Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Yes. This isn't the part of Burke I have really focused on, but I think I agree with him.
 
I think this thread has really very little to do with the topic, and quite a lot to do with finding excuses to offend or be offended about the subjects of race and racism.


I think the idea that we, in America, are being "replaced" is kind of a paranoid fantasy.
 
What if you wanted your race to dominate because of personal advantage to yourself, but had no particular views about racial superiority?

OK that's a bit of a gotcha there, I suppose. You'd clearly be a racist, and your action would be indistinguishable from that of a supremacist but not for the usual reasons. An odd and unlikely situation, in which you would be instigating something for reason different from that of its other adherents.

I imagine there is an argument here that could be made, using something like the pragmatic maxim, and such, regarding the degree to which doing something can be separated from the reason for doing it, but I'm not inclined to start a whole new argument about that. I will take your point, even though I suspect it feeds some of your other ideas.

By the same token, though, one might suggest that there is a meaningful difference between a person advocating genocide on millions for reasons of ethnic hatred and mistake belief, and a farmer who supports it because the ashes will make his tomatoes grow better.
 
So, I thought about it a little more, and then decided not to say anything, and then decided to say something about it after all.

I have had some thoughts, and even said some things out loud, that could be mistaken for "replacement theory" and/or racism.

I wish more of my coworkers were Americans, meaning people born and raised in America, specifically, the United States. Or Canada. Canada is really just the suburbs of America. It used to be I didn't even need a passport to go there. Whatever.

So, I'm a programmer, and I work with a lot of Indians, and a smaller number of native Chinese. I work with a few European immigrants.

The number of Americans I work with is kind of small, and a whole lot smaller than it used to be.

Now, there's no problem for me, personally, working with people of those different ethnicities. In fact, I kind of like it. I'm into history, and culture, and mythology, and language and all sorts of elements of these things that make different groups of people different. However, the last time I was working as someone with responsibility for hiring, every single person we interviewed was Indian.

I thought, "What the heck is wrong with America that no Americans want this job, or are qualified for it? Where did we go wrong?"

However, I don't blame the Indians. I'm glad they are there. We need programmers. However, it does make me sad that there isn't a big enough group of American kids graduating in the appropriate fields to work in STEM related areas.

I think where the "replacement theory" morons go wrong is they see my Indian coworkers and complain that they "taking American jobs." I see them, and lament that there are too few Americans available who are qualified to compete for those jobs.
 
Last edited:
Bruto, all of this has been gone over already, in depth, yesterday. Yes, White Supremacists are racists. But there is more to being a supremacist than having some views that might be characterized as racist.

I'm not debating it any further. There is no stopping these folks from misusing and overusing the terms, anyway. What they really want to do is call people names, after all. I'll just continue to quietly laugh at them and shake my head.
I think I was basically agreeing with you - that supremacy includes views that go beyond those of racism. I also agree that some people throw those terms around rather more freely than they should, reading into loose language and common idioms more than they should. That is not to say that such things should not be remarked on, nor that context and history should not be included in how we judge a person's statements. If you're trying to impress a point of view on others, you would do well to take note of connotations. But the fact that there is a continuum where boundaries can be blurry does not mean that there are no broad categories. There is a meaningful difference between preference, bias, racism, and supremacy.
 
So, I'm a programmer, and I work with a lot of Indians, and a smaller number of native Chinese. I work with a few European immigrants.
I work in IT as well. This is a really interesting post, and I think you are pulling on a thread that leads to very interesting places.

The number of Americans I work with is kind of small, and a whole lot smaller than it used to be.
Depending on which bit of IT you are talking about this is quite widespread. In the UK, lots of service desk roles are in India, lots of dev roles outsourced there. Some to Eastern Europe as well. Lots of roles it is effectively borderline impossible to hire a non-Indian. I've done recruitment processes where every one of 20 applicants was Indian. If we spent more money I think it would begin to shift.

Now, there's no problem for me, personally, working with people of those different ethnicities. In fact, I kind of like it. I'm into history, and culture, and mythology, and language and all sorts of elements of these things that make different groups of people different. However, the last time I was working as someone with responsibility for hiring, every single person we interviewed was Indian.
I won't push you on this, but I wonder if you noticed any cultural differences that would be relevant to their ability to deliver work? IBM did a lot of work years ago on this question.

I thought, "What the heck is wrong with America that no Americans want this job, or are qualified for it? Where did we go wrong?"
This is the kind of thing that happens to empires. On the one hand you have labour arbitrage going on, that shifts jobs overseas and you create incentives for skills to build up in those regions and reduce the incentives at home. When you lose the entry level jobs overseas you create a problem that slowly cascades up the system. There was something similar that I recall being reported in the NHS. Routine procedures were being outsourced, which meant that there wasn't the opportunity to gain the skills needed for the complicated cases. Also, the routine cases provided the spare capacity in the system that could be flexed to make room when there were too many difficult cases. Basic queuing theory.

What you also then get is that industry and government doesn't have to care whether schools and universities are actually doing a good job, because its cheaper to hire in talent from abroad anyway. Why bother to wait years to train somebody, when you can export the risk of training them for the right thing and just hire them when you need them?

These kind of processes happen again and again in varying forms. It happened to the Romans, it happened to the British.

However, I don't blame the Indians. I'm glad they are there. We need programmers. However, it does make me sad that there isn't a big enough group of American kids graduating in the appropriate fields to work in STEM related areas.
Try being in the UK. At least Amazon, Twitter and so on are headquartered in the US. In most other places you've got the same outsourcing, but you've also got the global consolidation to the US, so neither the entry jobs, nor the top tech jobs are here. Generally the best talent gets drawn to the US. How is American youth supposed to compete with this giant vacuum sucking talent at cheaper cost from the entire globe?

This is really what "Replacement" is. It's more convenient to import new people and push the existing population to the side. This is both politically and economically. (In the UK the Labour party who were set up to represent the working class were faced with a clash between the progressive/globalist politics of it's leadership/activist/media class and the views of it's working class base, so they replaced their traditional base with a new one - minorities. This is a bit of a side issue, but I thought the parallel to the US might be of interest.)

That then raises another question. Why would all these democratic nations do this?

I think where the "replacement theory" morons go wrong is they see my Indian coworkers and complain that they "taking American jobs." I see them, and lament that there are too few Americans available who are qualified to compete for those jobs.
Why do you think that there are so few Americans available? Did that just happen? The direction of technology has certainly been apparent even to ordinary people since the late 90s, and for anybody who knew what was going on, rather longer. That's plenty of time to train people. It's not like Intel or Microsoft would have sat on their hands and taken no interest in the long term future of their recruitment. Even if you are recruiting from the top of the pyramid, that pyramid has to have a base.

I think you are wrong if you think the "they are taking our jobs" thing puts the blame on the Indians. This is a situation that was created by processes within the US. Look at China. The US chose to build up the Chinese economy, which then drained away manufacturing jobs from the west. It's the same thing over and over. That is the process that is being complained about. My experience is that the reading of "they are taking our jobs" that blames the Indians comes from people who are in favour of the changes being complained about. Intentionally or not, that interpretation means that the concern you are articulating is dismissed as racist without the substance of the concern being addressed.

Your observation is partly what was one my mind when I asked in one of these threads about the tragedy of the commons. I think something like the tragedy of the commons is at the heart of Adam Smith.
 
Last edited:
In the pre-U.S. colonies, the "they" who were going to ruin everything with their weird customs, weird clothes and weird food, who would never adopt the language or the American identity, were the Germans. In the 19th Century, it was the Irish and the Italians on the East Coast, and the Chinese on the West Coast, who were going to ruin America by never integrating culturally and overrunning good, white Protestants. In the 20th Century, it was Mexicans and other Latinos who filled the slot of "imminent threat to civilization", ironically being characterized as such by many of the descendants of the previous "imminent threats to civilization". It just seems like some unsavory outsiders have always been about to destroy paradise forever. It also seems pretty likely that a century from now mainstream 'Muricans of Mexican and African ancestry will be worried about having their good 'Murican culture diluted by, oh, let's say the Canadians, with their weird language, weird sports and weird beer.
 
All i know is that when I call my ISP or Electric CO with a question about my bill, if i get one more person with a thick accent who I can barely carry on a simple conversation with, leading to multiple transfers to another (usually Indian) who also is unable to speak in coherent sentences, I WILL ******* SCREAM! dur taken ur jobs! :boxedin:
 
All i know is that when I call my ISP or Electric CO with a question about my bill, if i get one more person with a thick accent who I can barely carry on a simple conversation with, leading to multiple transfers to another (usually Indian) who also is unable to speak in coherent sentences, I WILL ******* SCREAM! dur taken ur jobs! :boxedin:
But those people probably are not immigrants. They are more likely right at home in Mumbai or somewhere, the companies outsourcing the work to them. They're not immigrants. Everyone here, including the immigrants, is replaced by our own businesses.
 
It's effectively "rule of so". You summed up what I said to be something completely different to what I said. Now you are reading you failure to understand the reference in my answer to be confirmation that you were correct in your initial mischaracterisation.

Honestly, for a skeptics forum, this place has a remarkable number of psychics who can read people's true motives hidden behind their posts.

My not recognizing your reference had no special meaning. I asked you and Warp12 several questions and instead of answering them you posted a dodge.

It's really that simple.
 
Last edited:
I don't have to assume that you did not listen to enough of it to know what it was about since you wrote:

However, I doubt that it would have changed your mind to do so since you don't seem to be interested in the presentation of an argument. Instead you require that "a video like that" should start and end in a particular way, and since you think that this one didn't, it's reason enough for you to dismiss it. You "take it" that it is a certain way and "guess" that it's hard to summarize based on your ignorance of what it is.

I have no idea who "we" are supposed to be and supposed to "already know".
My goodness! Aren't you defensive.

I did listen to enough to know what it was about and it didn't change even at the end.

"the presentation of an argument"

What argument? She drones on and on about no brainer stuff. And droning on in monotone makes it harder to listen to.

Maybe someone else will weigh in on their impression of the vlog.
 
But those people probably are not immigrants. They are more likely right at home in Mumbai or somewhere, the companies outsourcing the work to them. They're not immigrants. Everyone here, including the immigrants, is replaced by our own businesses.

Yes, i realize that, i was just reacting to the outsourcing comments in the previous two posts. The 'takin r jobs' reference was just random S Park rambling ;)
 
Last edited:


Pretty good summary by "Beau of the Fifth Column"


From the comments....

“If you can convince the lowest white man he’s better than the best colored man, he won’t notice you’re picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he’ll empty his pockets for you.” LBJ

... so true!
 
My goodness! Aren't you defensive.

Maybe someone else will weigh in on their impression of the vlog.

I just watched the whole thing and my impression is that the point was "Richard Dawkins is a white supremacist" ...or something like that. :blush:
 
In the pre-U.S. colonies, the "they" who were going to ruin everything with their weird customs, weird clothes and weird food, who would never adopt the language or the American identity, were the Germans. In the 19th Century, it was the Irish and the Italians on the East Coast, and the Chinese on the West Coast, who were going to ruin America by never integrating culturally and overrunning good, white Protestants. In the 20th Century, it was Mexicans and other Latinos who filled the slot of "imminent threat to civilization", ironically being characterized as such by many of the descendants of the previous "imminent threats to civilization". It just seems like some unsavory outsiders have always been about to destroy paradise forever. It also seems pretty likely that a century from now mainstream 'Muricans of Mexican and African ancestry will be worried about having their good 'Murican culture diluted by, oh, let's say the Canadians, with their weird language, weird sports and weird beer.

Folks worried abound foreign cultures over running American society ought to look at the German migration to Texas in the mid 19th century. By 1890 German culture and language dominated large parts of Texas hill country, where communities had German schools and German newspapers.

It turns out Texas culture was not ruined by the Germans but rather was enhanced.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 343 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
In a 17:22 min. video about the book The War on the West and the history of U.S. eugenics, the mention of Richard Dawkins's recommendation of the book the day after another racist mass shooting must obviously mean that the point of the video is that Dawkins is a white supremacist even though Dawkins takes up less than a minute,
Why he would recommend that book is interesting but not really what the video is about, which you would know if you had watched it. But I guess that being backed up by somebody else who also doesn't seem to have watched the video is great as confirmation of your views.

ETA: Richard Dawkins tweet + comments.
Forget labels like “right wing” & “dark web”, read a book without preconceptions about the author & judge what it actually says. For what it’s worth, I always vote left & I think Douglas Murray’s The War on the West is utterly superb. Please read it with an open mind. Please.
12:57 PM · May 15, 2022

Lol
Douglass Murray is a major supporter of “great replacement theory.”

Seriously? Promoting a proponent of Replacement Theory hours after one of his fellow travellers went on a racially motivate mass-murder spree in the US?
I can't believe you don't understand what you're doing here.

"Please read it with an open mind. Please." is what peddlers of nonsense always ask you to do. And why would skeptics even dream of recommending reading something with a critical mind, right?
 
Last edited:
In a 17:22 min. video about the book The War on the West and the history of U.S. eugenics, the mention of Richard Dawkins's recommendation of the book the day after another racist mass shooting must obviously mean that the point of the video is that Dawkins is a white supremacist even though Dawkins takes up less than a minute,
Why he would recommend that book is interesting but not really what the video is about, which you would know if you had watched it. But I guess that being backed up by somebody else who also doesn't seem to have watched the video is great as confirmation of your views.

ETA: Richard Dawkins tweet + comments.


"Please read it with an open mind. Please." is what peddlers of nonsense always ask you to do. And why would skeptics even dream of recommending reading something with a critical mind, right?
Here's another person you accuse of not watching the vlog because they don't have the same reaction you had.

I appreciate your posts. You put a lot of time into some of them like your posts in the COVID threads. But you shouldn't be upset everyone is not as enamored as you are by Rebecca's vlogs.
 
Here's another person you accuse of not watching the vlog because they don't have the same reaction you had.

I appreciate your posts. You put a lot of time into some of them like your posts in the COVID threads. But you shouldn't be upset everyone is not as enamored as you are by Rebecca's vlogs.

I watched it and I will summarize it since dann did not. . . I guess her point is that "The Great Replacement" (TGR) is just the latest iteration of eugenic/"Bell Curve" type racism -you know, those now debunked attempts to justify racism as being based on "scientific principles." She starts with how the Buffalo murderer was influenced by TGR caca. She goes over the history of the ideas central to TGR: how the Nazis got their ideas from an American and that many Americans advocated instituting similar principles, from the 1930s all the way to the Regan era and even today through the likes of Steve Bannon, et al and some publications like "Mankind Quarterly." And she is pointing out that Dawkins is recommending a book written by a proponent of this type of racism and Dawkins implores us to read it with an open mind.

All in all, it is definitely an anti-Dawkins piece, even if he is only mentioned briefly. I don't know anything about the book he recommends, other than Watson's description of it. I think it's an interesting watch and gives some background on key ideas in TGR conspiracy theories. She is a bit boring to listen to, though, I'll give you that.
 
I just took a look at the book -Douglas Murray's "The War on the West: How to Prevail in the Age of Unreason," that is the subject of Watson's video. More specifically, I read through the transcript of a WSJ podcast he was on, discussing the book.

I have to say that I don't find the discussion centered at all on anything about "The Great Replacement." What it seems to focus on is what Murray calls, "the temptation of the overcorrection." IOW, a "wild swing to, as it were, correct a historic wrong by a present day wrong." Basically, American society has begun to overcorrect past injustices by committing new injustices -chiefly by turning White people into the bad guys of history and society.

This is a complicated issue and I do think he makes some good points. I do think there is an overcorrection of sorts in that we don't need to denigrate "Whiteness" in order to elevate "Non-whiteness." Not in today's society. And certainly not in the past. Murray brings up how the British and the Americans both confronted the evils of slavery by waging wars to end it, at great cost to both countries.

You could see replacement theory as a very similar overcorrection by some White people.

Forgot to add: I don't find much merit in Watson's tying of this particular book to replacement theory, especially to the past history she takes so much time and tedium to go through. I don't think it's particularly fair to smear Dawkins simply because he liked the book and recommends it. I think it's important to critically examine all sides of the issue and find some common ground to move forward.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom