Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

Does this mean that I have been promoted from "Racist" to "White Supremacist"? I'm not certain that these labels are being consistently or properly applied.

Why do you feel that way? Seems to be a distinction only in your mind. White Supremacists are racist.
 
Last edited:
Does this mean that I have been promoted from "Racist" to "White Supremacist"? I'm not certain that these labels are being consistently or properly applied.

I'm really not trying to be snarky here (or derail the conversation), but what do you consider the difference between "white supremacist" and "racist"? I've always thought that the former is simply a subset of the latter. If some people don't -- in other words, some people honestly believe one can be a white supremacist without being a racist -- then this may help me better understand where stuff like "replacement theory" is coming from.
 
Why do you feel that way? Seems to be a distinction only I'm your mind. White Supremacists are racist.

I'm really not trying to be snarky here (or derail the conversation), but what do you consider the difference between "white supremacist" and "racist"? I've always thought that the former is simply a subset of the latter. If some people don't -- in other words, some people honestly believe one can be a white supremacist without being a racist -- then this may help me better understand where stuff like "replacement theory" is coming from.


I agree that White Supremacists are racists. However, I make a distinction between the two as to how the terms are generally applied today. A person may be commonly labelled a "racist" for not being approving of another race or ethnicity or their culture. I don't think this requires a notion of racial superiority, just an intolerance to difference. "White Supremacist" would imply a notion/belief that whites are superior to all other races.
 
Last edited:
I'm really not trying to be snarky here (or derail the conversation), but what do you consider the difference between "white supremacist" and "racist"? I've always thought that the former is simply a subset of the latter.

If the former is a subset of the latter, the terms are not interchangeable.

If some people don't -- in other words, some people honestly believe one can be a white supremacist without being a racist -- then this may help me better understand where stuff like "replacement theory" is coming from

There are white separatists for example, a small minority of non-violent activists who simply want to separate from the rest of the country. They don't really profess to be "superior" in the way most of the Nazis and KKK did.
 
I agree that White Supremacists are racists. However, I make a distinction between the two as to how the terms are generally applied today. A person may be commonly labelled a "racist" for not being approving of another race or ethnicity or their culture. I don't think this requires a notion of racial superiority, just an intolerance to difference. "White Supremacist" would imply a notion/belief that whites are superior to all other races.

Ah, I think I get it -- "those people suck" does not necessarily mean "my people are superior."
 
If the former is a subset of the latter, the terms are not interchangeable.
Well, not interchangeable. But it's also not incorrect (to invoke a double negative) to call white supremacists racists, any more than it would be to call a crow a bird.
 
If the former is a subset of the latter, the terms are not interchangeable.



There are white separatists for example, a small minority of non-violent activists who simply want to separate from the rest of the country. They don't really profess to be "superior" in the way most of the Nazis and KKK did.

Yes the Anti hate Racists, who want to preserve a non hybridized Genetic code. Diversity tends to build stronger offspring, that's the folly in being Racist. Let evolutionary biology take it's corse, and see where we are in 10,000 years. But I highly doubt the Human Race or this Planet is worth saving after the last ten years.
 
All this hemming and hawing about this and that allows the replacement boys to avoid talking about the basic premise of their theory.

That being when and if the white populations of the western democracies become minorities the dang foreigners will take over and destroy the cultures of the respective countries.

The replacement boys are having trouble selling this gloom and doom scenario so they argue around the edges.

A laughingly over blown version of the feared calamity is posited in the dystopian great replacement novels I referenced in an earlier. Nobody but the replacement nerds buys that stuff anymore.

But the real problem the replacement boys have is the Muslim representative, the gay mayor, the latino sheriff, the Asian college president and the black president who upon assuming their positions of responsibility maintain the nation's traditions, thus neutering their theory.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
All this hemming and hawing about this and that allows the replacement boys to avoid talking about the basic premise of their theory.

That being when and if the white populations of the western democracies become minorities the dang foreigners will take over and destroy the cultures of the respective countries.

The replacement boys are having trouble selling this gloom and doom scenario so they argue around the edges.

A laughingly over blown version of the feared calamity is posited in the dystopian great replacement novels I referenced in an earlier. Nobody but the replacement nerds buys that stuff anymore.

But the real problem the replacement boys have is the Muslim representative, the gay mayor, the latino sheriff, the Asian college president and the black president who upon assuming their positions of responsibility maintain the nation's traditions, thus neutering their theory.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.

Very well said.
 
All this hemming and hawing about this and that allows the replacement boys to avoid talking about the basic premise of their theory.

That being when and if the white populations of the western democracies become minorities the dang foreigners will take over and destroy the cultures of the respective countries.

The replacement boys are having trouble selling this gloom and doom scenario so they argue around the edges.

A laughingly over blown version of the feared calamity is posited in the dystopian great replacement novels I referenced in an earlier post. Nobody but the replacement nerds buys that stuff anymore.

But the real problem the replacement boys have is the Muslim representative, the gay mayor, the latino sheriff, the Asian college president and the black president who upon assuming their positions of responsibility maintain the nation's traditions, thus neutering their theory.

Very well said.

And I would further point out that the replacement boys are remarkable quiet about the largely white hoard who attempted to overthrown the last presidential election.

One wonders what the replacement line would be had the crowd been latino?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Replacement theory is mostly about institutions being affected by demographic changes. If a lot of immigrants to your town don't participate in your PTA, either because they're less interested or because they don't feel welcome there, then the PTA's influence declines. Recreational and retail businesses will either change to appeal to the newcomers, or lose out to competitors who do so. They can get by for a while appealing only to traditionalists (including being hostile to the newer immigrants) but over time that customer base ages out. Younger customers won't go where immigrant members of their own peer groups aren't welcome.

In other words, "it's about culture" actually means "it's about rap music at the roller rink." Get over it. You're too old to hang out there anyhow.
 
I'm really not trying to be snarky here (or derail the conversation), but what do you consider the difference between "white supremacist" and "racist"? I've always thought that the former is simply a subset of the latter. If some people don't -- in other words, some people honestly believe one can be a white supremacist without being a racist -- then this may help me better understand where stuff like "replacement theory" is coming from.


"White supremacist", in the past, was used to denote people or groups who espouse racism, and specifically white racial superiority, and advocate laws which would enshrine that superiority. So, anyone who doesn't like black people is a racist. Anyone who wants to write laws that subjugate black people is a white supremacist.
 
I asked my wife whether she thought comparing immigrants to blood sucking vampires was reasonable, but all she did was bare her teeth and hiss something in a foreign language. Something something pendejo, whatever the hell that means.
 
Ireland has seen significant immigration in the last two decades, approximately 650,000 non-Irish are resident in the country.
The largest groups are Polish and British, with >10k from right other count (probably, the 2022 census is not available yet); Lithuania, Latvia, Romania, Brazil, Italy, Spain, France and Germany. It appears to be generally beneficial, though we may need to consider getting rid of the Brits as they're the only nationality that has a lower than Irish level of workforce participation.
 
And I would further point out that the replacement boys are remarkable quiet about the largely white hoard who attempted to overthrown the last presidential election.

One wonders what the replacement line would be had the crowd been latino?

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 341 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.

Yeah, wonder which parts of "Western Culture" "help a traitor commit high treason by trying to manipulate an election and laying siege on the building the certification is held in" and "claim election fraud with no evidence while it's actually your 'side' committing the election fraud" belong to.
 
Replacement theory is mostly about institutions being affected by demographic changes. If a lot of immigrants to your town don't participate in your PTA, either because they're less interested or because they don't feel welcome there, then the PTA's influence declines. Recreational and retail businesses will either change to appeal to the newcomers, or lose out to competitors who do so. They can get by for a while appealing only to traditionalists (including being hostile to the newer immigrants) but over time that customer base ages out. Younger customers won't go where immigrant members of their own peer groups aren't welcome.

In other words, "it's about culture" actually means "it's about rap music at the roller rink." Get over it. You're too old to hang out there anyhow.

*Sad disco noises*
 
If races really existed, that is, if they actually were different one from another, then they would unavoidably have a hierarchy. There would be one superior race, no matter what, and one inferior to all the others.

Seems to me, a racist is simply somebody who believes that races really exist. (Pace shuttit, the word "racist" still has the same venomous meaning it always had, and its acceptation has not widened.) Since racism lies in the land of belief, where anything can be accepted as true in the absence of evidence, the door of ignorance is wide open to madness.

As we see.
 
Last edited:
Dunno about those other novels, but The Turnip Diary is revered and much read among the Whiter Than the Whitewash set.

And believed. Yes, in some foggy way they regard it as really happening. Or just about to happen. Or bound to happen someday, and until then they keep their guns oily.

The Turner Diaries had an influence on The Oklahoma City Bomber, (Timothy McVeigh), and other members of the Militia Movement.

The book was wrfitten under a pseudonym by a Neo-Nazi named Luther Pierce and is a wish fullfillment fantasy. It has our "Hero" Turner crash blow up Federal buildings with explosives etc.

The excuse our "Heroes" use to justify their uprising against the Fedewral government is that the Feds are going to take our guns. (Note this is the only right our "Heroes" care about, but only for "White" People.)

In this wish fullfillment fantasy of death. Our "Heroes" fight against the evil Jews and set about a campaign of mass genocide.

Thus the "White" spouses of mixed "Race" couples are hung from lampposts. Non-"Whites", including mixed "Race" children, (Most esspecially Jews), are slaughterd in enmass in ravines in masacres described with joy by our Neo-Nazi scum bag writer.

So called "inferior" groups are starved etc., which is also described with glee and joy. Jews are called "Satan's spawn", and Hitler is called "the Great One." All those "Whites" who oppose this slaughter and horror are executed, i.e., murdered by slaughter and terror. (So much for freedom of speech and assembly etc.)

Nuclear bombs are used, and in an orgy of slaughter more than 3/4 of the population of the US perishes in c. 1 year.

The slaughter then spreads world wide with non-"White" areas being nuked and the survivors being exterminated. And we get the "glorious" dawn of an all "White" world. Meanwhile all non-Whites have been exterminated including all the "inferior" inhabitants of Africa and East Asia.

The author is positively orgasmic about all this terror, mass murder and genocide. The thought of murdering billions gives this Neo-Nazi the greatest possible joy. I have little doubt that this idiot would, with joy, have smashed in the head of a child of the "wrong" race.

Fortunately this piece of offal is dead.
 
Last edited:
I admit I haven't read all 14 pages of the thread, but I don't really see much discussion of replacement theory here.

I looked at my own posts, and they all seem to be about reacting to things people are saying, but those things weren't replacement theory.

Well, whatever. I favor letting people into the Untied States, but enforcing laws against illegal immigration. I think that mkaes me in favor of replacement, i.e. the presence of all those Hindus is going to change the culture, somewhat, and I'm ok with that.

I do not think legal immigration is some sort of Democratic conspiracy to win elections by importing Democratic voters.

Is there any significant disagreement? I mean, I know people could quibble about things, but is there anyone here who thinks we need to slow down immigration lest our Judaeo-Christian, Roman-legacy, Western, or All American culture be destroyed?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom