Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Yeah, always from a very very very very small fraction of the population but they tried to turn it into "We all think like this".

Anything else of your weak gibberish you want addressed?

I hate to agree with some people but I don't think there is much evidence to support the belief that is a small fraction of the population that gets nervous about immigration.
 
I hate to agree with some people but I don't think there is much evidence to support the belief that is a small fraction of the population that gets nervous about immigration.

People have been "nervous" about immigration for a very long time. Can you show the countries that have been worse due to immigration?
 
Because the actual conversation has gotten quite tedious.

I tend to agree, I've listened to SGU for years, I was never especially impressed or unimpressed with her. I do think that there was a pretty wide spread antipathy towards her that was almost certainly primarily motivated by sexism. Mostly because I don't get any reaction to her other than, meh.

I do think she was largely correct in the whole elevator gate thing. Some dude put her in an awkward and uncomfortable position late at night. All she said was, dudes, don't do that. Quite reasonable but some how set off a **** storm.
It went well beyond that before the storm started... it's off-topic here but there's a huge thread about it and IIRC I think Wiki has a decent summary. I don't want to bother checking my memory on that.
 
Last edited:
Here's a Kentucky replacement story. . .

Several years ago during the Bosnian war several Bosnian families immigrated to a rural Kentucky county which I won't name.

It turns out a few of the families had teenaged boys who were crackerjack basketball players. When it came time for basketball tryouts the Bosnian kids easily made the team knocking a few of local boys off the team and replacing one of the seniors in the starting five.

Basketball is big in rural Kentucky and a few of the townsfolk were livid that the Bosnian kids came into the county and unseated a few local kids who had been playing ball since grade school. They called for the removal of the Bosnians from the team and the firing of the coach and the superintendent of schools.

The position of the coach, superintendent and the school board was that the Bosnian kids were enrolled in the local schools and were entitled to tryout, make the team and get playing time just like everybody else.

They prevailed but much of the local chatter about the whole matter was hateful.

Years later when the coach moved on to another, better paying, county and the superintendent retired the Bosnian haters claimed they's run them off. The haters couldn't explain how it took 5 long years to run a successful coach off to a higher paying job and get a 65 year-old man to retire.

it was widely rumored that the coach, the superintendent and several of the school board members had been so disgusted by seeing a few of their neighbors behave so badly that lost any taste for public service to the particular county.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Well, immigrants doubled the rape rate in Sweden.
What is your source for this claim?

When I searched for this I came up with a misleading BBC headline from 2018.

Sweden rape: Most convicted attackers foreign-born, says TV

I can see those right-wing sources having a field day with that headline without reading the article.
The Mission Investigation programme, due to be broadcast on Wednesday by SVT, said When Sweden took in its highest number of asylum seekers in 2015, the number of reported rapes declined by 12%. At the height of the migration crisis, some 160,000 migrants arrived there - more per capita than any other EU country.

"We are very clear in the programme that it is a small percentage of the people coming from abroad who are convicted of rape," chief editor Ulf Johansson told the BBC.

He pointed out that the number of reported rapes in Sweden was far higher, so no conclusions could be drawn on the role of immigrants in sexual attacks. ...



And this report doesn't say the rate of rapes doubled, it said the majority of those convicted were born outside of Sweden:

Sweden’s Lund University researcher faces prosecution for study that showed most rapes are committed by immigrants (forget the prosecution bit, it's not related).
 
What is your source for this claim?

When I searched for this I came up with a misleading BBC headline from 2018.

Sweden rape: Most convicted attackers foreign-born, says TV

I can see those right-wing sources having a field day with that headline without reading the article.




And this report doesn't say the rate of rapes doubled, it said the majority of those convicted were born outside of Sweden:

Sweden’s Lund University researcher faces prosecution for study that showed most rapes are committed by immigrants (forget the prosecution bit, it's not related).


Them immigrants is doin' plenty 'o rapin', from what I can tell...

During the data analysis, the researchers found that out of 3,039 offenders included in the study, 59.2 per cent were immigrants. Out of these, 47.7 per cent were born outside Sweden. The researchers recommended further investigating the higher number of immigrants indulging in sexual crimes and taking contextual characteristics of these offenders into account during further studies.


Another article:

Sweden’s migrant rape crisis
https://unherd.com/2021/04/swedens-migrant-rape-crisis/

How far does this signify over-representation? On the basis of population records kept by the official agency Statistics Sweden (SCB), approximately 20% (19.7%) of the Swedish population are foreign-born individuals. Among those convicted of rape and perpetrated rape, the foreign-born account for 47.7% of those convicted — so they are over-represented by a factor of 2.4.

Moreover, if we piece various statistics together, we find there are 565,902 foreign-born people living in Sweden who were born in North Africa and the Middle East, representing 4.9% of Sweden’s population. Yet 16.4% of those convicted of rape and attempted rape are foreign-born individuals from North Africa and the Middle East: over-representation by a factor of 3.3. And that figure rises to 4.7 when you consider all foreign-born citizens from Africa (excluding North Africa.)


No doubt a lot of liberals face a real conundrum when dealing with a decision over whether to shout about victimized women and risk putting immigrant rapists in a bad light.

Let's not quibble over minor details, them brothers are clearly sexin' up the ladies...whether they want it or not.

Yay, culture!
 
Last edited:
Again, I have no idea who said but it has led to the current climate around immigration:

If responsible people don't address immigration, irresponsible people will.
The current climate around immigration is that Americans are friendlier towards immigration than they have been at any point since Gallup started polling in 1965.

That quote is just an alarmist rhetorical flourish, about as meaningful as "If responsible people don't address hate speech, irresponsible people will." It offers no guidance on what these notional responsible people should be doing differently.

I mean, we already have a horrifically illiberal immigration system. The idea that we should make it even worse for the sake of avoiding a backlash that is in reality a frontlash should not be countenanced.
 
What if you wanted your race to dominate because of personal advantage to yourself, but had no particular views about racial superiority?

That would be racism as well. No matter what your motivation is to rob a bank, you are still a bank robber.

Hans
 
This reminds me of an old saying about the most dangerous thing for a masochist is to meet a sadist. A people whose self deprecation borders on self loathing had better make sure it doesn't fall in with a people who agree that that people is right to loath itself.

Obviously you know little of sadomasochism. No problem; it's a subject most people really don't wanna know about.

Hans
 
And what was there a few generations earlier, before all the Irish immigrants swarmed in and ruined the neighborhood? So it goes.

Hey guess what: we all get ******* replaced.

Yeah, if by no others, our own offspring. Live with it. ... Correction: Die with it.

Hans
 
Yeah seriously the hateful, stupid, and proudly wrong have got to stop threatening us with them being replaced.

Like don't threaten me with a good time. What's next you're going to threaten with a second season of Firefly?
 
I'm not conflating them. Until there is no correlation between race and culture though, cultures producing different outcomes is going to mean races perform differently.


Sure, but they are highly correlated.

*snip*

Race and culture is coincidentally related due to geography: Races tend to occupy certain geographic zones, and so do cultures. However, in modern times (meaning the latest century or so), this relation is disappearing: Races and cultures are being mixed, but under different mechanisms. At this point, you can no longer infer the culture of a person from their race.

Hans
 
Again we're being trapped in sloppy language that the people trying to trap us created.

"Race" was never a real logical concept, but it was treated as one for so long that the people who illogically clumped together started to have shared experiences, ya know a culture (or at least part of / start of one.)

"Race" doesn't exist but being treated a specific way because of your race does. This is not complicated.
 
Whenever I hear people say there is no correlation between race and culture, it makes me laugh. Clearly these people cannot separate the theoretical from the practical. Maybe it doesn't work this way in some parts of the world, but here in the US there is a large degree of correlation between the two.

There are exceptions to every rule, but stereotypes are often well-founded and reality-based.

And whenever I hear someone say there is no such thing as race, I am reminded of how Larry Bird and Magic Johnson look pretty much the same. I guess we all have our own ways of defining the word.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom