Islam's war on freedom

didnt you see my answer?

when you criticize Sharia laws you are criticizing a part of islam.

OK, so it is possible to criticize Islam, even in part?

So certain Muslims shouldn't impose a ban on criticizing Sharia on the grounds of "religious immunity"?
 
I don't want to end Islam. I want to end the abuses and not excuse Islams complicity.
What you want is personify Islam, pretend that it is a moral agent that can be complicit in anything. This sentence and many of the others you wrote in this discussion are evidence of this. That is fundamentalist talk. I don't think you are an Islamic fundamentalist, so I expect you to be able to stop talking like this.

Islam can't do anything by itself, therefore Islam cannot be blamed for anything. Islam is not a single thing, it is not a moral agent of greater importance than individual people, there isn't a one-true-Islam. If you are not a fundamentalist Muslim, I expect you to be able to understand: Islam is a nebulous poorly defined set of beliefs that 1000 million people think they share but each give their own interpretation.

Martin Luther protested the Catholic church and that led to a reformation.
Martin Luther was not a moderniser who protested against the Catholic church because he thought it was too fundamentalistic and too strict in its Christian teachings. Quite the opposite; he was a fundamentalist himself and he wanted to return to a stricter and more literal interpretation of Christianity.

We need to do something to end the oppression of the Islamic church.
There is no Islamic church. Islam does not have a priesthood, no pope, no ultimate authority on religious matters. Perhaps because of the absence of such a thing, governments of Islamic countries have often taken such a role. According to many Muslims, these government have become oppressive, and have steered away too far from fundamental Islamic teachings. There is a man who fights against these oppressive regimes and against the countries that support them, to bring about a sort of Islamic reformation. I don't think you like him, and IMHO for good reason.
 
{sigh}

This is so dishonest Tsukas. A.) No one is saying the UN should debate the merits of different religions. We are saying they should debate various policies of religious organizations implemented through various governments that lead to human rights abuses. B.) I wouldn't mind if you made this remark at the beginning but at least 4 of us have told you over and over that religion informs governments around the world (see below). If religion is behind policies that lead to government policies that harm humans then damn straight. What is so hard to get about that? C.) Genital mutilation and honor killing is easily within the scope of the UN and the link to religion and it is within the scope of the UN to encourage governments to protect their citizens against religious abuse.


the·oc·ra·cy
  1. a form of government in which God or a deity is recognized as the supreme civil ruler, the God's or deity's laws being interpreted by the ecclesiastical authorities.
So, are you going to continue to stick your fingers in your ears and hum?

And at least 1 of me has been saying over and over that it doesn't matter what informed their laws; human rights are unalienable a priori, so there is no need to discuss ideological rationales.

And I have still yet to meet this independent entity know as Islam.

But by all means, keep talking down to me, your grace; I am sure it will help you make your point.
 
Last edited:
they are all Christians, they cant get married.
What?

i doubt that the terrorists claim is true that they act in the name of god.
Then you are naive.

Did Islam atack on 9/11 or a group of people that claims to act in the name of Islam and Allah?(or someone else?)
They didn't do it because they were atheist. That's for damn sure. There's not any controversy as to this point unless you are a CT. They were upset with the Great Satan defiling holy lands in Saudi Arabia.

indeed alot if not most terrorists use Islam/Koran/jihad to justify their violence. can this be blamed on Islam? what is the correct interpretetion of Islam? the one Osama is using?
There is only one salient point. Does Islam lead to violence? That's it. All the rest is a red herring.

I concede that not all Muslims are violent. You know that.

some interpretations of religions or Islam can and was abused to justify violence.
blame that on abuse.
No, raise consciousness as to the violence done in the name of religion until those who belong to that religion who are acting in these ways change.

Criticize.

Isnt the USA God's choosen country or so?
There is no such thing as god. Manifest Destiny was a racist policy used to justify genocide and the theft of Native American land. I condemn such policies and I fight such idiotic notions that the USA is god's chosen country.

Your argument is directed at the wrong person. Start a thread on Manifest Destiny and I promise to join you. Fair enough?

Manifest destiny isn't the subject of this thread. It's another red herring.


some claim to be gods choosen peoples.
And I criticize them often and loudly be they Jewish, Christian or Muslim. I'm an equal opportunity denouncer.

Are you getting this?

....can you as an Atheist be a real American?
Not only that but I can criticize it. And I do so often. I encourage you to criticize America. Please do so. Criticism is good, so long as it is not the pathological kind.

Healthy debate and discussion should include criticism.

I'll say it again, you are using the wrong arguments when it comes to me.
 
My thesis is simple.

Islam is a source and catalyst of violence for all of the reasons I've stated (see above post).

When Muslims react in outrage to Muslim atrocity to the degree they responded in outrage to cartoons of Mohammad then we will have achieved something very important.

When and if that happens, the criticism should continue but until then we haven't even scratched the surface.

how many moslems worldwide have demonstrated against terror in the name of Islam?

how many moslems worldwide have demonstrated against the mohamed cartoons?
 
And at least 1 of me has been saying over and over that it doesn't matter what informed their laws; human rights are unalienable a priori, so there is no need to discuss ideological rationales.
This is nonsense. Islamic nations don't accept your premise and that is a reason enough to criticize religion in and of itself.

But by all means, keep talking down to me, your grace; I am sure it will help you make your point.
I'd just as soon point out the flaws in your arguments. Thanks though.
 
human rights are unalienable a priori, so there is no need to discuss ideological rationales.

Then how is someone supposed to confront the Islamic countries violating human rights based on their Sharia?

You can't say they are wrong because they'll claim it's their religious right to follow their Sharia.

It's a catch-22.
 
OK, so it is possible to criticize Islam, even in part?

So certain Muslims shouldn't impose a ban on criticizing Sharia on the grounds of "religious immunity"?

i answered that already a while ago in this topic, i think a ban against criticism against sharia laws is wrong.
 
This is nonsense.

Your logic is overwhelming.

Islamic nations don't accept your premise and that is a reason enough to criticize religion in and of itself.

I'd just as soon point out the flaws in your arguments. Thanks though.

But the UN does. It is the whole point of the HRC. But you already showed that you have no clue how the HRC functions, so I doubt you will care.
 
ah ok, if they could they would, how do you know?

Look at parts of Africa, Indonesia, Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Once they have the numbers and means, they'll try to expand.

only cause they are undeveloped countrys they dont invade us.

It's more than just one factor, but repercussions is a big one I guess, especially when you've been spending as a country like Saudi Arabia so much money on spreading Salafism already, I can't imagine you'd want that to go to waste.

but i guess they still are infiltrating our democracys to take them over....

Yea.
 
Islam can't do anything by itself, therefore Islam cannot be blamed for anything.
In his book, The Selfish Gene, Dawkins speaks of gene's intentions. Now, to be fair, Dawkins goes to great lengths to point out that gene's don't really have intentionality but that his anthropomorphism is a means of conveying an idea. You could spend your time attacking Dawkins for doing this and perhaps I've failed to do as Dawkins does and point out that my figure of speech is the same as his but in the end you know what I mean and I'm not going to get into a semantical debate with you.

Islam is not a single thing, it is not a moral agent of greater importance than individual people, there isn't a one-true-Islam. If you are not a fundamentalist Muslim, I expect you to be able to understand: Islam is a nebulous poorly defined set of beliefs that 1000 million people think they share but each give their own interpretation.
America isn't one single thing. It's a nation of 50 states and numerous territories and 300 million people. Yet there is value in referring to America collectively and indeed criticizing America. Getting hung-up over the fact that America isn't a single conscious entity doesn't advance a discussion about American excesses and crimes. Abu Ghraib and extraordinary rendition are American failures and sins and America needs to face up to them and accept the responsibility even if America doesn't really exist except as a concept. The death and destruction in Iraq is real and America is responsible. American appologist like myself could make an argument that not all Americans agreed with the war and that America isn't monolithic and therefore it's wrong to critisize America but that is dishonest and you know it.

Can we skip the silly semantics?

Martin Luther was not a moderniser who protested against the Catholic church because he thought it was too fundamentalistic and too strict in its Christian teachings. Quite the opposite; he was a fundamentalist himself and he wanted to return to a stricter and more literal interpretation of Christianity.
You miss the important point. He was willing to question and criticize and this opened the door to reformation.

There is no Islamic church. Islam does not have a priesthood, no pope, no ultimate authority on religious matters. Perhaps because of the absence of such a thing, governments of Islamic countries have often taken such a role. According to many Muslims, these government have become oppressive, and have steered away too far from fundamental Islamic teachings. There is a man who fights against these oppressive regimes and against the countries that support them, to bring about a sort of Islamic reformation. I don't think you like him, and IMHO for good reason.
You are correct but it can't be stated strongly enough that humanity might yet celebrate him if the end result is similar to Luther's.

As always, good post.
 
Last edited:
Your logic is overwhelming.
And your edits are dishonest.

But the UN does.
But you don't want the UN criticizing religion, the basis for the governments and the atrocities in question.

It is the whole point of the HRC.
And you want to handicap them.

But you already showed that you have no clue how the HRC functions, so I doubt you will care.
This isn't argument.
 
connection to Christianity
Then you are naive.
what? When Osama claims to act in the Name of Allah, you belive him?
not bad for an Atheist. There is no God. also not when you call him Allah.
They didn't do it because they were atheist. That's for damn sure. There's not any controversy as to this point unless you are a CT. They were upset with the Great Satan defiling holy lands in Saudi Arabia.

well i am a CT. but that aside.
yes i think this is the main reason UBL declared his Jihad against the US.
and i think in his eyes he was justified by the koran to declare Jihad (as the Defensive war interpretation)
Isnt Saudi Arabia a very Islamic country? with a full inplementation of sharia laws? did that country agree on UBL's Jihad? Did the majority of people in SA agree on UBL's Jihad?

There is only one salient point. Does Islam lead to violence? That's it. All the rest is a red herring.
No it does not. Some Interpretations of Islam do lead to violence.
I concede that not all Muslims are violent. You know that.
not all? ther are a few non violent folowers of a violent religion?
they arent real moslems then?
No, raise consciousness as to the violence done in the name of religion until those who belong to that religion who are acting in these ways change.

Criticize.

There is no such thing as god. Manifest Destiny was a racist policy used to justify genocide and the theft of Native American land. I condemn such policies and I fight such idiotic notions that the USA is god's chosen country.

Your argument is directed at the wrong person. Start a thread on Manifest Destiny and I promise to join you. Fair enough?

you are not a real american then? you do not interpret your country correctly when you dont belive it is God's chosen country`?

its not directed at the wrong person, you are an American, you admitted it :D

i hope you get it :)
[/QUOTE]
Manifest destiny isn't the subject of this thread. It's another red herring.


And I criticize them often and loudly be they Jewish, Christian or Muslim. I'm an equal opportunity denouncer.

Are you getting this?

Not only that but I can criticize it. And I do so often. I encourage you to criticize America. Please do so. Criticism is good, so long as it is not the pathological kind.

Healthy debate and discussion should include criticism.

I'll say it again, you are using the wrong arguments when it comes to me.

i think it is not my arguments that are wrong, i think you direct your criticism not where it belongs.

i dont want to be criticed because i am an atheist just cause there are so many Atheist criminals.
 
Tsuka, here's a hypothetical debate at the HRC:

President Tsuka: Somalia should stop executing people for being homosexuals, it goes against basic human rights.

Representative of Somalia: Homosexuality is a crime punishable by death in our Sharia. Sharia is our way of life, our religion, you can't criticize our religion.

What would be your reply?
 
Look at parts of Africa, Indonesia, Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Once they have the numbers and means, they'll try to expand.
shall we destroy them before they develope? or is it enough to keep them undeveloped?

It's more than just one factor, but repercussions is a big one I guess, especially when you've been spending as a country like Saudi Arabia so much money on spreading Salafism already, I can't imagine you'd want that to go to waste.
oh yeah our special friend SA....
i have no car :) i try to avoid any of my money going to SA.

are they the representants of Islam in Germany?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom