Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Why would it be shocking if Syrians committed rapes and sexual assaults at a vastly different rate when moved into the context of a liberal culture where women present themselves in a way that would mark them out as prostitutes in other parts of the world?


Right? But a liberal will shout from the highest mountain about supposed "rape culture" on a college campus, while denying the very real ways that women are viewed in some foreign cultures. I mean, they will bitch about those foreign cultures loudly until said foreigners become part of their protected class known as "immigrants".
 
Try to settle on an argument, Warp.

If someone's culture is not cooked in by their DNA then that someone should be able, with a reasonable effort, to immigrate to another country and/or culture without violating cultural norms.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
The question isn't whether they should be able to do this, or even whether they can do this, but whether and to what extent they in fact do do this. Nobody is claiming that it is impossible for somebody from Syria who is super keen to come to America, work hard and be as American as he can be to do that. The question is do they want to do that, and will they do that.
 
The question isn't whether they should be able to do this, or even whether they can do this, but whether and to what extent they in fact do do this. Nobody is claiming that it is impossible for somebody from Syria who is super keen to come to America, work hard and be as American as he can be to do that. The question is do they want to do that, and will they do that.

Since America (or England) did not turn into some form of hell on earth, none of your weak arguments have merit. :)
 
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

Let's not even talk about how atheists criticize religion in one breath and then deny the existence of god in the next. How contradictory!
 
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.
Let's not even talk about how atheists criticize religion in one breath and then deny the existence of god in the next. How contradictory!


That is a pretty bad analogy. Racism is defined, per Webster:

a belief that race is a fundamental determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race
...
the systemic oppression of a racial group to the social, economic, and political advantage of another


And, the best part is when liberals talk about how people are often discriminated against because of their race. It's almost like race is a real thing to them...until it isn't. Or something.

Oh well, the liberals can work it out amongst themselves, I guess. I'm moving on.
 
Last edited:
Try to settle on an argument, Warp.

If someone's culture is not cooked in by their DNA then that someone should be able, with a reasonable effort, to immigrate to another country and/or culture without violating cultural norms.

The question isn't whether they should be able to do this, or even whether they can do this, but whether and to what extent they in fact do do this. Nobody is claiming that it is impossible for somebody from Syria who is super keen to come to America, work hard and be as American as he can be to do that. The question is do they want to do that, and will they do that.

So all the Bird/Magic stuff is pointless?

All that matters is that they both follow the rules of basketball?

So in the U.S. the "refs" are the legislatures and immigration officials who make sure the immigration and naturalization process is followed?

So who cares about GRT?

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
...Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

If you're implying there's some sort of irony or contradiction here, I'm afraid I'm not seeing it. If I truly believed that race was a nonexistent concept, I'd have even more reason to condemn those who judge people based on it.
 
And, the best part is when liberals talk about how people are often discriminated against because of their race. It's almost like race is a real thing to them...until it isn't. Or something.

Oh well, the liberals can work it out amongst themselves, I guess. I'm moving on.

Warp, your ruse is transparent.

You don't like liberals so you find some of them who have differing opinions (e.g. radical leftist v. centrists) and pretend that the differences are really incoherency.

After you do that for a few posts you stomp off in a pretend superior huff.

I am not fooled.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

So all liberals are the same?

Excuse me but I have to ask why you don't realize that one might suspect that your they-all-look-alike-to-me mindset isn't a carry over from an unspoken belief system about non-whites and non-Christians?

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Since America (or England) did not turn into some form of hell on earth, none of your weak arguments have merit. :)
I don't know. There have been multiple muslim rape gangs targeting young girls in the North of England, turning them into underage prostitutes and so forth. The number of girls involved is quite astounding. It really depends on what you regard as a problem.

#diversityisourstrength
 
...And, the best part is when liberals talk about how people are often discriminated against because of their race. It's almost like race is a real thing to them...until it isn't. Or something.

I'm pretty sure you know perfectly well this statement is silly, but in the off chance you're genuinely confused by the point I'll explain. There is no contradiction in stating that people have been discriminated against due to physical differences that historically have been used to define one's race, while simultaneously believing that "race" as a concept is obsolete, or at least so poorly defined in its current form it's essentially meaningless and in dire need of an overhaul.
 
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

Well race is socially constructed, whether it's biologically coherent or not.
The categories we've come up with in the US that you check a box for are socially constructed. The US government itself makes that explicit on the census. And you can be racist on that basis.

Whoopie Goldberg thought the Holocaust was white on white crime. Maybe so, but the Nazis weren't focused on American conceptions of whiteness when they developed their racial theories.
 
Excuse me but I have to ask why you don't realize that one might suspect that your they-all-look-alike-to-me mindset isn't a carry over from an unspoken belief system about non-whites and non-Christians?


What do my feelings about "non-Christians" have to do with anything? Is there some assumption being made?
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure you know perfectly well this statement is silly, but in the off chance you're genuinely confused by the point I'll explain. There is no contradiction in stating that people have been discriminated against due to physical differences that historically have been used to define one's race, while simultaneously believing that "race" as a concept is obsolete, or at least so poorly defined in its current form it's essentially meaningless and in dire need of an overhaul.
I'm not sure "race", as used by people every day, is the kind of concept that you can "overhaul". It's a social observation rather than a scientific theory. If I can look at somebody and see with a high degree of accuracy that they, or their recent ancestors, were north African, or Indian, or scandinavian.... it is serving the function people demand of it. Deconstructing "race" isn't going to make those Syrians not be responsible for a vastly disproportionate amount of rapes in Sweden.
 
Warp said:
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.moving on.

I'm pretty sure you know perfectly well this statement is silly, but in the off chance you're genuinely confused by the point I'll explain. There is no contradiction in stating that people have been discriminated against due to physical differences that historically have been used to define one's race, while simultaneously believing that "race" as a concept is obsolete, or at least so poorly defined in its current form it's essentially meaningless and in dire need of an overhaul.

Stellafane, Warp ain't in makin' sense mode. He's in complainin' mode.

Later on this evening' he'll drop a big ole one and he'll feel better.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
I don't know. There have been multiple muslim rape gangs targeting young girls in the North of England, turning them into underage prostitutes and so forth. The number of girls involved is quite astounding. It really depends on what you regard as a problem.

#diversityisourstrength

So neither the USA nor England have turned into a hellhole, ruled by evil immigrants. Got it. Any more weak accusations? :)
 
Whoopie Goldberg thought the Holocaust was white on white crime. Maybe so, but the Nazis weren't focused on American conceptions of whiteness when they developed their racial theories.
Maybe the loud ignorance of Whoopi Goldberg is something we can all agree on?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom