Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

The issue with the somewhere people is that they are dumb. Their position is fake and they are not actually connected to something.

Soccer fans are not a "we" with the team
https://youtu.be/xN1WN0YMWZU

You did not actually save the French in WW2
https://youtu.be/gy19YmQHHJU

You are not actually part of something you haven't contributed to
And after all, the presumed "nowhere people" who are immigrating are not going nowhere. They're coming somewhere. If they really didn't care where they were, why did they leave? The somewhere/nowhere issue is more about being in the wrong where.
 
Dunno about those other novels, but The Turnip Diary is revered and much read among the Whiter Than the Whitewash set.

And believed. Yes, in some foggy way they regard it as really happening. Or just about to happen. Or bound to happen someday, and until then they keep their guns oily.
 
Nah. If you really consider the "western" culture to be unsuccessful, there's nothing I can do that will convince you.

You could start by being specific. But we both know you won't go beyond "Hurr durr, Culture".

I could spend hours getting information measuring the success of the "western" culture against others, gdp, living standards, education etc etc etc with the expectation of nothing more than yet another of your dismissive sardonic one liners.

Here's another one: You did not provide any evidence of a specific, testable connection from "Western culture" to "gdb, living standards etc. :rolleyes:
You have a nice track record of making big assumptions, claiming to have all this "information" but you won't show it, because I am a big meany.

Not worth the effort.

You never brought anything to the table, so you owe me a "Thanks for spending time with my never ending stream of baseless anecdotes"

But in general, you're right, now worth the effort.
 
Last edited:
Seriously Darat? You really don't feel you live in a country with a culture? No legal framework within which you consider your actions? No moral framework within which you behave? No shared expectations of interaction between individuals that dictates your behaviour to others? No political framework within which you consider your government? Oh well.

Please tell me the differences about the "moral framework of 'the European' Culture" and the "moral framework of the 'African Culture'".
 
Last edited:
If white people want to have fewer children or no children, or only marry people of different races that is their choice.

People should have the choice to do whatever they want to do and not be condemned for it. I think once you're a citizen of a country you should be free to live your life however you see fit.

Yeah, sorry bud, but over here in reality, people have realized long ago that this is going to be problematic and invented a thing called Democracy. You will hate Democracy but one of the core values is: The choice of the majority. Unlucky for you the amount of people who want their "race" white and pure is very small, so we tend to ignore them and do what the majority wants. You're welcome.

ETA: If you don't like democracy, why not move out into the woods, where no human being will tell you what to do?
 
Last edited:
If white people want to have fewer children or no children, or only marry people of different races that is their choice.

People should have the choice to do whatever they want to do and not be condemned for it.

I think once you're a citizen of a country you should be free to live your life however you see fit.
Do you think there could be any tragedy of the commons situation where this approach might fail? It seems like there is some kind of invisible hand of the market idea in there that everybody doing their own thing is going create a working, sustainable society. If it turned out that the invisible hand functioned in a dystopian way, what then?
 
I’m an immigrant to the US. Who or what have I replaced?

presumably the replacement would come when you mate with one of their women and have only part-white offspring. Depending on what kind of immigrant you are, the changes from parent to offspring may be unnoticeable to noticeable enough to overwhelm the white.
 
I'm stunned, stunned I tell you that proponents of 'White Replacement Theory' can't or won't answer my question.


Well, I guess the idea might be that if you bred with a "native" white person you would dilute/degrade the bloodline? Or maybe that you would also be utilizing resources that should be allocated first and foremost to "native" whites? I don't know how deep the ideology goes.
 
Last edited:
"I can't define the 'culture' that I am so afraid to lose to immigrants but it's your fault for not understanding the 'culture' I can't define!"

But it doesn't really matter does it. We all know what the culture is that he doesn't want to admit holding dear to... white skinned, privileged, conservative, gun-toting and imagined supremacy over mud people.

"White Culture" means never letting a darkie get into in a position of authority over you
 
Last edited:
But it doesn't really matter does it. We all know what the culture is that he doesn't want to admit holding dear to... white skinned, privileged, conservative, gun-toting and imagined supremacy over mud people.

"White Culture" means never letting a darkie get into in a position of authority over you


:rolleyes:
 
Do you think there could be any tragedy of the commons situation where this approach might fail? It seems like there is some kind of invisible hand of the market idea in there that everybody doing their own thing is going create a working, sustainable society. If it turned out that the invisible hand functioned in a dystopian way, what then?
I suppose it depends on how closely bound the second paragraph of that post is to the first. It would appear that the post begins with the question of relative birth rates and interracial relations. If you want to predict a dystopian result from that you might do well to specify what that result might be, and what is dystopian about it. And then, of course, you might have to think at least a little critically on whether the argument of the "tragedy of the commons" is actually true and applicable in this situation, or is (as some might point out) the fear-mongering rant of a white supremacist, a xenophobic eugenicist, who opposed federal aid to poor countries, and advocated the starvation of the poor as a better solution to the world's problems...and probably also a poor historian when it comes to the commons of which he speaks. Of course that doesn't mean he was wrong all the time, but it does seem worth asking - sorry to have to bring it up again - whether everything you want is always worth the price.

The third paragraph is a bit ambiguous, but "live your live the way you see fit" does not necessarily mean "do whatever you want." Since it could be anything between a libertarian free for all and a suggestion that we shouldn't have telescreens in the bedroom, I think it's best left unargued.
 
Last edited:
USA is has been committed to supporting the Cuban people for decades, as a place of refuge for ANY Cuban who makes it to the USA.
I dont see why we would suddenly end that policy. Was Communism suddenly no longer an evil system?
I believe we should also offer asylum to anyone who makes it here from North Korea, Iran, Saudi Arabia.
I think if most Cubans were voting Blue, we would have kept our Dry Foot policy.


The USA has never been committed to supporting the Cuban people. The USA has been committed to making conditions for Cuban people so insufferable that it would make them overthrow their government.

You have heard about the wet feet, dry feet policy (Wikipedia), but you don't seem to have understood what it was about. Apparently, you haven't heard about the current negotiations with Cuba where the USA is trying to persuade Cuba to let the USA ship Cuban immigrants back to Cuba. The USA as "a place of refuge for ANY Cuban who makes it to the USA" is as big a lie as the one about supporting the Cuban people.

During the pandemic, the alleged U.S. commitment to supporting the Cuban people consisted in aggravating the blockade, making it even more difficult and expensive for Cuba to get hold of medicine and syringes, in the hope that enough Cubans would die from the virus to make them blame their own government instead of the U.S. administration, which many of them did, at first: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13811640#post13811640
But instead, the pandemic and new restrictions introduced by two (!) administrations made it obvious to the Cuban people, which government cares about its people's lives and health, and which one doesn't. USA 3,008; Cuba 754.
 
It's a feature of human vision that we notice something light getting darker quicker, than something dark getting lighter - it has probably something to do about spotting shadows.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom