Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

That’s, arguably, a part of a culture. But your description is too broad.

For example, many Texans are against people from California coming here: “Keep your California culture in California!“ By your definition, Texas and California share the same “culture.” But it should be obvious that, in many ways, they are worlds apart.
Or maybe people just think they are.
 
If Hispanics magically started voting Republican in huge numbers, and espouse highly conservative views like being anti-abortion, pro-lower taxes, pro-gun, You can bet your ass Democrats would start supporting a wall.

:)
No we wouldn't. Because it takes years before immigrants can vote, and, a lot of Hispanics already hold conservative views.
 
You mean the mostly right-wing Republican, anti-Communist Cubans?

The ones who lost their "Dry Foot Policy" under Obama by EO?

Its interesting how Obama dropped the Dry Foot Policy, but enacted DACA.
Nothing to do with current relevance? :rolleyes:

DACA recipients have been here for years, they came as children but weren't born here. As for anti-communist Cubans, any reason they can't apply for asylum like other immigrants fleeing persecution?

ETA: I'm not familiar with Obama's change in Cuban immigration. I am familiar with him trying to normalize relations with Cuba, something that is long overdue.
 
Last edited:
Current "Affirmative Action" programs are a topic of their own, although I wouldn't be surprised if Replacement Theory touched on the subject.

Keep in mind its not actually a "theory" in the true sense of the word. Its a "Conspiracy Theory", a belief that rejects the standard explanation for events and instead falsely credits nefarious, covert groups or organizations with carrying out some secret plot.

White Replacement Conspiracy Theory is just a rehash of Nazi Germany's "Ersatz Arier mit untermenchen", the alleged conspiracy, supposedly driven by the Jews, to replace or weaken the Aryan race with subhumans. It was bull-**** in the 1930's, and its still bull-**** in this century
 
Last edited:
That's overly reductive, cultures are a continuum made up of subcultures done to even family level cultures. To say there is no European culture because there are differences between Italian and Swiss cultures, well, overlapping Vend Diagrams. There are likely things that most Europeans so that are different from what most South East Asians due. Eat a lot cheese for instance.

Yes, cultures are a continuously evolving and shifting set of overlaps and thus there is no 'European' culture.
Nor is there some mythical static eternal culture that needs protecting.
What is considered an acceptable culture now is not the same as the one 50 years ago, so I guess we are all replacing the true culture of our ancestors.
 
That's overly reductive, cultures are a continuum made up of subcultures done to even family level cultures. To say there is no European culture because there are differences between Italian and Swiss cultures, well, overlapping Vend Diagrams. There are likely things that most Europeans so that are different from what most South East Asians due. Eat a lot cheese for instance.

And this very very very important piece of "culture" will soon be replaced by "eating a lot of hummus". Oh the humanity.Dark times ahead for poor Europe.
 
You really really really really really really really need to back this claim up with anything. But I won't hold my breath, since it's just another attempt of making "culture" relevant.

It's the culture of the USA among other countries. I'm assuming you live in the USA, so how's it going? is it effective?
 
That is not a definition of a culture, its merely a definition of the word culture.

It's the culture you I both live in, Darat. I'm sure you know what it entails. I have no intention of getting involvd in describing every little detail in order to give you the opportunity to nitpick my views.
 
That's the problem with racial categorization on the basis of literal color or some super-specific phenotypic standard that the categorizers wouldn't apply to other races. If you extended Europe to as far as Syria and had those people remove their robes and turbans and dressed them up like Westerners with Western language and mannerisms, the number of "white people" in the world would grow by a few million.

Try to trace all the East Asian descended people in the world (no color connotation in the term) and you can go from the Arctic circle to Indonesia and find all skin colors and slightly different noses and eyes. Now imagine half of Eastern Asia was historically Buddhist and the other half atheist or whatever and they had a bunch of crusades between them and they persecuted a small minority of moneychangers and scapegoats, themselves East Asian-descended, and decided they weren't truly East Asian and they tainted the pure white-skinned Asian gene pool.

Yeah. Culture, race, ethnicity. They're all made up notions that are not very useful for categorizing people, and yet they seem so important. Wars are fought over the stupid things.

So, I can understand wanting to "preserve a culture", even if I can't define, and won't attempt to define, exactly what a "culture" is in general, or the exact boundaries of a specific culture.

I was in Toronto last week, and the Royal Ontario Museum had a rather funny diorama in its "First Nations" exhibit. Picture a classic "Indian scene" in a museum. Three Amerindian-colored manequins, dressed in native garb, inside some sort of primitive house, but one is using a power drill, one has a cell phone. One has a camera on a tripod.

The point was about preserving and adapting a culture while adopting elements that came from elsewhere. Is that power drill part of "their" culture? Or ours?

For my part, it's not really an important question. However, if the parents disown their son for marrying a white girl, they're racist.


Anyway, more specific to the thread topic, I don't see immigration to the United States as a threat to my culture. If anything, it's part of my culture. Maybe the fact that my mom is an immigrant makes me less concerned about other immigrants. Immigration is surely an all-American thing.
 
It's interesting that neither the OP nor the Media in general is mentioning that the full name of the Theory is "White Christian Replacement", and that it's based in anti-Semitism.
 
I think of them as white, although I agree that not everyone does.

I think Greeks are a little bit "less white".


As you can see: ;)

If Hispanics magically started voting Republican in huge numbers, and espouse highly conservative views like being anti-abortion, pro-lower taxes, pro-gun, You can bet your ass Democrats would start supporting a wall.

:)
 
It's the culture you I both live in, Darat. I'm sure you know what it entails. I have no intention of getting involvd in describing every little detail in order to give you the opportunity to nitpick my views.

I 100% sincerely don't.

This is so frustrating as folk keep talking about a culture or the culture or other cultures and never, ever define the culture they are talking about.

If a culture is so clear and so apparent, why is it so difficult for folk to define it or them?

It makes no sense at all.

Someone not sure who mentioned a shared language as part of a culture, but that can't be the case for a "European culture", our different languages don't even all share the same roots, someone has mentioned shared legal traditions, again that can't be the case for a "European culture", it can't be a shared religion and so on.

(Lplus - next part is not directed at you personally - your post just triggered this thought in me.)

I do wonder if we are seeing an "unconscious" assumption that because Germans look like the Danes, who look like Italians, who look like Irish, who look like French folk and so on folk are making an unchallenged assumption that because they look like "us" we have a shared culture? Not realising the huge differences in the myriad of cultures in these European countries?
 
Last edited:
We are basically on square one. A claim was made "Immigration of non whites is destroying culture X."

So far, the definition of culture is "Well, you know!"
 
Last edited:
I 100% sincerely don't.

This is so frustrating as folk keep talking about a culture or the culture or other cultures and never, ever define the culture they are talking about.

If a culture is so clear and so apparent, why is it so difficult for folk to define it or them?

It makes no sense at all.

Someone not sure who mentioned a shared language as part of a culture, but that can't be the case for a "European culture", our different languages don't even all share the same roots, someone has mentioned shared legal traditions, again that can't be the case for a "European culture", it can't be a shared religion and so on.

(Lplus - next part is not directed at you personally - your post just triggered this thought in me.)

I do wonder if we are seeing an "unconscious" assumption that because Germans look like the Danes, who look like Italians, who look like Irish, who look like French folk and so on folk are making an unchallenged assumption that because they look like "us" we have a shared culture? Not realising the huge differences in the myriad of cultures in these European countries?

And obviously they do share cultural elements.

For example there are many very keen football fans in Denmark and Germany... oh.
 
And obviously they do share cultural elements.

For example there are many very keen football fans in Denmark and Germany... oh.
There is a book on my reading list called The Road to Somewhere: The Populist Revolt and the Future of Politics. My understanding of that is that it claims there are two types of people. "Somewhere people" who feel connected to a particular place and feel connected to some kind of continuity associated with that, and "Nowhere people" who feel at home in London, Rome, or LA and see their own rootlessness as freedom.

I wonder if the reason some people are asking "what is culture" is that they are nowhere people and are incapable of seeing the world from the perspective of somewhere people?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom