Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

I've read one of his books, but not that one, and seen a few of his videos. He tows a line right at the edge of where you can still be mainstream.

I think one way of looking at this is that there is a desire to avoid situations where minorities are asked to change their cultural practices to fit in with anglo culture. That would be colonialism. There is also a desire to have identical outcomes for all races and cultures. Unless one supposes somehow all cultures are going to produce equal outcomes, this poses a problem. There is an claim that the things that a culture rewards are arbitrary and chosen by the dominant cultural or racial group to reinforce their own dominance. That's why you have all these things saying punctuality, goal orientedness, saving, meeting deadlines, hard work, meritocracy and so on are aspects of whiteness and we need to reengineer the culture so it doesn't reward them.

I think his central theme is that the liberal desire to be nice has led to a failure to confront difficult truths which then has unfortunate implications.

He says, while being insulted for the last few weeks :rolleyes: Typical right winger confusion -> "I am a horrible person, I can't understand how anyone could be different!?"
 
Last edited:
Not to get off topic, but people might find interest in the search string "rebecca watson and richard dawkins feud" for some historical background here. A lot of us old timers are well acquainted with it. :D


BTW, I don't see any overcorrection. And worrying about apologizing for being white sounds like an excuse a racist might make to not want self evaluation.

I'm white, I welcome immigrants, I see the racists as a minority of whites with big microphones so to speak. It doesn't reflect on me and ignoring history to protect white snowflakes is absurd.

TBH, I've pretty much always considered Watson to be a well meaning but ultimately clueless airhead.
 
Last edited:
unicorns are real.
I have evidence:

krstei11.jpg
 
There is also a desire to have identical outcomes for all races and cultures. Unless one supposes somehow all cultures are going to produce equal outcomes, this poses a problem.
Why does the first sentence refer to "races and cultures", while the second sentence edits that down to just "cultures"? I mean, if you're going to conflate ethnicity and culture as though they are the same thing, why not just explicitly state that you don't think certain ethnicities are as capable as others by using "races and cultures" in the second sentence?

Ethnicity and culture aren't the same thing, by the way. I'm perfectly fine with stating that different cultures will produce different outcomes. For example, a feudal culture with a deeply entrenched caste system is very unlikely to be as innovative as a broadly egalitarian culture. But I see nothing to support the idea that different ethnic groups starting from the same point and having equal opportunities for success would be more or less likely to have a better outcome based on the ethnicity of each.
 
Not to get off topic, but people might find interest in the search string "rebecca watson and richard dawkins feud" for some historical background here. A lot of us old timers are well acquainted with it. :D
Yeah, that was weird. I don't remember posting much, if at all, about that back then. But I definitely formed some opinions.

BTW, I don't see any overcorrection. And worrying about apologizing for being white sounds like an excuse a racist might make to not want self evaluation.

I'm white, I welcome immigrants, I see the racists as a minority of whites with big microphones so to speak. It doesn't reflect on me and ignoring history to protect white snowflakes is absurd.
As a white man, I don't have a problem with admitting that many white people have historically used their ethnic identity as an excuse to be incredibly ****** to people who aren't white. But I also don't feel any personal guilt about it, any more than I'd feel personal guilt if I had a distant relative who committed murder.

I also don't have a problem acknowledging white privilege, because acknowledging its existence and the fact that I've benefited from it isn't the same as saying it's right.
 
Why does the first sentence refer to "races and cultures", while the second sentence edits that down to just "cultures"? I mean, if you're going to conflate ethnicity and culture as though they are the same thing, why not just explicitly state that you don't think certain ethnicities are as capable as others by using "races and cultures" in the second sentence?
I'm not conflating them. Until there is no correlation between race and culture though, cultures producing different outcomes is going to mean races perform differently.

Ethnicity and culture aren't the same thing, by the way.
Sure, but they are highly correlated.

I'm perfectly fine with stating that different cultures will produce different outcomes.
OK, so then we shouldn't expect different racial groups to do the same.

For example, a feudal culture with a deeply entrenched caste system is very unlikely to be as innovative as a broadly egalitarian culture. But I see nothing to support the idea that different ethnic groups starting from the same point and having equal opportunities for success would be more or less likely to have a better outcome based on the ethnicity of each.
You don't think that, say your stereotypical asian culture with lots of pressure to revise, and being asked "why you no doctor yet?" and having to get higher marks that other races to get passed affirmative action would produce a different result to a cultural group that didn't have that "why you no doctor yet?" attitude and who had lots of affirmative action, and bar lowering directed to it?

Also, I think if you are talking feudal culture... you are probably talking at a completely different level of analysis. I'm meaning like urban culture, ghetto culture, wasp culture.... that kind of thing.
 
Last edited:
I'm not conflating them. Until there is no correlation between race and culture though, cultures producing different outcomes is going to mean races perform differently.


Sure, but they are highly correlated.


OK, so then we shouldn't expect different racial groups to do the same.


You don't think that, say your stereotypical asian culture with lots of pressure to revise, and being asked "why you no doctor yet?" and having to get higher marks that other races to get passed affirmative action would produce a different result to a cultural group that didn't have that "why you no doctor yet?" attitude and who had lots of affirmative action, and bar lowering directed to it?

Also, I think if you are talking feudal culture... you are probably talking at a completely different level of analysis. I'm meaning like urban culture, ghetto culture, wasp culture.... that kind of thing.


Number one, if you don’t want to be seen as a racist, maybe you shouldn’t do caricatures? Just a thought…

Asians, Mexicans, Black people… any person of any race living in the United States is living in the same culture. I felt, as a mixed Anglo/Mexican descent person, that same kind of pressure. My wife is of Mexican descent, her father put that kind of pressure on her -she is a doctor now (I’m not). That, “put pressure on your kids,” thing isn’t a racial characteristic. It’s not even universal. White people put pressure on their kids also, but not all of them. That has everything to do with family dynamics and socioeconomic status/demographics.

The real question is why do non-white groups have worse outcomes than white people? I think the evidence is pretty clear that it’s a result of historical racism that we are still feeling today. There is prejudice in hiring. Black kids live in neighborhoods with worse schools and then get pushed out of those neighborhoods when “improvement” in the form of gentrification occurs.

I do think that White people need to take an honest look at the history and acknowledge that there are still problems stemming from past racial
injustices. I don’t think this means that they are bad people or that they need to be replaced. But it does mean that remaining blind to the issues, continuing to whine about how white people have been done dirty and not actively working to elevate conditions for everyone will lead to resentment from non-white people. That’s where we are now.

Murray is worried about a “War on the West.” I call BS on that. Those Western values of human rights, free thought, liberty, democracy, etc? We all want those things. If there is a “war” on anything, it’s a fight to make sure that all people get to fully benefit from them. White people should join that fight.
 
Last edited:
There is NO causal relationship between Race and Culture, as evidenced by adoptions.
What is causally related is Culture and Upbringing - and 2nd generation migrants that are not forced into ghettos usually assimilate the host country culture so much that they have problems returning to the origin country of their parents.
 
*snip*

You don't think that, say your stereotypical asian culture with lots of pressure to revise, and being asked "why you no doctor yet?" and having to get higher marks that other races to get passed affirmative action would produce a different result to a cultural group that didn't have that "why you no doctor yet?" attitude and who had lots of affirmative action, and bar lowering directed to it?

And this is how people easily turn stereotypes into racism without even realising it.
 
Last edited:
...You don't think that, say your stereotypical asian culture with lots of pressure to revise, and being asked "why you no doctor yet?" and having to get higher marks that other races to get passed affirmative action would produce a different result to a cultural group that didn't have that "why you no doctor yet?" attitude and who had lots of affirmative action, and bar lowering directed to it?

Your argument as articulated above makes absolutely zero sense, and the fact that you apparently don't realize this demonstrates why your position is fatally flawed. You yourself state that the Asian "why you no doctor yet?" trope is stereotypical (we'll overlook the racist way it's worded for the moment), as in a gross oversimplification of reality. And yet you blithely apply this non-fact to illustrate some point you apparently believe you are making about different cultures and affirmative action, seemingly unaware that what you've just said is as nonsensical as my stating Atlantean culture produces better swimmers. In both cases, the claimed point is equally mythical.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you'll disagree, but from the perspective of England, I would say that this concern about how things are said looks a lot like middle class morality and class prejudice.

No, it doesn't.

I live in Coventry, by the way.
 
Number one, if you don’t want to be seen as a racist, maybe you shouldn’t do caricatures? Just a thought…

Asians, Mexicans, Black people… any person of any race living in the United States is living in the same culture.
No they very obviously aren't. Call it subcultures if you want to call the collectioction of those things across the whole country the culture.

I felt, as a mixed Anglo/Mexican descent person, that same kind of pressure. My wife is of Mexican descent, her father put that kind of pressure on her -she is a doctor now (I’m not). That, “put pressure on your kids,” thing isn’t a racial characteristic. It’s not even universal. White people put pressure on their kids also, but not all of them. That has everything to do with family dynamics and socioeconomic status/demographics.
Right, and that pressure is uniformly distributed by race? There is lots of research that different countries have profoundly different attitudes to work. I recall some from decades ago that IBM did. Some countries are very ordered and keen on rules and being on time, others not so much. Some countries are very keen on hierarchy and deferring decision making to superiors, others not so much. Some cultures believe in deferred gratification and saving, others not so much.

Your contention is that when people emigrate to the US, they lose all these different traits from their original country? Different cultural traditions produce profoundly different results.

The real question is why do non-white groups have worse outcomes than white people?
Some do, some have better outcomes.

I think the evidence is pretty clear that it’s a result of historical racism that we are still feeling today. There is prejudice in hiring. Black kids live in neighborhoods with worse schools and then get pushed out of those neighborhoods when “improvement” in the form of gentrification occurs.
Is it your contention that all ethnic groups are identically distributed when it comes to cultural attitudes to things like timekeeping, studying, saving etc...? There is lots of left wing activist literature that identifies these things as being elements of whiteness that we need to change the culture so that they don't confer advantage.

I do think that White people need to take an honest look at the history and acknowledge that there are still problems stemming from past racial injustices. I don’t think this means that they are bad people or that they need to be replaced. But it does mean that remaining blind to the issues, continuing to whine about how white people have been done dirty and not actively working to elevate conditions for everyone will lead to resentment from non-white people. That’s where we are now.
How long do you think it will take? It's been, what 60 years of the temporary affirmative action programme, and welfare? Other groups have come in, been treated like **** and are now doing better than the white population.

xjx388;13815159Murray is worried about a “War on the West.” I call BS on that. Those Western values of human rights said:
I think you know that you are mischaracterizing Murray here. In any case, if those are western values, it seems like kind of imperialistic to impose those values on the rest of the world. What if their values differ to these?
 
TBH, I've pretty much always considered Watson to be a well meaning but ultimately clueless airhead.

Because the actual conversation has gotten quite tedious.

I tend to agree, I've listened to SGU for years, I was never especially impressed or unimpressed with her. I do think that there was a pretty wide spread antipathy towards her that was almost certainly primarily motivated by sexism. Mostly because I don't get any reaction to her other than, meh.

I do think she was largely correct in the whole elevator gate thing. Some dude put her in an awkward and uncomfortable position late at night. All she said was, dudes, don't do that. Quite reasonable but some how set off a **** storm.
 
There is NO causal relationship between Race and Culture, as evidenced by adoptions.
What is causally related is Culture and Upbringing - and 2nd generation migrants that are not forced into ghettos usually assimilate the host country culture so much that they have problems returning to the origin country of their parents.
People are "forced" into ghettos? There is no element of when large numbers of some particular group move to the US, they want to congregate together? Near me there is a Greek area of town, a Jewish are of town, an area with a lot of Somalis... nobody is making them congregate together.

I'm sure they do have difficulty returning to their original country. That isn't the same as being wholly submerged into their new one and having completely lost their cultural origins.
 
Something somewhat more back on topic.

So, historically, every time there has been large scale immigration from a particular part of the world, there has been a negative backlash against it, regardless of what the people look like. Its almost as thought racism as we currently understand it, isn't really the issue but perhaps some other human impulse that is sometimes expressed as racism? Perhaps, those that are more in favor of large scale immigration might try to address that without just calling people racists?

Again, I have no idea who said but it has led to the current climate around immigration:

If responsible people don't address immigration, irresponsible people will.
 
Last edited:
I do think she was largely correct in the whole elevator gate thing. Some dude put her in an awkward and uncomfortable position late at night. All she said was, dudes, don't do that. Quite reasonable but some how set off a **** storm.
This was during the sex panic of 2011. It's not like it was an isolated thing. Is The Central Scrutinizer still around? He and Watson were frenemies as I recall.
 
Last edited:
Something somewhat more back on topic.

So, historically, every time there has been large scale immigration from a particular part of the world, there has been a negative backlash against it, regardless of what the people look like. Its almost as thought racism as we currently understand it, isn't really the issue but perhaps some other human impulse that is sometimes expressed as racism? Perhaps, those that are more in favor of large scale immigration might try to address that without just calling people racists?

Again, I have no idea who said but it has led to the current climate around immigration:

If responsible people don't address immigration, irresponsible people will.

Yeah, always from a very very very very small fraction of the population but they tried to turn it into "We all think like this".

Anything else of your weak gibberish you want addressed?
 
If responsible people don't address immigration, irresponsible people will.
Good quote. I agree with your whole post. I do not think responsible people are going to deal with immigration though.
 
So, historically, every time there has been large scale immigration from a particular part of the world, there has been a negative backlash against it, regardless of what the people look like.

Yeah, always from a very very very very small fraction of the population but they tried to turn it into "We all think like this".


Your above assertion does not seem to reflect the facts.

In 2018, a survey of 27 countries around the world showed that a median of 45% wanted fewer or no immigrants, 36 % wanted to keep the current immigration levels and only 14% wanted immigration to increase. The median of those opposing was the highest in countries receiving the most migrants, with 51% in European countries.


This is a pretty good Wiki:

Opposition to immigration
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opposition_to_immigration
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom