Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

So all liberals are the same?

Excuse me but I have to ask why you don't realize that one might suspect that your they-all-look-alike-to-me mindset isn't a carry over from an unspoken belief system about non-whites and non-Christians?

What do my feelings about "non-Christians" have to do with anything? Is there some assumption being made?

Avoidance yet again! It's not just about your "feelings" about non-whites and non-Christians.

It's about your well demonstrated presumption that people in certain groups are all the same.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
It's about your well demonstrated presumption that people in certain groups are all the same.


Sure, occasionally you run into a liberal who is against gun control and immigration, but it is rare. There are general commonalities among cultures, races, and political affiliations. And as stated before, there are exceptions to every rule.
 
Sure, occasionally you run into a liberal who is against gun control and immigration, but it is rare. There are general commonalities among cultures, races, and political affiliations. And as stated before, there are exceptions to every rule.

What next? Ya' gonna' tell us that some of your best friends are liberals?

You just don't get that the differences between individuals are greater that those of cultures, races, and political affiliations.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Originally Posted by Warp12 View Post
Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

Your funny.

Yo do realize that we are talking about different things here. If you mean "race" in the biological sense there is no such thing has different Human "races".

You see "race" in another way of saying subspecies. Biological divisions of a single species, that although they can interbreed are more genetically distinct from another subspecies in the same species then members of the subspecies are from each other.

No matter how you divide up Humanity you just don't find this in the Human "race". It appears that not only are we one species we are one subspecies. The fact that Human groups look different turns out to be highly misleading in terms of dividing Humanity into subspecies no matter how you try to do so.

The term "race" originated as a scientific term in the 19th century to describe subspecies and it was applied to Humans. It was subsequently used by racists to create a hierarchy of Humanity based on the notion that some "races" were superior to other "races". In its more extreme form some people thought of Humanity divided into different species!

Up to today this concept of "race" is used to arrange Humanity into a hierarchy of being by people who really think Humanity is really divided into hierarchly distinct "races" that are biologically quite distinct from each other. This belief is bad science but is a significant social fact. Why? Because acting on the belief of such a hierarchy of being and oppressing etc., members of groups based on such beliefs is racist, even though the belief in seperate Human "races" is a fantasy. Fantasies can be powerful social facts.

"Races" are basically socially created based on notions that certain observable group differences clearly indicate fundamental biological differences between humans. Further the biological differences used to distinguish different Human "races" has varied over time. (For example In the past many people thought that Italians, Spanish etc., were not "white".) Jews were also believed by many in the past to be a seperate "race", along with all sorts of other groups.

The Number of Human "races" accordingly has wildly varied over time according to many people. (Some have given dozens of races other have reduced it to 4 or even less)

Just for fun the genetic differences between Australian Aborigines and Europeans is less than the differences between East and West Africans. Yet Australian Aborigines and Europeans are differnt "races" and East and West Africans are the same "race".
 
You just don't get that the differences between individuals are greater that those of cultures, races, and political affiliations.
What has this got to do with anything? The average height difference within a sex is bigger that between the sexes. You still have almost all the tall people being male. The difference in the likelihood to go around raping people differs vastly more between men than between cultures/races, but out of the men who do commit rapes, some cultures/races are way over represented. Obviously most Syrians aren't rapists, but they seem to be a much more rape enthusiast heavy group than ethnic Swedes.
 
What has this got to do with anything? The average height difference within a sex is bigger that between the sexes. You still have almost all the tall people being male. The difference in the likelihood to go around raping people differs vastly more between men than between cultures/races, but out of the men who do commit rapes, some cultures/races are way over represented. Obviously most Syrians aren't rapists, but they seem to be a much more rape enthusiast heavy group than ethnic Swedes.

Wow, these have been the weakest points you made so far.
 
What has this got to do with anything? The average height difference within a sex is bigger that between the sexes. You still have almost all the tall people being male. The difference in the likelihood to go around raping people differs vastly more between men than between cultures/races, but out of the men who do commit rapes, some cultures/races are way over represented. Obviously most Syrians aren't rapists, but they seem to be a much more rape enthusiast heavy group than ethnic Swedes.

Warp's pulling a cheap debate trick in which he takes the opposing views of people here (and liberals of different view points) and pretending the statements are coming out of one mouth tries to call them contradictory.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Them immigrants is doin' plenty 'o rapin', from what I can tell...

Another article:

Sweden’s migrant rape crisis
https://unherd.com/2021/04/swedens-migrant-rape-crisis/

No doubt a lot of liberals face a real conundrum when dealing with a decision over whether to shout about victimized women and risk putting immigrant rapists in a bad light.

Let's not quibble over minor details, them brothers are clearly sexin' up the ladies...whether they want it or not.

Yay, culture!
From your link:
I think that is a mistake, ethically and analytically, not least because the overwhelming majority of foreign-born men living in Sweden are not guilty of crimes. It goes without saying that the group as a whole cannot be condemned for the actions of a very small percentage.
 
Is the idea that, to imagine a rather extreme case, if 10% of Syrians were rapists, but you had no way to know which ones, then it would be wrong to to display reluctance to the free inflow of Syrians since 90% of them were not rapists?
 
From your link:


Nobody said that all foreign-born men were raping women. Just that they are very much statistically overrepresented. Is that so difficult to understand?

This "immigrant apologism" is pretty ridiculous.

Warp12 said:
No doubt a lot of liberals face a real conundrum when dealing with a decision over whether to shout about victimized women and risk putting immigrant rapists in a bad light.
 
Last edited:
Implying that Larry Bird and Magic don't look similar partly because they are of different races, is now overtly racist? Seriously?

The real criticism should be because nobody said that all people of one race "look alike". They certainly may share some similar discerning features, however. Of course, I will give a little leeway here for any of our blind forum members...they may not be able to grasp this.
I'm not quite sure how you are defining "race" but it is essentially not a biological distinction.

Yes there are some genes that identify a person's skin and hair color, etc. But it amounts to only a small percentage of one's genetic makeup. And it's not consistent. Biologically we are all one race.
 
Sure, occasionally you run into a liberal who is against gun control and immigration, but it is rare. There are general commonalities among cultures, races, and political affiliations. And as stated before, there are exceptions to every rule.

So what race am I as a typical liberal? Does that differ from the race of a typical conservative?:confused:
 
Nobody said that all foreign-born men were raping women. Just that they are very much statistically overrepresented. Is that so difficult to understand?

This "immigrant apologism" is pretty ridiculous.
And some of the links in the thread suggested reasons might have to do with who gets convicted, not necessarily that foreign born residents commit a disproportionate number of rapes.

I also posted the number of rapes went down recently and I have yet to find a source that said rapes doubled with an influx of immigrants.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom