Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

"What if you can believe that white replacement theory is accidentally true for non-racist reasons" is a neat take, but it ultimately fails for the reasons that have already been brought up here by others: Hispanic immigrants historically cannot be taken for granted as blue votes.

It's supposedly been "true for decades" that Democrats believe they are and so are trying to encourage a flood of non-white immigrants, but these decades of immigrants have so far not turned the US into a deep blue sea politically. When is this supposed decades-old strategy supposed to start paying dividends? 50 more years from now? 100? Are we supposed to believe that between all the in-fighting as Democrats struggle like crabs in a bucket to get elected or stay elected just in the next year or two, they're all cooperatively planning or maintaining an enduring "long game" over-strategy intended to secure the political power of people who haven't even been born yet?
 
Last edited:
That's a little different. If Ireland suddenly sees a wave of conversions to Buddhism, its a matter of free choice.

How is it different? It's exactly the same conspiracy.

*They* are going to outbreed *us* and then use *our* good democratic values to institute a *scary theocracy*

The fear of Catholicism at the time was the same as the fear of Islam now.
 
I make an exception for refugees fleeing persecution/war. I think all nations should do their best to have a generous refugee policy. Its the moral thing to do. Not saying they should guarantee citizenship or permanent settlement.

And the people fleeing economic upheaval due to the decisions of the West and China/India as well by now?
They should be left to die or scrabble for hunger wages without ever being able to try to go somewhere better?
 
"Replacement Theory" is just another way of saying "Dems are not Real Americans and therefore shouldn't vote!"

It's not about immigrants who will change the makeup of US society, it's about Progressives already having done so, and de-legitimizing their right as voters to do so.
It's not about preventing a Path to Citizenship for Migrants, it's about disenfranchising current non-GOP voters.

Americans claiming to be worried that Immigrants might not share their values are actually worried that most Americans don't share their values.
 
The paranoia being instigated through Replacement Theory in the US is very similar to the current Indian Government's rallying slogan od "Hindu khatre mein hai" (Hindus are in danger.) In the end, just a dog whistle for racists and bigots to rally around.
 
I never claimed the USA is or ever was a nation-state.

We are a post-colonial nation, developed mostly by invaders who massacred the natives following an absurd and racist ideology of racial supremacy and manifest destiny.

Unlike Ireland, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Lithuania, etc.

Italy and Germany have only existed since the 19th century; Germany has subsequently been split and re-unified; Ireland (by which I assume you mean the Republic and are leaving out the Six Counties) has only been an independent state for around a hundred years; France is a mish-mash of what was a bunch of disparate dukedoms and kingdoms (ask Bretons and Basques about how they feel being under the rule of a Parisian elite) and Alsace and Lorraine have gone back and forth between France and Germany; Lithuania has been through many forms, including being occupied by the Russians against their will on more than one occasion.

Not good examples of nations being unified for centuries...
 
Italy and Germany have only existed since the 19th century; Germany has subsequently been split and re-unified; Ireland (by which I assume you mean the Republic and are leaving out the Six Counties) has only been an independent state for around a hundred years; France is a mish-mash of what was a bunch of disparate dukedoms and kingdoms (ask Bretons and Basques about how they feel being under the rule of a Parisian elite) and Alsace and Lorraine have gone back and forth between France and Germany; Lithuania has been through many forms, including being occupied by the Russians against their will on more than one occasion.

Not good examples of nations being unified for centuries...

You can add Spain to that list where there are at least two indepenence movements (basque and catalan).

Japan has at least the Ainu in the north and the reason we do not hear about people in Russia and China who would not consider themselves part of either coutry is because those voices are repressed. Take a look at a nation and there are always people who disagree about what that nation is. Immigration or not.
 
I would like to see a summary, typed up by the thread starter, describing the different "cultures" of different countries, in great detail :rolleyes:
 
Many Democrats do pretty much believe in open-borders.

They believe all illegals detained in the USA should be released with a pending court date, with no control over where they go after they are released. If they don't come to their court hearing, oh well. They will just live & work in the USA until the next big amnesty bill is passed by Congress.

Many on the far-Left also believe that Mexicans have the historic right to come to the southwest USA, as it used to be part of Mexico. They also see Latin American migration to the USA and citizenship as a form of reperations for past American involvement in Latin American affairs. The DSA literally calls for no borders.
Will you be supporting your various claims with citations and evidence?
 
It's kind of similar to the situation around Bloody Kansas. Once you start using immigration to swing elections your going in a bad direction.
Indeed. The actions of the murderous, pro-slavery, "Border Ruffians" from Missouri was reprehensible.
 
Just re-read some of the start of this thread and once again was struck by the very strange from my perspective use of "white" and "non-white". The argument doesn't make any sense from a "European" perspective as the group Hercules56 singles out as being "non-white" are "Hispanics" - which from this side of the Atlantic means white.
 
Bollocks. Amnesty which Reagan signed into law BTW, didn't grant anyone citizenship. And you know who opposed the bill? Employers who wanted to keep exploiting undocumented immigrants.



During the buildup to the 2016 Republican Primary, various pundits who supported Trump claimed that neither party wanted to deal with illegal immigration and it would take an "outsider" to fix it. The claim was that "Establishment Republicans" didn't want to deprive their corporate masters of cheap labor and Democrats were planning to make illegal immigrants citizens to buy their votes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom