Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.

Rest assured that anybody who claims that "there are [just] two kinds of people" is mistaken.

The reason that some people ask "what is culture" is that the term can mean many different things, so when in a discussion about culture, it is necessary to establish a working definition.

Hans
 
I am old enough to remember when the first foreigners came to Denmark to find work in the 1960s. Nowadays, Danish culture is defined by nationalists as the difference between Christianity (even though Danes hardly ever go to church) and Islam. In the 1960s, the bad foreigners who couldn't and shouldn't be integrated into Danish culture were Italians, Greeks and even Austrians! The Germans were only seen as a problem when they "invaded" Danish beaches in the summer, and then they were missed when they could afford to go to Mallorca or the Canaries instead.


ETA: It just occurred to be that nobody back then came up with, 'The Austrians shall not replace us!'

Actually, I don't remember those groups being viewed that way. We were annoyed at some of the tourists, but I think the immigration from those countries was (and is) minimal. Note: The Germans were a special case, for obvious reasons.

The first sign I saw of replacement theory in Denmark was in the 70ties when somebody noticed the number of children an average Turkish family had (in Turkey) and then extrapolated the number of years it would take till the Turks were a majority in the country.

Needless to say, an average Turkish immigrant family in Denmark turned out to not have significantly more children than Danish families.

Hans
 
Needless to say, an average Turkish immigrant family in Denmark turned out to not have significantly more children than Danish families.

Hans
If that hadn't been the case, would their concern have been valid?
 
Actually, I don't remember those groups being viewed that way.


Most people don't - and not just because most people hadn't been born. :)
The book about Danish bikers, Action, mand!, describes how Bjørn Andersen and his friends were fighting with people of the mentioned nationalities at the Saga cafeteria in Vesterbrogade, if I remember correctly. You know, 'They steal our girls!', the replacement theory of the 1960s.

We were annoyed at some of the tourists, but I think the immigration from those countries was (and is) minimal. Note: The Germans were a special case, for obvious reasons.

The first sign I saw of replacement theory in Denmark was in the 70ties when somebody noticed the number of children an average Turkish family had (in Turkey) and then extrapolated the number of years it would take till the Turks were a majority in the country.

Needless to say, an average Turkish immigrant family in Denmark turned out to not have significantly more children than Danish families.


At this day and age, Turkish immigrants and their descendants even have divorce rates very similar to those of the descendants of vikings! :)
 
I see we're getting more and more into "Okay but would I be right if I wasn't intentionally and hilariously over the top completely wrong about the entire core base facts of what I am arguing?" territory.
 
I’m an immigrant to the US. Who or what have I replaced?

Well, obviously a child that would have been born if you hadn't come here, duh.

A bit of an over simplification but its a valid question. Ok, I suppose it possible that the secret cabal of elites(The Jews!) is conspiring to bring vast numbers of others(the swarthy people), but how exactly are they getting rid of the white people? Subliminal messages on Fox news telling them to not have sex?
 
Last edited:
Yeah not only does God allocate a limited number of souls, he divides them by country.
 
Well, obviously a child that would have been born if you hadn't come here, duh.

A bit of an over simplification but its a valid question. Ok, I suppose it possible that the secret cabal of elites(The Jews!) is conspiring to bring vast numbers of others(the swarthy people), but how exactly are they getting rid of the white people? Subliminal messages on Fox news telling them to not have sex?

I've seen the likes of Tucker Carlson - there aint anything subliminal about the message!
 
And to think we would be denied such amazing discourse from the racists if not for this board's steadfast devotion to free speech.

(Oh come on give me that one...)
 
My request is a little older. So will you or nah?

Nah. If you really consider the "western" culture to be unsuccessful, there's nothing I can do that will convince you.

I could spend hours getting information measuring the success of the "western" culture against others, gdp, living standards, education etc etc etc with the expectation of nothing more than yet another of your dismissive sardonic one liners.

Not worth the effort.
 
I think we got to the point about 10 pages ago that it's clear the people can just pick and chose from a grab-bag of vaguely shared ideas, declare it a "culture" and expect us to act like it's some sacred concept we have to protect.
 
I 100% sincerely don't.

This is so frustrating as folk keep talking about a culture or the culture or other cultures and never, ever define the culture they are talking about.

If a culture is so clear and so apparent, why is it so difficult for folk to define it or them?

It makes no sense at all.

Someone not sure who mentioned a shared language as part of a culture, but that can't be the case for a "European culture", our different languages don't even all share the same roots, someone has mentioned shared legal traditions, again that can't be the case for a "European culture", it can't be a shared religion and so on.

(Lplus - next part is not directed at you personally - your post just triggered this thought in me.)

I do wonder if we are seeing an "unconscious" assumption that because Germans look like the Danes, who look like Italians, who look like Irish, who look like French folk and so on folk are making an unchallenged assumption that because they look like "us" we have a shared culture? Not realising the huge differences in the myriad of cultures in these European countries?

Seriously Darat? You really don't feel you live in a country with a culture? No legal framework within which you consider your actions? No moral framework within which you behave? No shared expectations of interaction between individuals that dictates your behaviour to others? No political framework within which you consider your government? Oh well.
 
I don't think my Culture has to racially pure, which is the topic. Some vague little semantic argument nested 3 deep means less than nothing to me and it shouldn't mean anything to you.
 
Nothing to do with current relevance? :rolleyes:

DACA recipients have been here for years, they came as children but weren't born here. As for anti-communist Cubans, any reason they can't apply for asylum like other immigrants fleeing persecution?

ETA: I'm not familiar with Obama's change in Cuban immigration. I am familiar with him trying to normalize relations with Cuba, something that is long overdue.

USA is has been committed to supporting the Cuban people for decades, as a place of refuge for ANY Cuban who makes it to the USA.

I dont see why we would suddenly end that policy. Was Communism suddenly no longer an evil system?

I believe we should also offer asylum to anyone who makes it here from North Korea, Iran, Saudi Arabia.

I think if most Cubans were voting Blue, we would have kept our Dry Foot policy.
 
Second generation immigrants and later (or first gen who arrived very young) almost always stray from their culture/religion and adopt their host nation's culture to a larger extent than their predecessors. Are we really worrying about culture here or is it about some adaptive traits and mutations among some human groups that we find physically appealing and want to retain?
 
One of the plot lines in dystopian great replacement novels like The Camp of the Saints, Submission and their cousin, The Turner Diaries has Muslims, third world people and the like pulling off improbable invasions and "replacements" of places like France, England and the U.S. while the populations of the invaded countries sit on their hands (in the case of the U.S. keep their gun safes locked).

In these novels one of the favorite plot lines is that the elitist, socialist, internationalist leaders of the invaded nations roll over and play dead while hordes of invaders roam the country side. In some plot lines the presidents and prime ministers openly welcome the invaders and somehow convince the rest of their governments and its citizens to sit by while the invaders take over.

Yeah, right. . .

I can't help but suspect this his sort of stupid fiction fuels the paranoia of some gullibles.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 340 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom