I'm not conflating them. Until there is no correlation between race and culture though, cultures producing different outcomes is going to mean races perform differently.
Sure, but they are highly correlated.
OK, so then we shouldn't expect different racial groups to do the same.
You don't think that, say your stereotypical asian culture with lots of pressure to revise, and being asked "why you no doctor yet?" and having to get higher marks that other races to get passed affirmative action would produce a different result to a cultural group that didn't have that "why you no doctor yet?" attitude and who had lots of affirmative action, and bar lowering directed to it?
Also, I think if you are talking feudal culture... you are probably talking at a completely different level of analysis. I'm meaning like urban culture, ghetto culture, wasp culture.... that kind of thing.
Number one, if you don’t want to be seen as a racist, maybe you shouldn’t do caricatures? Just a thought…
Asians, Mexicans, Black people… any person of any race living in the United States is living in the same culture. I felt, as a mixed Anglo/Mexican descent person, that same kind of pressure. My wife is of Mexican descent, her father put that kind of pressure on her -she is a doctor now (I’m not). That, “put pressure on your kids,” thing isn’t a racial characteristic. It’s not even universal. White people put pressure on their kids also, but not all of them. That has everything to do with family dynamics and socioeconomic status/demographics.
The real question is why do non-white groups have worse outcomes than white people? I think the evidence is pretty clear that it’s a result of historical racism that we are still feeling today. There is prejudice in hiring. Black kids live in neighborhoods with worse schools and then get pushed out of those neighborhoods when “improvement” in the form of gentrification occurs.
I do think that White people need to take an honest look at the history and acknowledge that there are still problems stemming from past racial
injustices. I don’t think this means that they are bad people or that they need to be replaced. But it does mean that remaining blind to the issues, continuing to whine about how white people have been done dirty and not actively working to elevate conditions for everyone will lead to resentment from non-white people. That’s where we are now.
Murray is worried about a “War on the West.” I call BS on that. Those Western values of human rights, free thought, liberty, democracy, etc? We all want those things. If there is a “war” on anything, it’s a fight to make sure that all people get to fully benefit from them. White people should join that fight.