Islam's war on freedom

Did you read past the thread title?

Give me one example of blatant intolerance in this thread or be reported for derailing it.

ETA: Still waiting
 
Last edited:
Did you read past the thread title?

Give me one example of blatant intolerance in this thread or be reported for derailing it.


I did, which makes me think that some people in it might be simply insane.
So if, dear Goury, the thread title states "Islam's war on freedom" and the
OP whines about the UN, I assume that the UN is controlled by teh evil
Joos ehm Islamists, right? :rolleyes:

How much more blatant intolerance do you need to see yourself within
the mirror, oh great sensible reporting one? :rolleyes:
 
Do you have anything to add to this topic?


I have, which makes me think that some people in it might be simply insane.
So if, dear Goury, the thread title states "Islam's war on freedom" and the
OP whines about the UN, I assume that the UN is controlled by teh evil
Joos ehm Islamists, right? :rolleyes:

How much more blatant intolerance do you need to see yourself within
the mirror, oh great sensible reporting one? :confused:
 
Your reply, no matter how many times you repeat it, is incoherent and doesn't address the topic of this thread.
 
Back on topic, I see Tsuka is back online.

Could you answer please?

Tsuka, here's a hypothetical debate at the HRC:

President Tsuka: Somalia should stop executing people for being homosexuals, it goes against basic human rights.

Representative of Somalia: Homosexuality is a crime punishable by death in our Sharia. Sharia is our way of life, our religion, you can't criticize our religion.

What would be your reply?
 
Your reply, no matter how many times you repeat it, is incoherent and doesn't address the topic of this thread.


Well, if you don't answer my on-topic questions, why should I? :rolleyes:

...which makes me think that some people in it might be simply insane.
So if, dear Goury, the thread title states "Islam's war on freedom" and the
OP whines about the UN, I assume that the UN is controlled by teh evil
Joos ehm Islamists, right? :rolleyes:

Simple question, Goury.
 
Oliver, this is a serious conversation about things that have real implications in the world.

If you don't want to participate, LEAVE.

Being concerned about the fact that the UN is being bullied into not criticizing Sharia because religion is taboo, is not intolerance. It's a real and reasonable concern.
 
Last edited:
Oliver, this is a serious conversation about things that have real implications in the world.

If you don't want to participate, LEAVE.


Well, Goury - you asked me to point out blatant ignorance. That's
what I did, but you are not willing to agree with me or at least answer
my on-topic question in a way, that disproves this ignorance.

Quite the opposite: You're even more blatantly ignorant by ignoring
the blatant ignorance ... Funny, but not unexpected ... ;)

Here's my question again:

How is the UN controlled by the "Islamists against Freedom" again? :confused:
 
Well, Goury - you asked me to point out blatant ignorance. That's
what I did, but you are not willing to agree with me or at least answer
my on-topic question in a way, that disproves this ignorance.

You haven't given me an example of intolerance in this thread.

You don't understand the topic of this thread.

Quite the opposite: You're even more blatantly ignorant by ignoring the blatant ignorance ... Funny, but not unexpected ...
You're talking nonsense.

Here's my question again:

How is the UN controlled by the "Islamists against Freedom" again? :confused:
Read the OP again, and the links, and the discussions so far. This is not what this thread is about.
 
You haven't given me an example of intolerance in this thread.

You don't understand the topic of this thread.

You're talking nonsense.

Read the OP again, and the links, and the discussions so far. This is not what this thread is about.


Oh, I completely understand the OP - but it has nothing whatsoever
to do with "Islamists war on Freedom", as the Thread title claims.

Two different pairs of shoes. Don't you agree?
 
Oh, I completely understand the OP - but it has nothing whatsoever
to do with "Islamists war on Freedom", as the Thread title claims.

Two different pairs of shoes. Don't you agree?

It's a bit over the top, but let's just call it Pat Condell's creative license. This doesn't change the value of the argument.

Have you got an example of intolerance in this thread yet?
 
It's a bit over the top, but let's just call it Pat Condell's creative license. This doesn't change the value of the argument.

Have you got an example of intolerance in this thread yet?


Okay, let's forget the thread title and start with the OP's ignorant sources.
Official link to the [SIZE=-1]Human Rights Council's [/SIZE]resolution for a start - oh great skeptical one.


Shouldn't be that hard, is it?:

http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/
 
Lots of Christians ignore the bits of the Bible that they don't like. They're still Christians in the sense that matters.

The same goes for Muslims and their holy texts.

So what’s your point Captain Obvious?
 
Nah, nah ... You're not going to speak in Youtube-Videos now like the
Truthers would do, are you, Goury?

You won't even look at it? You're dishonest Oliver.

These are videos of the UN's HRC conference in progress. It's even better than any transcripts.

Here's another one.



Any legitimate concerns about Sharia is being undermined, every step of the way, by the Islamic countries.

How can you have a debate like this?

ETA: and BTW, you have no business to talk about people using Youtube videos, see your first post in this thread above, which BTW has nothing to do with this topic.
 
Last edited:
Can you give me one example of blatant intolerance in this thread?

Without the smilies.

The use of the 700 Club video on the first page is a good example. Can you really tell me that you think they gave an unbiased presentation? I mean, streets in London where non-Muslims can't walk? Please tell me of these mythical streets, because I'd love to visit them to see for myself.

This thread could just as equally be called 'Christianity's war on Freedom' as it could with Islam. It's not the majority of the religious, is the extreme and loud fundie sub-groups who are the problem, and with that I'll agree regardless of the doctrine they espouse.

It isn't that I think the UN's move on the issue of bringing up religious connections to human rights violations was warranted. I absolutely don't, and am a bit appalled at the audacity of the organization to make such a move. I think the overall tone of the thread, however, has been a bit too heavily pointed toward a religious motif, often to the detriment of conversation as to exactly why the UN move in the case cited is a bad one.

Another examople I can come up with was the question posed that actually asked if there were any significant Muslim "thinkers" (I'll assume they mean intellectuals or scholars) of a secular nature, and I have to admit I was dumbfounded by the question-- not because I didn't know of any, but because I couldn't fathom why someone would start from the opinion that there isn't anyone worth mentioning. Orhan Pamuk was one of the first who came to mind, not because he was a Nobel winner (in literature), but because a scandal he was involved in was covered by US press. Pamuk made a statement about the ethnic Armenians and Kurds who were killed in Turkey, typically referred to as the Armenian Genocide in Western history, but was considered criminally slanderous by the far right of the Turkish nationalists (and some in the government). However, the resistance to his statements and his subsequent trial were by the secularist nationalism, not religious. Pamuk isn't what you would consider 'visibly' Muslim (I've heard he sometimes referrs to it as 'secular Muslim'), but he acknowledges, identifies, and often writes about his Muslim heritage and how it reconciles and clashes with his education and appreciation for Western culture. Another 2006 Nobel winner who also happens to be Muslim is Muhammad Yunus, another individual whose recognition saw relatively noticable coverage in the US (for his micro-loan financing). Two notable humanitarian names I came up with were Shirin Ebadi of Iran and Abdul Sattar Edhi of Pakistan, both Muslims who have had the support of the US government, though mostly implicitly so as to not undermine their efforts. I'm sure there are others in the fields of mathematics and chemistry, but names escape me at the moment.

Please keep in mind that I'm not calling anyone here bigoted, but I'm amazed at some of the harsh language and heavy-handed rhetoric being used toward Islam, when the vast majority of Islam is not really reflective of the extremism you point out. I'm all in favor of demanding an end to extremism, but I don't limit it to just the Muslim extremists. Christian dominionism particularly bothers me, and bothers me more urgently than the Islamic extremism because of its proximity and more immediate ramifications to my life. Ny biggest concern on this topic is that the fight really does become one of Christian vs. Muslim ideologies, led by the loud and the extreme for both sides while the rest of us are in reality more opposed to the extremism of both.
 
Do dominionists have seats at the UN, where they can undermine any effort to raise concerns about abuses?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom