Islam's war on freedom

Evidence?
Look up the word faith. Is there any objective evidence that Mohammad flew to heaven on a white horse? What is the basis for Muslims to believe that he did?

Islamic scholars tend to agree that submission to God is a virtue, and that submission to anything else is not.
And how does one know what god's mind and will is?

Here's a hint, they are called Imams and clerics. Yeah, that's the flaw in your argument.


If only Islamic fundamentalists believed submission to worldly authorities was a virtue... then they wouldn't be causing so much trouble.
I don't know. Fundamentalists believed in submission to Mao and Stalin and that didn't do us much good. In fact it resulted in the death of millions, perhaps as many as 100 million.

To varying degrees this is true of all religions and ideologies. Most movements within Islam probably do quite well when it comes to critical thinking and skepticism compared to many other religions, because Islamic teaching is generally quite hostile towards superstitions and belief in non-abstract deities.
I prefer skepticism, critical thinking, free speech, freedom of the press and democracy. Perhaps it's just me. In the meantime, submission to Imams and clerics is causing all kinds of hell.

Oh, and the Muslim religion does no such thing. Perhaps it is skeptical of specific kinds of superstition like the Baptists are skeptical of Catholic iconography being idolatry, but few theologies are more hostile to science and critical thinking.

For this reason I think we should criticize religion often and loudly.
 
Last edited:
Regarding your notion that Islam is anti-superstition. Again, perhaps in a way as all theologies are skeptical of some beliefs. That said.

Footprints in the Sands of Science © Neil deGrasse Tyson

At no time since the eleventh century has the scientific influence of the Islamic world been equal to what it enjoyed the preceding four centuries. The late Pakistani physicist Abdus Salam, the first Muslim ever to win the Nobel Prize, lamented:
There is no question [that] of all civilizations on this planet, science is the weakest in the lands of Islam. The dangers of this weakness cannot be overemphasized since honorable survival of a society depends directly on strength in science and technology in the conditions of the present age.​

​
 
Sir would you please stop tap dancing and just answer the question?

By the way...we call these things numbers 1 witch is the one I use so I already gave you mine.Now how about you grow a set and answer the question?

i dont know how many.
 
Nevermind me expecting a coherent and reasonable answer based on you actually understanding anything of that which I quoted. Nevermind!

you kept mixing male circumcision and FGM.
they have released a fatwa that forbids all forms of FGM. (the link i gave you)
show me a newer fatwa that alows any form of FGM.

your links are about male circumcision.
 
Tell me just what % of the billion or so who practice this do you equate with wanting such things?
Give me a guess sir!
Even 1% is a awful big number that must be dealt with in the most severe way!
Pardon my semantics, but define "take over the world". "I endorse this worldview and hope for the rest of the world's sake that everyone will end up accepting it because it is so incredibly wonderful" is a different thing entirely from "we are, God willing, going to take over the world by force and make everyone else turn to Islam or face horrific consequences!".

I'd like for everyone in the world to use logic and reason. Does that mean I "want logic and reason to take over the world"? In a sense, yes. Does it mean I want a pseudo-Stalinist "everyone must be atheist and succumb to my interpretation of what science is" deal? Of course not.
 
Is there any objective evidence that Mohammad flew to heaven on a white horse?
Probably not. How does the absence of such evidence prove that Islam propagates the notion that ignorance is a virtue?

And how does one know what god's mind and will is?
According to most Muslims, particularly Sunnis, by reading the Quran. That supposedly gives one direct access to God's mind and will.

Yeah, that's the flaw in your argument.
No, that is only a flaw in the argument of those who claim that submission only to God and nothing else is possible, even desirable; which includes most Muslims.

I don't know. Fundamentalists believed in submission to Mao and Stalin and that didn't do us much good.
I haven't heard of those Islamic fundamentalists. I don't think Mao and Stalin had many suicide bombers and plane hijackers.

Mao is a particularly bad example. Much of the horror he caused was due to the fact that he encouraged hundreds of millions of young people not to be submissive at all, but rather to violently rebel against everything and everyone for whatever reason, causing all of society's support structures to collapse.

I prefer skepticism, critical thinking, free speech, freedom of the press and democracy.
I noticed.

Perhaps it's just me.
Well, no it is not just you. There are other people who feel the same way.
 
Regarding your notion that Islam is anti-superstition. Again, perhaps in a way as all theologies are skeptical of some beliefs. That said.
(snip)

There is no question [that] of all civilizations on this planet, science is the weakest in the lands of Islam.(snip)
To a fundamentalist Muslim, that just shows how far Muslim countries have strayed from "Real Islam".
 
Which makes Islam and scholars complicit when they hold the opinion of permissibility for centuries - only to suddenly figure out it's wrong and it should be condemned and even persecuted when some Germans drop by for a conference. :rolleyes:

"Hold the opinion of permissibility" suggests an element of pro-active descision makeing that is somewhat unlikey.
 
Folks the thread is not about FGM. Though clearly there are Muslim, Christians and Jews that practice it and clearly religion and the irrational religious dogma is at the root of it.

Since it seems to have survived changes in religion that is questionable.
 
There isn't much Christian terrorism around these days but there were protests in northern Irland.

i know. and there was Moslem protests against terrorism in the name of Islam, in several countrys. here in the German talking part of Europe there was a big number of Islamic Organisations that public stated that they are against Terrorism and organised Protests.
 
If you start threads full of hateful chest-beating attacking "Islam" you are falling into the cognitive error of lumping together and dehumanising a huge number of very disparate people.

I agree. Like people everywhere most Muslims are at bottom as decent as anyone else. Where it goes wrong is when their religion endorses intimidatory practices and sectarians are granted the authority of the state to engage in them. This encourages the less savory amongst them to acquire political influence through religion.

I don't think Islam is the problem so much as its access to government. If Muslims can be convinced that secularism is a good thing, then Islam is likely to become much more benign. If we are lucky, Turkey and Iran will eventually swing decisively in this direction and drag the other Muslim states with them.

If we are even luckier, the US will stop going in the opposite direction.
 
Because people make the religion. For every different person, there is a different type of Islam, just like for every Christian, there is a different Christianity.

By "people" I assume you mean the believers. To which I would reply, no, believers do not make the religion. Religion is simply ideas and stories, and the ideas and stories would exist independently of people believing in them. No one believes in Star Wars, but the ideas and stories that make up Star Wars still exists.
 
By "people" I assume you mean the believers. To which I would reply, no, believers do not make the religion. Religion is simply ideas and stories, and the ideas and stories would exist independently of people believing in them. No one believes in Star Wars, but the ideas and stories that make up Star Wars still exists.

Lots of Christians ignore the bits of the Bible that they don't like. They're still Christians in the sense that matters.

The same goes for Muslims and their holy texts.
 
This whole thread and the argumentations, the biases, fears and POV's can be summed up as this:

 
Too bad that muslim women wear headscarfs - yellow badges would make it a lot more easier, wouldn't it? :confused:

Please do not post off-topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom