Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

What is a new phenomenon and what is an old evil simply rebranded AND what is a a symptom and what is the disease isn't always super-obvious.
 
What if you wanted your race to dominate because of personal advantage to yourself, but had no particular views about racial superiority?
Then you're still a political white supremacist, which is why these distinctions aren't all that interesting or important. "It's not that I think white people are superior, I just want white people to be superior."

It does speak to why ethical egoism is also an odious and self-defeating moral stance, however.
 
I just took a look at the book -Douglas Murray's "The War on the West: How to Prevail in the Age of Unreason," that is the subject of Watson's video. More specifically, I read through the transcript of a WSJ podcast he was on, discussing the book.

I have to say that I don't find the discussion centered at all on anything about "The Great Replacement." What it seems to focus on is what Murray calls, "the temptation of the overcorrection." IOW, a "wild swing to, as it were, correct a historic wrong by a present day wrong." Basically, American society has begun to overcorrect past injustices by committing new injustices -chiefly by turning White people into the bad guys of history and society. This is a complicated issue and I do think he makes some good points. I do think there is an overcorrection of sorts in that we don't need to denigrate "Whiteness" in order to elevate "Non-whiteness." Not in today's society. And certainly not in the past. Murray brings up how the British and the Americans both confronted the evils of slavery by waging wars to end it, at great cost to both countries.

You could see replacement theory as a very similar overcorrection by some White people.

Forgot to add: I don't find much merit in Watson's tying of this particular book to replacement theory, especially to the past history she takes so much time and tedium to go through. I don't think it's particularly fair to smear Dawkins simply because he liked the book and recommends it. I think it's important to critically examine all sides of the issue and find some common ground to move forward.

I'm curious - not curious enough to find and read the book and don't have the time either (and expecting to be out of touch for a couple of weeks after tonight). But I wonder if that is what is actually being done, or if it's just another over-correction, as we're seeing these days in the rush to forbid critical race theory so completely that people wonder if they can mention why Martin Luther King got famous.

I hope someone has the time and energy to read the book and find out whether the apparent allegations of over-correction are backed up.
 
Listen I'm as done as anyone with the whole "Whyte Peeple" thing and yeah Liberalism tends to take "Self Depreciating" into "Self Loathing" territory.

But that's an annoyance, not an actual problem. Rolling your eyes (which I do all the time) at liberals constantly apologizing for being white in that joking but not joking way they do doesn't equate it to massive, ingrained, social, political, and economic inequalities against minorities.

Again this "Liberals are annoying so Conservatives get to be evil" which is a really dumb take because Liberals are never going to stop being annoying.
 
Then you're still a political white supremacist, which is why these distinctions aren't all that interesting or important. "It's not that I think white people are superior, I just want white people to be superior."

It does speak to why ethical egoism is also an odious and self-defeating moral stance, however.
There are various ways of looking at this but the upshot seems to be that if you do a terrible thing, knowing that it's a terrible thing, and knowing that if you intended its terrible results you'd be wrong to do it, it's all right to go ahead and do it if you don't care.
 
It fits. "Everyone deep down inside is just as horrible as mean and are faking being good" is a huge part of this whole new mentality.
 
I just took a look at the book -Douglas Murray's "The War on the West: How to Prevail in the Age of Unreason," that is the subject of Watson's video. More specifically, I read through the transcript of a WSJ podcast he was on, discussing the book.
I've read one of his books, but not that one, and seen a few of his videos. He tows a line right at the edge of where you can still be mainstream.

I think one way of looking at this is that there is a desire to avoid situations where minorities are asked to change their cultural practices to fit in with anglo culture. That would be colonialism. There is also a desire to have identical outcomes for all races and cultures. Unless one supposes somehow all cultures are going to produce equal outcomes, this poses a problem. There is an claim that the things that a culture rewards are arbitrary and chosen by the dominant cultural or racial group to reinforce their own dominance. That's why you have all these things saying punctuality, goal orientedness, saving, meeting deadlines, hard work, meritocracy and so on are aspects of whiteness and we need to reengineer the culture so it doesn't reward them.

I think his central theme is that the liberal desire to be nice has led to a failure to confront difficult truths which then has unfortunate implications.
 
Listen I'm as done as anyone with the whole "Whyte Peeple" thing and yeah Liberalism tends to take "Self Depreciating" into "Self Loathing" territory.

But that's an annoyance, not an actual problem. Rolling your eyes (which I do all the time) at liberals constantly apologizing for being white in that joking but not joking way they do doesn't equate it to massive, ingrained, social, political, and economic inequalities against minorities.

Again this "Liberals are annoying so Conservatives get to be evil" which is a really dumb take because Liberals are never going to stop being annoying.

Yup!
 
USA is has been committed to supporting the Cuban people for decades, as a place of refuge for ANY Cuban who makes it to the USA.

I dont see why we would suddenly end that policy. Was Communism suddenly no longer an evil system?

I believe we should also offer asylum to anyone who makes it here from North Korea, Iran, Saudi Arabia.

I think if most Cubans were voting Blue, we would have kept our Dry Foot policy.

This was done during the time Obama was trying to normalize relations with Cuba. Trump and the republicans put the kibosh on that.
 
Listen I'm as done as anyone with the whole "Whyte Peeple" thing and yeah Liberalism tends to take "Self Depreciating" into "Self Loathing" territory.

But that's an annoyance, not an actual problem.


It is more than an "annoyance". The seeds to of bigger future problem have been, and continue to be planted. The fruit that this tree is going to bear is going to be very bitter; it doesn't take much imagination to see that.
 
It is more than an "annoyance". The seeds to of bigger future problem have been, and continue to be planted. The fruit that this tree is going to bear is going to be very bitter; it doesn't take much imagination to see that.
This reminds me of an old saying about the most dangerous thing for a masochist is to meet a sadist. A people whose self deprecation borders on self loathing had better make sure it doesn't fall in with a people who agree that that people is right to loath itself.
 
Replacement theory is mostly about institutions being affected by demographic changes. If a lot of immigrants to your town don't participate in your PTA, either because they're less interested or because they don't feel welcome there, then the PTA's influence declines. Recreational and retail businesses will either change to appeal to the newcomers, or lose out to competitors who do so. They can get by for a while appealing only to traditionalists (including being hostile to the newer immigrants) but over time that customer base ages out. Younger customers won't go where immigrant members of their own peer groups aren't welcome.

In other words, "it's about culture" actually means "it's about rap music at the roller rink." Get over it. You're too old to hang out there anyhow.

The recent Spielberg film of "West Side Story" makes this point visually; The Jets (the White gang) rips down a sign in Spanish over the front of a Puerto Rican restaurant to reveal it used to be an Irish pub.
 
The recent Spielberg film of "West Side Story" makes this point visually; The Jets (the White gang) rips down a sign in Spanish over the front of a Puerto Rican restaurant to reveal it used to be an Irish pub.


And what was there a few generations earlier, before all the Irish immigrants swarmed in and ruined the neighborhood? So it goes.

Hey guess what: we all get ******* replaced.
 
And what was there a few generations earlier, before all the Irish immigrants swarmed in and ruined the neighborhood? So it goes.

Hey guess what: we all get ******* replaced.


"Gangs Of New York" dealt with the coming of the Irish.
 
It is more than an "annoyance". The seeds to of bigger future problem have been, and continue to be planted. The fruit that this tree is going to bear is going to be very bitter; it doesn't take much imagination to see that.


And as you gesture at that small bitter tree with growing trepidation and alarm imagining what fruit it will someday bear, you're blind to the tidal wave of flaming toxic poo looming up to wash away the whole scene.

(That would be class animus in a world of depleting resources, by the way. Your pet race feud, all sides of it, is a distraction that's done its part to build that wave but will soon become an unaffordable luxury.)
 
And what was there a few generations earlier, before all the Irish immigrants swarmed in and ruined the neighborhood? So it goes.

Hey guess what: we all get ******* replaced.


This thread generates a fantasy in me where I become a benign dictator and then decree that anyone of any identified race can only procreate with someone of another race and then maybe eventually we can put this nonsense of superior race to rest.

Let's replace everybody.

And then, we get confronted with aliens from outer space.
 
This thread generates a fantasy in me where I become a benign dictator and then decree that anyone of any identified race can only procreate with someone of another race and then maybe eventually we can put this nonsense of superior race to rest.

Let's replace everybody.


But must we breed with Bolivians? They are like a really short group of people. Maybe we can breed them up to be taller or something. That's like my one reservation with regards to your plan.
 
But must we breed with Bolivians? They are like a really short group of people. Maybe we can breed them up to be taller or something. That's like my one reservation with regards to your plan.


Oddly enough, they are first on my fantasy benign dictatorship list.
 
I watched it and I will summarize it since dann did not. . . I guess her point is that "The Great Replacement" (TGR) is just the latest iteration of eugenic/"Bell Curve" type racism -you know, those now debunked attempts to justify racism as being based on "scientific principles." She starts with how the Buffalo murderer was influenced by TGR caca. She goes over the history of the ideas central to TGR: how the Nazis got their ideas from an American and that many Americans advocated instituting similar principles, from the 1930s all the way to the Regan era and even today through the likes of Steve Bannon, et al and some publications like "Mankind Quarterly." And she is pointing out that Dawkins is recommending a book written by a proponent of this type of racism and Dawkins implores us to read it with an open mind.

All in all, it is definitely an anti-Dawkins piece, even if he is only mentioned briefly. I don't know anything about the book he recommends, other than Watson's description of it. I think it's an interesting watch and gives some background on key ideas in TGR conspiracy theories. She is a bit boring to listen to, though, I'll give you that.
Thanks for the summary and taking the time to watch it. Going from that and the parts of it I watched, I repeat, except for the Dawkins fetish, I don't see anything remarkable or that wasn't a no brainer.

Now had she discussed why RT differs from simple racism it might have been more interesting. But to just go down a list of historical racist events, does she think this is new material for anyone? I suppose she does.

People have hated immigrants and 'other' ethnicities for as far back as history goes. There's a link somewhere (not sure which thread) of an experiment with infants that demonstrated as early as infancy babies recognize 'other' and 'my group' and have a preference for 'my group'. IOW it is an innate characteristic humans have given this is well before they could have learned it from their parents or other caregivers. We have to learn to overcome it which thankfully a lot of us have.
 
I just took a look at the book -Douglas Murray's "The War on the West: How to Prevail in the Age of Unreason," that is the subject of Watson's video. More specifically, I read through the transcript of a WSJ podcast he was on, discussing the book.

I have to say that I don't find the discussion centered at all on anything about "The Great Replacement." What it seems to focus on is what Murray calls, "the temptation of the overcorrection." IOW, a "wild swing to, as it were, correct a historic wrong by a present day wrong." Basically, American society has begun to overcorrect past injustices by committing new injustices -chiefly by turning White people into the bad guys of history and society.

This is a complicated issue and I do think he makes some good points. I do think there is an overcorrection of sorts in that we don't need to denigrate "Whiteness" in order to elevate "Non-whiteness." Not in today's society. And certainly not in the past. Murray brings up how the British and the Americans both confronted the evils of slavery by waging wars to end it, at great cost to both countries.

You could see replacement theory as a very similar overcorrection by some White people.

Forgot to add: I don't find much merit in Watson's tying of this particular book to replacement theory, especially to the past history she takes so much time and tedium to go through. I don't think it's particularly fair to smear Dawkins simply because he liked the book and recommends it. I think it's important to critically examine all sides of the issue and find some common ground to move forward.
Not to get off topic, but people might find interest in the search string "rebecca watson and richard dawkins feud" for some historical background here. A lot of us old timers are well acquainted with it. :D


BTW, I don't see any overcorrection. And worrying about apologizing for being white sounds like an excuse a racist might make to not want self evaluation.

I'm white, I welcome immigrants, I see the racists as a minority of whites with big microphones so to speak. It doesn't reflect on me and ignoring history to protect white snowflakes is absurd.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom