Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

I disagree with you and think you are ignorant, or ideologically bound. Repeating the statements that make me think that reinforces my judgement.

Honestly, from a right wing perspective, people like you are terrific at sending the centre to the right... so keep on going.

Ok :thumbsup:

Ah, the gool ole "It's the libruls fault that people chose to become "conservatives"!!!!!!!!!" :D:D
 
Last edited:
Yes, the posts of your camp on the forum certainly helped me give more serious consideration to right wing thought. In a sense I'm grateful.

"IT'S ALL YOUR FAULT THAT I AM A RIGHT WINGER!!!YOU SHOULD HAVE BEEN NICER TO ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
 
I am getting a lot of amusement from this thread.

For example we are now getting quotes and references to Burke. A very interesting thinker and a rather ambigious one.

I have been amused for sometime by Burke's contradictions and omissions. He decried the French Revolution for it's violence and potential for tyranny yet had no problem asserting that the French Revolution and all it's effects / changes should be rooted out and utterly destroyed in what amounts to a holy war. For a man of "reason", his denouncations of the French Revolution bordered on and frequently passed into hysterical manicheanism. His talk of Marie Antoinette in his "Reflections" is actually very over the top.

And Burke's belief that the French Revolution was the result of a conspiracy of intellectuals part of whose design was to get sexual access to aristocratic females to corrupt them with their inferior ancestry is risible nonsense. Reading Burke's foaming at the mouth diatribes reminds me of some one obssessed with "precious bodily fluids" and "purity of essence".

This guy also supported the American Revolution.

Regarding slavery. The role of slavery in the development of the USA has traditionally be seriously underplayed. Afterall by the start of the Civil War and for quite sometime before cotton had been, by far, the principle American export. One can also talk about the value of other exports like rice and tabacco and surgar etc. Further slaves served an important source of portable wealth used has collateral for loans, speculative investment, mortgages etc. And further served has a basis for atracting foreign investment. In 1860 the value of slaves amounted to c. 16-18% of the total wealth of the USA. And of course a far higher percentage of the wealth of the slave owning South. In fact it appears that in 1860 c. 70% of the millionaries in the USA were slave owners.

Of course the idea that the USA was created by the "invisible hand" is hilarious. No doubt the "invisible hand" was responsible for the conquest of America from the Indigenous peoples. Of course it was actually epidemic disease and conquest. No doubt the "invisible hand" was responsible for the mass use, early on, of indentured servitude?

One could talk about the role of government policies regarding tariffs, internal improvements, corporations etc. all of which played a role in creating the USA. The "invisible hand" that created the USA is stuff and nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Has anybody ever microwaved curried fish near you?
Yes. I have eaten curried fish and liked it when it is not too spicy. I realize many do not. As noted, though, I would not consider it objectionable if someone simply said, "I don't like curried fish, please don't bring it to my barbecue." In the case of something like that, I think it would also be quite acceptable to say "I'm preparing and hosting a barbecue with a distinctive flavor and odor, and that of curried fish would conflict with it, so please don't bring any." I like the smell of burgers and hot dogs on a barbecue, and have no argument with those who want it unalloyed. That's not the same as calling all Indian food "stinky crap."

While I'm at it, to save some space, I might point out that although I think Eagle Puncher's assertion a bit extreme applied to an Englishman, and its implication of responsibility for one's ancestry dangerously wrong, it is no more absurd than your attacks on others for the imagined acceptance of unspecified sins of unspecified agency.
 
I like the smell of burgers and hot dogs on a barbecue, and have no argument with those who want it unalloyed. That's not the same as calling all Indian food "stinky crap."


So, are you saying that if I refer to Indian food as "stinky crap", that makes me a racist? This keeps getting better and better...presenting "racism in caricature".

My opinion is that these words are tossed around way too much. So much so to the point that they barely mean anything anymore.


If you aren't saying that, then maybe consider starting a thread on BBQ etiquette.
 
Last edited:
So, are you saying that if I refer to Indian food as "stinky crap", that makes me a racist? This keeps getting better and better...presenting "racism in caricature".




If you aren't saying that, then maybe consider starting a thread on BBQ etiquette.
I don't think, given a certain allowance for careless speech, such a statement alone makes you a racist, but in the context of a variety of other statements, it does no service to your assertion that you're not.
 
Last edited:
Yes, the posts of your camp on the forum certainly helped me give more serious consideration to right wing thought. In a sense I'm grateful.

And I moved from being concerned about white replacement to sympathizing with the social/political left because of the overwhelming number of fascists and OBAMA BORN IN KENYAA! deplorables I realized I shared spaces with.

I'm always suspicious of the "your intolerance is driving me to the right" line. There will people very passionate about being socially responsible when talking about race. To me that comes from a position of empathy. And I think that's more benign than the views of people at the other end of the spectrum.
 
I don't think, given a certain allowance for careless speech, such a statement alone makes you a racist, but in the context of a variety of other statements, it does no service to your assertion that you're not.
I'm sure you'll disagree, but from the perspective of England, I would say that this concern about how things are said looks a lot like middle class morality and class prejudice.
 
I'm sure you'll disagree, but from the perspective of England, I would say that this concern about how things are said looks a lot like middle class morality and class prejudice.

Dogwhistle for "I am working class, I am not happy about it and it's all entirely the fault of immigrants!!!"
 
I consider this argument to be garbage. You are really broadening the definition of a "White Supremacist". Almost comically so, as we all have preferences for different things, and may have disdain for certain things attached to a culture. It doesn't mean we are characterized as a "White Supremacist".

I don't like Indian food. I'll take pizza and burgers over it any day. And if someone is trying cook Indian food, get the hell out of the kitchen. And I don't want none of them Indians or their sympathizers bringing that stinky crap to my BBQ. Marvel at my "White Supremacy"...and pass me the ketchup.
I prefer Coke to Pepsi.... but that's not because I think it's intrinsically superior in any sense beyond my liking it more. I don't like Dr Pepper at all, but if you like it, I'm happy for you. I don't think you are wrong to prefer Dr Pepper. Different people like different things.

Do you mean "superior" in the sense of thinking one race is better than another in some absolute sense, or do you include if you have a personal preference but not a belief in your preferences superiority?


So you have a preference to only see white voters around you when you go to vote? You have a preference to only see white faces in your neighborhood, only see white faces at the grocery store?
 
Last edited:
The topic wasn't, "Reasons Jimbob regards Warp12 as a racist".

The topic was the difference between the terms "Racist" and "White Supremacist".

But thanks for your clarification. I hold your opinion on these matters in very high regard.
All you have to do is report his posts. One of the mods will take action against him if he is repeatedly derailing the thread.
 
Yes.

That's because you went to the end instead of listening to what she had to say. I am not going to give you a summary.
You assume I didn't listen to enough of it to have formed a different opinion from yours. And a cogent video like that one usually (should) starts and ends with a summary of the point.

I take it the point was droning on with no-brainer stuff about the alt-right we already know?

I guess it's hard to summarize that into 'a point'.
 
Last edited:
I don't know who that is but I see you dodged the questions I asked.
It's effectively "rule of so". You summed up what I said to be something completely different to what I said. Now you are reading you failure to understand the reference in my answer to be confirmation that you were correct in your initial mischaracterisation.

Honestly, for a skeptics forum, this place has a remarkable number of psychics who can read people's true motives hidden behind their posts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom