Islam's war on freedom

No, you're muzzling any discussion about Islam by portraying any critics of it as Islamophobes.

That is by definition anti-free speech.

no, that is not the case. the only one i called an islamophobe is MrBaracuda, and till now it is only him i call an islamophobe atm. but also islamaphobes have a right to express their oppinion. i dont want nor can i prevent him from posting his oppinion. i can challange it.
 
it is not the religion that is violent.
{sigh}

Ok, I realize that you have an agenda and that you are not going to back down from that agenda but I'm not going to simply walk away.

...CALLS for violence against infidels...

Note the word. "Calls".

See it?

Ok. Can we move on?
 
That's nice. No one is demonizing the whole of Islam.

Your red herring is getting old and smelly.

Can we move on?

Christianity is not criticized for the pedophile priests.....
the Church is a bit criticized for that.

why do we do it diffrent with Islam?
we can criticize countrys for sharia laws, we can criticize groups for their violnce. but can we critize the religion itself? Do we know that religion enough to criticize it?
 
{sigh}

Ok, I realize that you have an agenda and that you are not going to back down from that agenda but I'm not going to simply walk away.



Note the word. "Calls".

See it?

Ok. Can we move on?

who is Islam?
is Islam calling for violence? or are some moslems calling for violence?
why do most moslems not follow that call to violence? do they missinterpret the religion?
or is it maybe you, that takes some moslem groups and present them as THE representants of Islam.
 
Can you answer my question DC?

How can one criticize Sharia without criticizing Islam?
 
Christianity is not criticized for the pedophile priests.....
I'm not sure of the link but if you can establish it, then start a thread and I promise to be there. I've no problem with that at all.

the Church is a bit criticized for that.
A "bit"? That's disingenuous.

why do we do it diffrent with Islam?
To the extent that we treat it differently it's because,
  • Muslims are strapping on bombs and blowing people up in the name of god.
  • Because of 9/11.
  • Because what unites many terrorists around the world is Islam.
Speaking the truth shouldn't be an offense.

...we can criticize countrys for sharia laws, we can criticize groups for their violnce. but can we critize the religion itself? Do we know that religion enough to criticize it?
Yes, of course. To ignore that religion in general and Islam in particular contributes to violence would require a level of dishonesty that I'm simply not capable of. I can't close my eyes that easily.

Social anthropologists and other social scientists have known for a long time now that --
  • The division of people breeds contempt.
  • Believing that you are superior to others breeds enmity.
  • Believing that others are corrupt and sinful breeds intolerance.
  • To sum it up, religion divides people between adherent and infidel, or as Muslims put it god's holy people and Kafir and naturally pits the believer against the unbeliever.
I can't pretend that religion doesn't do these things. I don't know how you can.
 
who is Islam?
is Islam calling for violence? or are some moslems calling for violence?
why do most moslems not follow that call to violence? do they missinterpret the religion?
or is it maybe you, that takes some moslem groups and present them as THE representants of Islam.
My thesis is simple.

Islam is a source and catalyst of violence for all of the reasons I've stated (see above post).

When Muslims react in outrage to Muslim atrocity to the degree they responded in outrage to cartoons of Mohammad then we will have achieved something very important.

When and if that happens, the criticism should continue but until then we haven't even scratched the surface.
 
Can you answer my question DC?

How can one criticize Sharia without criticizing Islam?

when you criticize sharia laws, you are critizicing a specific point about Islam.
do you also want to criticize their belive in a God?
 
who is Islam?
is Islam calling for violence? or are some moslems calling for violence?
why do most moslems not follow that call to violence? do they missinterpret the religion?
or is it maybe you, that takes some moslem groups and present them as THE representants of Islam.

How many Muslim majority / Islamic countries are even able to invade any country of the 'unbelievers'? At least without getting destroyed themselves in the process.

You might see why a call for jihad is not so convenient.
 
I'm not sure of the link but if you can establish it, then start a thread and I promise to be there. I've no problem with that at all.

A "bit"? That's disingenuous.
they are all Christians, they cant get married.

To the extent that we treat it differently it's because,
  • Muslims are strapping on bombs and blowing people up in the name of god.
  • Because of 9/11.
  • Because what unites many terrorists around the world is Islam.
Speaking the truth shouldn't be an offense.
i doubt that the terrorists claim is true that they act in the name of god.

Did Islam atack on 9/11 or a group of people that claims to act in the name of Islam and Allah?(or someone else?)

indeed alot if not most terrorists use Islam/Koran/jihad to justify their violence. can this be blamed on Islam? what is the correct interpretetion of Islam? the one Osama is using?

Yes, of course. To ignore that religion in general and Islam in particular contributes to violence would require a level of dishonesty that I'm simply not capable of. I can't close my eyes that easily.

Social anthropologists and other social scientists have known for a long time now that --
  • The division of people breeds contempt.
  • Believing that you are superior to others breeds enmity.
  • Believing that others are corrupt and sinful breeds intolerance.
  • To sum it up, religion divides people between adherent and infidel, or as Muslims put it god's holy people and Kafir and naturally pits the believer against the unbeliever.
I can't pretend that religion doesn't do these things. I don't know how you can.

some interpretations of religions or Islam can and was abused to justify violence.
blame that on abuse.

Isnt the USA God's choosen country or so? some claim to be gods choosen peoples. sounds pretty superior.do all US Citizens belive that the USA is God's choosen country? can you as an Atheist be a real American? :P
 
Last edited:
How many Muslim majority / Islamic countries are even able to invade any country of the 'unbelievers'? At least without getting destroyed themselves in the process.

You might see why a call for jihad is not so convenient.

ah ok, if they could they would, how do you know?

only cause they are undeveloped countrys they dont invade us.

but i guess they still are infiltrating our democracys to take them over....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom