Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Whenever I hear people say there is no correlation between race and culture, it makes me laugh. Clearly these people cannot separate the theoretical from the practical. Maybe it doesn't work this way in some parts of the world, but here in the US there is a large degree of correlation between the two.

There are exceptions to every rule, but stereotypes are often well-founded and reality-based.

And whenever I hear someone say there is no such thing as race, I am reminded of how Larry Bird and Magic Johnson look pretty much the same. I guess we all have our own ways of defining the word.

One has dark skin, both are Homo Sapiens. What was your point again? And what, from your expert point of view is the name of Magic Johnsons "race"?
 
Last edited:
Speaking of basketball again. . .

Back in the 70's Esquire magazine ran an article on white NBA stars who played like black men (whatever that is/was) and black stars who played like white men.

Rick Barry and Pistol Pete were said to play like blacks while Paul Silas and Nate Thurman were said to play like white guys. It was, IMHO, a useless article.

But the idea takes the discussion to the old nurture vs. nature argument.

The supposed correlation between race and culture suggest that there is something in blacks, or whites "that makes 'em act like they do".

And to the point. . .if it's all about nature, rather than nurture, then we see the root of the GTR. . .the idea that people who, by their nature, can't be trusted to continue European/white culture shouldn't be allowed to immigrate.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
"They all look the same to me."

Someone said the quiet part out loud again.

I think at this point we're all frogs sitting in boiling water. In steps, the dialog has grown rather overtly racist, to the point that, had recent terminology been used at the beginning, most of us would probably have been too outraged to even engage.
 
I think at this point we're all frogs sitting in boiling water. In steps, the dialog has grown rather overtly racist, to the point that, had recent terminology been used at the beginning, most of us would probably have been too outraged to even engage.


Implying that Larry Bird and Magic don't look similar partly because they are of different races, is now overtly racist? Seriously?

The real criticism should be because nobody said that all people of one race "look alike". They certainly may share some similar discerning features, however. Of course, I will give a little leeway here for any of our blind forum members...they may not be able to grasp this.
 
Last edited:
Implying that Larry Bird and Magic don't look similar partly because they are of different races, is now overtly racist? Seriously?

But why even bring up this point in a thread where the topic under discussion is supposed to be culture? Unless, of course, it was about race all along, and people are finally dropping the "culture" pretext and simply admitting the truth. Hence my "frog in boiling water" comparison.
 
But why even bring up this point in a thread where the topic under discussion is supposed to be culture? Unless, of course, it was about race all along, and people are finally dropping the "culture" pretext and simply admitting the truth. Hence my "frog in boiling water" comparison.


It was mentioned because someone else just disputed, a few posts up, that there is such thing as different races; this is not the first time this has been presented recently.

Again we're being trapped in sloppy language that the people trying to trap us created.

"Race" was never a real logical concept, but it was treated as one for so long that the people who illogically clumped together started to have shared experiences, ya know a culture (or at least part of / start of one.)

"Race" doesn't exist but being treated a specific way because of your race does. This is not complicated.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13815391#post13815391
 
Last edited:
Implying that Larry Bird and Magic don't look similar partly because they are of different races, is now overtly racist? Seriously?

The real criticism should be because nobody said that all people of one race "look alike". They certainly may share some similar discerning features, however. Of course, I will give a little leeway here for any of our blind forum members...they may not be able to grasp this.

How very disingenuous, Warp. Your inference is that the collation between race and culture so strong that one's culture is largely determined by their race.

This ignores that Bird grew up in rural French Lick, Indiana while Magic grew up in the city of Lansing, Michigan.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
People have been "nervous" about immigration for a very long time. Can you show the countries that have been worse due to immigration?
Doesn't matter, in a democracy, you have to account for how the people feel.
 
What is your source for this claim?

When I searched for this I came up with a misleading BBC headline from 2018.

Sweden rape: Most convicted attackers foreign-born, says TV
What is misleading about the headline? You mean the things you highlighted? Remember, the BBC are a globalist, pro-immigration organisation, so you have to read them with that it mind.

The Mission Investigation programme, due to be broadcast on Wednesday by SVT, said When Sweden took in its highest number of asylum seekers in 2015, the number of reported rapes declined by 12%. At the height of the migration crisis, some 160,000 migrants arrived there - more per capita than any other EU country.

"We are very clear in the programme that it is a small percentage of the people coming from abroad who are convicted of rape," chief editor Ulf Johansson told the BBC.

He pointed out that the number of reported rapes in Sweden was far higher, so no conclusions could be drawn on the role of immigrants in sexual attacks. ...

So, you have two counter claims there, that the rapes declined and that relatively few immigrants were rapists. I'll deal with them in reverse order.

1. Why does it matter that relatively few of them are rapists? If being pro-immigration doubles the rape rate, this is just trying to change to a more convenient the question. Is there a way of filtering out the immigrants so you keep out the rapists. As I think you'll see from the data, one way of doing that would be to restrict non-western immigration.

2. What you see in the data is an increasing rate of rapes that goes up with immigration. There is a blip for one year in the increasing trend.

I found the below graph showing immigration into Sweden, you can see the non-Western immigration is ballooning from the 1990s.


What you also see is that immigration went up until 2016 and then started to decline. It increases by less than 6% from 2014 to 2015. That's just the increase in immigrants arriving in one year, so as a percentage of the total number of immigrants in the country, it is going to be tiny. I'm not sure the fact that the rate of rapes decline for a single year, only to go back up, which they would have known by the time they wrote the article but didn't say, is anything other than noise.



Let's look at where the immigrants are coming from. In 1980, you see that 87% of the foreign born population was European, with close to half of that being from Finland. By 2017, only 45% of the foreign born population is European, with less than a quarter of that being Finnish.They have been replaced by Syrians as the biggest foreign born group. Syrians are 9.2% of foreign born Swedes and 1.7% of the total population. You then have the Fins at 8.4% and the Iraqis at 7.5%, Poles at 4.9%, Iranian's at 4%, and Somalis at 3.5%. There are then some more western countries until you get to Afghanistan at 2.34%. So that's about half of the non-western immigrants coming from Syria, Iraq, Iran, Somalia and Afghanistan. They are now 5% of the population. If you compare the figures by continent of origin, Europe has been going up steadily, but Asia has come from nowhere at some point in the past could of decades to the point where it has almost caught up:

So, we are talking about immigrants from the Middle East - Syrians, Iraqis etc.

That highest year for migration that the BBC mentioned was where it went up by 7,274. That 7,274 is about 0.7% of the foreign born, non-European population of Sweden. Is it being the highest year for migration at that point significant in interpreting the drop in rapes?

Let's look at the figures on rapes:




You've got this huge exponentially growing trend.

And this report doesn't say the rate of rapes doubled, it said the majority of those convicted were born outside of Sweden

Sweden’s Lund University researcher faces prosecution for study that showed most rapes are committed by immigrants (forget the prosecution bit, it's not related).
Unless Sweden is operating some kind of quota system for rapes, I'm not sure what the argument is? Would Swedish men have stepped in to fill the ecological niche? I don't have data on the ethnicity of the rapists who weren't caught, but given the skew in the data for the convictions, it makes you wonder...
 
It was mentioned because someone else just disputed, a few posts up, that there is such thing as different races; this is not the first time this has been presented recently.

And your rebuttal to that was to point out that Larry Bird and Magic Johnson look different?? That's the line of scientific thought you're going with?

Look, for what it's worth I personally don't think it's super useful to try to deny that there's probably some legitimacy to the concept of races (if in fact anyone in this thread has proposed such a view). But given the fluid definitions of the term, evolving genetic mixes among previously fairly heterogeneous peoples, and the growing realization that criteria once used for racial classification are largely arbitrary and meaningless compared to actual genetic diversity, it's probably not a hill to die on. And it's a piss-poor look for anyone who's trying to build an argument based on "culture."
 
Last edited:
And your rebuttal to that was to point out that Larry Bird and Magic Johnson look different?? That's the line of scientific thought you're going with?

Look, for what it's worth I personally don't think it's super useful to try to deny that there's probably some legitimacy to the concept of races (if in fact anyone in this thread has proposed such a view). But given the fluid definitions of the term, evolving genetic mixes among previously fairly heterogeneous peoples, and the growing realization that criteria once used for racial classification are largely arbitrary and meaningless compared to actual genetic diversity, it's probably not a hill to die on. And it's a piss-poor look for anyone who's trying to build an argument based on "culture."



The real piss-poor argument would be to claim my statement was "overtly racist", imo. I'm not dying on a hill...I gave an opinion. One which you seem to partly agree with.

Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existence of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.
 
Last edited:
What is misleading about the headline? You mean the things you highlighted? Remember, the BBC are a globalist, pro-immigration organisation, so you have to read them with that it mind.



So, you have two counter claims there, that the rapes declined and that relatively few immigrants were rapists. I'll deal with them in reverse order.

1. Why does it matter that relatively few of them are rapists? If being pro-immigration doubles the rape rate, this is just trying to change to a more convenient the question. Is there a way of filtering out the immigrants so you keep out the rapists. As I think you'll see from the data, one way of doing that would be to restrict non-western immigration.

2. What you see in the data is an increasing rate of rapes that goes up with immigration. There is a blip for one year in the increasing trend.

I found the below graph showing immigration into Sweden, you can see the non-Western immigration is ballooning from the 1990s.
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_27129628d283306f29.png[/qimg]

What you also see is that immigration went up until 2016 and then started to decline. It increases by less than 6% from 2014 to 2015. That's just the increase in immigrants arriving in one year, so as a percentage of the total number of immigrants in the country, it is going to be tiny. I'm not sure the fact that the rate of rapes decline for a single year, only to go back up, which they would have known by the time they wrote the article but didn't say, is anything other than noise.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_27129628d29bab907c.png[/qimg]

Let's look at where the immigrants are coming from. In 1980, you see that 87% of the foreign born population was European, with close to half of that being from Finland. By 2017, only 45% of the foreign born population is European, with less than a quarter of that being Finnish.They have been replaced by Syrians as the biggest foreign born group. Syrians are 9.2% of foreign born Swedes and 1.7% of the total population. You then have the Fins at 8.4% and the Iraqis at 7.5%, Poles at 4.9%, Iranian's at 4%, and Somalis at 3.5%. There are then some more western countries until you get to Afghanistan at 2.34%. So that's about half of the non-western immigrants coming from Syria, Iraq, Iran, Somalia and Afghanistan. They are now 5% of the population. If you compare the figures by continent of origin, Europe has been going up steadily, but Asia has come from nowhere at some point in the past could of decades to the point where it has almost caught up:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_27129628d35aca5307.jpg[/qimg]
So, we are talking about immigrants from the Middle East - Syrians, Iraqis etc.

That highest year for migration that the BBC mentioned was where it went up by 7,274. That 7,274 is about 0.7% of the foreign born, non-European population of Sweden. Is it being the highest year for migration at that point significant in interpreting the drop in rapes?

Let's look at the figures on rapes:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_27129628d367d23a54.png[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_27129628d371a2c1a2.jpg[/qimg]

You've got this huge exponentially growing trend.


Unless Sweden is operating some kind of quota system for rapes, I'm not sure what the argument is? Would Swedish men have stepped in to fill the ecological niche? I don't have data on the ethnicity of the rapists who weren't caught, but given the skew in the data for the convictions, it makes you wonder...

Great, now please show us how Sweden turned into the hellhole you like to make it look like :rolleyes:
 
This ignores that Bird grew up in rural French Lick, Indiana while Magic grew up in the city of Lansing, Michigan.

And one grew up poor in a broken home, endured a brief teenage marriage that produced a child he's rarely seen, and dropped out of college after only a few weeks; while the other grew up in a stable middle-class home with doting supportive parents. Guess which was which?
 
I think at this point we're all frogs sitting in boiling water. In steps, the dialog has grown rather overtly racist, to the point that, had recent terminology been used at the beginning, most of us would probably have been too outraged to even engage.

Well it's a bit. He's normalizing it and we can't stop him.

That's the whole point.
 
The real piss-poor argument would be to claim my statement was "overtly racist", imo. I'm not dying on a hill...I gave an opinion. One which you seem to party agree with.

Now can we get back to the part in the thread where liberals call people "racists" in one breath, and then deny the existences of different races in the next? That's like my favorite part.

Try to settle on an argument, Warp.

If someone's culture is not cooked in by their DNA then that someone should be able, with a reasonable effort, to immigrate to another country and/or culture without violating cultural norms.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 344 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Have you read the content of the link? Their data does not contain anything about the ethnic origin of the rapists. They just say that it if they were, it would mean that the asylum seekers were committing rapes at a vastly higher frequency than native Swedes and assumes they aren't.

The data set that does contain information on whether the rapists were foreign born shows that this group is raping at a very much higher level than the native Swedes.

Why would it be shocking if Syrians committed rapes and sexual assaults at a vastly different rate when moved into the context of a liberal culture where women present themselves in a way that would mark them out as prostitutes in other parts of the world?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom