Is there anything to "Replacement Theory"?

(Don't forget for our USA folk at least a few of the European countries are non-white.)

And you are now another one talking about "the culture" yet not defining what culture you are talking about! It's getting a tad frustrating.

I quote from a post of mine replying to a previous request of yours for a definition of culture:-

To me it's a combination of political and economic principles within a legal and moral framework which has developed in europe, particularly western europe over the last 1000 or more years. It has clearly been effective, in that the application of that culture has led to a number of countries which are the go to destinations for refugees and economic migrants the world over.

Effectively it's a liberal (reasonably) democracy (ish) with the legal and moral framework developed within europe and exported in particular to North America, Australia and New Zealand. It isn't perfect, but it seems to be popular. And I have no intention of elaborating further.
 
(Don't forget for our USA folk at least a few of the European countries are non-white.)

Really? Who?

Maybe Albania. Anyone else?

(I don't count Turkey as part of Europe. It kind of is. Sort of.)
 
To me it's a combination of political and economic principles within a legal and moral framework which has developed in europe, particularly western europe over the last 1000 or more years. It has clearly been effective, in that the application of that culture has led to a number of countries which are the go to destinations for refugees and economic migrants the world over.

You really really really really really really really need to back this claim up with anything. But I won't hold my breath, since it's just another attempt of making "culture" relevant.
 
I quote from a post of mine replying to a previous request of yours for a definition of culture:-



Effectively it's a liberal (reasonably) democracy (ish) with the legal and moral framework developed within europe and exported in particular to North America, Australia and New Zealand. It isn't perfect, but it seems to be popular. And I have no intention of elaborating further.
That is not a definition of a culture, its merely a definition of the word culture.
 
I quote from a post of mine replying to a previous request of yours for a definition of culture:-



Effectively it's a liberal (reasonably) democracy (ish) with the legal and moral framework developed within europe and exported in particular to North America, Australia and New Zealand. It isn't perfect, but it seems to be popular. And I have no intention of elaborating further.


That’s, arguably, a part of a culture. But your description is too broad.

For example, many Texans are against people from California coming here: “Keep your California culture in California!“ By your definition, Texas and California share the same “culture.” But it should be obvious that, in many ways, they are worlds apart.
 
If Hispanics magically started voting Republican in huge numbers, and espouse highly conservative views like being anti-abortion, pro-lower taxes, pro-gun, You can bet your ass Democrats would start supporting a wall.

:)
 
I don't think you can discuss the realities of modern discrimination without broaching the topic of affirmative action programs. You may disagree, and I am OK with that. As I say, that is a different topic.
Affirmative action certainly has relevance, as an effect not a cause. It's a response (whether you approve of it or not, and whether you're right or not) to the historical disadvantage and ongoing social bias that keeps minorities from gaining a fair foothold. But I don't think it's relevant to this exchange. My argument here is with your suggestion that identifying racial friction requires that black people hark back the whipping of their enslaved ancestors on the plantation, rather than on the discrimination they have faced in the century and a half since. Your post #344, to be precise, which was snide, gratuitiously off the point and historically ignorant, and, though I am not quite as eager as some to get out the big brush, it certainly could be read by many as racist.
 
That’s, arguably, a part of a culture. But your description is too broad.

For example, many Texans are against people from California coming here: “Keep your California culture in California!“ By your definition, Texas and California share the same “culture.” But it should be obvious that, in many ways, they are worlds apart.
Can cultures not be layered? There are cultures that are specific to particular parts of the US that are nonetheless part of a greater US culture?
 
If Hispanics magically started voting Republican in huge numbers, and espouse highly conservative views like being anti-abortion, pro-lower taxes, pro-gun, You can bet your ass Democrats would start supporting a wall.

:)
You might want to look into partisan attitudes toward Cuban immigration and give that some further thought.
 
You might want to look into partisan attitudes toward Cuban immigration and give that some further thought.

You mean the mostly right-wing Republican, anti-Communist Cubans?

The ones who lost their "Dry Foot Policy" under Obama by EO?

Its interesting how Obama dropped the Dry Foot Policy, but enacted DACA.
 
Our friend Warp has tip toed around the discussion of the rights of immigrants. It's no wonder.

The Founding Fathers thought of the right to emigrate as a God given right and they had such a problem with England putting restrictions on immigration to the colonies that they listed it as one of the grievances in the Declaration of Independence:

"He has endeavoured to prevent the population of these States; for that purpose obstructing the Laws of Naturalization of Foreigners; refusing to pass others to encourage their migration hither, and raising the conditions of new Appropriations of Lands."'

Simply put the English didn't want to feed the economic engine that was the colonies and allow us yanks to out compete the mother land.

The sad truth is that this open boarders and free trade approach ran smack up against the blatant racism of 19th century America. It seems that when immigration involved Chinese and Mexicans it got demoted from a God given right to a mere "lawful process" administered by government functionaries.

IMHO, great replacement theory (present company excluded) is just a modern version of the same sad bigoted line.

----------
Dope Clock II: It's been 329 days since Bobby Menard announced plans to create "Artists Valley". So far all he has done is lie through his teeth.
 
Last edited:
Your post #344, to be precise, which was snide, gratuitiously off the point and historically ignorant, and, though I am not quite as eager as some to get out the big brush, it certainly could be read by many as racist.


Bruto, you should know me better by now, as often as we have interacted. Of course I am being dramatic and exaggerating:

Yeah, they probably recall their days on the plantation, whippin' them negroes. White people are the devil, I tell ya! :rolleyes:


This was in response to this idea was put forth that these people are concerned about becoming the minority because they feel some sort of guilt, or fear that they will be treated in a bad way...because the assumption is that these whites have "of course" been bad to these groups.

I think it is a stupid assumption to make.
 
If Hispanics magically started voting Republican in huge numbers, and espouse highly conservative views like being anti-abortion, pro-lower taxes, pro-gun, You can bet your ass Democrats would start supporting a wall.

:)

Umm living in New Mexico and having met and talked to many 1st and 2nd generation immigrants I have discovered that many of them really don't actually like paying taxes, love guns*, and being mostly Catholics aren't exactly pro-choice.

Yet they still mainly vote Democrat for some reason that I just can't put my finger on /s

*you may notice New Mexico is a very blue state with very lax gun laws, and actually pretty low taxes.
 
Affirmative action has nothing to do with it. Implying that one must hark back to the days of slavery to find discrimination and hatred suggests an unfortunate lack of observation and perspective. The statement I was criticizing is both hyperbolic and ignorant.

And it was clear what you were talking about, but it is a great example of bad faith argument and a deliberate misunderstanding to score an imagined point whilst denying that racial discrimination is still a problem.




Pretending that discrimination is ancient history does not make it so.

Current "Affirmative Action" programs are a topic of their own, although I wouldn't be surprised if Replacement Theory touched on the subject.
 
And it was clear what you were talking about, but it is a great example of bad faith argument and a deliberate misunderstanding to score an imagined point whilst denying that racial discrimination is still a problem.


Wrong again, Jimbob. See my above response to Bruto. You're making a lot of assumptions.
 
Last edited:
No.

If there is an European 'culture' it's about attacking our neighbors for doing things differently.
Now that we can't do that with actual weapons anymore it's down to words and football matches, but even within countries there is no real single culture.
Try to cheer for the English rugby team in Glasgow, talk in dutch in the south of Belgium (or vise versa) etc etc.

That's overly reductive, cultures are a continuum made up of subcultures done to even family level cultures. To say there is no European culture because there are differences between Italian and Swiss cultures, well, overlapping Vend Diagrams. There are likely things that most Europeans so that are different from what most South East Asians due. Eat a lot cheese for instance.
 
Really? Who?

Maybe Albania. Anyone else?

(I don't count Turkey as part of Europe. It kind of is. Sort of.)

That's the problem with racial categorization on the basis of literal color or some super-specific phenotypic standard that the categorizers wouldn't apply to other races. If you extended Europe to as far as Syria and had those people remove their robes and turbans and dressed them up like Westerners with Western language and mannerisms, the number of "white people" in the world would grow by a few million.

Try to trace all the East Asian descended people in the world (no color connotation in the term) and you can go from the Arctic circle to Indonesia and find all skin colors and slightly different noses and eyes. Now imagine half of Eastern Asia was historically Buddhist and the other half atheist or whatever and they had a bunch of crusades between them and they persecuted a small minority of moneychangers and scapegoats, themselves East Asian-descended, and decided they weren't truly East Asian and they tainted the pure white-skinned Asian gene pool.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom