So, I'm a programmer, and I work with a lot of Indians, and a smaller number of native Chinese. I work with a few European immigrants.
I work in IT as well. This is a really interesting post, and I think you are pulling on a thread that leads to very interesting places.
The number of Americans I work with is kind of small, and a whole lot smaller than it used to be.
Depending on which bit of IT you are talking about this is quite widespread. In the UK, lots of service desk roles are in India, lots of dev roles outsourced there. Some to Eastern Europe as well. Lots of roles it is effectively borderline impossible to hire a non-Indian. I've done recruitment processes where every one of 20 applicants was Indian. If we spent more money I think it would begin to shift.
Now, there's no problem for me, personally, working with people of those different ethnicities. In fact, I kind of like it. I'm into history, and culture, and mythology, and language and all sorts of elements of these things that make different groups of people different. However, the last time I was working as someone with responsibility for hiring, every single person we interviewed was Indian.
I won't push you on this, but I wonder if you noticed any cultural differences that would be relevant to their ability to deliver work? IBM did a lot of work years ago on this question.
I thought, "What the heck is wrong with America that no Americans want this job, or are qualified for it? Where did we go wrong?"
This is the kind of thing that happens to empires. On the one hand you have labour arbitrage going on, that shifts jobs overseas and you create incentives for skills to build up in those regions and reduce the incentives at home. When you lose the entry level jobs overseas you create a problem that slowly cascades up the system. There was something similar that I recall being reported in the NHS. Routine procedures were being outsourced, which meant that there wasn't the opportunity to gain the skills needed for the complicated cases. Also, the routine cases provided the spare capacity in the system that could be flexed to make room when there were too many difficult cases. Basic queuing theory.
What you also then get is that industry and government doesn't have to care whether schools and universities are actually doing a good job, because its cheaper to hire in talent from abroad anyway. Why bother to wait years to train somebody, when you can export the risk of training them for the right thing and just hire them when you need them?
These kind of processes happen again and again in varying forms. It happened to the Romans, it happened to the British.
However, I don't blame the Indians. I'm glad they are there. We need programmers. However, it does make me sad that there isn't a big enough group of American kids graduating in the appropriate fields to work in STEM related areas.
Try being in the UK. At least Amazon, Twitter and so on are headquartered in the US. In most other places you've got the same outsourcing, but you've also got the global consolidation to the US, so neither the entry jobs, nor the top tech jobs are here. Generally the best talent gets drawn to the US. How is American youth supposed to compete with this giant vacuum sucking talent at cheaper cost from the entire globe?
This is really what "Replacement" is. It's more convenient to import new people and push the existing population to the side. This is both politically and economically. (In the UK the Labour party who were set up to represent the working class were faced with a clash between the progressive/globalist politics of it's leadership/activist/media class and the views of it's working class base, so they replaced their traditional base with a new one - minorities. This is a bit of a side issue, but I thought the parallel to the US might be of interest.)
That then raises another question. Why would all these democratic nations do this?
I think where the "replacement theory" morons go wrong is they see my Indian coworkers and complain that they "taking American jobs." I see them, and lament that there are too few Americans available who are qualified to compete for those jobs.
Why do you think that there are so few Americans available? Did that just happen? The direction of technology has certainly been apparent even to ordinary people since the late 90s, and for anybody who knew what was going on, rather longer. That's plenty of time to train people. It's not like Intel or Microsoft would have sat on their hands and taken no interest in the long term future of their recruitment. Even if you are recruiting from the top of the pyramid, that pyramid has to have a base.
I think you are wrong if you think the "they are taking our jobs" thing puts the blame on the Indians. This is a situation that was created by processes within the US. Look at China. The US chose to build up the Chinese economy, which then drained away manufacturing jobs from the west. It's the same thing over and over. That is the process that is being complained about. My experience is that the reading of "they are taking our jobs" that blames the Indians comes from people who are in favour of the changes being complained about. Intentionally or not, that interpretation means that the concern you are articulating is dismissed as racist without the substance of the concern being addressed.
Your observation is partly what was one my mind when I asked in one of these threads about the tragedy of the commons. I think something like the tragedy of the commons is at the heart of Adam Smith.