Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Nothing that I posted assigns "92% of rapes to immigrants". So, your retort is misplaced, I'm afraid, and I am not the audience for your linked article.

Do you consider that to be a measured and thoughtful response to my post, or more of a 'grasping at any straws to dismiss evidence contrary to your views' kind of answer?
I'm asking because you are relatively new to this forum, and you may not be aware of the phenomenon of confirmation bias.
Giving you the benefit of the doubt here- take it or leave it, as you wish.
 
Despite the truly repugnant tone of your post, I will respond with more civility than you deserve.
You have fallen for a disinformation campaign, aimed at those with your kind of cognitive biases.
Read this, and perhaps you can see how you have been misled.
https://mythdetector.ge/en/disinfor...-92-of-rapes-committed-by-migrants-in-sweden/

My thoughts about your facts.
1. There seems to be a bit of a trend to stop collecting stats on things like ethnic differences in offending. People have gone out and gathered statistics, so the fact that the Swedish government make answering these kinds of questions more difficult than it would need to be doesn't seem to be an insurmountable problem. I guess they could easily disprove the stats that have been claimed by starting to record these things systematically again? I don't think that they will though.

All this "no statistics is collected" stuff is also weasel words. No statistics are systematically collected by the Swedish government. Samples have been collected though, showing 58% of convicted rapists are foreign born.

2. "The number of registered crimes has increased in Sweden as compared to the previous years, however, there is no basis to connect the increased crime rate to the migrants." There is no basis for connecting the fact that they vastly increased the population that is convicted of rape at an extremely disproportionate rate with the increase in rapes? That's the argument. If they think it's not collected, they could easily start collecting stats. They are also equivocating, moving the claim from rapes to all crime.

Do you have anything that disproves the claim that immigrants commit vastly disproportionate numbers of rapes in Sweden, rather than the claim that immigrants commit vastly disproportionate amount of all crime?

It's not like it would be a surprising finding that people from some countries are more rapey than people from other countries. This seems particularly intuitive when those people are encountering women behaving in a way that, in their country of origin, would mark them out as prostitutes.
 
Last edited:
My thoughts about your facts.
1. There seems to be a bit of a trend to stop collecting stats on things like ethnic differences in offending. People have gone out and gathered statistics, so the fact that the Swedish government make answering these kinds of questions more difficult than it would need to be doesn't seem to be an insurmountable problem. I guess they could easily disprove the stats that have been claimed by starting to record these things systematically again? I don't think that they will though.

All this "no statistics is collected" stuff is also weasel words. No statistics are systematically collected by the Swedish government. Samples have been collected though, showing 58% of convicted rapists are foreign born.

2. "The number of registered crimes has increased in Sweden as compared to the previous years, however, there is no basis to connect the increased crime rate to the migrants." There is no basis for connecting the fact that they vastly increased the population that is convicted of rape at an extremely disproportionate rate with the increase in rapes? That's the argument. If they think it's not collected, they could easily start collecting stats. They are also equivocating, moving the claim from rapes to all crime.

Do you have anything that disproves the claim that immigrants commit vastly disproportionate numbers of rapes in Sweden, rather than the claim that immigrants commit vastly disproportionate amount of all crime?

It's not like it would be a surprising finding that people from some countries are more rapey than people from other countries. This seems particularly intuitive when those people are encountering women behaving in a way that, in their country of origin, would mark them out as prostitutes.

Wow, your posts are getting weaker and weaker. We reached "Stream of consiousness" level. :(
 
Despite the truly repugnant tone of your post, I will respond with more civility than you deserve.
You have fallen for a disinformation campaign, aimed at those with your kind of cognitive biases.
Read this, and perhaps you can see how you have been misled.
https://mythdetector.ge/en/disinfor...-92-of-rapes-committed-by-migrants-in-sweden/

You forget that some people will never, ever let facts and evidence get in the way of their echo-chamber induced, fixed ideas!
 
Last edited:
You forget that some people will never, ever let facts and evidence get in the way of their echo-chamber induced, fixed ideas!


No matter. The commenter in question is easily replaced.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 345 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
No matter. The commenter in question is easily replaced.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 345 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
We are all easily replaced. People are like pens. If they don't work, you shake them. If they still don't work, you chuck them away.
 
At this point, it appears to me that this thread has run its course, and whatever little value it may have initially offered has been wrung out of it long ago. Pretty much like every other CT, Replacement Theory may be conceivable, but no one has put forth an atom of evidence that it's really happening. End of discussion really. Yet another impotent idea that any remotely objective, reasonable, and logical observer would agree got thoroughly trashed, and without much heavy lifting.

What remains after that shark got jumped has devolved into marginally relevant content that just toes the boundary of "Yep, this is racist" territory, and then deflecting, obscuring, and/or ignoring when called on it. Rinse and repeat. As a result, much of the discourse has sunk to the level of juvenility more associated with other forums, posts that I'm frankly surprised haven't been deported to serve out their existence among their cultural brethren in AAH.

So maybe it's high time to find more worthwhile pursuits. I suppose there will be the inevitable "I win!!!" post or two. But somehow I think I'll manage to live a meaningful life anyway.
 
Something somewhat more back on topic.

So, historically, every time there has been large scale immigration from a particular part of the world, there has been a negative backlash against it, regardless of what the people look like. Its almost as thought racism as we currently understand it, isn't really the issue but perhaps some other human impulse that is sometimes expressed as racism? Perhaps, those that are more in favor of large scale immigration might try to address that without just calling people racists?

Again, I have no idea who said but it has led to the current climate around immigration:

If responsible people don't address immigration, irresponsible people will.

I hate to agree with some people but I don't think there is much evidence to support the belief that is a small fraction of the population that gets nervous about immigration.

People have been "nervous" about immigration for a very long time. Can you show the countries that have been worse due to immigration?

Doesn't matter, in a democracy, you have to account for how the people feel.

Oh great, more gibberish. :thumbsup:


Just want this exchange to be in context and let other folks judge the merits.
 
Last edited:
At this point, it appears to me that this thread has run its course, and whatever little value it may have initially offered has been wrung out of it long ago.. . ..

I think what scares a lot of CT folks is a precipitous change in culture.

If you look at some of the posts here there's a grave concern among CTers that the left is going to liberalize the U.S. at the same time masses of immigrants who don't give a hoot for traditional conservative values flood the country.

it's theorized that the country will be changed for the worst.

The idea that Mexicans, Muslims and non-white third world people are certain to befoul the country smacks of racism and bigotry. And nobody wants to be called a racist and a bigot, even if that's exactly what they are.

When called out these folks spout their unresolved gripes about white guilt, illegal immigration and the cancel culture as a diversion.

The whole "you're a racist. . .don't call me racist" back and forth takes us away from an intelligent discussion of what the future of western culture really could be.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 345 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
As a USAian, the cultural values that frighten me are those of religious extremism and crime as a way of life. But it seems unlikely to me that immigrants who do bring more of those sorts of things with them are going to outpace either the religious extremism or the gang and family crime that tried and true natural born citizen type people here do.

The ‘most perpetrators of y are x’ argument on its own promotes useless prejudice. You also need to show what proportion of x ever perpetrate y. If it’s low then suggesting extraordinary vigilance is IMO useless as well as being divisive and unfair. You can be a normal amount of cautious of everybody and get the same benefit as being hypercautious of x.
 
Them immigrants is doin' plenty 'o rapin', from what I can tell...


No doubt a lot of liberals face a real conundrum when dealing with a decision over whether to shout about victimized women and risk putting immigrant rapists in a bad light.

Let's not quibble over minor details, them brothers are clearly sexin' up the ladies...whether they want it or not.

Yay, culture!

Warp12, do you think that this post displays an appropriate level of sympathy for the rape victims being discussed here?
You see, to me it looks like your flippant, gleeful crowing is more about attacking immigrants than it is about protecting women from sexual assault.
 
I'm not conflating them. Until there is no correlation between race and culture though, cultures producing different outcomes is going to mean races perform differently.
In a thread devoted to discussion of lies and damn lies, it isn't surprising to find discussion of statistics.

The person quoted above thinks correlations between properties X and Y and between properties Y and Z imply correlation between X and Z. That fallacy is often seen in pseudoscientific attempts to support some of the arguments seen in this thread, so it's worth giving a counterexample to that fallacy.
  1. Individual 1 has property X but not Y and not Z.
  2. Individual 2 has properties X and Y and Z.
  3. Individual 3 has properties X and Y but not Z.
  4. Individual 4 has properties X and Y and Z.
  5. Individual 5 has none of the properties X, Y, and Z.
  6. Individual 6 has properties Y and Z but not X.
  7. Individual 7 has none of the properties X, Y, and Z.
  8. Individual 8 has property Z but not X and not Y.
Calculating the Pearson sample coefficients for that example,
  • the correlation between X and Y is 1/2,
  • the correlation between Y and Z is 1/2,
  • but the correlation between X and Z is 0.
 
Last edited:
I want to pick at the mention that blacks in America commit a disproportionate number of homicides.
This is actually true.
Now, this is presumably why Warp12 and his amoral associate have been crowing about this, as it ties in with their general antipathy to melanin.
However, I don't think this is anywhere near as simple as claiming black people are somehow inherently more prone to violence than whites. If that was the case, then homicide rates for black majority countries would be the highest in the world. That is not the case. In fact, Latin America has the dubious distinction of having the greatest representation in the rankings of countries with the highest homicide rates, although a number of Caribbean nations also feature in the higher ranks.
Looking at some of the other stats, Russia has higher rates than Congo, Tanzania or Ethiopia- so a predominantly white country has more murders per capita than several African countries. Moreover, rates in several African countries are comparable with the US, and more are lower.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate

So, the problem with the racist 'blacks are more violent' claim is that- unsurprisingly- it doesn't add up. What is the case is that blacks in America are more violent than their compatriots of other ethnicities. This then leads to the question of why that should be. I have my own thoughts on this, but I was wondering if Warp12 had any?
Warp12, what's your explanation of this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom