Islam's war on freedom

you are not a real american then? you do not interpret your country correctly when you dont belive it is God's chosen country`?

its not directed at the wrong person, you are an American, you admitted it :D

i hope you get it :)

Oh good LORD PLEASE RID US OF THE IDIOCY EXPRESSED RIGHT HERE!
 
You've asked me for proof that the HRC has banned criticism of Sharia in their debates and agree with number 3 of RandFan's list?

No - I asked you for evidence for this claim:

The problem is that we can't criticize certain countries because they'll automatically say we are attacking their religious beliefs.
 
connection to Christianity
I don't understand your point.

what? When Osama claims to act in the Name of Allah, you belive him?
not bad for an Atheist. There is no God. also not when you call him Allah.
My atheism has nothing to do with it. That a delusion leads to irrational behavior doesn't obviate the irrational behavior.

yes i think this is the main reason UBL declared his Jihad against the US.
and i think in his eyes he was justified by the koran to declare Jihad (as the Defensive war interpretation)
Isnt Saudi Arabia a very Islamic country? with a full inplementation of sharia laws? did that country agree on UBL's Jihad? Did the majority of people in SA agree on UBL's Jihad?
Completely beside the point. The extent that Islam led UBL to act the way he did I criticize it. Nothing more, nothing less.

No it does not. Some Interpretations of Islam do lead to violence.
Which is all that is necessary for my criticism but it's worse than that. Islam propagates ignorance is virtue, submission as virtue and discourages critical thinking and skepticism.

not all? ther are a few non violent folowers of a violent religion?
they arent real moslems then?
I don't subscribe to True Scotsman fallacies. To criticize religion isn't to declare all religious adherents as evil or violent.

you are not a real american then? you do not interpret your country correctly when you dont belive it is God's chosen country`?
Do you subscribe to True Scotsman fallacies?

i dont want to be criticed because i am an atheist just cause there are so many Atheist criminals.
  • If atheism is used as pretext for violence I will gladly condemn it.
  • If there is a link between atheism and crime I will gladly acknowledge it.
Are you getting my point yet?
 
No - I asked you for evidence for this claim:

The problem is that we can't criticize certain countries because they'll automatically say we are attacking their religious beliefs.

http://www.iheu.org/node/3193

Pakistan: [Imran Ahmed Siddiqui] Thank you very much Mr. President. Mr. President, the voices which we hear in this Council and the issues they raise are not unfamiliar. There is an agenda behind it and you have already given a ruling on the discussion of Sharia law in this Council6. We have strong objections on any discussion, any direct or indirect discussion, any out of context, selective discussion on the Sharia law in this Council. I would therefore request the president to exercise his judgement and authority and request the speaker not to touch issues which have already been debarred from discussion in this Council. Thank you very much, Sir.
Egypt: Mr. President, through you Sir, please Sir, I would humbly and kindly ask my colleague from Slovenia to reconsider. What we are talking now about is not about the right of NGOs to speak but about the Sharia law and whether it is admissible to discuss it in this Council. I appeal to my colleague from Slovenia not to accept any discussion of the Sharia law in this Council because it will not happen. And we will not take this lightly. This is not about NGOs participation in the Council. Before the speaker… before that, one spoke as freely as we want on sexual orientation, gays and lesbians, yes, because they see it under the VDPA (Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action) and they have been touching on the VDPA and nobody objected. This is not about NGOs and their participation in the Council. This is about the Sharia law. So I appeal to our colleagues not to get us there because we will stay there and it’s a good omen that we have these beautiful machines with us here because we will need them. [While concluding, he waves the small ‘voting’ machine in the air, triumphantly.] Thank you.
Pakistan: Mr. President, very respectfully I would like to state again that this is not the forum to discuss religious sensitivity. It will amount to spreading hatred against certain members of the Council. I mean, it has happened before also that selective discussions were raised in the Council to demonise a particular group. So we would again request you to please use your authority to bar any such discussion again, at the Council. Thank you very much.
Egypt: Mr. President, I am not speculating. I have a copy of this statement. I have listened carefully to the first paragraph. I did not interrupt. I tell you it was clear that the copy that I have in my hand. I am telling my colleagues from Canada and Slovenia so that everyone will bear the consequences, that this statement is about the Sharia law. I don’t want anybody to say that they didn’t know in advance. I have a copy here. If anybody doesn’t believe me they can take a look at the statement. This statement will not be read in this Council without a vote. Thank you.
Iran: Thank you Mr President. Actually I requested the floor for raising the point of order in support of what has been said by Egypt and by Pakistan, but apparently it was not acceptable so that was all. Thank you.
After the break, the president curbs under the pressure:
President: Thank you. Well, I hereby say that it was accepted and this is why I said I inadvertently missed it. I apologise to you for this procedural faux pas. Ladies and gentlemen, no need to hide behind whatever, so I will just ask your attention. Let me recall that before we suspended this meeting I made a remark and that remark has two points. One of the points was a warning on what the debate in this Council should not – repeat, should not – slip into. I warned, and I think I am in agreement with all of you here, that this Council is not prepared to discuss matters…religious matters in depth. Consequently we should not do it. I would like to recall what I said in a previous session, and it is in our record, on the 13th of March. “As long as a statement…made with restraint from making a judgement, or evaluation of a particular set of legislation, which is not in the point of our discussion, the speaker may continue.” It was among… within a circumstance that was quite similar as the same in which we are today. Having said that, I will give back the floor to the representative of the NGO in question, with the understanding that as long as the statement will restrain from making a judgement or evaluation of any particular set of legislation which is, indeed, not the point of our discussion, this statement may continue. Distinguished representative of Egypt, you have the floor.

Egypt: Thank you, Mr. President. Now you have made your ruling we will listen attentively to the statement. At the first attempt to link any bad practices to a certain religion, in any way, we will reply to your ruling. Thank you.

So if they can't discuss religion, then they can't discuss Sharia, if they can't discuss Sharia, then they can't discuss these countries policies and abuses of human rights.

It's a catch-22.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand your point.

My atheism has nothing to do with it. That a delusion leads to irrational behavior doesn't obviate the irrational behavior.

Completely beside the point. The extent that Islam led UBL to act the way he did I criticize it. Nothing more, nothing less.

Which is all that is necessary for my criticism but it's worse than that. Islam propagates ignorance is virtue, submission as virtue and discourages critical thinking and skepticism.

I don't subscribe to True Scotsman fallacies. To criticize religion isn't to declare all religious adherents as evil or violent.

Do you subscribe to True Scotsman fallacies?


  • If atheism is used as pretext for violence I will gladly condemn it.
  • If there is a link between atheism and crime I will gladly acknowledge it.
Are you getting my point yet?

Islam leads to violence is a true scotsman fallacy.
 
You could spend your time attacking Dawkins for doing this
And I have done so. I really don't think Dawkins' figure of speech is a useful one, I think it is more likely to cause misunderstanding of evolution than to promote it.

America isn't one single thing. It's a nation of 50 states and numerous territories and 300 million people. Yet there is value in referring to America collectively and indeed criticizing America.
America (or more correctly the United States) does however have structures that enable it to make collective decisions. It even has a single leader to represent all of it.

Islam does not.

Can we skip the silly semantics?
No. Semantics is a very important science. :)

You miss the important point. He was willing to question and criticize and this opened the door to reformation.
He didn't question and criticise "Christianity". He wasn't standing outside of Christianity with little knowledge of it and criticise Christianity for failing to meet personal non-Christian standards.

You are correct but it can't be stated strongly enough that humanity might yet celebrate him if the end result is similar to Luther's.
It is quite unlikely that all of humanity (or even all of Islam) will celebrate him. Luther didn't actually manage to reform Christianity either, but instead caused it to split up. I can't imagine Osama Bin Laden ever becoming a less controversial figure than Luther ever was.
 
Thanks Pardalis. I think the history of this ruling is critical to the points being made that this will not interfere with the debate on human rights. That I'm affraid is dishonest and indefensible given the facts.

Discussion of religious questions now banned at UN Human Rights Council

The UN Human Rights Council is not allowed to judge religions, according to president Doru Romulus Costea of Romania. Criticism of Sharia law or fatwas is now forbidden.

This ruling follows attempts by the Egyptian and Pakistani delegates at the Council to silence criticism of human rights abuse in the Islamic world.
The representative of the Association for World Education, in a joint statement with the International Humanist and Ethical Union, had denounced the stoning to death of women accused of adultery and of girls being married at the age of nine years old in countries where Sharia law applies.

The speaker, David Littman, was interrupted by no fewer than 16 points of order and the proceedings of the Council were suspended for forty minutes when the Egyptian delegate said that “Islam will not be crucified in this Council” and attempted to force a vote on whether the speaker should be allowed to continue.
 
http://www.iheu.org/node/3193

After the break, the president curbs under the pressure:


So if they can't discuss religion, then they can't discuss Sharia, if they can't discuss Sharia, then they can't discuss these countries policies and abuses of human rights.

It's a catch-22.

Thank you for that - it's a hefty piece of text so I'll probably not be able to read it tonight.
 
One more try. What would those be?



So, if all forms are forbidden now on the basis of "Hurting moslems is against Islam/Koran", why is there a fatwa from one month ago telling us basically science is respected but useless when it comes to male circumcision, which is pretty much the same as female circumcision, since both involves removing the prepuce, from the penis and the clitoris, respectively, all the while at the conference they suddenly respect science so much, they would go as far as banning something which was apparently condoned and tolerated by Muhammad himself, even if the chain of narrators for that specific hadith is weak?

Another question would be: Why is there no update on islamonline.net about this, when this conference was so important and such a breakthrough?

i thought FGM is OT, but
are you comparing FGM to male circumcision? it is in no way comparable, in the link i gave they discussed this in that debate.
they compared FGM to cut of a boys glans or the whole Penis.
 
And I have done so. I really don't think Dawkins' figure of speech is a useful one, I think it is more likely to cause misunderstanding of evolution than to promote it.
Then we fundamentally disagree.

America (or more correctly the United States) does however have structures that enable it to make collective decisions. It even has a single leader to represent all of it.
:) Exactly! Thank you.

Islam does not.
A great point of criticism. Power corrupts and unelected power corrupts even more. Islam, like other religions, propagates the idea that faith and submission to god are virtues. Given that people have to rely on go-betweens for god... that's bad.

No. Semantics is a very important science. :)
It won't advance our discussion.

He didn't question and criticise "Christianity". He wasn't standing outside of Christianity with little knowledge of it and criticise Christianity for failing to meet personal non-Christian standards.
Neither here nor there. Luther openly questioned Catholic dogma and authority. It is trivially true that his questioning of Catholic authority had great influence on the reformation. That's not a controversial point and your debating that fact is rather pointless.

It is quite unlikely that all of humanity (or even all of Islam) will celebrate him.
Oh, I agree that it is unlikely but if his actions should, by chance, render similar results to Luther's, his name will be remembered as long as Luther's. There is little question about that. But this is all off topic. Why don't you start a thread in R&P and we can debate Luther's contributions to the reformation.

Luther didn't actually manage to reform Christianity either, but instead caused it to split up.
I hate to be redundant but you are seriously missing the point. The Catholic Church today isn't the same as the Church in Luther's time. No, it might not have moved in the direction that Luther wanted but that's not the point.

The reformation was real and Luther was a major spark that that started the fire. Now, you might think that is arguable but it is really not a topic of this thread.

I can't imagine Osama Bin Laden ever becoming a less controversial figure than Luther ever was.
No question. And he might very well be credited with bringing about a reformation. I don't know yet. It's too soon for either of us to tell. Let's be honest enough about that. The important point is that OBL got people to focus on Islam. Let's see where it leads.
 
Last edited:
...snip...

It is quite unlikely that all of humanity (or even all of Islam) will celebrate him. Luther didn't actually manage to reform Christianity either, but instead caused it to split up. I can't imagine Osama Bin Laden ever becoming a less controversial figure than Luther ever was.

He did quite literally reform the tenets of what was accepted as (western) Catholic principles. Of course not everyone accepted that and as a direct result of this process there was a long period of increased (and directly Christian related) persecution and movements that tore countries apart and inflicted terrible violence on a huge number of people.

Some people have a mistaken view that the reformation was somewhat akin to the "enlightenment". It wasn't. It was the creation of an even more fundamental, prescriptive and controlling form of Christianity than that of Roman Catholicism of the time.

I pray ;) that we do not see a "reformation" of Islam in the same sense in my lifetime - the bloodshed and suffering would be widespread and terrible.
 
oh no doubt, im sure there are Moslems that do really belive they will take over the world :) like in other religions.



Please explain sir!

You ashed very sarcastically if someone thought they wanted to take over the world!
I show you that they them selves say the believe they will take over the world!
Tell me just what % of the billion or so who practice this do you equate with wanting such things?
Give me a guess sir!
Even 1% is a awful big number that must be dealt with in the most severe way!
 
Please explain sir!

You ashed very sarcastically if someone thought they wanted to take over the world!
I show you that they them selves say the believe they will take over the world!
Tell me just what % of the billion or so who practice this do you equate with wanting such things?
Give me a guess sir!
Even 1% is a awful big number that must be dealt with in the most severe way!

they say? well i agree some say and belive it. you call them they, you give me the number you think it is.
 
It wasn't. It was the creation of an even more fundamental, prescriptive and controlling form of Christianity than that of Roman Catholicism of the time.
Odd thing to say.

Before the reformation: A single dogmatic controlling authority.
After the reformation: Many forms of Christianity including Unitarian and other liberal church's.

I pray ;) that we do not see a "reformation" of Islam in the same sense in my lifetime - the bloodshed and suffering would be widespread and terrible.
I concede that it was bloody and there was much suffering. The ending of Slavery and the civil rights movement also led to bloodshed. I'm not sure that is a valid reason not to seek Islamic reformation.
 
Islam propagates ignorance is virtue,
Evidence?

submission as virtue
You missed something. Islamic scholars tend to agree that submission to God is a virtue, and that submission to anything else is not. If only Islamic fundamentalists believed submission to worldly authorities was a virtue... then they wouldn't be causing so much trouble.

and discourages critical thinking and skepticism.
To varying degrees this is true of all religions and ideologies. Most movements within Islam probably do quite well when it comes to critical thinking and skepticism compared to many other religions, because Islamic teaching is generally quite hostile towards superstitions and belief in non-abstract deities.
 
i thought FGM is OT, but
are you comparing FGM to male circumcision? it is in no way comparable, in the link i gave they discussed this in that debate.
they compared FGM to cut of a boys glans or the whole Penis.

Nevermind me expecting a coherent and reasonable answer based on you actually understanding anything of that which I quoted. Nevermind!
 
they say? well i agree some say and belive it. you call them they, you give me the number you think it is.



Sir would you please stop tap dancing and just answer the question?

By the way...we call these things numbers 1 witch is the one I use so I already gave you mine.Now how about you grow a set and answer the question?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom