Islam's war on freedom

Care to prove it?

Are you kidding? Prove what? That he's undermined human rights issues? That he believes in a 'reconstructionist', 'dominionist', theology?

If you're not willing to google "Bush dominionism" then I'm hesitant to derail the thread into what would inevitably be split off into a thread in the politics section.
 
Probably not. How does the absence of such evidence prove that Islam propagates the notion that ignorance is a virtue?
I'm not sure what the disconnect here is. Do you understand what faith is?

According to most Muslims, particularly Sunnis, by reading the Quran. That supposedly gives one direct access to God's mind and will.
Then they don't need to go and listen to Imams. I think you and I know that is a load of crap.

No, that is only a flaw in the argument of those who claim that submission only to God and nothing else is possible, even desirable; which includes most Muslims.
In the real world people listen to and follow the directions of their religious leaders.

I haven't heard of those Islamic fundamentalists. I don't think Mao and Stalin had many suicide bombers and plane hijackers.
Not the point. The only salient point is that fanatical submission is very, very dangerous.

Mao is a particularly bad example. Much of the horror he caused was due to the fact that he encouraged hundreds of millions of young people not to be submissive at all, but rather to violently rebel against everything and everyone for whatever reason, causing all of society's support structures to collapse.
Mao is a particularly excellent example because it demonstrates the problem of submitting to a charismatic figure. Mao's followers submitted themselves only to his will. Often acting in ways that were irrational like killing all of the sparrows. They didn't all come up with the idea on their own. They didn't all come up with the idea to reject intellectualism on their own. They didn't all come up with the idea to melt down their iron implements on their own. They were submitting to the will of Mao. I'm surprised you think this is a bad example given it's such an obvious good example.

I will say it again, submission to authority is a very, very dangerous thing. Just because it's a new authority that is rejecting the old authority doesn't change anything. It's simply a matter of meet the new boss, worse than the old boss.

If the followers of Mao were truly skeptical and capable of critical thinking they would have been willing to question Mao and not to blindly follow his directions when he told them to go out and kill the sparrows. They wouldn't have so readily given their will to him and melted down their iron implements.
 
Last edited:
To a fundamentalist Muslim, that just shows how far Muslim countries have strayed from "Real Islam".
I thought the discussion was between you and I? I don't care what a true Muslim thinks as it relates to this discussion. Only that Muslims, real, pseudo and imagined have poor skepticism and critical thinking skills and that Islam has ensured that these people live apart from the enlightenment. Of course, this is only important if you think the enlightenment has contributed to the quality of human life, reduced human suffering decreased mortality rates. I do.
 
Since it seems to have survived changes in religion that is questionable.
I don't at all see how that follows. Has religion changed as far as religious views on chastity and fornication?

Religion is conducive to FGM because religion places such a high premium on sexual fidelity and chastity.

That's the problem.
 
I have, which makes me think that some people in it might be simply insane.
So if, dear Goury, the thread title states "Islam's war on freedom" and the
OP whines about the UN, I assume that the UN is controlled by teh evil
Joos ehm Islamists, right? :rolleyes:

How much more blatant intolerance do you need to see yourself within
the mirror, oh great sensible reporting one? :confused:
That's dishonest and a strawman.
 
Please keep in mind that I'm not calling anyone here bigoted, but I'm amazed at some of the harsh language and heavy-handed rhetoric being used toward Islam, when the vast majority of Islam is not really reflective of the extremism you point out. I'm all in favor of demanding an end to extremism, but I don't limit it to just the Muslim extremists.
If there is any language of mine that you find offensive I will hapily address it and appologize if that is appropriate.

I'm not against Muslims. I'm against religious fanaticism and I'm very concernd about Islam at this time. I don't think that is unfounded and I think it demonstrable that many who are Islamic are moving to reduce critisicm of Islam and I can't think of a worst thing to do in modern western civilization.

I think Muslims should join us in the 21st century and not us join them in the bronze age.
 
Last edited:
In the real world people listen to and follow the directions of their religious leaders.

and who is this in Islam?
and do Christians follow the pope? for example about condoms?
btw, why did the US president not folow the religious leader, the Pope?
the Pope did say NO WAR, and Bush didnt listen to him.
how come God gave direct commands to Bush without informing the Pope? or is Bush a more respected religious leader than the Pope?
 
Last edited:
If there is any language of mine that you find offensive I will hapily address it and appologize if that is appropriate.

I'm not against Muslims. I'm against religious fanaticism and I'm very concernd about Islam at this time. I don't think that is unfounded and I think it demonstrable that many who are Islamic are moving to reduce critisicm of Islam and I can't think of a worst thing to do in modern western civilization.

I think Muslims should join us in the 21st century and not us join them in the bronze age.

the Moslems i know, including one Imam are alot more modern than you ever will be. you try to judge Moslems by the deeds of terrrists.
shall i judge you for the deeds of the soldiers at abu graib? ( yes i know, not all US citizens are that violent like those soldiers, but the outrage was not big enough)
 
Last edited:
and who is this in Islam?
I've already answered this question. That you ignore the answer and argue ad nauseam is a fallacy.

...and do Christians follow the pope? for example about condoms?
Sadly many do, and sadly many die because of it. I criticize the pope and the catholic church often for such ignorant and malicious nonsense.

btw, why did the US president not folow the religious leader, the Pope?
the Pope did say NO WAR, and Bush didnt listen to him.
I've no idea as to the significance of this but here is a hint Bush ISN'T a Catholic.

John F. Kennedy was a Catholic. This is what he had to say: :"I do not speak for my church on public matters; and the church does not speak for me."

how come God gave direct commands to Bush without informing the Pope? or is Bush a more respected religious than the Pope?
  • Bush is an a-hole who lied to the American people.
  • There is no god.
  • Your argument is really, really stupid.
Can't you find a better argument? This is really lightweight nonsense.
 
i am on topic....


do you have ANYTHING to add to the topic?

You agreed earlier that Sharia law should be criticized freely. This means you agree with this thread's premisse.

Then why are you still trying to portray Randfan as islamophobe?
 
Last edited:
I've already answered this question. That you ignore the answer and argue ad nauseam is a fallacy.

Sadly many do, and sadly many die because of it. I criticize the pope and the catholic church often for such ignorant and malicious nonsense.

I've no idea as to the significance of this but here is a hint Bush ISN'T a Catholic.

John F. Kennedy was a Catholic. This is what he had to say: :"I do not speak for my church on public matters; and the church does not speak for me."


  • Bush is an a-hole who lied to the American people.
  • There is no god.
  • Your argument is really, really stupid.
Can't you find a better argument? This is really lightweight nonsense.

oooh loo now, Bush is not a Christian?

i can undertand Moslems that get angry when people criticize their religion when they have no clue about that religion, like you just demonstrated.

who is the religeus leader for the Moslems? i must have missed that answer. so pls answer it again.
 
you try to judge Moslems by the deeds of terrrists.
That's a lie.

shall i judge you for the deeds of the soldiers at abu graib?
You have every right to criticize America for these crimes. You have every right to hold Americans accountable for these crimes.

That's all I want to do as it applies to Islam. I want Islam to take responsibility. I want to raise the consciousness of Muslims to stand up more and speak out more to end these atrocities.

If Bush were not leaving office by the end of the year I would join others in calling for his impeachment because I think America has a responsibility for what has happened.

Again, you:
A.) Don't understand my point.
B.) Make the wrong arguments because of your ignorance.
​
Why don't you listen to what I'm saying rather than imagine what I'm saying?
 
You agreed earlier that Sharia law should be criticized freely. This means you agree with this thread's premisse.

Then why are you still trying to portray Randfan as islamophobe?

because he does not understand Islam. he seems to see it as that monolithic world overtaking conspiracy like MrBaracude sees it.

but i would not go so far to call him an islamophobe, but interesting you brought it up. thx.
 
That's a lie.

You have every right to criticize America for these crimes. You have every right to hold Americans accountable for these crimes.

That's all I want to do as it applies to Islam. I want Islam to take responsibility. I want to raise the consciousness of Muslims to stand up more and speak out more to end these atrocities.

If Bush were not leaving office by the end of the year I would join others in calling for his impeachment because I think America has a responsibility for what has happened.

Again, you:
A.) Don't understand my point.
B.) Make the wrong arguments because of your ignorance.
​
Why don't you listen to what I'm saying rather than imagine what I'm saying?

Have you gone on the streets to protest the abuse in Abu Graib?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom