Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

It's effectively "rule of so". You summed up what I said to be something completely different to what I said. Now you are reading you failure to understand the reference in my answer to be confirmation that you were correct in your initial mischaracterisation.

Honestly, for a skeptics forum, this place has a remarkable number of psychics who can read people's true motives hidden behind their posts.

There is quite the number of skeptics who are still waiting for your definition of "White/European Culture" and how exactly this culture is in danger of being destroyed by immigration. You did not deliver so far. Maybe act reasonable before lashing out at a community you are not forced to be a member of.
 
There is quite the number of skeptics who are still waiting for your definition of "White/European Culture" and how exactly this culture is in danger of being destroyed by immigration. You did not deliver so far. Maybe act reasonable before lashing out at a community you are not forced to be a member of.

 
That's not why I regard you as a racist.

It's because you assert that specific racist arguments are not racist

The topic wasn't, "Reasons Jimbob regards Warp12 as a racist".

The topic was the difference between the terms "Racist" and "White Supremacist".

But thanks for your clarification. I hold your opinion on these matters in very high regard.

Well, Warp, yesterday when you were asked if you agreed with the Founding Fathers that free trade and immigration were God giving rights you said yes.

But when asked to elaborate you jumped on another horse and told us the God given right to immigrate is limited by "established legal constraints" which are enforced by those ". . . appointed to do so".

I suspect you realized it would be difficult to explain how mere government functionaries could be empowered to routinely constrain God given rights so you started an off-the-subject rant about illegal immigration.

When asked directly if those constraints could be enacted in order to save country's culture and predominant race you changed the subject yet again.

Now you are back to your old trick of telling the rest of us what the subject is and what we can talk about.

I was not aware that you are a moderator here.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Well, Warp, yesterday when you were asked if you agreed with the Founding Fathers that free trade and immigration were God giving rights you said yes.

But when asked to elaborate you jumped on another horse and told us the God given right to immigrate is limited by "established legal constraints" which are enforced by those ". . . appointed to do so".

I suspect you realized it would be difficult to explain how mere government functionaries could be empowered to constrain God given rights so you started an off-the-subject rant about illegal immigration.

When asked directly if those constraints could be enacted in order to save country's culture and predominant race extinct you changed the subject yet again.

Now you are back to your old trick of telling the rest of us what the subject is and what we can talk about.

I was not aware that you are a moderator here.

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.


"God given"? What exactly does that mean, lol?

Immigration is dictated by law. I don't make the laws. I am not theorizing about future laws that may or may not be passed. There was no "off topic" rant.

I don't get your angle, tbh. Jimbob was addressing a specific statement and ignoring the context of the entire discussion.
 
Last edited:
Well, Warp, yesterday when you were asked if you agreed with the Founding Fathers that free trade and immigration were God giving rights you said yes.

But when asked to elaborate you jumped on another horse and told us the God given right to immigrate is limited by "established legal constraints" which are enforced by those ". . . appointed to do so".

I suspect you realized it would be difficult to explain how mere government functionaries could be empowered to routinely constrain God given rights so you started an off-the-subject rant about illegal immigration.

When asked directly if those constraints could be enacted in order to save country's culture and predominant race you changed the subject yet again.

Now you are back to your old trick of telling the rest of us what the subject is and what we can talk about.

I was not aware that you are a moderator here.

"God given"? What exactly does that mean, lol?

One would think that someone so concerned about his nation's culture and law would not need the phrase explained.

Immigration is dictated by law. I don't make the laws. I am not theorizing about future laws that may or may not be passed. There was no "off topic" rant.

Having argued yourself in a corner you ought to explain how a practice you endorse, empowering government functionaries to routinely constrain God given rights, is not destructive of American culture.

I don't get your angle. . .

Clearly so . .

---------
Dope Clock II: It's been 342 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
It's pretty simple. White supremacists are white racists. Unlike racists of other ethnicities.

White supremacy or white supremacism is the belief that white people are superior to those of other races and thus should dominate them. The belief favors the maintenance and defense of any power and privilege held by white people. White supremacy has roots in the now-discredited doctrine of scientific racism and was a key justification for European colonialism. It underlies a spectrum of contemporary movements including neo-Confederates, neo-Nazism and the so-called Christian Identity movement.
White supremacy (Wikipedia)


It is probably possible to find a very small number of people of other ethnic groups who are white supremacists much the same way that a very small number of Jews worked for the Nazis, but usually the racism of other ethnicities will believe in the supremacy of their own ethnic group. Racism in China (Wikipedia), Racism in Japan (Wikipedia).

It seems paradoxical, but an inferiority complex can cause white people to become white supremacists:
White supremacy’s inferiority complex - White supremacy has been a useful tool to control the anger of the poor and vulnerable. (AlJazeera, Nov 30, 2016).
They would like to feel superior and pretend that they do, but they fear that they aren't and act out.
 
White supremacy or white supremacism is the belief that white people are superior to those of other races and thus should dominate them.

It's pretty simple. White supremacists are white racists. Unlike racists of other ethnicities.


That's what you got out of that? Quite frankly, with so many people around here being unable to understand the difference between what is characterized as run-of-the-mill racism vs supremacy, few should be using the terms. And even fewer labeling people as such.
 
Last edited:
That's what you got out of that? Quite frankly, with so many people around here being unable to understand the difference between what is characterized as run-of-the-mill racism and supremacy, few should be using the terms. And even fewer labeling people as such.

Sure you would like that.
 
That's what you got out of that? Quite frankly, with so many people around here being unable to understand the difference between what is characterized as run-of-the-mill racism and supremacy, few should be using the terms. And even fewer labeling people as such.
This is all starting to remind me of the scene in, forum favourite, Woody Allen's Love and Death where somebody classifies all types of jew with the aid of some colourful illustrations.
 
You assume I didn't listen to enough of it to have formed a different opinion from yours.


I don't have to assume that you did not listen to enough of it to know what it was about since you wrote:
I got bored with her droning on and went to the end, still no point.


However, I doubt that it would have changed your mind to do so since you don't seem to be interested in the presentation of an argument. Instead you require that "a video like that" should start and end in a particular way, and since you think that this one didn't, it's reason enough for you to dismiss it. You "take it" that it is a certain way and "guess" that it's hard to summarize based on your ignorance of what it is.

And a cogent video like that one usually (should) starts and ends with a summary of the point.

I take it the point was droning on with no-brainer stuff about the alt-right we already know?

I guess it's hard to summarize that into 'a point'.


I have no idea who "we" are supposed to be and supposed to "already know".
 
That's what you got out of that? Quite frankly, with so many people around here being unable to understand the difference between what is characterized as run-of-the-mill racism vs supremacy, few should be using the terms. And even fewer labeling people as such.


I don't doubt that the subtle nuances of "run-of-the-mill racism", white supremacy and other versions of racism are extremely interesting to run-of-the-mill racists, white supremacists etc.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you'll disagree, but from the perspective of England, I would say that this concern about how things are said looks a lot like middle class morality and class prejudice.
Perhaps it is, but it makes a difference, I think, whose language one is speaking of, and what it is speaking about. But, as I said in the post you find fault with, I do not think that Warp12's statement makes him a racist. It just does nothing to negate the opinion of others, based on other statements.
 
That's what you got out of that? Quite frankly, with so many people around here being unable to understand the difference between what is characterized as run-of-the-mill racism vs supremacy, few should be using the terms. And even fewer labeling people as such.
It seems pretty obvious that if you believe in racial differences, and believe that your race is superior and should enjoy a power separate and above others (necessary components of white supremacy) you must be a racist, because the definition of a racist is included in the definition of a racial supremacist. The opposite may not be true, but the set of racists contains the subset of white racists, and that subset contains the subset of white supremacists.

Or do you believe a person can believe in racial supremacy without believing in a difference between races?
 
It seems pretty obvious that if you believe in racial differences, and believe that your race is superior and should enjoy a power separate and above others (necessary components of white supremacy) you must be a racist, because the definition of a racist is included in the definition of a racial supremacist. The opposite may not be true, but the set of racists contains the subset of white racists, and that subset contains the subset of white supremacists.

Or do you believe a person can believe in racial supremacy without believing in a difference between races?
What if you wanted your race to dominate because of personal advantage to yourself, but had no particular views about racial superiority?
 
I've read Burke.
Yes they do, Otto. They just don't understand it.​

Finding a passage that you like from him that isn't related to his central argument in his Reflections on the Revolution in France, and agrees with other comments I've made about him, is irrelevant. Do you think that because I cite one of his arguments, I agree with him on everything....
No. In one of my few previous posts that mentioned Burke, probably in some other thread, I noted the irony inherent in your use of "religion" as a pejorative while telling us to read Burke. I went on to note that Burke's writings include refutations of many of your ideas.

You told us the best way to understand your ideas was to read Burke. That would have been an effective way to communicate only if your ideas are substantially consonant with what Burke has written. But some of your ideas are obviously discordant with Burke's, and you now appear to acknowledge that you don't always agree with Burke. It seems your suggestion that we read Burke was just a dodge, a way to avoid having to explain your own ideas.

You disagree that America was made great by the invisible hand of the market?
It is abundantly clear that you and I disagree about what makes America great. Since we disagree so fundamentally about the nature of America's greatness, it is folly for you to ask whether we agree concerning the causes of that greatness.
 
It seems pretty obvious that if you believe in racial differences, and believe that your race is superior and should enjoy a power separate and above others (necessary components of white supremacy) you must be a racist, because the definition of a racist is included in the definition of a racial supremacist. The opposite may not be true, but the set of racists contains the subset of white racists, and that subset contains the subset of white supremacists.

Or do you believe a person can believe in racial supremacy without believing in a difference between races?


Bruto, all of this has been gone over already, in depth, yesterday. Yes, White Supremacists are racists. But there is more to being a supremacist than having some views that might be characterized as racist.

I'm not debating it any further. There is no stopping these folks from misusing and overusing the terms, anyway. What they really want to do is call people names, after all. I'll just continue to quietly laugh at them and shake my head.
 
Yes they do, Otto. They just don't understand it.​


No. In one of my few previous posts that mentioned Burke, probably in some other thread, I noted the irony inherent in your use of "religion" as a pejorative while telling us to read Burke. I went on to note that Burke's writings include refutations of many of your ideas.
I have a positive view of religion. Me pointing out the similarity between the universalist beliefs of this forum and Christian catechisms isn't coming from a place of contempt for Christianity, or indeed religion in general.

Regardless of that, what does Burke having arguments elsewhere that may or may not agree with me have to do with anything? I didn't say that Burke was an infallible prophet. I'm sure there are things he said that I would question... I don't share his Marie Antoinette fascination for example. Probably there are other things as well. All I did was point to his main argument in his Reflections on the Revolution in France and people have done everything but address that argument.

You told us the best way to understand your ideas was to read Burke. That would have been an effective way to communicate only if your ideas are substantially consonant with what Burke has written. But some of your ideas are obviously discordant with Burke's, and you now appear to acknowledge that you don't always agree with Burke. It seems your suggestion that we read Burke was just a dodge, a way to avoid having to explain your own ideas.
Only the most craven dogmatist would find themselves completely in agreement with the entire life's work of any figure of importance. The idea that me saying I agree with this argument of his requires me to support every argument the man ever made is ridiculous. People on this forum have historically made references to Dawkins books.... I doubt that means that they are committed to standing by the man's every utterance on Twitter. Was every person who thus quoted Dawkins actually doing so as a dodge?

In any case, you have misunderstood my views on religion, so this whole post seems moot.

It is abundantly clear that you and I disagree about what makes America great. Since we disagree so fundamentally about the nature of America's greatness, it is folly for you to ask whether we agree concerning the causes of that greatness.
Maybe so. As a particularist, that doesn't bother me very much. Different cultural traditions often have radically incompatible views of the world. That is why attempting to impose one set of morality over too broad a population requires tyranny. Universalists often struggle with this.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you'll disagree, but from the perspective of England, I would say that this concern about how things are said looks a lot like middle class morality and class prejudice.


In his Reflections on the Revolution in France, Edmund Burke spoke of prejudice as a source of legitimacy, as something worth preserving. That prejudice in favor of prejudice has become a pillar of conservative thought.

Burke said:
In this you think you are combating prejudice, but you are at war with Nature.

Burke said:
You see, Sir, that in this enlightened age I am bold enough to confess that we are generally men of untaught feelings: that, instead of casting away all our old prejudices, we cherish them to a very considerable degree; and, to take more shame to ourselves, we cherish them because they are prejudices; and the longer they have lasted, and the more generally they have prevailed, the more we cherish them. We are afraid to put men to live and trade each on his own private stock of reason; because we suspect that the stock in each man is small, and that the individuals would do better to avail themselves of the general bank and capital of nations and of ages. Many of our men of speculation, instead of exploding general prejudices, employ their sagacity to discover the latent wisdom which prevails in them. If they find what they seek, (and they seldom fail,) they think it more wise to continue the prejudice, with the reason involved, than to cast away the coat of prejudice, and to leave nothing but the naked reason; because prejudice, with its reason, has a motive to give action to that reason, and an affection which will give it permanence. Prejudice is of ready application in the emergency; it previously engages the mind in a steady course of wisdom and virtue, and does not leave the man hesitating in the moment of decision, skeptical, puzzled, and unresolved. Prejudice renders a man's virtue his habit, and not a series of unconnected acts. Through just prejudice, his duty becomes a part of his nature.

Burke said:
First I beg leave to speak of our Church Establishment, which is the first of our prejudices,—not a prejudice destitute of reason, but involving in it profound and extensive wisdom.

Burke said:
To avoid, therefore, the evils of inconstancy and versatility, ten thousand times worse than those of obstinacy and the blindest prejudice, we have consecrated the state, that no man should approach to look into its defects or corruptions but with due caution; that he should never dream of beginning its reformation by its subversion; that he should approach to the faults of the state as to the wounds of a father, with pious awe and trembling solicitude. By this wise prejudice we are taught to look with horror on those children of their country who are prompt rashly to hack that aged parent in pieces and put him into the kettle of magicians, in hopes that by their poisonous weeds and wild incantations they may regenerate the paternal constitution and renovate their father's life.

Burke said:
On what other principle than that which I have stated can we account for an appearance so extraordinary and unnatural as that of the ecclesiastical possessions, which had stood so many successions of ages and shocks of civil violences, and were guarded at once by justice and by prejudice, being applied to the payment of debts comparatively recent, invidious, and contracted by a decried and subverted government?

Burke said:
To be honored and even privileged by the laws, opinions, and inveterate usages of our country, growing out of the prejudice of ages, has nothing to provoke horror and indignation in any man.

Burke said:
...I am not sagacious enough to discover how this despotic sport made of the feelings, consciences, prejudices, and properties of men can be discriminated from the rankest tyranny.

Burke said:
Everything depends upon the army in such a government as yours; for you have industriously destroyed all the opinions and prejudices, and, as far as in you lay, all the instincts which support government.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom