you linked me twice to "Circumcision for males" this is not comaprable to FGM.
Yes, I noticed that. My bad. While it's about male circumcision, it still has this part:
First of all, scientific researches, even though we highly respect them, are not a source of religious teachings. In fact, there is no contradiction between Islam and any proven scientific fact. Scientific researches and theories may change as time passes by and more technologies are available, and history is witness to that.
Therefore, it should be clear that Muslims do not skip their religious teachings while depending on speculations or tentative researches that might be proven wrong.
That is islamonline.net's position regarding science in a fatwa issued at the beginning of June this year, a little more than 1 1/2 years after the conference you referred to. Now, it's strange to me they'd make such a statement in light of the decision reached at said conference and the grounds they were made on, namely medical experts and the conclusion that 'FGM' contradicts the principle of not hurting a Muslim.
This is a fatwa issued by Qaradawi in 2004 in which he says:
In conclusion, female circumcision is permissible, on condition that just a small part is to be cut.
He goes on about medical opinion:
For example, Dr. Ahmad Shawqi Al-Fangari says:
It is medically established that the clitoris plays a central role in female sexual stimulation. Female circumcision, as practiced by midwives, means cutting the entire clitoris, and sometimes it involves cutting part of the labia. [...]
The operation itself is often performed in unhygienic conditions by unqualified midwives [...]
I believe that the way the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) advised the midwife to follow in practicing female circumcision does not have such damaging effects as cited by doctors and sociologists above. Such effects are rather the result of what is called Pharaonic circumcision (that is, infibulation), which, in fact, mutilates the female genitals and involves removing the entire clitoris, the prepuce, and adjacent labia, followed by sewing up the vulva.
DC said:
a guy online gives advice. from 2004
while i linked you to a Debate at an University with real imortant people in Islam and Doctors. from 2006.
Uh, islamonline.net is run by
Qaradawi. You know, the guy who took part in the conference you linked to.
when Islam is only partial as Monolithic like you belive it is, then now FGM is forbidden in Islam.
The NGO guy in the video claims otherwise and goes as far as to say (if I am not mistaken) 90% of Egyptian females still suffer from FGM.
Which begs the question: Did they mean FGM as in cutting off parts in their declaration, or did they mean circumcision as cited in 'Umdat al-Salik, which is certified by al-Azhar?
Let's have a look at your page (sorry for the English users):
Bei der zwei Tage währenden Diskussion ging es vor allem um die Klärung zweier grundsätzlicher Fragen. Gibt es in den Heiligen Schriften eine verbindliche Aufforderung des Propheten Mädchen zu verstümmeln? Dazu äußerten sich die Gelehrten. Sie waren sich bald einig, dass alle diesbezüglichen Überlieferungen als «schwach», das heißt unglaubwürdig, einzustufen sind, weil sie dem Koran und der Ethik des Islam widersprechen.[...]
Schwieriger war die Klärung der Frage, ob wirklich sämtliche Formen der Verstümmelung weiblicher Genitalien als körperschädigend eingestuft werden können. [...]
Auf medizinische Beurteilungen hatte vor allem Sheikh Qaradawi gesteigerten Wert gelegt.
Da Männer selten Augenzeuge der Verstümmelungen sind, wird das Kappen der Klitoris oft als positive «Veredelung» gewertet, vergleichbar mit der Beschneidung des Mannes.
Das dem absolut nicht so ist, machten die Darlegungen der Mediziner unmissverständlich klar. Dr. Lukman, Gynäkologe und Chirurg aus Addis Abeba, verglich die Entfernung der Klitoris mit dem Abtrennen der Eichel des Mannes, die Pharaonische Verstümmelung gar mit dem Abhacken des gesamten Penis. Prof. Kentenich zählte die unsäglichen Begleiterscheinungen auf, die Verstümmelungen nach sich ziehen.
Doesn't sound like they're talking about the permissible circumcision as laid out by 'Umdat al-Salik and islamonline.net, now does it? It's pretty vague in my opinion:
2. Weibliche Genitalbeschneidung ist eine ererbte Unsitte, die in einigen Gesellschafen praktiziert wird und von einigen Muslimen in mehreren Ländern in Nachahmung übernommen wurde. Dies ohne textliche Grundlage im Koran, respektive einer authentischen Überlieferung des Propheten.
3. Die heutzutage praktizierte weibliche Genitalbeschneidung fügt der Frau physische und psychische Schäden zu. Daher müssen diese Praktiken unterbunden werden
Also see this
transcript of an interview with Gum'a on the topic and while he says it is forbidden, a cleric by the name of Safwat Higazi disagrees and makes a good point:
If it reaches the point that someone prohibits something that existed in the days of the Prophet, and was not prohibited by him – this is completely unacceptable, whether it is the Mufti or anyone else.
While it certainly is subject to discussion, it is not forbidden, nor apparently enforced by law in place like Egypt, as the NGO guy at the UNHRC meeting states.
so i ask again, can you show me the part in the koran or some fatwa or something like that that demands FGM in Islam?
I never said it is demanded. See my quote of 'Umdat al-Salik and Qaradawi's fatwa of which I cited his conclusion.
btw: you didnt even read my link and you conclusded already that it is propaganda for idiots like me......
tells me alot about you.
Well, when they start off with examples of the cutting off of females' genital parts and the sewing of the vagina, which is something I am not talking about nor ever claimed to be Islamic praxis or endorsed by Islam, to go on and condemn
that, why should I read it when it is - as turns out -
very vague anyway and apparently addressing these practices?
Instead, you should have just pointed some parts out you want to discuss.