it is indeed a undeveloped religion, they have rules that maybe made sence some 100's of years ago. but sure not today. Christian religion evolved during time. not islam. but there are modern moslems that dont take the koran word by word anymore.
and i think Islam and all religions should be critizised when they violate Human Rights or do not respect other people religions.
and especially when it comes to Female rights, Islam is number one to be critizised, no doubt.
but even there there are Islamic "Clerics" that teach equal rights, and also there is a cultural problem, it cannot only be pointesd to religion.

Critique should be welcome, but the Demonisation alla limbough and other right wing nuts is contraproductive and often is based on uninformed oppinions.

after 9/11 i withnessed Moslems protesting Terrorism and Violence in the name of Islam. even imams in iran told their listeners that massmurder like 9/11 is wrong and finds no justification in the Koran. thats the stuff the right wing nuts ignore or claim they lie when thei say such things.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom