Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

And obviously they do share cultural elements.

For example there are many very keen football fans in Denmark and Germany... oh.
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.
 
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people?

No one is asking that, what is being asked is for you to define the specific culture you are talking about.

If, for example, you say there is a common european culture then you must be able to say what that culture is. Otherwise how could you have concluded there is a shared culture?
 
... Germans look like the Danes, who look like Italians, ...


Brits seem to think so. We certainly don't! Some Danes think I look like an Italian, but I have brown eyes and am slightly darker than most Danes.

I do wonder if we are seeing an "unconscious" assumption that because Germans look like the Danes, who look like Italians, who look like Irish, who look like French folk and so on folk are making an unchallenged assumption that because they look like "us" we have a shared culture? Not realising the huge differences in the myriad of cultures in these European countries?


The difference you are pointing out becomes obvious as soon as you compare two European countries. Denmark and Germany, for instance. Or Denmark and the UK. One British author, Helen Russell, wrote a whole book about the many differences between English and Danish culture: The Year of Living Danishly: Uncovering the Secrets of the World's Happiest Country
 
Last edited:
Danes are Germans with a sense of humour.


I am old enough to remember when the first foreigners came to Denmark to find work in the 1960s. Nowadays, Danish culture is defined by nationalists as the difference between Christianity (even though Danes hardly ever go to church) and Islam. In the 1960s, the bad foreigners who couldn't and shouldn't be integrated into Danish culture were Italians, Greeks and even Austrians! The Germans were only seen as a problem when they "invaded" Danish beaches in the summer, and then they were missed when they could afford to go to Mallorca or the Canaries instead.


ETA: It just occurred to be that nobody back then came up with, 'The Austrians shall not replace us!'
 
Last edited:
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.

"I can't define the 'culture' that I am so afraid to lose to immigrants but it's your fault for not understanding the 'culture' I can't define!"
 
"I can't define the 'culture' that I am so afraid to lose to immigrants but it's your fault for not understanding the 'culture' I can't define!"

Well, to be fair, it's got to be pretty uncomfortable being backed into an increasingly tiny corner, resisting the urge to just blurt out "C'mon, you know what I mean, culture! Culture!!! It's as obvious as black and white!!"
 
Last edited:
For example, many Texans are against people from California coming here: “Keep your California culture in California!“ By your definition, Texas and California share the same “culture.” But it should be obvious that, in many ways, they are worlds apart.
The late Molly Ivins was a keen observer of the various cultures whose juxtaposition/contrasts/competition set Texas apart from all other states of the US. In one of her essays, she listed about a dozen of those cultures, concluding with the one thing they have in common: they're all rotten for women.

That's overly reductive, cultures are a continuum made up of subcultures done to even family level cultures.
Here is an example of subcultures combining within an unusual family to shape the character of a man who (at some time after Molly Ivins wrote this) went on to become President of the United States:
Molly Ivins said:
I have known George W. Bush slightly since we were both in high school, and I studied him closely as governor. He is neither mean nor stupid. What we have here is a man shaped by three intertwining strands of Texas culture, combined with huge blinkers of class. The three Texas themes are religiosity, anti-intellectualism, and machismo.

It's the culture of the USA among other countries. I'm assuming you live in the USA, so how's it going? is it effective?
It's going badly enough for "Replacement Theory" to have become an excuse for murder. Judging by this and some other threads, it's going badly enough for some to bend over backwards trying to justify that excuse for murder.

Once upon a time, the plague of "Replacement Theory" was regional:
Molly Ivins said:
I believe all Southern liberals come from the same starting point--race. Once you figure out they are lying to you about race, you start to question everything.
But now, the disease has spread beyond Confederate states.

It's been spreading for a while. In 1992, at the Republican National Convention, Pat Buchanan delivered his notorious "culture war" speech, leading Ivins to remark:
Molly Ivins said:
It probably sounded better in the original German.

This is so frustrating as folk keep talking about a culture or the culture or other cultures and never, ever define the culture they are talking about.

If a culture is so clear and so apparent, why is it so difficult for folk to define it or them?

It makes no sense at all.
It makes perfect sense. Proponents of "Replacement Theory" start with the idea of a culture we all share, but that allegedly shared culture is the culture of Pat Buchanan's speech. If they were to identify that culture, it would become obvious that many of us emphatically reject that culture, and the foundation of their argument would crumble.

Someone not sure who mentioned a shared language as part of a culture, but that can't be the case for a "European culture"
Right. We don't all speak the Nazi dialect of German. We don't all speak the racist dialects of American English.

There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.
It's more useful to acknowledge the fact that there are two kinds of people in the world:
  • People who prefer mayonnaise.
  • People who prefer mustard.
That's a bit of an over-simplification, but it's less likely to lead to false assumptions than the stuff shuttit is reading.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.
 
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.


Are you familiar with German nationalist ideology and the concept of vaterlandslose Gesellen?

Besides, many Germans, including many workers, regarded the socialists as extremists and traitors. The term vaterlandslose Gesellen (literally: fellows without a fatherland) had been used since the 1850s to discredit early socialists as disloyal and subversive. The claim that they had no allegiance to their country and were instead internationalists was particularly powerful in the context of the nationalist undercurrents in mid-nineteenth-century Europe.
Blood and Iron: The Rise and Fall of the German Empire 1871-1928 (Google Books)


It paved the way for the Nazi persecution of Jews, Gypsies and communists. You know, "Nowhere people" ...
The Road to Somewhere by David Goodhart - a liberal's rightwing turn on immigration (The Guardian, March 22, 2017). Of course, it's on your "reading list", but you don't really have to read it. You are already there!
 
Are you familiar with German nationalist ideology and the concept of vaterlandslose Gesellen?
No, but that sounds correct. There are big strands in Communism, particularly of the Trotskyist type that thinks in this way. You have anti-family ideas in there as well.

It paved the way for the Nazi persecution of Jews, Gypsies and communists. You know, "Nowhere people" ...
The Road to Somewhere by David Goodhart - a liberal's rightwing turn on immigration (The Guardian, March 22, 2017). Of course, it's on your "reading list", but you don't really have to read it. You are already there!
Well, we are again in a period where nowhere people are undermining family, community and so on and trying to build some post national utopia. I don't know what to tell you. If there is one thing we learn from history it is that we don't learn from history.
 
It makes perfect sense. Proponents of "Replacement Theory" start with the idea of a culture we all share, but that allegedly shared culture is the culture of Pat Buchanan's speech. If they were to identify that culture, it would become obvious that many of us emphatically reject that culture, and the foundation of their argument would crumble.
(...)
It's more useful to acknowledge the fact that there are two kinds of people in the world:
  • People who prefer mayonnaise.
  • People who prefer mustard.
That's a bit of an over-simplification, but it's less likely to lead to false assumptions than the stuff shuttit is reading.


In Denmark, in the 1960s and '70s, people feared that Danish cooking would be replaced by something foreign. Particularly, garlic was a tell-tale sign that something was seriously wrong and foreigners were ruining genuine Danish culture. Nowadays, everybody eats and enjoys it, even Danish racists!
Danish cuisine before the 1970s was pretty bland. Nowadays, even the French talk about how Danish gastronomy reached dizzying heights (France24, Oct 10, 2021)
 
No, but that sounds correct. There are big strands in Communism, particularly of the Trotskyist type that thinks in this way. You have anti-family ideas in there as well.


No, Bismarck and Nazis thought that way. And you think that way, too. Bismarck was the one who made the concept of vaterlandslose Gesellen popular, and it really took off in the Third Reich.

Well, we are again in a period where nowhere people are undermining family, community and so on and trying to build some post national utopia. I don't know what to tell you. If there is one thing we learn from history it is that we don't learn from history.


You obviously learn nothing from history or from anything else. You probably haven't even noticed that most immigrants, i.e. 'nowhere people', are really into family. It's one of the things Nazis hate about Jews.
 
The reason no one wants to define this “culture” that is being replaced is that “replacement fear-y” (because that’s what it is -a fear) is not based around replacement of a culture. It is based around actual, physical replacement.

Replacement in jobs. Replacement in the voting booth. Replacement in the halls of power.

That’s the only kind of replacement that makes any sense. Indeed, it’s the version people like Tucker Carlson, et al are peddling right now.

The problem, for them, is that they have co-opted this “replacement fear-y” from White Supremacists and dressed it up to sound less racist. So when Carlson and friends talk about “immigration,” or “culture” we know they are actually talking about non-white people. Their denials ring hollow.
 
After people who look like me have been replaced, what happens to them? What should happen to them?

They won't get to decide, that's for sure, and shuttit & me both know it.
 
After people who look like me have been replaced, what happens to them? What should happen to them?

They won't get to decide, that's for sure, and shuttit & me both know it.


Well…we weren’t supposed to tell you this, but what the hell: reeducation camps. ;)
 
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people? Culture is seen as something to be sampled, rather than something to be part of.

The issue with the somewhere people is that they are dumb. Their position is fake and they are not actually connected to something.

Soccer fans are not a "we" with the team
https://youtu.be/xN1WN0YMWZU

You did not actually save the French in WW2
https://youtu.be/gy19YmQHHJU

You are not actually part of something you haven't contributed to
 
The reason no one wants to define this “culture” that is being replaced is that “replacement fear-y” (because that’s what it is -a fear) is not based around replacement of a culture. It is based around actual, physical replacement.

Replacement in jobs. Replacement in the voting booth. Replacement in the halls of power.

That’s the only kind of replacement that makes any sense. Indeed, it’s the version people like Tucker Carlson, et al are peddling right now.

The problem, for them, is that they have co-opted this “replacement fear-y” from White Supremacists and dressed it up to sound less racist. So when Carlson and friends talk about “immigration,” or “culture” we know they are actually talking about non-white people. Their denials ring hollow.


No, no, no, it's actually worse than that. Take sackett's example:
After people who look like me have been replaced, what happens to them?


'People who look like me!' Unless sackett is a Goth or a Punk or a member of some other subculture that really stands out, this has nothing at all to do with culture, which is the reason why they find it so difficult to describe the culture. It is racism, pure and simple, posing as a war of cultures.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom