Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

The USA has never been committed to supporting the Cuban people. The USA has been committed to making conditions for Cuban people so insufferable that it would make them overthrow their government.


Documentation:
the "only foreseeable means of alienating internal support is through disenchantment and disaffection based on economic dissatisfaction and hardship." It recommended a policy that would be "adroit and inconspicuous as possible" while aiming to deny "money and supplies to Cuba, to decrease monetary and real wages, to bring about hunger, desperation and overthrow of government.
United States embargo against Cuba: History (Wikipedia)


The actual document:
The Decline and Fall of Castro
Salient considerations respecting the life of the present Government of Cuba are:

1. The majority of Cubans support Castro (the lowest estimate I have seen is 50 percent).
2. There is no effective political opposition.
3. Fidel Castro and other members of the Cuban Government espouse or condone communist influence.
4. Communist influence is pervading the Government and the body politic at an amazingly fast rate.
5. Militant opposition to Castro from without Cuba would only serve his and the communist cause.
6. The only foreseeable means of alienating internal support is through disenchantment and disaffection based on economic dissatisfaction and hardship.

If the above are accepted or cannot be successfully countered, it follows that every possible means should be undertaken promptly to weaken the economic life of Cuba. If such a policy is adopted, it should be the result of a positive decision which would call forth a line of action which, while as adroit and inconspicuous as possible, makes the greatest inroads in denying money and supplies to Cuba, to decrease monetary and real wages, to bring about hunger, desperation and overthrow of government.
Memorandum From the Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Inter-American Affairs (Mallory) to the Assistant Secretary of State for Inter-American Affairs (Rubottom), April 6, 1960 (Office of the Historian, U.S. Gov)


Hercules56: "The USA is has been committed to supporting the Cuban people for decades." Yeah, right! And replacement theory and Dry Foot policy and democracy and human rights. It's what the USA has been all about for decades, isn't it?! People die because of that alleged support! :mad:
 
Seriously Darat? You really don't feel you live in a country with a culture? No legal framework within which you consider your actions? No moral framework within which you behave? No shared expectations of interaction between individuals that dictates your behaviour to others? No political framework within which you consider your government? Oh well.

You’ve got the wrong end of the stick. I’m asking for a description of what folk mean when they identify a certain culture. So if someone says “European culture” they say what that culture is, the values of that culture, what that culture entails and so on.
 
When the Vampires started immigrating to Transylvania, there was a lot of debate about culture and what it meant. Some folks claimed that Transylvanians didn't really have any culture of their own. The most vocal of Transylvanian liberals scoffed at the notion that changes in culture were a threat to the happiness and prosperity of their community.

Well, it turns out they were right. A year later, all of Transylvania was living in happy, peaceful unison...sleeping in caskets and drinking blood.
 
Last edited:
When the white supremacists had to resort to fairy tales to justify their replacement theory ...
 
When the Vampires started immigrating to Transylvania, there was a lot of debate about culture and what it meant. Some folks claimed that Transylvanians didn't really have any culture of their own. The most vocal of Transylvanian liberals scoffed at the notion that changes in culture were a threat to the happiness and prosperity of their community.

Well, it turns out they were right. A year later, all of Transylvania was living in happy, peaceful unison...sleeping in caskets and drinking blood.

There is no debate about what culture means. What is missing is a description of the particular culture people are talking about.

Do you have a description of “white culture” or “British culture” or “European culture” or “western culture”?
 
There is no debate about what culture means. What is missing is a description of the particular culture people are talking about.

Do you have a description of “white culture” or “British culture” or “European culture” or “western culture”?

...and how it is being threatened by immigrants?
 
...and how it is being threatened by immigrants?

The theory is that when migrants get to a new place and become a dominate power, they will kill all the natives with guns and disease, steal all their stuff and force the survivers to live on reservations.
Because that's the only way Supremacists can deal with multiculturalism.
 
...and how it is being threatened by immigrants?

Oh that’s of course the other big ..er… problem - they won’t say what the “problem” or “problems” are.

Seeing the above might give them a hint - I’ll spell it out - see I say there is a problem and then I tell you what the problem is, I don’t say there is a problem and then leave everyone hanging as to what the problem is I am referring to. It’s very easy if you want a discussion and a debate.
 
You’ve got the wrong end of the stick. I’m asking for a description of what folk mean when they identify a certain culture. So if someone says “European culture” they say what that culture is, the values of that culture, what that culture entails and so on.

Sorry Darat, no deal. All that leads to is requests for "further and better details" and nitpicking the individual ideas until the whole thing disappears down the rabbit hole, at which point the questioner declares there is no such thing as a specific culture - which is what they always wanted to state in the first place.

Well done, you won - have an internet point.:thumbsup:
 
Sorry Darat, no deal. All that leads to is requests for "further and better details" and nitpicking the individual ideas until the whole thing disappears down the rabbit hole, at which point the questioner declares there is no such thing as a specific culture - which is what they always wanted to state in the first place.

Well done, you won - have an internet point.:thumbsup:

Translation: "I can't define culture. Now I am angry at someone else!!!"
 
All that leads to is requests for "further and better details" and nitpicking the individual ideas until the whole thing disappears down the rabbit hole, at which point the questioner declares there is no such thing as a specific culture - which is what they always wanted to state in the first place.


Exactly, 110% correct. Basically it turns into one gigantic circle jerk.
 
Sorry Darat, no deal. All that leads to is requests for "further and better details" and nitpicking the individual ideas until the whole thing disappears down the rabbit hole, at which point the questioner declares there is no such thing as a specific culture - which is what they always wanted to state in the first place.

Well done, you won - have an internet point.:thumbsup:

All you are saying is that you won't support your claims about a culture, no different to any other claim whether the claim is the earth is flat or it rains a lot in Wales, it's up to you to support your claim.
 
I can understand their reluctance to more specifically articulate what it is they fear and why.
When talking to the Hindu fundamentalists in India, I ask them what aspect of their religious culture or tradition is threatened by the notion of a secular state? I point out that no Hindu is prevented from going to temples and practicing their faith even in public spheres...in fact they themselves seem pretty keen on excluding certain types of "Hindus" from such observances. There are no strictures on the clothes they wear, the food they eat or the markers of identity that they proudly wear---the sandal wood mark on the forehead, the sacred thread, the Brahmin top knot...schools and institutions ensure that their right to wear these with pride are protected.
Letting them talk for a bit ultimately results in their lament that their traditional casteist birth-right privileges are being violated. Essentially that they are no longer allowed to practice untouchability and/or oppress others based on caste.
 
The Great Replacement: The Past & Disturbing Present of American Nazis (Rebecca Watson on YouTube, May 18, 2022 - 17:22 min.)

 
Sorry Darat, no deal. All that leads to is requests for "further and better details" and nitpicking the individual ideas until the whole thing disappears down the rabbit hole, at which point the questioner declares there is no such thing as a specific culture - which is what they always wanted to state in the first place.

Well done, you won - have an internet point.:thumbsup:

This is exactly what the "its never racism unless you can absolutely prove it 100% beyond any possible doubt racism apologists" do in "....white black" threads.

In this case though, if you are going to claim that "your culture" is being replaced by "the other culture" you damned well better be able to define what is being replaced, and what you claim it is being replaced with. I know you probably don't what to have to say the quiet bits out load, but the claim fails if you don't!
 
Last edited:
When the Vampires started immigrating to Transylvania, there was a lot of debate about culture and what it meant. Some folks claimed that Transylvanians didn't really have any culture of their own. The most vocal of Transylvanian liberals scoffed at the notion that changes in culture were a threat to the happiness and prosperity of their community.

Well, it turns out they were right. A year later, all of Transylvania was living in happy, peaceful unison...sleeping in caskets and drinking blood.

When the white supremacists had to resort to fairy tales to justify their replacement theory ...


Does this mean that I have been promoted from "Racist" to "White Supremacist"? I'm not certain that these labels are being consistently or properly applied.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom