Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

If races really existed, that is, if they actually were different one from another, then they would unavoidably have a hierarchy. There would be one superior race, no matter what, and one inferior to all the others.

Seems to me, a racist is simply somebody who believes that races really exist. (Pace shuttit, the word "racist" still has the same venomous meaning it always had, and its acceptation has not widened.) Since racism lies in the land of belief, where anything can be accepted as true in the absence of evidence, the door of ignorance is wide open to madness.

As we see.

I think races might exist, but they aren't divided by color. But this often gets conflated with culture at the end of the day, plus variations within the racial groups, so any actual distinguishable races don't seem greatly relevant to all this noise about demographic changes and stuff. And people are much more alike than different anyway.

I don't agree at all with your first paragraph, depending on what you mean by superior. Technologically advanced? Human populations simply didn't have access to the same resources.
 
I'd love to "replace" a lot of Republicans. I'm all for it!

When I was a liberal hater I thought ya maybe the Dems are bringin' in the Mexicans yada yada. Now I see it is all ********. Now I see who the racists really are.
 
Because it is my BBQ and I set the rules. And even the smell of that food will put me off my meal. But, really, I am just kind of making a point that having a disdain for some aspects of a culture is not necessarily the same as being a racist, or especially a white supremacist.

My opinion is that these words are tossed around way too much. So much so to the point that they barely mean anything anymore.

Okay, distain for the culture of others isn't necessarily racist.

But one of the propaganda tricks of the haters is to belittle of culture of others as a sort of prelude to eventually dismissing the humanity of the people in that culture.

It's considered polite to simple say you don't like this or that about a non-white culture. But telling Indians that they can't bring food to your home is just plain rude.

I can't help but think you have a hissy fit if you were treated that way.

Do Indians not deserve your respect? The same respect you expect be given you. Are Indians not human?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
I realize that we must make some allowances for style and manner of expression, but it is hard sometimes to separate preference from racism from supremacy when language is not carefully used.

If I were, for example, not fond of Indian food (I love it but that's a different matter) and wanted nothing but good old American barbecue at my barbecue (I like that too), I'd be safely immune to an accusation of racism if I said "I prefer hamburgers and it's my barbecue this is what I do." I'd be safely immune to an accusation of supremacy if I added that I hate Indian food and won't allow it in the vicinity, though in the racism department it's getting a little whiffy. But if I have to add that it's "stinky crap?" Pushing it.
 
I realize that we must make some allowances for style and manner of expression, but it is hard sometimes to separate preference from racism from supremacy when language is not carefully used.

If I were, for example, not fond of Indian food (I love it but that's a different matter) and wanted nothing but good old American barbecue at my barbecue (I like that too), I'd be safely immune to an accusation of racism if I said "I prefer hamburgers and it's my barbecue this is what I do." I'd be safely immune to an accusation of supremacy if I added that I hate Indian food and won't allow it in the vicinity, though in the racism department it's getting a little whiffy. But if I have to add that it's "stinky crap?" Pushing it.

Exactly! Let me give an example by saying a bunch of stuff I don't really mean. . .

------------------

You damn Americans and your damn BBQs were you eat dead animal flesh and drink beer and talk your talk and after you get drunk you pull your guns out and your damn dull-witting offspring get their gabby little dirty mitts on the guns after you pass out and following your damn drunken examples end up shooting their siblings who probably aren't their siblings anyway because you Godless boy-men can't keep your flys zipped!

Stay out of my country!


-----------------

See how easy that was.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
I realize that we must make some allowances for style and manner of expression, but it is hard sometimes to separate preference from racism from supremacy when language is not carefully used.

If I were, for example, not fond of Indian food (I love it but that's a different matter) and wanted nothing but good old American barbecue at my barbecue (I like that too), I'd be safely immune to an accusation of racism if I said "I prefer hamburgers and it's my barbecue this is what I do." I'd be safely immune to an accusation of supremacy if I added that I hate Indian food and won't allow it in the vicinity, though in the racism department it's getting a little whiffy. But if I have to add that it's "stinky crap?" Pushing it.
Has anybody ever microwaved curried fish near you?
 
Bikers. Sure, I recall them (I'm from 1948). They hardly represent the Danish population or culture. Don't even think they merit the label 'subculture'.


It is so long ago that Danes had never heard the word bikers (or subculture) and a long time before the internet. I just happened to remember that it was mentioned in that book. You will also have a hard time finding Per Madsen's racist ramblings against Turkish immigrants in Ishøj a decade later because the internet hadn't been invented yet.


ETA: i was surprised to see that Wikipedia has short article about the racist grønjakkerne in the 1980s.
 
Last edited:
I consider this argument to be garbage. You are really broadening the definition of a "White Supremacist". Almost comically so, as we all have preferences for different things, and may have disdain for certain things attached to a culture. It doesn't mean we are characterized as a "White Supremacist".

I don't like Indian food. I'll take pizza and burgers over it any day. And if someone is trying cook Indian food, get the hell out of the kitchen. And I don't want none of them Indians or their sympathizers bringing that stinky crap to my BBQ. Marvel at my "White Supremacy"...and pass me the ketchup.

That's not why I regard you as a racist.

It's because you assert that specific racist arguments are not racist
 
That's not why I regard you as a racist.

It's because you assert that specific racist arguments are not racist


The topic wasn't, "Reasons Jimbob regards Warp12 as a racist".

The topic was the difference between the terms "Racist" and "White Supremacist".

But thanks for your clarification. I hold your opinion on these matters in very high regard.
 
No, we are discussing whether there is any reason to suppose having a system that operates on the basis of letting innumerable free agents pursue their own interests with minimal constraint (in this case immigration) should be expected to produce a good result.

Sounds like the United States of America to me.

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.​
Edmund Burke, a year before that Declaration of Independence, wrote:
Burke said:
In this character of the Americans, a love of freedom is the predominating feature which marks and distinguishes the whole: and as an ardent is always a jealous affection, your colonies become suspicious, restive, and untractable, whenever they see the least attempt to wrest from them by force, or shuffle from them by chicane, what they think the only advantage worth living for. This fierce spirit of liberty is stronger in the English colonies probably than in any other people of the earth; and this from a great variety of powerful causes; which, to understand the true temper of their minds, and the direction which this spirit takes, it will not be amiss to lay open somewhat more largely.

First, the people of the colonies are descendants of Englishmen. England, Sir, is a nation, which still I hope respects, and formerly adored, her freedom....


Skipping down to Burke's final sentences:
Burke said:
For, in order to prove that the Americans have no right to their liberties, we are every day endeavouring to subvert the maxims which preserve the whole spirit of our own. To prove that the Americans ought not to be free, we are obliged to depreciate the value of freedom itself; and we never seem to gain a paltry advantage over them in debate, without attacking some of those principles, or deriding some of those feelings, for which our ancestors have shed their blood.


Would shuttit benefit from reading Burke? Probably not, but others might benefit from reading Burke's various refutations of shuttit's ideas.

Yes. The country the invisible hand built.

you're kidding, right?
No matter how silly or outrageous shuttit might sound, we should not assume shuttit is kidding.
 
No, we are discussing whether there is any reason to suppose having a system that operates on the basis of letting innumerable free agents pursue their own interests with minimal constraint (in this case immigration) should be expected to produce a good result. That looked a lot like a market to me, so I wondered about a parallel. Are we assuming an invisible hand idea, or could there be a tragedy of the commons where free immigration leads to a problem?

Dogwhistle for "Do we really want these pesky non whites to destroy our precious country!?"
 
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.​
Yes, I assumed it was obvious that I had America, at least partly, in mind when I wrote that, and subsequently confirmed that it applied to the US.

Edmund Burke, a year before that Declaration of Independence, wrote:



Skipping down to Burke's final sentences:



Would shuttit benefit from reading Burke? Probably not, but others might benefit from reading Burke's various refutations of shuttit's ideas
I've read Burke. If you look back, you'll find me saying that he supported the revolution in America and was opposed to the one in France for the reasons he explains. Finding a passage that you like from him that isn't related to his central argument in his Reflections on the Revolution in France, and agrees with other comments I've made about him, is irrelevant. Do you think that because I cite one of his arguments, I agree with him on everything.... or that if I ask a question about the founding assumptions of America, and whether they might not have failure cases, then I commit myself to disagreeing with all arguments in support of America? This is a very tribal way of looking at things.

No matter how silly or outrageous shuttit might sound, we should not assume shuttit is kidding.
You disagree that America was made great by the invisible hand of the market? Are you claiming 18th and 19th Century America was a centrally planned command economy?
 
Last edited:
Yes, I assumed it was obvious that I had America, at least partly, in mind when I wrote that, and subsequently confirmed that it applied to the US.


I've read Burke. If you look back, you'll find me saying that he supported the revolution in America and was opposed to the one in France for the reasons he explains. Finding a passage that you like from him that isn't related to his central argument in his Reflections on the Revolution in France, and agrees with other comments I've made about him, is irrelevant. Do you think that because I cite one of his arguments, I agree with him on everything.... or that if I ask a question about the founding assumptions of America, and whether they might not have failure cases, then I commit myself to disagreeing with all arguments in support of America? This is a very tribal way of looking at things.


You disagree that America was made great by the invisible hand of the market? Are you claiming 18th and 19th Century America was a centrally planned command economy?

America was made "great" by one of your ancestors who owned black people and forced them to pick cotton.
 
America was made "great" by one of your ancestors who owned black people and forced them to pick cotton.
In common with most people, to the best of my knowledge, my ancestors never owned slaves and the idea that the would have done seems kind of unlikely. Maybe if you go back 2000 years there is some aristocratic Roman blood in me, and she owned slaves... but really, if you want to be like that, everybody's ancestors owned slaves. I'm pretty confident that many of my ancestors were serfs, does that count? Anyway, that slavery is what made America great is a ridiculously uninformed moral catechism.
 
In common with most people, to the best of my knowledge, my ancestors never owned slaves and the idea that the would have done seems kind of unlikely. Maybe if you go back 2000 years there is some aristocratic Roman blood in me, and she owned slaves... but really, if you want to be like that, everybody's ancestors owned slaves. I'm pretty confident that many of my ancestors were serfs, does that count? Anyway, that slavery is what made America great is a ridiculously uninformed moral catechism.

Yeah, I get it, the truth hurts. Here you are, rambling about the bad influence of non whites but ignoring the fact that non whites made the country you are so viciously defending. :)
 
Yeah, I get it, the truth hurts. Here you are, rambling about the bad influence of non whites but ignoring the fact that non whites made the country you are so viciously defending. :)
I disagree with you and think you are ignorant, or ideologically bound. Repeating the statements that make me think that reinforces my judgement.

Honestly, from a right wing perspective, people like you are terrific at sending the centre to the right... so keep on going.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom