Islam's war on freedom

What I see here is alot of people trying to confuse the issue, alot of apologists and even a twoofer trying to divert this discussion into making people who criticize the UN's decision look as though they are being islamophobic.

That's really dishonest, especially from people who are supposed to be freedom-lovers.

Can we get back on topic? If countries who use Sharia can't be criticized because of their religious immunity, then how can we address the human rights problems in these countries?
 
From a rhetorical stand point it's always best to attack the speaker first so I give you kudos on your rhetorical skills but I'm afraid you get no points for your argument.

No, it's not Limbaugh. I don't know who it is.

But let's discuss it.

He makes a great point. Muslims don't get outraged much over Muslim atrocity. You won't have Muslims filing to the streets in protests over Muslim atrocity. Muslims do get outraged over cartoons and they will take to the streets with AK-47 and banners if you print a cartoon of Mohammad.

Here's the thing. When Al Jazeera and the Muslim street express the degree of outrage over Muslim atrocity that they do over cartoons we will have gotten somewhere.

That's the point that I want the criticism to move us to. That's not likely to happen so long as those who should be in favor or human rights choose first to try and silence criticism of Islam in the name of political correctness.
Muslims%20Against%20Wahhabi%20Protest%20DC%20October%2022nd,%202007%20063.jpg


its exactly those generalisations i ment, those are not critiques, thats just not true.....
but indeed, the protests about the cartoons did get alot more Media coverage, and while i have no problems with the protests i hade huge troubles with the violnce at the protests.
 
...snip...

Can we get back on topic? If countries who use Sharia can't be criticized because of their religious immunity, then how can we address the human rights problems in these countries?

But since it's been shown in this thread that human rights atrocities may be criticised and discussed regardless of which country they occur in why are you still going on about the earlier misinterpretation?
 
Can we get back on topic?

We know there are good non-violent Muslims, that's not the issue.
 
ritique should be welcome, but the Demonisation alla limbough and other right wing nuts is contraproductive and often is based on uninformed oppinions.
Not the point of this thread.

after 9/11 i withnessed Moslems protesting Terrorism and Violence in the name of Islam. even imams in iran told their listeners that massmurder like 9/11 is wrong and finds no justification in the Koran. thats the stuff the right wing nuts ignore or claim they lie when thei say such things.
I also witnessed the same as you did. Sadly the printing of cartoons brought about much more outrage from the Muslim community than did the killing of innocent Americans.

That point can't be made often enough. Consciousness needs to be raised among Muslims. Stifling of debate and criticism is the wrong thing to do.
 
Last edited:
But since it's been shown in this thread that human rights atrocities may be criticised and discussed regardless of which country they occur in why are you still going on about the earlier misinterpretation?

The problem is that we can't criticize certain countries because they'll automatically say we are attacking their religious beliefs.
 
What I see here is alot of people trying to confuse the issue, alot of apologists and even a twoofer trying to divert this discussion into making people who criticize the UN's decision look as though they are being islamophobic.

That's really dishonest, especially from people who are supposed to be freedom-lovers.

Can we get back on topic? If countries who use Sharia can't be criticized because of their religious immunity, then how can we address the human rights problems in these countries?

i think we have very very good reasons to criticize countrys that use sharia laws. but we have to do it without double standards.
but the US has its Saudi oil connections, so critique is pretty silent....
switzerland has its Irani gas connections, so critique is pretty silent.....

and with critizising it is not done. i think we have to find PEACEFULL ways to stop countrys using sharia laws. Criticizing is just the begining. some things cannot be accepted today, stoning and such should be gone a long time ago already....

in this point i sure do agree that it is totaly wrong to NOT criticize such countrys.
i just dislike the demonisation
 
From the OP:

A petition has been lodged with the British government to make the Prophet Muhammad's birthday a national holiday. If you live in the UK and you think this is a bad idea, please sign this counter petition.
http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/nomuhammadday/

I'm not going to sign such an anti-petition, I'm all for more public holidays so if a group of Brits can persuade the government to get us another one why should I oppose it? This to me is absolutely no different to the English nationalists that are always going on about how St. Georges day should be a public holiday.
 
i think we have very very good reasons to criticize countrys that use sharia laws. but we have to do it without double standards.
but the US has its Saudi oil connections, so critique is pretty silent....
switzerland has its Irani gas connections, so critique is pretty silent.....

and with critizising it is not done. i think we have to find PEACEFULL ways to stop countrys using sharia laws. Criticizing is just the begining. some things cannot be accepted today, stoning and such should be gone a long time ago already....

in this point i sure do agree that it is totaly wrong to NOT criticize such countrys.
i just dislike the demonisation
If we wait until there are no double standards nothing will ever get done. That's just BS. I'm happy to criticize America and its dealings with the Saudis. Bush, Cheney and company are duplicitous pricks. Got it?

Halliburton can kiss my white anglo saxon arse.

America has exploited South America and Saudi Arabia and other nations. It was wrong and I'm happy to stand up and admit it. Please start a thread and I will join you.

That said, this thread is about the silencing of criticism of Islam. Such is morally wrong, repugnant and reprehensible.

I hope that is clear and I'm certain it is not overstated.
 
Not the point of this thread.

I also witnessed the same as you did. Sadly the printing of cartoons brought about much more outrage from the Muslim community than did the killing of innocent Americans.

That point can't be made often enough. Consciousness needs to be raised among Muslims. Stifling of debate and criticism is the wrong thing to do.

how much Christians do protest Christian Terrorism?



Consciousness needs to be raised among Muslims.
indeed, but not with generalisations or demonisations.
 
i think we have very very good reasons to criticize countrys that use sharia laws. but we have to do it without double standards.

But how can we do it if these countries are protected becaus of some phony "religious immunity"?

i just dislike the demonisation
Nobody is demonizing anything, it's all in your head.

That's the whole point of this thread, and that's what lead the president of the Human Rights counsel to give in to the extremists: Because he was afraid to be viewed as islamophobic, he decided there wouldn't be any criticizing of Sharia.

AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT YOU ARE DOING IN THIS THREAD

You're doing the exact same thing. Because we are criticizing Sharia, constructively mind you, you've jumped in this thread attacking and accusing Baracuda and Randfan of being islamophobic.

We should be able to criticize anything without being labeled intolerant.

We're not intolerant, we're just debating.

If you don't like it, go back to the twoofer subforum.

Listen to what Randfan is saying, it makes a heck of alot of sense, and he's not being islamophobic.

"Preventing criticism is paramount more important than all other issues."

"That point can't be made often enough. Consciousness needs to be raised among Muslims. Stifling of debate and criticism is the wrong thing to do."
 
Last edited:
how much Christians do protest Christian Terrorism?
I'm trying to make this clear but you don't seem to be getting it so let my try it again. I'm not a Christian apologist. I critisize Christianity in the R&P forums weekly. Please join me there and join in. The Christians don't protest Christian terrrorism enough and I'm happy to critisize them for that (how much Christian terrorism is there?).

Consciousness needs to be raised among Muslims.
indeed, but not with generalisations or demonisations.
Fine.
  1. Muslim atrocity is wrong.
  2. Muslims are not sufficiently outraged at Muslim atrocity.
  3. It is wrong for the HRC to bar criticism of Islam during debates of human rights abuses.
  4. We should actively denounce any and all religious violence and atrocity.
Are you against any of those items?
 
If we wait until there are no double standards nothing will ever get done. That's just BS. I'm happy to criticize America and its dealings with the Saudis. Bush, Cheney and company are duplicitous pricks. Got it?

Halliburton can kiss my white anglo saxon arse.

America has exploited South America and Saudi Arabia and other nations. It was wrong and I'm happy to stand up and admit it. Please start a thread and I will join you.

That said, this thread is about the silencing of criticism of Islam. Such is morally wrong, repugnant and reprehensible.

I hope that is clear and I'm certain it is not overstated.

Silencing justified criticism is morally wrong. I think we also should be carefull with the criticism.
 
i think we have very very good reasons to criticize countrys that use sharia laws. but we have to do it without double standards.

Don't you understand that they are the ones with the double standards, they are the ones asking for special treatment.

Sharia is both law and religion at the same time.

If they enforce Sharia on their people, and Sharia violates human rights, then if the UN's humans Rights counsel wants to do its job they inevitably are going to have to criticize Sharia and their religion.

understood?
 
Last edited:
...snip...

  1. Muslim atrocity is wrong.
  2. Muslims are not sufficiently outraged at Muslim atrocity.
  3. It is wrong for the HRC to bar criticism of Islam during debates of human rights abuses.
  4. We should actively denounce any and all religious violence and atrocity.
Are you against any of those items?

Yes - number 2.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom