Islam's war on freedom

Your reasoning and logic is overwhelming.


So you didn't look up the definition of a theocracy?

How about you look up the definition of Sharia ("Sharia law" being redundant)?

ETA: Why don't you give us your definition of those two words? This should be interesting.
 
Last edited:
Your reasoning and logic is overwhelming.
Your rhetoric isn't.

Sorry, but that is still the same assertion that you've restated again and again without evidence. Your leap from a government actions being based on a religion meaning that the religion must be debated is wrong.
That doesn't even make sense.

As I said before, and you ignored before, in an assault trial, do you debate heterosexism in the Church? Ideological motives are rather irrelevant.
Look at the links above. Sharia law is specific. I'm sorry if you refuse to acknowledge facts. Sharia law calls for specific punishments for having a child out of wed lock. Putting your fingers in your ears and humming might make you feel good but it won't change the facts.
 
So you didn't look up the definition of a theocracy?
Facts are troublesome.

How about you look up the definition of Sharia ("Sharia law" being redundant)?
And how would one go about criticizing the act of putting someone to death under sharia (a human rights abuse) and not criticize religion? It is Islamic religious law. Things that make you go hmmmmm..

ETA: Why don't you give us your definition of those two words? This should be interesting.
Don't hold your breath.
 
Last edited:
But I do criticize and attack Christianity and for good reason. Spend some time in the R&P forums. I criticize Christianity frequently. Some Christians have me on ignore for pointing out that the god of the Bible condoned stoning women for adultery and killing of children. I quote passages proving that almost daily at times. I'm equitable in my denunciation of religion I assure you.

Then you need to be much clearer and more precise in what you criticise.

If you are criticising a religion in general for what it teaches, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly do doing just that.

If you are criticising a specific cultural practise, or law, or sect, or person, or group, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly to just doing that.

What you should not do is issue a blanket condemnation of a religion-in-general because of specific cultural practises, laws, sects or whatever just because you are too lazy to distinguish between the two.

I can criticise snake-handlers as irresponsible idiots without generalising that to a criticism of every Christian sect that hasn't explicitly disavowed "taking up serpents" and denounced snake-handling. (I could even do it if I lived in a world where a significant percentage of Christians were snake-handlers).

The problem Kevin is that there is gross abuse carried out in the name of Islam at this very moment. And it's not just in the name of Islam it is condoned and encouraged by the religion. Further, many nations are theocratically Islamic and it is specifically the oppression by the religious clerics and their influence of the governments that cause so many problems.

So criticise the specific people or groups doing it, for the specific actions they take. Is that too hard?

Any time you start going on about "attacking... er, criticising... er, I mean, taking steps to forcibly reform" Islam you're immediately going to alienate many devout Muslims who aren't evil lunatics. Why on Earth would you want to do that?
 
And how would one go about criticizing the act of putting someone to death under sharia (a human rights abuse) and not criticize religion?

Exactly, and that's what the countries who kept pushing for banning criticizing them are counting on. Whatever we say against some of their practices they'll always say: "You can't criticize my religion".

It's a win-win situation for them.
 
Then you need to be much clearer and more precise in what you criticise.

If you are criticising a religion in general for what it teaches, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly do doing just that.

If you are criticising a specific cultural practise, or law, or sect, or person, or group, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly to just doing that.

What you should not do is issue a blanket condemnation of a religion-in-general because of specific cultural practises, laws, sects or whatever just because you are too lazy to distinguish between the two.

I can criticise snake-handlers as irresponsible idiots without generalising that to a criticism of every Christian sect that hasn't explicitly disavowed "taking up serpents" and denounced snake-handling. (I could even do it if I lived in a world where a significant percentage of Christians were snake-handlers).

So criticise the specific people or groups doing it, for the specific actions they take. Is that too hard?

Any time you start going on about "attacking... er, criticising... er, I mean, taking steps to forcibly reform" Islam you're immediately going to alienate many devout Muslims who aren't evil lunatics. Why on Earth would you want to do that?
  • In Infidel, Ayaan Hirsi Ali documents specific abuses endemic to religious indoctrination, how do you critisize the abuses without acknowledging the religious basis of those abuses?
  • How do you critisize the many abuses commited under Sharia by many disparate groups whose only link is the religion that gave them the law?
I honestly don't know how you separate the religion from the abuse. If the religion had nothing to do with the abuse it would be a fair request. As it is Mohammad did marry a child and many individuals from many different ethnic backgrounds justify pedophilia based on that fact.

I think we need to honestly address the problems. We need to encourage open dialog and a willingness to criticize religion when it is used to further human rights abuses.

Islam can survive and if it does that will be fine with me but there must be fundamental changes.
 
Then you need to be much clearer and more precise in what you criticise.

If you are criticising a religion in general for what it teaches, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly do doing just that.

If you are criticising a specific cultural practise, or law, or sect, or person, or group, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly to just doing that.

What you should not do is issue a blanket condemnation of a religion-in-general because of specific cultural practises, laws, sects or whatever just because you are too lazy to distinguish between the two.

I can criticise snake-handlers as irresponsible idiots without generalising that to a criticism of every Christian sect that hasn't explicitly disavowed "taking up serpents" and denounced snake-handling. (I could even do it if I lived in a world where a significant percentage of Christians were snake-handlers).



So criticise the specific people or groups doing it, for the specific actions they take. Is that too hard?

Any time you start going on about "attacking... er, criticising... er, I mean, taking steps to forcibly reform" Islam you're immediately going to alienate many devout Muslims who aren't evil lunatics. Why on Earth would you want to do that?
Why is it wrong to criticise a religion because of it's basic premises?
 
Last edited:
Then you need to be much clearer and more precise in what you criticise.

Sharia.

There, you can't be more precise than that.

If you are criticising a religion in general for what it teaches, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly do doing just that.
It's about being able to criticize Sharia. Any Muslim will know what this means.

If you are criticising a specific cultural practise, or law, or sect, or person, or group, then you should make it clear that you are doing exactly that, and stick strictly to just doing that.
Sharia is not an exotic cultural practice. Look it up.

What you should not do is issue a blanket condemnation of a religion-in-general because of specific cultural practises, laws, sects or whatever just because you are too lazy to distinguish between the two.
Again, Sharia is not a cultural practice.

So criticise the specific people or groups doing it, for the specific actions they take. Is that too hard?
That's exactly what we're doing, and we criticize the governments who promote and enforce these actions.

If they violate basic human rights, they shouldn't be able to hide under the guise of "religious freedom", or in this case "religious immunity".
 
Last edited:
But I do criticize and attack Christianity and for good reason. Spend some time in the R&P forums. I criticize Christianity frequently. Some Christians have me on ignore for pointing out that the god of the Bible condoned stoning women for adultery and killing of children. I quote passages proving that almost daily at times. I'm equitable in my denunciation of religion I assure you.

The problem Kevin is that there is gross abuse carried out in the name of Islam at this very moment. And it's not just in the name of Islam it is condoned and encouraged by the religion. Further, many nations are theocratically Islamic and it is specifically the oppression by the religious clerics and their influence of the governments that cause so many problems.

Banning the criticism of Islam is the worst possible move and antithetical to the purpose of the UN.

Martin Luther protested the Catholic church and that led to a reformation. We need to do something to end the oppression of the Islamic church.

I understand your point but the problems are so widespread and so entrenched at this point the best strategy, IMO, is to point out the abuses and not give religion a free pass simply because it is a religion.

But you are looking at this like the UN banned criticism of Islam forever in all contexts. This was the ban of criticism of religion in the Human Rights Council of the United Nations. Do you think it is the job of a body of intergovernmental bureaucrats to critique religions?
 
I think the thing that disturbs me about the OP -- if this is true, and the UN is effectively stifling discussion of religion and Sharia Law, is this:

Sharia Law isn't a religion. It's a framework of law that happens to be based on a religion. If you decide not to discuss religion, that's one thing*, but the UN not discussing law? What's left to discuss? Ponies?

*Okay, I realize that "discuss" and "criticize" technically have different meanings. However, I find that for many people, there is no distinction; in other word, even attempting to discuss -- say -- religion in a rational way is perceived as criticism. And I think that to not discuss religion -- any religion -- is a bad, bad, bad idea. Religion is one of history's primary justifications for the persecution of people by other people -- it has to be discussable. Otherwise, persecutors will simply come up with the explanation that their persecution is based in religion, and therefore may not be "criticized".

I sure hope that that's not the way the UN is going. Not that the UN has a whole lotta teeth, IMO, but one of its functions is to prevent genocide and large-scale persecutions, isn't it? Or am I living in a fantasy land?
 
Your rhetoric isn't.

That doesn't even make sense.

Oh, you are really winning me over with your rebuttals.

Look at the links above. Sharia law is specific. I'm sorry if you refuse to acknowledge facts. Sharia law calls for specific punishments for having a child out of wed lock. Putting your fingers in your ears and humming might make you feel good but it won't change the facts.

And your evidence that the rule means that the HRC can't critique a government for meting out those punishments if they violate human rights? Criticizing a government's actions is different than debating the merits of the theology it is based on. And I am still waiting for your evidence that the UN can't critique anything done by Sharia law or by Muslims.
 
But you are looking at this like the UN banned criticism of Islam forever in all contexts. This was the ban of criticism of religion in the Human Rights Council of the United Nations. Do you think it is the job of a body of intergovernmental bureaucrats to critique religions?
Of course you are ignoring the fact that many of the governments that we are talking about are theorcratic. And you still haven't given us a definition of theocracy but I'm guessing you know what it is.

To answer your question directly, when it comes to human rights abuses, damn straight. Of course.
 
Oh, you are really winning me over with your rebuttals.
Your rhetoric won't fix the nonsensical nature of your post.

And your evidence that the rule means that the HRC can't critique a government for meting out those punishments if they violate human rights? Criticizing a government's actions is different than debating the merits of the theology it is based on. And I am still waiting for your evidence that the UN can't critique anything done by Sharia law or by Muslims.
I can't make you see what you refuse to see. How do you criticize Sharia without criticizing religion? That's the whole point Tsukasa. That's what started all of this. You are being disingenuous.
 
Why is it wrong to criticise a religion because of it's basic premises?

I don't think it is, as long as you don't slip into the trap of defining "basic premises" in a different way to some of the actual practitioners of the religion. As long as all of the religion's followers agree that it's a basic premise, fire away.

  • In Infidel, Ayaan Hirsi Ali documents specific abuses endemic to religious indoctrination, how do you critisize the abuses without acknowledging the religious basis of those abuses?
  • How do you critisize the many abuses commited under Sharia by many disparate groups whose only link is the religion that gave them the law?
I honestly don't know how you separate the religion from the abuse. If the religion had nothing to do with the abuse it would be a fair request. As it is Mohammad did marry a child and many individuals from many different ethnic backgrounds justify pedophilia based on that fact.

Well, I find it very easy to separate the religion from the abuse unless every single Muslim (Muslim? Moslem? Are both okay?) in the world hitched a ride to Ayaan Hirsi Ali's place to abuse her.

As to how you criticise Sharia, you say "Sharia is cruel and barbaric, and lots and lots of other followers of Islam don't adhere to it because they agree that it is cruel and barbaric".

Islam can survive and if it does that will be fine with me but there must be fundamental changes.

I just got accused of straw-manning for mentioning the forcible reform of Islam, but unless there's an unspoken "or else!" at the end of that sentence then I can't make any sense of it. There must be fundamental changes... or what?

Again, Sharia is not a cultural practice.

Not all adherents of Islam adhere to or enforce Sharia. Ergo it's not an inherent part of the religion, it's a cultural practise of some people who happen to be Islamic.

There are lots of Muslims here in Australia. Los of them walk around the campus where I work all the time, headscarves and all. Yet despite this I haven't seen anyone being beheaded by culturally Australian Muslims.
 
Well, I find it very easy to separate the religion from the abuse unless every single Muslim (Muslim? Muslim? Are both okay?) in the world hitched a ride to Ayaan Hirsi Ali's place to abuse her.
By this logic no group could be criticized for their policies or practices. That just doesn't make sense. A significant number of Muslims engage in activities because of Islamic belief.

As to how you criticise Sharia, you say "Sharia is cruel and barbaric, and lots and lots of other followers of Islam don't adhere to it because they agree that it is cruel and barbaric".
I've no problem with that. I'm happy to admit that many followers of Islam don't adhere to Sharia. I'm happy to admit that many followers of Islam are peaceful people who are unhappy with the abuses carried out in the name of their religion.

Like Martin Luther and other reformers did, let's criticize the religion and focus the debate on the abusive aspects of Islam in hopes that it will bring about significant change.

I would like religion to go away but that's not going to happen. So we need to bring about change and we need serious change when it comes to Islam. The sky isn't falling but the problems are growing and in the not too distant future we face some very real challenges.
 
Last edited:
I think one of the main problems is that the Quran is not supposed to be interpreted in any way, shape or form. Where other major religions have evolved over time and tend to interpret or just forget about entirely certain parts of their holy books that are not relevant and/or acceptable in modern time.
 
Of course you are ignoring the fact that many of the governments that we are talking about are theorcratic. And you still haven't given us a definition of theocracy but I'm guessing you know what it is.

To answer your question directly, when it comes to human rights abuses, damn straight. Of course.

Well there's the problem.

Why should the UN debate the merits of different religions? That is not they're job. And that is not the job of the HRC. It is all about governments and what they do, regardless of their ideological reasoning for their actions.

Again, in court, do you debate the merits of heterosexism in the Church during an assault trial? No, because that is not the point of the justice system.

The point of the UN is to deal with governmental actions, not ideologies, and not religions. The guiding philosophy for their actions is irrelevant, they abuse human rights agreed internationally, that's all that needs debating in the UN.

If I shouted or talked down to you, would it help me make my point?

Your rhetoric won't fix the nonsensical nature of your post.

Well, just call everything I say nonsense and you don't have to provide anything substantive, now do you?

I can't make you see what you refuse to see. How do you criticize Sharia without criticizing religion? That's the whole point Tsukasa. That's what started all of this. You are being disingenuous.

Um, you criticize the abuse of human rights and ignore any theological reasoning for it, because it is extraneous for the UN?

But you calling me disingenuous is certainly a riot. My God, it took me this long for me to get you to say that you think it is under the purview of the UN to criticize religions.
 
Why should the UN debate the merits of different religions?
{sigh}

This is so dishonest Tsukas. A.) No one is saying the UN should debate the merits of different religions. We are saying they should debate various policies of religious organizations implemented through various governments that lead to human rights abuses. B.) I wouldn't mind if you made this remark at the beginning but at least 4 of us have told you over and over that religion informs governments around the world (see below). If religion is behind policies that lead to government policies that harm humans then damn straight. What is so hard to get about that? C.) Genital mutilation and honor killing is easily within the scope of the UN and the link to religion and it is within the scope of the UN to encourage governments to protect their citizens against religious abuse.


the·oc·ra·cy
  1. a form of government in which God or a deity is recognized as the supreme civil ruler, the God's or deity's laws being interpreted by the ecclesiastical authorities.
So, are you going to continue to stick your fingers in your ears and hum?
 
Last edited:
Which means eventually they can not criticise a or the source (the when it comes to Muslims) for - as an example - FGM in countries like Egypt, Sudan etc.

Jolly good!

FGM has nothing to do with Islam or religion, it is a regional / cultural problem.

in Nigeria for example, there are are more FGM cases in the Christian part of the country than in the Moslem part of the country.

something Islamaphobes like MrBaracude dont want to hear.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom